Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (65)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Did he overwrite Mr. Bean to record this? Tough call, but I think it was the right choice.

  • Love this song but it's painful to watch what drugs can do to you, gave up a long time ago but it hurts to see those that weren't able to get clean and sober no matter how brilliant they are. Merry Christmas, mates!

  • What makes this song so incredibly resonating is that the words are sad and very true that apply to Shane. He's a talent that is flawed by the addiction he so poignantly sings of. This is a magnificently haunting tune

  • By far the best Christmas song for ages.. I luv Shane (piss ead) and Kirsty is A star

  • He is only 40 in this clip; but looks much much much older due to the years of alcohol.

  • He does not play the piano

  • fun fact - the legend that shane is cant play the piano

  • @barky87 shane can play the piano he is just to out of it here to even sing. he probably turned up like this and they had to mime it in the state he was in. but he can def play the piano.

  • @atourdeforce i dont think he can, sure even in the fairytale of new york video it isnt shane playing the piano its one of his bandmates with shanes jacket on

  • @barky87 he can play the bodhran, guitar, piano,harmonica and banjo, altho some he plays more than most, he doesnt many instruments too often live because he has the rest of the bad, the reason he doesnt play on ftony is because he didnt play that piano part in the first place he only sits at the piano there to set an ambiance.

  • @atourdeforce i really dont think he can play the piano, its been said in interviews by people who work with him that he cant play the piano because of the joke made that his bandmate wouldnt wear his jacket to look like him while shooting the music vid because it smelled...i could be wrong but im gonna believe people who know him over a youtuber

  • Who would have thought looking at them both back in 97 that Shane would out live Kirsty by so long.

  • Man, he looks exactly as drunk as he sounds....

  • I saw Mr Bean in the beginning LOL!!

  • Classic!

  • never seen Shane lip-sink before. hahahah.

  • Looks so fake lol

  • Lip syncing is silly, but I doubt Shane would have done much of a performance looking at him here. It's sad to see someone so wasted. :(

  • @forgetfulmuse

    lip sync was standard on tv in the 80's. Artist were asked in alot of shows, so i gues that it was way cheaper than let a whole band play and do sound checks and whatever it takes for a life performance.

    Anyway, if they would bring back 80's television back, i wouldn't mind the lip sync, because it's always better

    than the crap that is shown today on tv. 

  • i really gotta stop drinking

  • both lip syncing... boo!

  • PLAYBACK?

  • FFS! that shits me that some shows don't let you play live. Personally I wouldn't do it! And can someone tell me what happened to kirsty? I only got into them recently and tried to find out but there's no info about it.

    RIP Kirsty

  • @nightfireadam it's on wikipedia (too sad or I'd recount)

  • @stjulienlepauvre Thanks I looked it up that's sad but honorable of her. and to the Mexicans involved, that's fucking disgusting behavior! those people involved should be fucking shot!... twice!!!!

    Thanks again for the info. :)

  • classic song makes me proud to be part irish, i love this band! kirstys voice is beautiful r.i.p. makes me wanna leave so cal and hit up galway-ireland.

  • anyone thought hes putting it on, i saw him on harry hill and there was nowt wrong and he sang the same way

  • i love this song but even for Shane's standards this is very disappointing he is not playing the piano,he is completely fucked on whatever he was smoking and kirsty is lipsyncing weak performance all im saying

  • shane drunk as a skunk not singing or playing the piano lol stone dead! kirsty of course lip sinc! lol RIP kirsty macColl

  • WDC LAD?, story horse! SHAAAAAAAM

  • hows the craic shane ,, may the ground come up to meet ya ,,,,rip kirsty mcoll

  • love  this , rip kirsty xx

  • best christmas song ever....R.I.P Kirsty MacColl....btw is this song big in America???

  • @COCKYBOiii yeah, I'd say it is popular in the US. Definitely big here in New York. Probably not as massive as it is in Ireland or UK. My UK friend says it is too cliche, overplayed in Britain. Definitely not a problem here. Not nearly as big as, say, Lennon's Happy Xmas

  • @COCKYBOiii mostly with Pogue fans over this side of the Pond other then that not so much defiantly something I LOVE to listen to on Christmas ever since I discovered the band only 3 years ago

  • lol this is dead.

  • A modern day Christmas classic to go along with those from Como, Sinatra, Ives, Crosby, Cole et al!

  • woah woah woah... you taped over mr bean?

  • skit i shane det är den bästa jullåten som någonsin skrivits passar så bra för vuxna men inte för barn

    

  • He is a fucking wreck here, its obvious at least shane is lip syncing, and was not playing the piano for sure...I feel really bad for him.

  • This is so depressing. It's so obvious they're lip synching. Shane makes me want to cry.

  • @kerrygrrl most bands lip sync on lives shows like this

  • and the boys of the NYPD chior where singing Galway Bay .....

  • hes fuckin fucked up dude..

  • thats Shane Mc Gowan he aint fucked up - thats him

  • He's not drunk, he's goofin' on heroin. Sad to see Shaneo like this. He's much better now thank God, he's off the gear.

  • My god he looks bad I wouldn't hav let him perform god he look ill but I luv this song sooooooooo much

    RIP Kirsty

  • he looks like hes stoned

  • they shouldnt have allowed them to go out like that..its such a shame watching him like that...

  • That's heroin. He was probably drunk at the time as well. Kristy looks pretty pissed off.

  • lol, yeah, he's definitely drunk. he looked about ready to fall asleep, lol. kinda funny, but sad.

  • The whole thing is just them miming along to the playback. Unfortunate, but I wouldn't have done it live with Shane in that condition (as per)... Still, gorgeous song! And Shane MacGowan is musical genius!

    RIP Kirsty

  • I dont think shane is even singing the start of it, actually is it all dubbed

  • This was over ten years ago! He just seems a tad tired...

  • is there something wrong with Shane MacGowan

  • C2H5OH

  • C2H5OH ?

  • C2H5OH

  • Bless him, yes there is

  • he is drunk ha

  • ues hes an alcoholic, and a bad one at that

  • THIS videos IS BAD

  • cheers for posting all these shane videos. love him.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more