Kelly Clarkson and Carly Smithson (Appreciation video)

[Ingrid89kc]

Kelly is so much better.

[supersporty34]

WOW I just realized the little back and forth the two of you posted on the vid I made! I just want to say that I made this not because I think Carly has as much status or power or could even be equal to Kelly. I know Kelly has been in the public eye for longer and has achieved a lot in her career thus far. Just give Carly some time. I simply made this because I love both Carly and Kelly's music and personalities.

[istarmusic]

I was being Sarcastic about her cd being number 1 on the charts because it wasn't. But I noticed you never gave the name of the cd of carly, you know the person you know so well and yes I am being sarcastic again. She received the award in 2003, in case you didn't know that either. Not for her cd, for vocalist in Ireland - not cd - you know the cd you can't remember because your such a great fan. Bet you one thing it wouldn't take you long to remember kelly's first cd huh? thats right.

[craazyonuu]

They are both amazing =D

[istarmusic]

Kelly is in a different league than Carly. Kelly is so much better. Carly got there because she had to pay back Randy for her previous contract that went belly up. Kelly got there because she's a super star!!! -No camparing the two-

[craazyonuu]

What the hell? Thats not true, Randy never worked with Carly, so get your information right, and don't get it from that stupid video that that stupid person made, k.

[istarmusic]

It IS true don't you watch tv or the news or the show for that matter hello!!!! As a matter of a fact it is old news where have you been???!!!!!!! CARLY HAD A CONTRACT WITH RANDY BEFORE THE SHOW EVEN STARTED!! SHE GOT IT FROM THE LAST TIME SHE AUTITIONED WITH IDOL BUT COULDN'T GET A VISA SO THEY SIGNED HER TO A CONTRACT INSTEAD HELLO!!! IDOL TALKED ABOUT IT ON TV!!! SHE EVEN HAD CD'S BUT THEY SUCKED - NOBODY WANTED THEM!

[craazyonuu]

I am a huge Carly fan, I think I would know. She even clarified in an interview that it's not true, and that it was a rumour. She even said in another interview that another reporter made up stuff, and that she is full of crap. And, she didn't get it the last time she auditioned, she got it when she was EIGHTEEN, in 2001! Not 2005, when she auditioned for season 5. Get you're facts straight, then come talk to me, k? Thanks.

[istarmusic]

I don't need your facts I have Carly's wonderful cd she put out in 2001 it is so wonderful it went all the way to number 1 on the charts wow the whole world knows the name or wait you know all the facts what is the name of that cd again? Who cares!!

Kelly didn't let a 16 year old beat her and she didn't have to try more than once to prove herself a super star!! But when you need more facts come talk to me k? thanks.

[craazyonuu]

I think I know more about Carly then you do. She didn't make number one on anything, the only thing she got that was close to a big award, was the mediar award in Ireland. So, if you need more facts, then come talk to me, believe me, I know more about Carly then you would ever in your life.. K?

[KentuckyFriedCruelty]

Geez can't we just appreciate them for being different people? This video wasn't meant to compare them or to see "who's better" but to just appreciate them for the different people that they are.

[ChixxKC]

Oh and btw this vid is awesome I love both Kelly and Carly, there 2 of my Idols

[ChixxKC]

Omg what performance is that at 1:25, I've never seen that one before.

[supersporty34]

It's "Amame" with A. Pires at the Latin Grammy's in (i think) 2003

[KellyokeCrazy]

Two of my favorite women in the music business! Your awsome making this video it's amazing i've sent the link to the top Carly and Kelly fansites :)

[katrinacabanos]

i love this video. :))

[ksluvscs]

This is a great video! My two fave singers ever in one video...nice!!!

[joepatrick55]

wow this is an awesome video! i too love both of them.

[supersporty34]

Awesome!! I knew I couldn't be the only one..lol

[mkjhgfdsq]

3:3O i was there that's weired, she was awesome.

kelly rocks