Added: 1 year ago
From: dasanwascm
Views: 7,026
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (105)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It states that in the ORIGINAL Japanese Red and Green, he says "Do you know what it feels like to have a pokemon dying?" or something like that, meaning that they changed the dialog later on (as well as many other things they changed, like all the sprites).

    Also, there is a Pokémon anime episode, where Ash's Pikachu gets injured on a cruiser and there are no nurses on. He had to hurry to a Pokémon center when they came to the next city. Fortunately Pikachu didn't die.

  • Raticate sucks... Gary probably just threw it overboard for being a terrible Pokemon.

  • OH MY GID I HAVE KILL RATICATE ......ME....BASTARD......oh wait thats from south park LOL

  • are you pisces, cancer or scorpio

  • I agree with the other stuff but I still think Prof. Oak is a jerk because when you start the game he is like.. "Are you a boy or a girl?" and then he says "This is my grandson... You have been rivals since you were really young. whats his name again?" I means seriously? Ok rivals since youth vs grandson.... Mmmm.... yeah... Fail Grandpa!

  • My name is Ash. : ] Hi

  • your really good at singing and I completly agreee awsome vid! :)

  • Sorry once you started to sing I had to hit the back button right away.

  • 3:47

    Is it just me, or do you kinda hear Lavender Town music? (Maybe I've been listening to too much of it e3e)

  • hey my sister has a drivers lisens and when she picks me up from school she takes me to mcdondoles

  • i dont why people saying you killed his raticate. he had no more use for his raticate so he got a new pokemon to take its palce.

  • YES!!!!!!!!!!!! Now I Can Live with myself X)

  • Fucked up audio

  • wow, I just looked at another video of the battle with GAry, and he says nothing like "do you know what its like to have a pokemon die?" at least in the sugarcoated english dub.

  • I hate to correct you on this, but in the American Red/Blue he says "Hey (insert name here) what are you doing here? your pokemon dont look dead, but I can make them faint."

    thats only the american version, In the japanses version of Pocket monsters ( the original) he says "そのは、ポケットモンスターダイを持って好きなものを知ってい­ますか?which translates to something along the lines of "So, do you know whats its like to have a pokemon die?" (since japanese doesnt translate directly to english) so to answer your theory, yes.

  • @DysentaryErik yes, you killed Gary's Raticate, but the US decided to sugarcoat the death and make it seem like its okay, it was a censor so to speak...

  • No wonder red stood on mt. silver for all those years..

  • YOu liar YOu e-raticate-ed it.

  • How dare you make Gary Oak out to be anything less than a fricken Pokelegend! He's the most hardcore character ever, he's Gary Motherfucking Oak. You WILL show him some respect. Smell ya later.

  • @anonymootle Eh, does your comment has anything to do with this video?

  • @Melkac Have you ever played Pokemon?

  • @anonymootle Yes, so, does that mean you haven't won any battle with Gary? I mean you could only think he's a "legend" that way.

    Good for you.

  • @Melkac Haha yeah, but Gary Oak is an 'internet meme' so what i originally said was a joke in its entirety ;P I wasn't serious ;)

  • I feel like a douchecanoe.. 

  • No, I killed raticate. I killed the shit out of it.

  • HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU... SHUT UP!!! THATS SONG IS COPYRIGHTED!!!

  • At least Gary grows up in Gold, Silver and Crystal and is a serious trainer

  • Comment removed

  • You stupid retard. You didn't even quote Gary in the pokemon tower right

  • No you killed Blue's Raticate...

  • "...and the answer is... *computer laggs and broswer frezzes for a few seconds*"

  • thank you for letting the world know the truth and your singing is great

  • But his raticate ALWAYS gets burnt/paralyzed/poisoned by moves that have a small chance to do so. And you held up the gameboy color games, not the origional red/blue (the good ol' black and white ones?) and I think the dialouge is different between them. The only reason I point these out is because I like the thought of Gary having feelings, nothing personal, OK? and yes, top rated comment, Gary FAILS All that money from beating trainers and he doesn't buy revives.

  • I would TOTALLY murder a Raticate!

  • You are not a bad singer, and your intro is cool. ^.^

  • I actually kinda liked the thought of Gary having a heart.... it actually saddens me to know the rumor's a lie :(

  • You may not have killed gary's raticate, but I demolished it.

  • She's a very good reader.

  • @SupermanReference Yes she is.

  • You're completely right-- If Gary's Raticate died, who can say that you didn't kill any of the other Pokemon? You fought around 20 other Trainers, why aren't their Pokemon dead?

  • ignore my first comment i posted it before i watched the vid .......

  • Its true you do kill his raticate because when you beat him you're at sea and there wasn't a pokemon center onboard so it died. Also when hes at lavender town hes there mourning for raticate.

  • even though as you just proved this theory wrong, i still wish to believe it as it adds more depth to character.

  • I don't know why...but i have a sudden urge to give her a hug :\

  • Also why would Raticate be the only dead pokemon on the SS Anne? I mean if supposedly he lost his pokemon due to its lack of healthcare in time, wouldnt the other pokemon fall to the same fate and die to? Leaving him with no living pokemon team? Lolz

  • This was really cute, I enjoyed it a lot. "I am not a RATICATE MURDERER!!"

  • in the pokemon manga books,pokemon and people really die

  • omg that makes anyone who plays PKMN Red/Blue all the way through is a total douche XD

  • I saw this on pokememes FAIL

  • there was a war thats why gary has no parrents alot of the alder trainers talk about it

  • Your rival lied about the Cubone so you don't catch on to why he's really there, to spare your feelings. He said he had JUST caught it, he only has five pokemon with him, cubone was not one of them. If he had just caught one it would have been his sixth pokemon.

  • Actually, I didn't beat Blue. He is a better trainer than me. :(

    Sorta like red from GSC. Never beat him either.

    Everyone else, though! :D

  • I rove women rike yuu.

  • i feel a thousand times better

  • ok, a few things

    1. I haven't played pokemon R/B in over a decade, but wasn't there a pokecenter on the S.S. Anne? or someone who could heal pokemon?

    2. Gary is not the "good guy", truly "good" guys don't go around gloating about how great they are & how much closer they are to obtaining your mutual goal. He doesn't care about his pokemon, he just wants the strongest ones, he only wants to be the "master". Gary lost sight of the point in raising pokemon, which is why Oak scolded him

  • @omgitsaaron yes,there was probobly a place to heal on the ship,it's just that he didnt make it to it in time.

  • The only move I used on Raticate was scratch. How the hell does it die with scratch.

  • the problem here, is Gary loves his pokemon dearly.

  • In G/S/C Red has isolated himself from the world, and when you talk to him he never says a word. Within the 3 years since his rise to glory he has discovered the truth that he had killed a Pokemon with his blind battling to become the best. This really damages him because he was praised for, and had always believed, that he was a friend of Pokemon.

  • @Kosta4243 He cannot accept this and tries to run away from the truth and the mindless misuse of Pokemon. When he is defeated he disappears to search for a land that is free of Pokemon violence.

  • Did you just read the whole pokemon conspiracy poster? lol I'm reading along with it as you talk about it.

  • no i dont train pokemon with love XD i would give you 5 stars but ill hit that like button instead

  • actually that was good singing

  • @TheFireyes Aw, thank you! lol

  • why didnt gary just use a revive like a normal pokemon trainer.... FAIL GARY!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • i had a fake pokeball when i was 3 and i threw it at someones cat, the owner told me to stop. i made a sad face : =(

  • i wish you did...

  • The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood.

    Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact.

  • You totally read that off of some post originally from 4chan. Semi-word-for-word.

  • Comment removed

  • where did u get that poke ball? I want one...

  • @sox2014 I found them at Toys R Us. The best part is, it's also a bouncy ball!

  • Comment removed

  • why raticate dies? pokemon don't die, they faint.

    plus gary is that trainner that abaddons his weak pokemon, he probably released or he is on pc box in exchange for exeggutor.

  • @JPU91 they die...why is there a pokemon tower? also read the manga...they die there

  • @0plmkoijn0 manga =/= games, just look at red blue and green are not even same persons.

    pokemon tower they are dead pokemon, and marowak dies, but thats only story wise, your pokemon and pokemon you battle, never never never never never die, plus why nintendo would make your pokemon or your friend die at risk of some anti-nintendo conspiracy thing? you troll belivers are just sad lol.

    Not to mention, even if it is true and he died? problem? pokemon is childish as hell,let it have some death.

  • @JPU91 im talking about pokemon in general...not just the manga...they die in every one of them...games/manga/anime there are dead pokemon...i dont believe garys raticate died i just think they took it out to get ready for the next pokemon on blue's team or green's team depending if you live in japan or anywhere else.im no troll...i pwn trolls...i agree with the childish part but they are aiming it more for the older ages now...they took a survey and found that the majority of players are older.

  • i had this game i cant get myself to fight gary a the end *sniff*

  • raticate murder.

  • I like this theory! Gary did infact say "'Do you know how it feels to have your pokemon die?" In the original Japanese translation. And besides, saying "What brings you here? Your Pokemon don't look dead!" implies that that is the reason he is there. Even if Raticate isn't a great Pokemon like everyone says, he might aswell have used a 6th Pokemon, and Raticate IS better than Exeggcute.

  • Comment removed

  • That was funny! :)

    I went to Gary's house, but he's got no stairs to go to the second level :o

  • i never thought about a pokecenter on the boat(that would have been REALLY helpfull though) and yeah i did notice he didnt say " do you know what its like to have a pokemon die". deep down inside i realy wish i did kill his raticate. raticate sucks.

  • @crayolian There is a place on the boat where you can heal your pokes....

  • @lCENSOREDI wait..wasnt it a bed or something, or am i thinking of silph co?

  • @crayolian I think it was implied that you slept in a bed, but you went to a room and talked to some chick.

  • @bleetoth

    no,red is actually based off of YOU from pokemon yellow

  • XD I like your intro.

    And I like your theory on the raticate! You made me laugh over and over! It's just fun to think of a story behind the story is why I think that rumor got popular.

  • Well, there's a rumour that says that Blue pushed Raticate to his limit, and when it fainted, he couldn't get to the center in time, and Raticate died.. He then buried the poor guy in the Pokemon Tower, that's why the next battle with Blue is in the tower and he asks you if you know how is it to lose a Pokemon. A pretty dark and sad story for a game that was aiming mostly for the young audience.

  • well gary atually pushed his raticate to death. red and blue had a very dark story, missingno being a dead kanhaskhan....and much more. So yes you killed the raticate kinda but he pushed it to hard.

  • to kill a charizard all you need is a bucket of water lol

  • I feel like a douchebag XD

  • but if u played the gold/silver series, blue or(gary) is a gym leader and red or (ash) is in a cave by himself but he has all the original starter poke'mon and gary has none...... so maybe he killed raticate,then stole all the starters and went to the cave cause not even his mom knew where he was lol just a theory

  • i think that Gary had an empty slot in his roster so that when he caught a cubone he wouldn't have to go fetch from the storage unit.

  • ...Yeahhhh. I sort've grew up on Nintendo, and I watched all of the first episodes (I think up to episode 60 or 70, plus Pokemon 2000 when it came out in theater.)

    His Raticate does die, and I'll tell you why; Pokemon, though thoroughly thought out, is NOT a logical world. Any time your Pokemon are injured, in game or show, Ash is forced to go to the nearest town. This is evident in the game and the show. Gary not having parents is established in the cartoon.

  • @d0Bored0b Lavender town is a reasonable place to hunt for Cubone, yes, but I think it's more than likely Gary went there to bury his Pokemon, and decided to clear his mind by trying to find another companion to replace him while there (like all pet owners or Pokemon masters do.) So while he was there burying his dead Raticate, he decided to hunt for a Cubone (i.e. your Pokemon don't look >>dead<<... I caught a Cubone.). Good theory, though, on your part.

  • @d0Bored0b Oh, and proof boats don't have Pokemon centers is in Pokemon 2000, forgot, I swear I remember them having to rush his Pokemon off the boat to the island to be healed. Or back to a city.

  • @d0Bored0b so if Pokemon is not a logical world, and Pokemon can be revived just as quick as taking them out to the PokeCenter, even if you do have him out for a long time just fainted, then how does it die? And how do you really know it was your fault? Those Pokemon of his did not level up for nothing.

  • Comment removed

  • @ttlyafterhour "How do you know it's really your fault?", this can't be won because neither side has proof he did or didn't. But you see him next after the boat. "then how does it die?" In the episodes, you clearly see Pikachu, as well as other Pokemon, barely struggling to hold on while being rushed to the poke-centers. The Pokemon (((Game))) isn't large enough to hold an extra game-mechanic (faint to dead Pokemon), and I guarantee you most people would've hated that, so they never added it.

  • 2. Gary fights you with an empty spot in his party in Lavender town. Why would he do that if he had the Raticate available to fill the spot?

    3. Gary's parents were never discussed in the anime, manga, or game. It's up for speculation but generally it's a safer assumption that if something is absent that it isn't there. For instance, next to me is a vacant spot on my floor. It's safer to assume it's just vacant rather than there being an invisible elephant there. Inb4religiousdebate

  • Couple problems with this:

    1. The script in Red and FireRed both change and not direct translations. America is notorious for toning down heavy themes in Child games. It's possible the script was original as the rumor states and it was changed. Not saying that the argument of it possibly being changed proves the theory, but it also means that you can't use it as an argument against the theory.

  • just a thought. but when he says "your pokemon don't look dead" implies that the only someone would go there is because they have a pokemon to bury... so that would lead me to believe that he was there to bury a pokemon. just sayin :P

  • I knew it! my friend tried to convince me of this, and I said the same thing to him :p been so long since I've fired up Red, might start again now....

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more