Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,122)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I like you more in the wizards of waverly place :/

  • ew, she's really bad at singing! Should really just stick to acting, damn.

  • She sucks...

  • she sounds good on her album but sux live

    but she still good

  • no hate but she should focus on her acting career or try another direction in music idk maybe RnB or somethin

  • To be honest, I don't think she can sing LOUDLY, Selena is a very good actress, but she just cannot belch out those notes right. Selena is improving, no doubt about it

  • Je trouve sa voix magnifique elle est douce et ... Wahou ! je l'adore <3

  • I also feel like choking while listening live to her performance, seems like the air can't pass freely in my throat, don;t know why. Maybe because she's not hitting the notes right, she's singing it but she can't hit the right one instead she hits the lower making it sound odd. In fact, at times I can hear the back up singers' voices louder than hers. But I love Selena, coz that's what she is. BRAVE AND BOLD. She always feel pretty and she is proud of who she is. Selena rocks!

  • sometimes actually, the problem in live performances is that, you can't hear your own voice due to the loud back ground music + the cheer of the crowd ... even though they have those gadgets that can make you hear yourself, still that's not enough of a help ... if you can't hear yourself you won't know if you are off key or anything ... maybe that's the reason ... but it could also be that she's not that of a good singer. But she can sing. [1]

  • She is certainly a much better singer than half the 'live' singing celebrities you get! I love her voice.

  • selena is way better then demi

  • @okokokokokokokokok70 you serious?? HAHA. 

  • that's embarrassing...

  • This was one of her bad performances... She really can sing, you just have to get her at the right point

  • why the fuck is she more popular than demi ??!!!

  • @razmo172 Its because of Justin.

  • @NatashaLovesJB no kidding... of cours it's because of him - she is TALENTLESS !!

  • @razmo172 Well she isnt Talentless. Shes a really good actor and on the singing part..well shes not the worst I have heard and still not the best either. But Demi deserves A LOT no Incredibly A lot MORE than Selena does in music. Just saying. Im not hating Selena. Peace.

  • @NatashaLovesJB yeah well let's be honest selena might be a good actress but she is still far of being amazing actresss and demi she is also a good actress and about the singing selena is one of the worst i've ever heard !! she can't sing one note right live without playback !! and demi she has FLAWLESS voice and she is an amazing singer so this is why i think she deserves a lot more than selena !

  • I love you Selena <3

  • iam a fan of seleana

  • Don't know music, her voice is easy for ears.

  • so weak.

  • Some people say it aggravate them wen she breathes after everything she says but it's really hard not to do tht.. I kno I do alot of shows is theaters and it's hard it takes alot of practice.. But I love her team jelena

  • Her voice is weak and quiet, she isnt awful, but she doesn't always stay in tune especially at the beginning of each verse because of how low it is. The harmonies that the band sing don't really help the performance, they just make Selena sound a bit flat. I do like Selena though, she comes across as very sweet and she seems like a great role model, i definitley dont hate her.

  • Comment removed

  • cringe worthy.

  • That was so boring.

  • amazing

    dont listen to haters there justin bieber fans that have on brains 

  • @pokemonman001 I think you mean NO brains.

  • I love Selena and everything, but it's true, she can't sing that well. She could be a lot worse, but could be a lot better. I still listen to her songs and everything but i find it unfair that she is able to build a music career without the talent that other ppl have and they hav to work their butts off to reach their goals. I can understand that she was very popular and having a music career would just make her even more famous, but let's face the facts. Singing's not her forte.

  • horrible!!!!!!!!

  • selena voce e de mas voce e linda e canta muito bem?

  • She can't sing

  • @qadrieemaan if she had such a beautiful voice they wouldn't have to edited the recorded song. She isn't perfect, get over it.

  • No its because she really can't sing. She's just another wanabe pop star who thinks she can be an artist. Think again. #sopathetic

  • I don't get it, she gets a load of hate but she's actually quite good. I swear half of it's just Disney prejudice anyway...

  • lil wayne uses auto tune and people still love him? lol

  • oooo People She Can't Sing Please but She try but she can't Sing

  • She is SOOO good in the begin a little bit soft.but REALLY GOOD!

  • She has a wonderful voice she just needs to sing a bit stronger :)

  • Ok let me clear this up Kay? SHE CAN SING, BEAUTIFUL VOICE, You guys are only saying she can't sing because you compare it to the actual song that's edited Okay? Her voice is beautiful and magnificent she can hit the low noted which I love about her. I'm a big fan and you should just chill and think about her voice instead of the negative things because I don't expect you to be little miss/mr perfect okay!? So shut up and enjoy the music. Don't enjoy it? Don't watch it idiots. Wanna insult me?

  • Her backup singers totally outshine her! I can't even hear her sing and when I did her she sounded terrible! Stick to acting bro.

  • When you sing!

  • You give me the chills!

  • bubble814xx did you hear your own voice i bet you are just jelouse so shut up ok

  • @glittergirls321 yes nice try and so on..she can sing yes for karaoke ...she has her fan but she can't sing good..next to demi lovato she is nothing..but we can't compare sel. and demi because demi is in another level of singing! demi should be famous not selena. i miss the '90 ...in the '90 SINGERS CAN SING!!!

  • Ppl that think her voice is weak think this is ur voice any better? Is everyone perfect? No And would you have the guts to go up there and sing for everyone? I wouldn't so Selena gomez is talented in many ways

  • to put it bluntly, she can't sing. shes beautiful, great at acting, and is a star, but singing is just not her thing.

  • Just spreading the word I wish to be a singer will anyone support me and spread my video around and give it good ratings? Please? I love music and being able to preform has always been a dream of mine, thanks.

  • Yes she can sing & Yes she's flawless.

  • Más encima esta con una pista de reforzamiento notoria horrible... Sinceramente canta pésimo ahhahahahah xD

  • Canta horrible ._. ajshjshajsh xD!

  • I LOVE HER, BUT HER VOICE IT'S JUST LIKE WEAK.

  • nice!

    

  • Selena is not completely horrible her songs have potential...her voice sounds like it needs and little more work but definant potential. Flat in some parts but I give her a 7/10

  • great she's not the best but she's good I just love her singing

  • a erson singin like that, does not deserve to be on that stage, and sig infront of the word biggest stars...

  • she doesnt sound that bad here

  • @shiningstars1997 person*

    

  • Booooo She sucks.

  • You people have no sense of sound! Selena ROCKS most likely wayy better than u so be quiet!

  • @Awesomista i agree!

  • I actually like this performance(:

  • Well, she can sing... But like not really live, it is not her strongest...

  • singing live is not her strongest

  • Okay, first off, just because she uses Auto-Tune, doesnt mean Anything! She can sing live, she is a beautiful, amazing, caring Person! All the haters need to STOP.

  • She can't sing? C'mon! Whaddya think she's doing?

  • why does she look black

    too much makeup

  • What's wrong with Selena? She's smart, amazing performer, if I had to give her a scale on numbers 1-10 saying how great she is, I can't even say that. It'd be 1,000,000,000,000 in my opinion. I'm a Selenator for life. I LOVE YOU, SELENA!

  • i think some people just love to hate. i'm not a fan of her at all but i don't see the problem with her voice at all. just because she doesn't belt out massive notes doesn't make her a bad singer. she has a beautiful tone!

  • ☆★☆★☆★☆INFINITE☆★☆★☆★☆STARS☆★☆­★☆★☆TO

    [:-))SelenaMarieGomezLive !!

    "Your The OutStanding Perfect Awesome Best in all you Do Perfectly & FanTasTic of Magnificent Beautiful Extraordinary Amazing Super AWES(☆)MENESS Beyond anything in all of Time."~!!!!~(O)_(O)~!!!!~"

  • Shes so pretty!

  • Best vocals!!! :) xxx

  • she looks so pretty in that dress

  • Well....it's a good thing she's pretty...

  • is she lip singing.. cause she isnt that bad..

  • Selena voice is a amazing all you guys have to do is just turn up your volume up a bit cause the video sound is down duh. I listened to her with my earbuds all the way up the volume she sounds so pretty and great and is so freaking beautiful. Love you Selena Gomez! ;D

  • I think her backup singers are pretty good....

  • Wth she sucks. -.-

  • Selena Gomez is a beautiful, sucessful person and i'm very proud of her. She hasn't done anything bad and she can probably sing better that most people. So all the haters should leave her alone, especially with her Justin Bieber boyfriend. Luv you Selena

  • lol

  • Okay Leave Selena Alone Okay? She CAN SING, Shes Just Got a Weak Voice Live , No offence to Selena - I love Her But You do Need to work On your Voice Sel Cuz It's Weak and Quiet. Anyway Back to My Point, She Can Sing shes Just Needs to Work On it and Besides No-Bodys Perfect. P.S at 1:33 She sounds AMAZING! Love you Sel <3

  • @GoldenSelenaGomez eh lol. yea very weak :S... btw a good song

  • @GoldenSelenaGomez how can you say this.. ok at 1:33 she hits one tone. but there are million other tones. sorry. its just horrible from 2:23 it's just ..... i dont have the words

  • aww i wish i got to go to a concert to her :(

  • I try not to cringe but I feel bad for her! Her voice it seems like shes talking when shes singing, hoping shes getting vocal lessons.. do love her but wow.

  • Go Selly!

  • Es bonita, pero no canta!

    

  • she can sing ! just you need a proper camera and

    first time you hear her live she sounds not so good

    but after a while she sound really good cuz u used 2 it

    plus she has a great attitude and is a good actress

  • This is much better than some of her other performences:D

  • Beautiful girl but very bad vocal for singing, not entertaining if it haven't been for the catchy song. Other talented singers deserve her fame more.She should concentrate on acting and polish the skill since her stunning look + good acting can bring her far. No hate.

  • She is amazing actress and an amazing person, but let's be real, she CAN'T sing! And don't say she can only not sing live, if you have to use autotune all the time, then why sing, if it's not real

  • @MsTal100 i think she can sing but her voice is to weak

  • @MsTal100 thats your own freakin opinion

    

  • @MsTal100 they do it to make millions of dollars

  • @mclovin9151 not to follow any morals

  • @MsTal100 she has a great voice,my vocal teacher even says she's great and he is very rare for saying someone is great.

  • I luv this video!!!

  • if you dont like Selena why did you come to this video.... and it is LIVE..... she is a good singer too.. she is never going to be good enough to people who dont like her, no matter what she does.. so just leave her alone and go tho videos of people you like

  • At the end you hear that she sings in playback. ;// !

  • .. yyyy.. !! SHE CAN"T SING!!!!!! pfutt! playbeck ;/ Demi Lovato sings amazing. <33 ;* I loove Deeemi!

  • EL JUEVES A LA CIUDAD DE MEXICO A PRESENCIAR ESTA HEROSUURAAA!!!!!!

  • haha, linda

  • This song is one of my favorites of Selena's

  • she's really pretty, but she really can't sing live

  • She hits the right notes, but her voice is just too soft and too weak to hold them. Lovely girl, but she should stick to acting.

  • She is so beautiful and great in the songs

  • I noticed that she sings better at slow songs live than fast pace songs.

  • Elle sait pas chanter! She can't sing!

  • @xVictooria ferme ta gueule jsuis sure qu'elle chante mieux qu'toi ! Fuck you, sure she sings wayyy better than you ;)

  • Oh, and I'm not being a hater- I think that she's still really talented- but she can't really sing live

  • it's not that she's just soft, but she also goes really flat quite often :|

  • Urm.. we can't hear you love! LOVE her but she can't sing, fact.

  • Yeah she can't sing live.

  • it sounds like she says "a gay without rain"

  • O__O

  • She ain't Whitney Houston, but she still is and always will be a Diva..

  • I LUV Selena Gomez She is so AWESOME nice pretty and I just think She is Amazing :)!

  • Yes her voice is pretty weak, however I can't really diss, my singing voice is awful!

  • she is a gift from heaven!

  • Love it

  • Yeah she can sing, But her voice is really weak.. Like you can barely hear her & she runs out of breathe to easily for not even dancing or anything. She's really pretty, But her voice is weak. Im not hating cause I really like her, But I'm saying how it is.

  • i love selena gomez she is my favorite artist in the whole wide world

  • Low :)

  • SHE SINGS SO GOOD IN DON`T KNOW WHY EVERYBODY SAYS THAT SHE DOESN`T. at first she`s an amazing person she can act, she can sing and she`s an amazing person i love her and i`m a huge fan of her so i love her. <3

    and i also want to become a singer because i looooooooove to sing

  • that's so boring

  • how come if u dont particularly think this person is as good live as someone like Rascal Flatts you automatically become a hater???

  • She's actually a really good singer, she has a good tone and power in her voice. Go Selena!!!

  • she cant really sing in person , but shes still amzing (:

  • En el estribillo cuando dice RAIN: A day without you is like a year without RAIN, cantan las del coro, Selena no llega a las notas. Y DESPUES DICEN QUE ES CANTANTE.

  • @LiveBieber hahahaha si canta! y canta mejor que tu te lo aseguro:) no la insultes ella no te hace nada asi que callate:)

  • She dont top the notes.

  • olha o tamanho da cabeça!!!kk

  • GUYS STOP JUDGING HER. SHE HAS A VERY BEAUTIFUL VOICE AND SHE'S LIKE THE MOST BEAUTIFUL GIRL ON THE PLANET. There's a reason for her to be a singer and that's her talent. Her voice is not as powerful as Demi's for example, but she CAN sing. And she has many other talents, maybe singing isn't her power but she's not doing it bad. This perfomance was really good, by the way :) and when one of you "haters" or should i call u "jealous bitches" reaches the top like Selena you can call me. :)

  • @SweetDream091 I tottaly argee with you!!!:)

    

  • I dont think Selena is a very bad singer..but I think she should learn to sing out..her voice has no power..but she got a nice tone

  • personally i think selena voice is pretty but not powerful..

  • If You Haters Can't hear her Why don't you Turn it up, she May not be a Power House JUst stop Judging her!

  • i can never hear her?

  • Love it :)

  • Yes she can sing beautifully!!!!!! Ok????

  • ella no tiene bonita voz en vivo como cuando se la arreglan pero almenos no hace playback como otros artistas

  • @fdj2mil Exacto

  • Comment removed

  • that aint singing, its whispering

  • @OneAndOnlyMileyC Lol r u deaf?

  • selena isnt singing live in this video....she cant sing

  • @perreomarie SHE CAN SING , AND HER SINGING IN THIS LIVE!

  • Selena is the best :) <3

  • ahahhahahhahhahaahhaahahahahah­haha omg x'D

  • but shes sooooooo pretty

  • @alice552504

    have u seen her without make up

    

  • yh she cant sing and shes so quite

  • @alice552504

    you are right, i just said the same

  • Honestly,shes BEAUTIFUL ! But she can't sing .

  • See, all of the people that say that she cant sing are completely jealous.

    They just cant stop listening to selena gomez song

    And yes , she can sing