Very nice interpretation of this piece! Others are complaining about the speed, but in this piece it's particularly good to not constantly use the same speed.
Could you consider recording the piece again after tuning your piano though? The instrument is really terribly false.
Oh, and lol@comments about SS. How could they have used a song as marching song that didn't have its premiere in current form before 1940?
true but in this case you can clearly see that the pianist is compensating the errors with speeding up... it is not a controled variation but a nervous result.....
Great job! i've heard a few people play this...or attempt, and they always just gave up!
congrats on going all the way through!
(i'm sure by now you've basically perfected it! and...like so many others, i was wondering if you could send me the music too? Hate to be a bother, but i'd really appreciate it!)
I like this piece best when people do "rough" recordings of it, yours especially. I feel that it calls for a bit of messiness, like it might just spill over & start ripping the piano apart. Lovely...
I liked a lot the general "feeling" your playing has apart some minor things like that pause at 1:39 and some other minor little things here and there
But despite that I liked your version more than all the others on youtube :-)
@annilien HI!! Can you send me the music sheet since he's sent it to you already :D I'm afraid he might be too overwhelmed with the asking if I ask myself....
Wow you played this piece of music so beautifully :) also for my music assessment i have to do a version of this song but with added effects and stuff, and i was wondering if there was any chance of you sending me the chords ? maybe only the beginning bit if you like, because i know you have a LOT of people asking! .. but i would really appreciate it .. thank you ! :)
Very nice! I just started listening today, and really like your version of it. Also,,, may i have music please? I thank you in advance. i put this in my favorites...
Great job! I love this song! I just played this in my orchestra! I played one of the French Horn parts. We had to hand out music back in, so I was really sad... I play the piano as well...
Would you please send me the sheet music?.... I would absolutely love to attempt this on my piano!
hey, i am auditioning to be drum major of my highschool marching band and this is the piece i am preparing to conduct, so i was wondering, if its not too much trouble, if you could send me the music also... Thanks for your time!
oh, i would be very pleased if you could send the sheets to me too !!! thanks a lot ! in fact, i think people believe it's german ss march because someone created a video about that subject with prokofiev's romeo and juliet... honestly, i think it is not the real ss march (they probably used wagner or stuff like that)
oh, and by the way, the guy that posted a german comment says that you should use a metronom (which is not very nice to hear, i guess) because you play faster at certain moments, but he says that you did a very good job ! ^^ that's true
Très bien joué! j'ai toujours rêver d'avoir cette partition. Je sais qu'on te l'a déjà demandé ms est ce que tu pourrais aussi me l'envoyer s'il te plait!
merci! j'ai essaye d'avoir un angle different, quelque chose un peu different. tu dois apprendre cette chanson, ce n'est pas trop difficile et c'est tres amusant.
This is an amzing song. I have never learned to play piano but I want to. Im getting lessons next year and I'll try learn this song when I get good at it. I envy your talent
Great! Could you send me the sheet music?
connorzwick 9 months ago
INCREDIBLEEE!!!
shanedawsonindo 1 year ago
This is incredible! I feel inspired.
I realise everyone's asking this, but could you please send me the sheets?
Sniknejyoreel 1 year ago
I needs sheeteths as well! Can plz giveth to me... eth
pokenerd99 1 year ago
Not good.
gladir360 1 year ago
Amazing!
Could you send me the sheet music please?
ashelia0dalmasca 1 year ago
i'm sobbing and crying. you forgot the second tranquillo part, which is one of the most touching ideas i ever heard in Prokofievs compositions. :´(
agrimm61 1 year ago
@agrimm61
yeah, same here, i'm learning this piece just to get to that part lol
burrtec3 3 months ago
Bravo!
legalsilk 1 year ago
Beautiful movement! If you are willing, sheet music would be much appreciated!
MsHallo1985 1 year ago
average.....
justinneversleep 1 year ago
Awesome. can you send me the sheet music please? what type of piano are you playing?
morchie717 1 year ago
Excellent. I can´t say more because I have no words to express how it is beautiful...
Nozdormuvecny 1 year ago
I really want the sheet music! Please, could you send it to me? I'll send you a message with my email.Thanks!
katerinasemionovna 1 year ago
Awsome ! May You send me a music sheets on email ? THANX !
kejmilll 1 year ago
Please send me the sheet music I'm so desperate I can't find it anywhere on the internet please !
jay123321321 1 year ago
Good effort, but very chaotic, many errors and no control over interpretation...
try to find inner peace, and once you are in control of your emotions, the music should come through... Keep up the good job ;)
mariachibuster 2 years ago
Cool! Would you please send me the sheet music for this?
Rhogitrad 2 years ago
Very nice interpretation of this piece! Others are complaining about the speed, but in this piece it's particularly good to not constantly use the same speed.
Could you consider recording the piece again after tuning your piano though? The instrument is really terribly false.
Oh, and lol@comments about SS. How could they have used a song as marching song that didn't have its premiere in current form before 1940?
hsnieman 2 years ago
Very true, this piece should not be played at the same speed throughout - parts of the piece alternate between a 4/4 and 3/4 time signature.
KIDD120387 2 years ago
true but in this case you can clearly see that the pianist is compensating the errors with speeding up... it is not a controled variation but a nervous result.....
mariachibuster 2 years ago
Savage. Well done!!!
thestig007000 2 years ago
i want to play this, too :/
History94lps 2 years ago
damn! that was very well played!
cheers!
shrineofmadlaughter 2 years ago
Loved it!!!
julialegrande 2 years ago
thats preety good. i never much fancied the piano version myself, but this isn't that bad.
SManifestosSkatastic 2 years ago
great!!!!!!!
fatinadelbosco 2 years ago
Fantastic sound!
Kastanienzweig 2 years ago
Great job! i've heard a few people play this...or attempt, and they always just gave up!
congrats on going all the way through!
(i'm sure by now you've basically perfected it! and...like so many others, i was wondering if you could send me the music too? Hate to be a bother, but i'd really appreciate it!)
funirishtraveler 2 years ago
i played the same version!! but it was to difficult for me!! :)
Very good!!!
raphineu 2 years ago
I like this piece best when people do "rough" recordings of it, yours especially. I feel that it calls for a bit of messiness, like it might just spill over & start ripping the piano apart. Lovely...
lustyrevelwenches 2 years ago
Oh my god. This is epic. Could you please send me the sheet music?
Fenrisulfr94 2 years ago 6
LOVELY!
slater4cc 2 years ago
Tuto skladbu miluju!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
úžasné
jitulkovy 2 years ago
I just subscribed to your channel. Congratulations for your nice works. I'd be grateful if you send me the sheet for this music. Thanks beforehand.
alitalia5 2 years ago
This is the best version on Youtube. Does anyone have free piano sheet music to it? Thanks, and great playing!
Webrider101 2 years ago
Ahaha I'm trying to play this on a keyboard with nowhere near enough keys... Nicely played, thanks for the decent angle to learn from :)
bingbangkoala 2 years ago
great!
bubbubbub 2 years ago
You are good!
And I know many ppl has asked u this before, but can u send the sheet music pls?
thx
IanTanYeeEn 2 years ago
sent
WWNS 3 years ago
You are impressive. :)
I can't read sheets, but the video itself is still helpful for learning by watching and listening and ear and so forth. So yeah, thank you for this.
Kat6295 3 years ago
this angle in particular should help with that, hope that goes well
WWNS 3 years ago
I liked a lot the general "feeling" your playing has apart some minor things like that pause at 1:39 and some other minor little things here and there
But despite that I liked your version more than all the others on youtube :-)
kokobil 3 years ago
yeah this was a quick one take.
glad you enjoyed it!
WWNS 3 years ago
hey, very nice playing!
could you please send me the music sheets ? I really want to learn this on my piano : )
annilien 3 years ago
just sent it
enjoy
WWNS 3 years ago
@annilien HI!! Can you send me the music sheet since he's sent it to you already :D I'm afraid he might be too overwhelmed with the asking if I ask myself....
patkaybites 2 months ago
Wow you played this piece of music so beautifully :) also for my music assessment i have to do a version of this song but with added effects and stuff, and i was wondering if there was any chance of you sending me the chords ? maybe only the beginning bit if you like, because i know you have a LOT of people asking! .. but i would really appreciate it .. thank you ! :)
TashaRuby08 3 years ago
ah thanks for the kind words
just sent it
WWNS 3 years ago
Very nice! I just started listening today, and really like your version of it. Also,,, may i have music please? I thank you in advance. i put this in my favorites...
348Frate 2 years ago
Hi..Very Nicely Done:) awesome.
++COULD I ALSO PLEASE HAVE THE MUSIC SHEET?? I want to try this on my keyboard..
Nitrazepam000 3 years ago
sure thing
sent
WWNS 3 years ago
HAWAY THE LADS
glennw1002 3 years ago
Wow this is really good. Can you send me the sheet music too by any chance? I'd love to learn this. Thanks!
You did a really good job playing this piece by the way. I was very impressed.
Shoodlemeep 3 years ago
thanks!
sent
WWNS 3 years ago
this is amazing!!!! I would love to do this for my music practical is there any chance you could send me the music sheets please thanks!
Mariapbuckley 3 years ago
thanks
just sent it
WWNS 3 years ago
Great job! I love this song! I just played this in my orchestra! I played one of the French Horn parts. We had to hand out music back in, so I was really sad... I play the piano as well...
Would you please send me the sheet music?.... I would absolutely love to attempt this on my piano!
Ellhime 3 years ago
The horn parts in the original ballet sound really fun/difficult.
check your pm
WWNS 3 years ago
hey, i am auditioning to be drum major of my highschool marching band and this is the piece i am preparing to conduct, so i was wondering, if its not too much trouble, if you could send me the music also... Thanks for your time!
P.S. very nice job playing!
erikmiddlechild 3 years ago
just sent it, goodluck with your audition
I'm glad I could help
WWNS 3 years ago
I know this is a hassle for you, as so many people are asking, but if you could please send it to me as well?
I would be entirely grateful; but if you dont want to, I understand.
alexatetris 3 years ago
oh, i would be very pleased if you could send the sheets to me too !!! thanks a lot ! in fact, i think people believe it's german ss march because someone created a video about that subject with prokofiev's romeo and juliet... honestly, i think it is not the real ss march (they probably used wagner or stuff like that)
MoNdRaGoN03 3 years ago
check your inbox for the sheet music!
and yeah, that would be kind of funny for Hitler to use music from a Romeo and Juliet ballet
WWNS 3 years ago
oh, and by the way, the guy that posted a german comment says that you should use a metronom (which is not very nice to hear, i guess) because you play faster at certain moments, but he says that you did a very good job ! ^^ that's true
MoNdRaGoN03 3 years ago
hah I see. thanks much
WWNS 3 years ago
Great job,
I wonder if you can send me the score in PDF.
Thanks
louismagie 3 years ago
I love this. Have you got the digital sheet music from it. If so, I would be grateful if you could send it to me.
ww2233A 3 years ago
Metronom... du hetzt bei manchen Stellen schade.und dann wieder zu langsam aber sonst ist es schon ganz nett.
wiesnase8 3 years ago
uhhhh nope, don't know german
or whatever that is
WWNS 3 years ago
lol.. wuts up with all the french in your comments?
jigt23 3 years ago
no clue, I don't know how they know that I know french
..that was a weird sentense
WWNS 3 years ago
its german dude and its because this was the marching song to hitlers S.S.
EIPtuningR32 3 years ago
where did you read that?
and this song isn't german.
WWNS 3 years ago
my god, nothing beats people's stupidity!
why on earth would hitler's SS march to music by a RUSSIAN composer?
just STFU
gibbons2000 3 years ago
Please, could I get the score too ?
many thanks!!
spamat38 3 years ago
I can't stop listening it
spamat38 3 years ago
Superbe !
je cherche la partition, si tu peux me dire ou tu l'as eut ^^
Merci.
musevideo 3 years ago
merci!
Je l'ai dans mon autre ordinateur.
Je l'enverrai vous quand j'ai le temps :]
WWNS 3 years ago
cool merci car j'arrive pas a la trouver la partition snif
musevideo 3 years ago
Très bien joué! j'ai toujours rêver d'avoir cette partition. Je sais qu'on te l'a déjà demandé ms est ce que tu pourrais aussi me l'envoyer s'il te plait!
worldfullofshoes 3 years ago
ah bien sur! je t'ai envoyé un message
WWNS 3 years ago
sind viel falsche Töne....
wiesnase8 3 years ago
shaky camera makes this so intense, good job
jakaput 3 years ago
hahaa sure
thanks
WWNS 3 years ago
Bravo, J'suis vraiment interessé par ta vidéo, très peu font cette partition, c'est bien dommage.. =)
tchous
Feeling0od 3 years ago
merci! j'ai essaye d'avoir un angle different, quelque chose un peu different. tu dois apprendre cette chanson, ce n'est pas trop difficile et c'est tres amusant.
WWNS 3 years ago
the touch....just the touch
pataplush 3 years ago
This is an amzing song. I have never learned to play piano but I want to. Im getting lessons next year and I'll try learn this song when I get good at it. I envy your talent
Headl1na 3 years ago
Pfft, way to skip like, 15 measures. My favourite phrase, too.
You played the Tranquillo beautifully, that second layer trill thing is a bitch.
I <3 Prokofiev. Good job.
MaestroLacrioso 3 years ago
too slow, but good:)
vettel92 3 years ago
yeah, I'm a bit better at it now, I promise haha
WWNS 3 years ago
You better be or she might come and beat you up - youtube style!
Lemonizm 3 years ago
omg im so jelous, ive just started playing this, and cant wait to be able to play it! you do it so well!
ellie4keeps 3 years ago
This is awesome :D
christoffff 3 years ago
Great. I love it as usual. Brilliant. Running out of words.
MJTTOMB 3 years ago 3