Someone just pointed this out...Beatles "White Album" has a "Faul" song--"I Will,"
I Will = short for- I William. PID---If you don't believe so, do the measurements--Faul's head alway's looks thinner and "Is" longer, eye spacing, size, etc., Ergo--PID?
There is another video that shows faul walking into a pub and everyone in the pub calls him billy?? Why call him Billy? I don't know the name of the video, but it exists. Then someone asks "Billy" to sing a song..
You know, it's hilarious that I found this video because Paul "allowed" it as a video response to his show at Amoeba Records in LA. I was curious what the phony one would have the brass to post on Macca's page and so I came here to check it out as I would ordinarily avoid trashing my mind with senseless tripe like this. Macca probably laughed his ass off at this because the old man who is sitting is the one named William. HAHAHA. Phony guy, you're still a schmuck.
It is obvious that the guy doing the introduction had walked in with Paul. The door was wide open, yet Paul's hand was in his pocket and he was too far away from it to push it with his shoulder. The logical conclusion is that he was giving Paul a tour, walked into the room and introduced him to a man named William.
Also he begins by saying "and", implying that it was the continuation of a conversation that was going on in the coridoor.
That's pretty good evidence. I have a good idea of who William was before he was bandleader Billy Spears. The clue is even in the name Billy Spears. This is a reincarnated being who used to be William Shakespeare. Find some images of Shakespeare online or even here on YouTube. Study the face of Shakespeare and you can see similarities.
It's obvious that Paul is being introduced to an old man whose name is William. Why would a McCartney impersonator permit an actor in his own film to give away his 'true identity?. And yeah - duh - when have you ever shaken hands with a southpaw and noticed he used his left hand? By the way, Paul is ambidextrous anyway. Take a look at the sleeve of the 'I Wanna Hold Your Hand' single (in 1964, PRIOR to his 'death'). - and see a cigarette in his right hand, way before 'Abbey Road'.
the old dudes name is william possibly or the paul look alike, but the thing is, that the real paul is left handed and in this clip "paul" reaches out to shake hands with his right. and looks very comfortable with it.
yea lol thats right lol its been a while too since ive heard anything or looked at anything about paul but i dont believe hes dead. i think thats is the genuine paul.
maybe paul is both handed,i can wipe my ass with both hands,but prefer the left.and sometimes the media changes the direction of photos or films to get another look and impression.
This whole rumour is so fucking confusing I mean the whole "you know william?" thing makes it true but the thing that doesn't is that clues are on help, rubber soul, and revolver which were released before alleged death which makes fake. This is one thing people will never find the answer 2:(.
William CAMPBELL is the red herring from the old "lookalike contest" story.
Most modern theories mention a Bill Sheppard, formerly of the Ontario Provincial Police, along with some other people who were temporary Paul replacements.
The craziest theories mention that one person is performing Paul, Vivian Stanshall, and a few other people, all at the same time!
its not about the left handed thing I believe, they say that paul's look alike was named willian campbell, the man says "you know william" and points a paul (or does he point at william? =P )
i've always heard about these clues,and found a few on my own,but seein vids and old articles,ect-what a bonus to have all this fotage bac[from the grave,so to speak]
maybe but who is George referring to as "Beatle Bill" in that earlier video just after he corrects John that it's the Fab 3 not the Fab 4? that one got me...
By the way, when I went to the imdb web page to check "Give My Regards to Broad Street", the very first thing that I saw was a pop-up ad for the most recent version of "Bionic Woman". It read, "One life ends; another begins". Ha ha ha; this stuff is getting creepy and following me everywhere.
Actually, it is the older man, Frank Duncan, who is being introduced as "William". But if you don't know that, it could look as though it's Faul that's being introduced as William because of the body language of the guy making the introduction. Another hidden clue perhaps?
the only reason i make "Paul is not dead" videos is because Mr. iamaphoney dose great "Paul is dead" videos so theres no point for me to do "Paul is dead" videos.
William cannot be the man sitting down because the other man was not looking at Paul and asking him "do you know William". The man was looking at the other man who was seated and asked HIM, "do you know William", referring to Paul.
The man addresses Paul as "William". The idea is that Paul's replacement after his death was a man by the name on William Campbell. Noticed a few people didn't quite get that one. Personally I don't believe any of it at all. But I love the vids. So observant
Thank you for that. I actually am skeptical about the theory, but people have done much investigation into it. This actually isn't the first time Paul has been called "William" or "Billy".
Paul is saying "That bitch Heather Mills is NOT going to take all my money - I'll beat the shit out of her again!!" but maybe I am wrong -- not sure if he says "bitch" or "stumped legged whore"
i dont follow all of this "PAUL IS DEAD" shit! What the hell?!!?!!! he is NEVER going to die... and i think you people must be waiting for it to happen if you are putting this shit on here.. paul is dead... yeah what the fuck ever!
I have to say I am a MAJOR Beatles fan and if there's one thing I've marveled at is how mind-numbingly consistent Paul is in his speech pattern, facial expressions and gestures. The Paul of 2007 is quite clearly the Paul of 1964. I've also enjoyed the "Paul is dead because he sucks solo" comments but I must ask you....could George Harrison really be the same guy who wrote "Here Come The Sun" and then "Gone Troppo"?
No you idiot. It's because he is taking a break until
November. He's doing research, as well as who knows what else. For all you know he could be working out and getting in shape so he could apply for a job as one of Paul's guards at his ranch. Then, when they're in private, he could tie him up and interview him.
First off, I don't recall addressing that comment to you, so I don't know where you get off calling me a dickwad. And if you're referring to that guy who was in the news not too long ago, the one who broke in yelling "I must see him", I already knew about that. Do I think it was him? Very possible. I think he has gotten in trouble...with Apple at least. Thats why some of his videos got pulled, maybe?
I realy appreciate all these movies you've made! I'm doing a research on the "Paul is Dead" hoax right now and watching all these videos has helped a lot.
Wow, I´ve also seen a lot of times that movie and never noticed that part... amazing... you know William, lol. I don´t want to wait till November, that´s too much time!!!! don´t goooooooo :)
Dont get me wrong, i love this theory... but its the old man whos called William... hence he is saying it TO Paul "You've met william"... check imdb if you dont believe me, actor - Frank Duncan ... nevertheness this rotten apple series is remarkable. I cannot wait for this rumoured movie.
Someone just pointed this out...Beatles "White Album" has a "Faul" song--"I Will,"
I Will = short for- I William. PID---If you don't believe so, do the measurements--Faul's head alway's looks thinner and "Is" longer, eye spacing, size, etc., Ergo--PID?
billy38010 5 days ago in playlist the rotten apple series
RottenApple, if your going to do horrible movies, please do it right.
Not a random scene.
WingedBeatle is BS too.
PID'ers are stupid.
GustavoVillarBatera 2 weeks ago
Who is Mia Rose? Are there two of her?
Pammigal 4 months ago
There is another video that shows faul walking into a pub and everyone in the pub calls him billy?? Why call him Billy? I don't know the name of the video, but it exists. Then someone asks "Billy" to sing a song..
SilenceDoGood25 4 months ago
What the..fuck? Really? You think right there, they're going to do it right in front of anyone? That's to suspicious.
MisterLambs 10 months ago
This is from a MOVIE!!! HELLO!!! What the **** does THIS have to do with the price of eggs?!?!??
Pmfried 11 months ago
the old man's name was William!
bluesrock2008 11 months ago
WILLIAM?! O.O
TheRealFellner 1 year ago
Y ahora mi gustada sección Paul está muerto je je
MARI007100 1 year ago
hands down my favorite rotten apple.
when the music kicks in about :20--wow, it takes effect
dddilly 1 year ago
when he signed his book for me(one of the highlights of my life)he wrote with his left and shook my hand with his right.c'mon people-be realistic!
everythingOKforever 1 year ago
People always shake hands with right hand, even the left handed.
kanervatie 1 year ago
he said ted you know william
TheAlexander1389 1 year ago
the old guy is named William
linksoer 1 year ago
You know, it's hilarious that I found this video because Paul "allowed" it as a video response to his show at Amoeba Records in LA. I was curious what the phony one would have the brass to post on Macca's page and so I came here to check it out as I would ordinarily avoid trashing my mind with senseless tripe like this. Macca probably laughed his ass off at this because the old man who is sitting is the one named William. HAHAHA. Phony guy, you're still a schmuck.
SilverHamer 1 year ago
It is obvious that the guy doing the introduction had walked in with Paul. The door was wide open, yet Paul's hand was in his pocket and he was too far away from it to push it with his shoulder. The logical conclusion is that he was giving Paul a tour, walked into the room and introduced him to a man named William.
Also he begins by saying "and", implying that it was the continuation of a conversation that was going on in the coridoor.
crossfacewalls 1 year ago
of course he was replaced
only a complete idiot, or someone being paid to distract you would say otherwise
use your EYES
lukkbox 2 years ago
use your medication XD
TheAmazingstarman 2 years ago 2
@lukkbox
and your ears, he nor anyone could have sounded as good as the original
DCAreaguy2001 1 year ago
@DCAreaguy2001
this is true
also
there is NO way the REAL paul mccartney would have written the fuckin frog chorus
think people!
lukkbox 1 year ago
yes why if is a movie they used that name ,why they don't used Peter, frank or another name , why that specific name william ?
demondan1974 2 years ago
That's pretty good evidence. I have a good idea of who William was before he was bandleader Billy Spears. The clue is even in the name Billy Spears. This is a reincarnated being who used to be William Shakespeare. Find some images of Shakespeare online or even here on YouTube. Study the face of Shakespeare and you can see similarities.
xander7ful 2 years ago
instead rotten apple's video, should be rotten brain.
Paul no está muerto, it's just marketing, además, eso es una pelicula, o un video, o cualquier chingadera, no prueba nada.
Yo conozco a zurdos que nunca me han saludado con la izquierda, always with the right hand.
Escarlinhos 2 years ago
im left handed i live in England and ive never used my left hand to shake, no 1 does its bad luck
balf1111117373 2 years ago
@balf1111117373
do you use your right hand to drink and smoke aswell?
no
lukkbox 1 year ago
@lukkbox lol wtf???
balf1111117373 1 year ago
@balf1111117373 loads of video clips of paul smoking and drinking with his right hand
but only since the left handed bass player was replaced by a right handed pianist lol
you should look into this more, google
its fascinating, and true
lukkbox 1 year ago
@lukkbox I'm right handed, and I 9 times out of 10 smoke and drink with my left hand.
Trune1984 1 year ago
Are you sure that william isn't the old guy?
bilos1993 2 years ago
My dad is a lefty and he shakes with his right.
Everyone shakes with the right because it's more polite because most people are righty.
xNikkaX3 2 years ago 14
@xNikkaX3
yes but your dad doesnt drink and smoke with his right does he?
lukkbox 1 year ago
@xNikkaX3 i wipe with my right too XD
cooks24 2 months ago
all people give the hand whit the right
pietrorock 2 years ago
If we could do a DNA test......
ColibriBand 2 years ago 4
When were they "knighted" by the dark Queen.
"...Let her out and let her in. Hey Jude, BEGIN" (heroin)
r8vjefo 2 years ago
its
"...Let IT out and let IT in, Hey Jude begin"
XD
no but really it is
beatlelvr96 2 years ago
the rotten apple is running out of ideas
stuarttravis88 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
For god's sake, IS there ANY human in the world who shakes hand with his left???!!!
yourenotaslave 2 years ago
Comment removed
yourenotaslave 2 years ago
It's obvious that Paul is being introduced to an old man whose name is William. Why would a McCartney impersonator permit an actor in his own film to give away his 'true identity?. And yeah - duh - when have you ever shaken hands with a southpaw and noticed he used his left hand? By the way, Paul is ambidextrous anyway. Take a look at the sleeve of the 'I Wanna Hold Your Hand' single (in 1964, PRIOR to his 'death'). - and see a cigarette in his right hand, way before 'Abbey Road'.
reverendflash 3 years ago 3
Yeah, PID is debunked bullshit. The Rotten Apple sucks. Paul is ALIVE!!!!
Goedhartbros 2 years ago
He points right at Paul when he says William... Also... When I smoke a ciggarette I hold in my left sometimes. And I am by no means ambidextrious.
richig761 2 years ago 2
yes we ali know William. what movie is this?
Basie369 3 years ago
so, is it William Shepherd or William Campbell?
faulconandsnowjob 3 years ago
the old dudes name is william possibly or the paul look alike, but the thing is, that the real paul is left handed and in this clip "paul" reaches out to shake hands with his right. and looks very comfortable with it.
Ryan111488 3 years ago
it doesn't matter if right handed or left-handed, you shake someone's hand with your right.... shaking with your left is considered disrespectful.
MusicDude86 3 years ago 2
yea lol thats right lol its been a while too since ive heard anything or looked at anything about paul but i dont believe hes dead. i think thats is the genuine paul.
Ryan111488 2 years ago
This is kinda obvious.
The old man's name is 'William',
it's not like he says to the old man
'You know William', like if Paul would be William Campbell.
EEVVx 3 years ago
The old man in the sit, is call William and Paul go to say hello to him
MercuryBeatles753 3 years ago 3
it sounds like he says, "Kev, you know William?"
milliondustopeners 3 years ago
Maybe it's the fact that "Billy" is shaking William's (the old man) hand with his right hand??? I don't know!!! It's ust my suggestion.
BeatlefanAfter909 3 years ago
maybe paul is both handed,i can wipe my ass with both hands,but prefer the left.and sometimes the media changes the direction of photos or films to get another look and impression.
neozos 3 years ago 2
@neozos can you please explain how a 5' 6" left handed bass player became a 6' right handed pianist please?
lukkbox 1 year ago
@lukkbox he was 5'11 and he became 6'1, by the looks of it. but who knows.
byemynameishi 1 year ago
The old mans name is william you phoney.
TheWho1231 3 years ago
i don't know if you ppl notice this but, the guy is talking TO Paul, "you know William?" so the other guy's name is William
enricaville 3 years ago 2
yeah i think he was introducing him to the old guy whose name is william, why would they make it so obvious in a movie then?
goshnessmaggy 3 years ago
paul was a life long smoker so Phiilip morris says he must be alive, he HASNT FILED ANY LAWSUITS againgst them.. #1 proof b*itches!
CryHepZero 3 years ago
This whole rumour is so fucking confusing I mean the whole "you know william?" thing makes it true but the thing that doesn't is that clues are on help, rubber soul, and revolver which were released before alleged death which makes fake. This is one thing people will never find the answer 2:(.
seanyd43 3 years ago
don't get it
Katsnjammer 3 years ago
William CAMPBELL is the red herring from the old "lookalike contest" story.
Most modern theories mention a Bill Sheppard, formerly of the Ontario Provincial Police, along with some other people who were temporary Paul replacements.
The craziest theories mention that one person is performing Paul, Vivian Stanshall, and a few other people, all at the same time!
Anyway, the William Campbell thing is old data.
ZeroCorpse 3 years ago
so what if she shakes with his right hand? Isn't that the "professional" way to formally shake hands anyway?
(that's what I was always taught)
SecretAgentHunt 4 years ago
What? I could understand the earlier so called clues. But what the fuck is this? Someone introducing Paul to a old geezer called William?
rondellhundftw 4 years ago 2
its not about the left handed thing I believe, they say that paul's look alike was named willian campbell, the man says "you know william" and points a paul (or does he point at william? =P )
jonathancremers 4 years ago
ever think that maybe, just maybe, the old man's name is William.
shalzi17 4 years ago 17
@shalzi17
it`s 99%
k0stil 1 year ago
i've always heard about these clues,and found a few on my own,but seein vids and old articles,ect-what a bonus to have all this fotage bac[from the grave,so to speak]
sanguine111 4 years ago
Paul was LEFT handed
rustynest 4 years ago
He's talking to paul saying "you know william?" then pointing at him...
un1q3u 4 years ago
BLATENTLY calling the old man William. This is insanely stupid. Only the unemployed would engage in such retarded conspiracy work
sterlingsir 4 years ago
maybe but who is George referring to as "Beatle Bill" in that earlier video just after he corrects John that it's the Fab 3 not the Fab 4? that one got me...
woodsz33 4 years ago 2
he says beatle phil
KnowGuitar 4 years ago
who the fuck is beatle phill?
Cotters2000 4 years ago
quienes sois?????como conoceis sta informacion???
querant 4 years ago
oh i get it paul is left handed?? and he gave out his right
gizzuworld 4 years ago 4
By the way, when I went to the imdb web page to check "Give My Regards to Broad Street", the very first thing that I saw was a pop-up ad for the most recent version of "Bionic Woman". It read, "One life ends; another begins". Ha ha ha; this stuff is getting creepy and following me everywhere.
HaHaHaPaulIsDead 4 years ago
Actually, it is the older man, Frank Duncan, who is being introduced as "William". But if you don't know that, it could look as though it's Faul that's being introduced as William because of the body language of the guy making the introduction. Another hidden clue perhaps?
HaHaHaPaulIsDead 4 years ago
So let me introduce to you...the one and only Billy Shears...
HaHaHaPaulIsDead 4 years ago 3
There's what appears to be the outline of a dead man on the street on this movie's cover.
lyricsology. com/m /mccartney_paul /give-my-regards. jpg.
Tdani81 4 years ago
Now I see. I had my doubts at first but this video explains everything.
So the old man knew and called him by his real name
Now this is a real pice of evidence
eznobile 4 years ago
This clip is from his MOVIE "Give My Regards to Broadstreet."
Pmfried 4 years ago
the only reason i make "Paul is not dead" videos is because Mr. iamaphoney dose great "Paul is dead" videos so theres no point for me to do "Paul is dead" videos.
Thank iamaphoney for posting:)
jrouly 4 years ago
isnt it at all possible that william was the fellow paul was shaking hands with?
polythenepam1969 4 years ago
William cannot be the man sitting down because the other man was not looking at Paul and asking him "do you know William". The man was looking at the other man who was seated and asked HIM, "do you know William", referring to Paul.
Tdani81 4 years ago
The man addresses Paul as "William". The idea is that Paul's replacement after his death was a man by the name on William Campbell. Noticed a few people didn't quite get that one. Personally I don't believe any of it at all. But I love the vids. So observant
andrewjamesguy 4 years ago
ohh yeeeeeahhh!
nickbear138 4 years ago
Thank you for that. I actually am skeptical about the theory, but people have done much investigation into it. This actually isn't the first time Paul has been called "William" or "Billy".
hercarebear2 4 years ago
I know he says something.... I just can't decipher it. Will someone please let me know what happens in this one???
hercarebear2 4 years ago
Paul is saying "That bitch Heather Mills is NOT going to take all my money - I'll beat the shit out of her again!!" but maybe I am wrong -- not sure if he says "bitch" or "stumped legged whore"
Earthlinked 4 years ago
i dont follow all of this "PAUL IS DEAD" shit! What the hell?!!?!!! he is NEVER going to die... and i think you people must be waiting for it to happen if you are putting this shit on here.. paul is dead... yeah what the fuck ever!
swimmyswimmy13 4 years ago
William Campbell was Billy Shears
ForYouBlue1969 4 years ago
Great job, iamaphoney ! It's so clear !
Truthseeker47 4 years ago
johnpaulolivier, you're going to scare the straights !
Truthseeker47 4 years ago
waaa?? i dont follow
shyface52 4 years ago
I Know WHAT!
Beatlepaul42 4 years ago
this is amazing !
peabodyenergy 4 years ago
sorry..."X men movie"... I don´t know actor´s name...
gugundo 4 years ago
were did yo get that?
"X Men"´s wolverine looks like Jhon by the way...
gugundo 4 years ago
I have to say I am a MAJOR Beatles fan and if there's one thing I've marveled at is how mind-numbingly consistent Paul is in his speech pattern, facial expressions and gestures. The Paul of 2007 is quite clearly the Paul of 1964. I've also enjoyed the "Paul is dead because he sucks solo" comments but I must ask you....could George Harrison really be the same guy who wrote "Here Come The Sun" and then "Gone Troppo"?
ghostysshow 4 years ago
If you put yesterday backwards it says: stick that rumour up yer bollocks ye cunt!!!!!!!!!! I'm on vacation!!!!!
obexley7 4 years ago
stop arguing about something so pathetic you geeks your all losers why dont you go out and get girlfriends
tonymontana1974 4 years ago
You're in real trouble, Tony Montana. You're starting to smoke your own cocaine.
HaHaHaPaulIsDead 4 years ago
John is Paul. Paul is dead!!! Facetransplantation!!!
johnpaulolivier 4 years ago
what was the clue in this?
itaigalgal 4 years ago
He introduced Paul as Willam. Billy is short for William. Fake Paul is Billy Shears.
GFA80 4 years ago 2
google william campbell
floydian709 4 years ago
No, it's jsut that iamaphoney is a phoney himself.
JamesStarkweather 4 years ago
No you idiot. It's because he is taking a break until
November. He's doing research, as well as who knows what else. For all you know he could be working out and getting in shape so he could apply for a job as one of Paul's guards at his ranch. Then, when they're in private, he could tie him up and interview him.
Just a thought.
RockXLight 4 years ago
No you dickwad. It's because he got caught and trust me he's already been to Paul's ranch. Look it up...
JamesStarkweather 4 years ago
First off, I don't recall addressing that comment to you, so I don't know where you get off calling me a dickwad. And if you're referring to that guy who was in the news not too long ago, the one who broke in yelling "I must see him", I already knew about that. Do I think it was him? Very possible. I think he has gotten in trouble...with Apple at least. Thats why some of his videos got pulled, maybe?
RockXLight 4 years ago
What about Ringo's "Don't Pass Me By"?
"You were in a car crash
and you lost your hair."
dougplank 5 years ago
wow, its been over two weeks since the last video was posted. are you discontinuing the series? did you get threats by people or MPL or something?
killjoy202 5 years ago
I realy appreciate all these movies you've made! I'm doing a research on the "Paul is Dead" hoax right now and watching all these videos has helped a lot.
Dolfinz1991 5 years ago
Great clue!!! I have seen this movie a thousand times and I never realized this
I'm shocked!!
34bx 5 years ago
Wow, I´ve also seen a lot of times that movie and never noticed that part... amazing... you know William, lol. I don´t want to wait till November, that´s too much time!!!! don´t goooooooo :)
marcoabz 5 years ago
Dont get me wrong, i love this theory... but its the old man whos called William... hence he is saying it TO Paul "You've met william"... check imdb if you dont believe me, actor - Frank Duncan ... nevertheness this rotten apple series is remarkable. I cannot wait for this rumoured movie.
mapples3b 5 years ago
Would make a good movie. What if the rumor was true?
tecpaocelotl 5 years ago
november is the month in which there will come a movie called; At Savile Row, We Swore. made by iamaphoney
MikeyNL1038 5 years ago
When did iamaphoney ever announce a movie? I mean, I had heard about a movie, but I always figured the youtube clips *were* the movie....
RockXLight 5 years ago
And why November? Is that when Paul died, in November 1966 (I thought it was that or September)?
RockXLight 5 years ago
Noooo! Don't go! Are we really going to have to wait until NOVEMBER to see the continuation (or conclusion) of The Rotten Apple series?
*Sigh*
If so, then farewell for now, Apaul Corps..
RockXLight 5 years ago
Billy himself
JohnnyAqua 5 years ago
What film is that from?? that is just a breathtakingly blatent "clue".Great find.
aEnthrallya 5 years ago
Give my regards to broad street
abbyroadme 5 years ago
I have seen that movie millions of times...never noticed that.
abbyroadme 5 years ago
man, you've got to keep this running, it's simply mindblowing. Cheers
RichardStarkey23 5 years ago
dude... omg!
Frozensquirrel 5 years ago
I love these. May I ask what happened to the other ones, if if they'll be coming back soon?
luisascavo 5 years ago