Added: 3 years ago
From: stewfig
Views: 40,880
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (370)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow! this is AMAZING! he's such a great singer!!!!! x]

  • awh:) so cute:)

  • bah i graduated with that mother fucker he's chill

  • guys he auditioned for a popular show we will see him soon :D

  • I agree. I like it better than Leona Lewise's version too.

  • I love him haha. SO fun to party with :) 

  • Out of tune guitar :P

  • I grew up with nate <3

    We both lived in Malone :D

  • I actually like this more than Leona Lewise's o.O

  • I love this fabulous man. Even if he did lose the Hollister hoodie I let him borrow. He's one of the funniest guys I've known. Drag Queens. I'm tellin ya... : )

  • he went to my skewl!

  • i really wanna know what he was gonna say at the end... >.>

  • I know Nate. Coming from the same town as him, I knew him in high school and even had to deal with him last semester at college. He has a decent voice, but he only thinks of himself. Nobody else. Nobody. He respects nobody, breaks rules in order to "win", and always needs a way to make himself seem like the best. No matter where he goes he always needs a reason to sing or play his guitar, even in situations like in the middle of class. He has no modesty, and has an unsatisfying ego. That's Nate.

  • @Mangekyu10 i also know Nate and he's nothing like what you explained. Maybe you should either get to know him or stop being so jealous

  • @OsakaKillerBunny Hold on, jealous? I will tell you straight out. Just about nobody in Malone, where he comes from and where people know the real Nate Marshall, is jealous of Nate. So, he doesn't break rules to win? I guess you didn't go to the birthday party at Titus Mountain he went to. He and friends played capture the flag with little flags. Instead of following the rules, he went outside of the building to catch the enemy flag. He then kept insisting he won, even though he knew the rules.

  • @Mangekyu10 i also know nate and he is a really good person. it may look different in your eyes but ur one of few who think that way

  • @Mangekyu10 HAHAHA OMG! I WAS THERE!! Fo realz!!! ;D straight up lawlz but srsly, that is why we stuck to hide n seek afterwards HAHA

  • @Mangekyu10 however can I just say this, you were not there?!?! D: D: D: and Hide N seek/war was fo realz my idea and this is why i was just like NO after that fight we're playing HIDE N SEEK AGAIN...NO ONE FOUGHT. Besides, G had the best hiding place ever. Inside a trash can. LMFAO

  • he's a sweet kid, lives down the hall from me. he's loud, loud, loud, but a sweetheart none the less. lol

  • he cant go back to idol cuz he already made it to the top 36...rules are once you make it to any of the TOP # you cant go back...when i went to the auditions those were part of the rules

  • Nathaniel you have a beautiful voice! I was hoping to see you on idol again this year....you were so close last year and should have made it through! Keep blessing us with your talent!

  • My grandma lives in Malone and knows him. =] I think he's adorable.

  • love the song, love his voice, love him. 5*

  • i personally like this song with him singing itmore than i do the original singer he sounds so sweet

  • i know him personally and he came to my school and performed bc my friend is like his cuz so he cam to talk to me after

  • he is so sweet and talented. loved his version of this song.

  • ive gotta admit, out of all the contestants, nathaniel is the one id mostly like to meet and be friends with.

    I LOVE HIM!!!!!!! hes such an amazing guy!!!

    and i love his sensitive side too! its so cute!!!

    im one of his biggest fans!

    <3<3<3<3<3 LOVE U NATHANIEL!!!!!

  • I love Nathaniel, he is amazing, he should have won, i wish i could meet him someday, he is my biggest inspiration, i wish i could meet him, really. hes amazing :], ♥nathaniel♥

  • he lives like 10-15 minutes away from me, he us to be in sadd and he was at some of my school dances, hes really awesome in person, and really good at the limbo haha

  • I was so upset when he got kicked off american idol :[[

    I think he should have won <33

  • i wish he would have won too!!!!!hes amazing!! <3 <3

  • love him<3333

  • You are an amazing musician once again!!  Absolutely blessed!! What a gift!

  • I LOVE THIS SONG!!! nathaniel you are AMAZING no lieee, BAM ! you gooo!

    ♥nathaniel!!♥

  • WOOP WOOP! go nathaniel! :D

  • those piercings are too sexy, lol!

  • I LOVE HIM SO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i swear they only cut him because he didn't choose a song that is playing on the mainstream pop stations 24/7. his voice is so beautiful.

  • AWW HES SOO CUTE<3 and hes a really good singerr

  • I love his voice!!

  • he should of sang this on ai...i def think he should of made it farther than he did

  • he used to go to my high school

  • ur good;)

  • He is such an awesome singer

  • Everyone has that shirt:/

    -looks in the hamper-

    Yep.

  • my Gf is his cousin

  • who are you?

  • i love gay men!

  • love him so much he shoulda won and i luv adam lambert to but they both shoulda been in a tie he has such a great personality

  • Who filimed this?? who did it is SO lucky!

  • hah he's wearing a chiodos shirt<3 c:

  • he was better here than on american idol haha

  • totally agree! except the fact that his guitar is painfully out of tune here..haha

  • speechless <3

  • I love him, he has a great voice. he was one of my favorite american idol contestants beside sexy ass Adam Lambert<3!

  • totally agree I just saw him but if I had found him sooner he would have totally been my favorite contestant next to Adam and Allison. Fyi I missed the weeks before the top 13 were annouced.

  • I agree!!!! I loved them both!

  • @juno1055 Hehe I have college english with him. ^_^

  • @juno1055 i met him in rl

  • @juno1055 Same! lol

  • and adam lamdert isn't gay or emo??

    your fuckin dumb

  • Um Adam Lambert is gay, but that duznt change anything. hes still an amazing artist and an awesome person..but yeah he is gay. not emo though.

  • Hmf. Gay or emo? Doesn't have anything to do with his voice. Which is great. <3 x'3

  • i love him!!!!!!!!

  • OHMYGAWSH

    Im about to start crying. I dont even freakin no why. Erg.

    I <3 you nate. I really dooooo!

  • i was hanging with nate last week it was preaty kool it was amazing he sang "halo" for us and i almost cried

  • You hung out with Nathaniel Marshall??!

  • that was really REALLY good... he should have made top 13.. it was that horrible song choice that did him in... whether or not he actually had say in what he was going to sing for semifinals, who knows... idol is notorious for manipulating things to get the final 2 that they want

  • Aweh, The little girl is so cute.

    I love Nathaniel, he was my favourite,

    I was devestated when he didn't make it,

  • I would have actually liked him in the top 13. Because I couldn't stand quite a few people in the top 13.

  • exactly!!! defenitly you are right!:D

  • He definetly should've made it over Jorge.

  • nathaniel to me you ARE MY american idol!

  • thats offensive. it doesnt matter if your gay or straight and what is wrong with being emotional? soryy but last time I checked Adam Lambert is actually gay. so please dont criticize him negatively.

  • nathaniel was just too emotional for america i suppose but i think he is an amazing talent and 100 times better than a lot of the people that went further... i hope he never gives up his dream

    he's young

    he still has time to realize all his dreams

    he has the best voice

    and sometimes emotion makes an artist

    i love nathaniel

    and

    adam

    and allison

  • ohmygod i love him!!! hes so good i wanted to cry when he got voted off!!!!!

  • i love his version of th song.

    he's such a good singer.

  • i fucking love him~

    i wanted to cry when he got voted off,

  • omg I LOVE HIM I WANTED HIM TO MAKE IT HE SOUNDS RLY GOOD IN THIS VID.!!!!!

  • He haves a great voice!

  • Wow this is an amazing version, by an amazing singer!! Love Ya Nate!

  • oh if for some reason you can't get to Nate's fan site with the info below, message me and I will send you the link as links can't be posted in the comments

    I just love this song by him..thank you so much for posting it. He did such a good job on it

  • <333

    hesa hottie... i just cant believe he got voted off..

    i love adam.. but i think hes better anyday!

  • i cant believe he got voted off he deserved to stay in the competition longer then he did and he has an awesome voice i think he should just start singing

  • How awesome!! I love him! Great voice

  • thanks for posting the . I had to change Nate's fan club to a new web address

    it is

    2natemarshalldotforumcabdotcom replace words dot with a period.

    or go to forumcab click on hosted forums at the top then scroll down to tv and movies and then Nate's headbanders. Come on over Nate fans just opened the new site. Had to close forumslands one due to connection problems

  • That guitar is SO OUT OF TUNE, can barely stand it. However, his voice is INCREDIBLE. Good job bro.

  • cody , kristen, and nathaniel are my fave idols who did not make it to top 12...

    cody can still join idol but kristen and nathaniel can't... huhu *sob*sob

  • What Are you talking about? Nathaniel is only 19 years old. There are people on american idol that are older than him.

    And his sexual orientation has nothing to do with it because adam might be bisexual or gay or straight. so what excactly are you talking about?

  • gender or sexual whatever has nothing to do with another chance for idol...

    kristen and nathaniel made it through top 36.. they are not allowed to join again... thank god, cody did not made it so he still have a chance... understand now?

  • i miss him...he deserved to make it further in the competition.

    btw this video is lovely =)

  • i wish he'd have made it. I sure would have voted for him!

  • how can u not love him.

  • He came to my school today and preformed in my class and OMG was he fantastic!! I Love Him!!! When he played this song for us i started to cry it was so great!!!

  • omg  lucky!!!! that awesome

  • Gosh, the judges weren't very fair to him or Cody Sheldon, because Cody didn't even make the top 36, and Nate should have been chosen for the wild card instead of the STUPID Tatiana! Oh my gosh, she get on my nerves. This was REALLY good, and thanks for posting this.

    I love you CoDy and NaTe. (:

    <33 Jamie

  • you know adam and him are gay im suprised they didnt end up going out

  • wow. roackalldaygirl...thats kind of ignorant.

  • I agree with whatsupfizznugget , that is VERY ignorant.

    I'm assuming you like guys, right? Do YOU date every guy you meet? Seriously... don't be so narrow-minded. =|

  • he shuld've flippin stayed!!!!!!!

  • agreeded butterredtoast21

  • I met him. He now resides in Vermont a few towns away from me. He works in the mall

  • i did too! at the champlain chocolates store, he was so nice! i love him <33333

  • ur soo lucky

  • He is better than a few of the remaining contestants....

    He should have went farther.

  • i was so pissed when he was voted off i mean come on he is a great singer the only reason they voted him off iz bcuz he is gay him being gay dnt mean he cnt sing he should have been in the top 13

  • LUCKY LUCKY LUCKY!!!!!!!!!!!

    oh my gosh!!! he is so hot!!!!!!!

    dude i cried when they voted him off!

  • I was so pissed when they voted him off. i felt like kicking seacrest in the mouth. no offense to seacreast though.

  • Ah, I still love this song. Been listening to it every night since March. I love his cover. I actually like it better than the original.

    He's voice is like an angel. (:

    <3 Anna

  • I love Nathaniel! I screamed so loud when they voted him off. I don't know why they would do that. <3

  • aww. why did he have to get kicked off. that mad me so mad. the only reason i still am watching is becuase of Adam Lambert.

  • oh how i love that boy so much. he is amazingggggg <3 !! -- adam lambert is also my fav.

    youre so lucky you got your own lil personal concert. im sooo jealous !! =D

  • at 0:04 to 0:07!!

    He's so beautifull

  • Omg

    I wish he stayed.

    His voice is amazing <3 <3

    The way he grins at the cameraaa

  • love him!

    <3

  • he's so amaaaaaaaaaaaaazingg

  • He's amazing & was definately one of my favorites. I was really disappointed that he didn't get another shot in the wildcard round.

  • Comment removed

  • amazing

  • i love megan joy she is so funny i love her so much luv you megan joy and u 2 riderbaby!

  • is he singing @ like a walmart or something? wow.  He's talented... i'd be afraid of people staring @ me if i were just sitting on the floor singing in the middle of a store. yeah, he wuz really dramatic on the show, but i liked him, bu my favorite is definitley danny gokey- ooohhhhh or adam lambert! I dunno.

  • he's great

    message me for fansite on myspace

  • he has a good voice and the only reason he was voted off is cuz of all the drama. I like him!

  • He really should of been up there instead of.... one person.... that just elimated tonight. Finally.

    I miss him. I still listen to him, this video, every night before I go to bed. I'm doing it now. Haha. Then I'll shut off my computer and go to bed. Well, yeah. Haha.

    <3 Anna

  • he really annoyed me with all of the emotional stuff but he sounds good! :)

  • he shud of stayed!!!!!!!!! but i <3 adam lambert

  • !! i went to dulles airport before!

  • Love his voice.

  • this sounds so gooooooood

  • this song is the best awsome :]

    <3333333333

  • wow

  • love him:)

  • nate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

  • he really have a good voice..

    T_T

    i <3 him

  • I love him he such a good guy

  • i love him too hes dope

  • i love that boy(:

    he inspires me .

    i wish i could have met him.

  • me too

  • I wish he would have made it further.

  • I FKN LOOOOVE HIM!!!

  • he was on american idol duhhhhh but he didnt make it to a time

  • He should have sang that on american idol

  • hey nate this is lauren breanna and cammie marshall from malone we know that u know hailey trim and celeste marshall we do 2 hope u r looking forward 2 hanging out with us and celeste!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!,­<3<3<3

  • Whoa, that gave me chills. Beautiful. Made me tear up a bit, actually.

    Nate is awesome. 'Nuff said. =)

  • I love him. (=

  • love the voice!

  • i love him!!!!!!

  • omfg omfg i love nate sooooo much.

    hes so gorgeous im inspired by him! <333

  • aww how cute bethany, hehe you wrote that in reading club XD

  • yes yess !

  • aw i love nathaniel! i'm terribly upset that he got voted off :( he definitely could have won! i'm sure i speak for everyone when i say that you're incredibly lucky to have met him and i'm very jealous! :) xoxo

  • I didn't want him to leaveee, he was *and still is* really good.

  • i hope u go to record studio and record ur version of bleeding love ! i really like ur version

  • totally agree! he should have done this song in the top 36 and he may have made it top 13!

  • Hope we hear from u again!

  • he got voted off?!!?  awh he was awsome! :(

  • I saw him today downtown :D

  • Nate has a good voice, he actually lives in the same town as me which is pretty cool.

  • He really should of made it.

    I mean, c'mon. He's voice is like an angel.

    I love this cover. It's like the best I've ever heard.

    I love you, Nate. I know you'll get signed one day.

    <3 Anna

  • I LOVE NATE!<3

    hes everything. i voted for him like a million times. and if saw him at the airport like this girl did, i would give him the hugest hug ever and like never let go! i love him that muchhhh. hes amazing. and hot. lol(:

  • God you're increadibly lucky.

    xD

    I hope you got a picture with him, haha.

    [[[[:

  • i think i have like the EXACT same guitar :]]

  • he was so goodd! and such a great personality. He puts such a unique spin on covers/other songs. He should have sang this song on american idol.

  • I JUST LOVE HIM :) <3

    He should win

  • Goodness he makes me smile.

    Grr....stupid america didnt vote for him =(

    but i still love you Nattteeee!

  • people don't understand your emotional sensitivity, depth, and intensity/your true passion for your dreams & to overcome struggles.I do understand as I'm like that too

    Remember Nate "All progress occurs because people dare to be different."-- Harry Millner

    "History has demonstrated that the most notable winners usually encountered heartbreaking obstacles before they triumphed. They won because they refused to become discouraged by their defeats"

    -- Bertie C. Forbes

    in dark hours, remember that

  • this is one of my favorites songs of Nate's..thanks for recording it. I also loved I would do anything./you really PERFORMED that song I could not see a single mistake..I agree you did not need to change a thing..everything.your pre-video, how you showed us who you really are more, your reactions to the judges,how everything seriously, Nathaniel, you did everything right and Simon was crazy. Everything you got bashed for was just completely human and normal reactions. Please visit the fansite