He obviously isn't lip synching he just had to cancel the rest of his tour. I just saw them on 8/6 in Atlantic City and 9/10 in Newark and both performances were amazing, but there were times where he was too tired to sing a few lines here and there,so obviously he wasn't lip synching either time and he was just AMAZING! Rest assured STP fans our front man does not lip synch!!!!! BTW he has sanf Crackerman for 20 years now. You don' t think he can still sing it on the ground?????
he was lip-syncing a backing track. This backing track is on a lower volume level and WITHOUT the Megaphone sound. of COURSE the backing track is without the megaphone…it’s safety! That way Scott feels free to use or not the Megaphone while singing the song, and that´s why you do not listen to the Megaphone while he is down( and that explains also why his voice volume drops a little during his time on the ground).[...]
[...] An A picture of him with a mic on his mouth doesn’t prove anything. Except the fact that he was determined to mantain the lie. People say “look at this picture here…of course he was singing”. Well, this is at least extremely naive.
STP is my fav band since1993 and forever will be, no matter what, but Scott Weiland is sadly already dead and for sale. Let’s face it.
As I stated before I don't think he was lip syncing. However until you've stepped into his shoes. Don't try to cast stones. I would like to see you tour for over a year, working your ass and vocal cords every night.
I don't believe that he was lip syncing, but even if he did who the fuck cares? We know he can really sing, just listen to his unplugged concerts with STP. He's one of the best front men alive today. Scott has payed his dues, and doesn't have to defend himself to anyone.
plus... did any of the sensationalist drama queens who cried lip synching stop to think for a second that he didn't climb back up until a break in the lyrics? I mean there were like 3 or 4 dudes trying to help him up who just sat, staring at him. You don't think he was down there with one finger in the air saying "hold on just a sec?"
He could have completely carried on singing with that fall because he's done crazy dance and jump moves all throughout his career and I've always respected the fact that his vocals remain solid.
Also, look at the singin before the fall - you can tell when he alternates between the megaphone and microphone that thats his own voice, not a backing track, because his voice fades as he pull the megaphone away. Its too difficult to sync so perfectly if it was a backing track.
I saw him last night in Charlotte: No lip-synching. When I was leaving I could only hear the monitors and not the instruments off the walls and could clearly hear that it was his voice and not the recording from 10+ years ago.
Lip sync or backing track.....call it what you want, but wither way, its BULLSHIT! All these bands start their careers off by playing LIVE. No track in the background helping the lead singer get through the song. This goes for so many bands. As soon as they hit it big, for some reason they feel the need to have a vocal track playing behind them.
his mic wasn't turned on. if his mic was on then you would have heard the mic pop when he fell. also, if his mic was on you would have heard him hit the ground.
I love Scott!!At least he is a real man who gets up and goes on.He doesnt cry about it,i bet on it that the most off you losers would who are laughing about this.
There's actually a difference between lip-syncing & the use of backing tracks. Lip-syncing is total production of vocals during a gig with the mic completely off & used as nothing more than a prop. Backing tracks are used to account for fluctuations in live vocals. ALOT of acts do this. Everyone from KISS to Eminem. I wouldn't go so far as saying Weiland was lip-syncing, but he was MOST DEFINITELY using a backing track. Doesn't make him any less of a pro than anyone else. STP is cool.
People please...take a look at the opening song, heaven and hotrods at red rocks a month or so ago. Its clear that he totally screwed this song up and there were no tracks behind him at all. He's a freaking pro...even if he messes up the opening song at the best venue in the country...that's what makes him Scott.
People please...take a look at the opening song, heaven and hotrods at red rocks a month or so ago. Its clear that he totally screwed this song up and there were no tracks behind him at all. He's a freaking pro...even if he messes up the opening song at the best venue in the country...that's what makes him Scott.
You've seriously gotta be really ignorant to vocalism to think Weiland is lip-synching here. He even sings different notes to the one on the core CD, I laugh even harder at people who think that there's a Core album vocal backing track being played. You must seriously be out of your minds, or haven't listened to Core since it came out.
@MrLeagueOJustice your an idiot, Robert Deleo is obviosly singing, and scott even though fell is singing, why do you think he waited til the solo to get up moron
@MrLeagueOJustice you don't know much about vocals if you truly think those are backing tracks.. hell, look at the video of maynard (of tool) fighting a fan onstage while singing the song pushit.. he still sounded nearly dead-on while putting a fan in a suplex wrestling hold. falling down and singing is much easier than wrestling and singing. scott weiland is a pro, 'nuff said.
He kept singing! Scott Weiland is not the kind of frontman that would use lip sync. They waited to the solo of dean to pick him up, bcuz he stood down there singing !
Hey it happens to the best of us. Take it in stride and keep going. Scott's vocal was not pre recorded. He likley landed on his feet maybe took a little roll. But this is a front man that is used to being active and moving around so I'm certain hes jumped at least this far before. Kudos for keeping it going.
Well, in my opinion sirs, I really couldn't give a shit if he died falling off stage.... I'm sure ass hell glad that Paul from slipknot died... aweful people like Aaron Lewis, stp, slipknot, led leplin, the who, bb king, pink floyed, aaron lewis, lisa loeb, majic johnson, nuchekke spegetti. and once this fith. Long live the Joggulo Hollocaust. ... Sangri la mutha fuck, ect,ect. Seriously , i bet you all live in one big pool house mansion sippin on drinks like it anint no thang.... well naw what
He so was fucking singing on the ground I was 5 ft from him He is a true fucking pro! I came here to clear the air on this shit. Anyone else that was there will verify.
@BDuv1 Exactly. Had he stopped singing, the band would've stopped playing. He kept singing, and the DeLeos and Kretz took that cue to mean to keep going. Btw, every show (Vegas, even) that I've been to where something like this happens, and it turns out everyone's alright, the audience seems to love the performers even more. Audiences can be really cool sometimes!
Also, when a band member falls of stage and potentially injures himself, you don't continue playing the song... You stop and see if he's alright to continue the show. The only reason the band is continuing to play the song is because if they stop, his vocals will keep on playing through the pa. But whatever man, this is common. It's no reason to stop liking STP.
He's obviously lip synching. I'm a semi-professional musician and this sort of thing happens more often than you think. My singer in my own band contemplates lip synching anytime his vocal chords are feeling rough. People pay money to watch these shows so you obviously have to "perform" well. How could he possibly be singing perfectly in cue seconds after falling off stage? He should be gasping for air. Vocalists are frequently auto tuning their voices when recording and lip synching on stage...
To use backing tracks the drummer has to play to a click track, this is when you know they are faking it by the drummers use of headphones. If you were to play this track along side other performance's and if they are bang on time its played to a click. But this is no good because you can not see scott after the fall, how bad was the fall he still could be holding the mic, its not impossible to sing into it.
I AM I AM I AM A LIP SYNCER,A LIP SYNCER! MIMING ALL THE TIME MIMING ALL THE TIME YEAH I DONT PLAY LIVE THATS NOT MY GAME I JUST SHOOT HEROIN AND PLAT TO BACKIN TAPES YEAH YEAH I AM I AM A LIP SYNCER BACKIN TAPES RULE MY WORLD MY BAND ARE EVEN NOT PLUGGED IN OHH YEAH YEAH I AM A LIP SYNCER A LIP SYNCER LIP SYNCING IS MY LIFE OH YEAH GIVE ME MORE HEROIN YOU ASS FANS! WE LIP SYNC.
I am an STP fan, its really hard to argue the video evidence here. I can't imagine someone falling like this is being able to continue singing perfectly like nothing happened. And if he was fine enough to sing, why not get right back up?
After Scott does a face first dive into the ground below the stage, the vocals continue without a hitch. I've seen STP 3 times since they reunited and half to say that those are his vocals continuing sounding as if they are off the Core CD. I know it's not Robert singing background vocals as Scott's are unmistakable. Also look at Dean Deleo throughing up his hands in frustraction at 2:49 toward the STP sound crew, while the guitar is still playing, in frustration that they did not stop the
After Scott does a face first dive into the ground below the stage, the vocals continue without a hitch. I've seen STP 3 times since they reunited and half to say that those are his vocals continuing sounding as if they are off the Core CD. I know it's not Robert singing background vocals as Scott's are unmistakable. Also look at Dean Deleo throughing up his hands in frustraction at 2:49 toward the STP sound crew, while the guitar is still playing, in frustration that they did not stop the ta
If he was lip-syncing, don't you think the voice would sound the same as it does on the record? It doesn't make sense that he would record a vocal track pre-tour, why not just sing? I believe he doesn't use trickery. I believe Scott Weiland is an amazing singer, and perhaps has the professional attitude it takes to sing after falling. I am a little surprised that the band kept playing, though. Just seems weird.
Scott doesn't lip sync at all, you HAVE to be kidding. I just saw them last week and was front center . . . NO lip sync. I love that he kept singing even from the pit.
Scott doesn't lip sync at all, you HAVE to be kidding. I just saw them last week and was front center . . . NO lip sync. I love that he kept singing even from the pit.
Scott doesn't lip sync at all, you HAVE to be kidding. I just saw them last week and was front center . . . NO lip sync. I love that he kept singing even from the pit.
lip synching??? No way. When he stood on the stage he mixed microphone singing with a megaphone. Please notice that after a fall he only sings to a microphone. And you can´t here megaphone. Get it??? Scott is the MAN.
no offense but anyone who concludes that he's lip-syncing from this video is a) not an STP fan and wants the band to fail or b) likes to base conclusions on inconclusive evidence. this video doesnt show scott weiland lip syncing, nor is there any other indication of a vocal track.
did anyone consider the fact that after he fell he just continued singing? after all he didnt hoist himself back on to the stage until another break in the song.
It's so obvious there's no playback that it makes me feel ashamed of those ones claiming there was a backing track. @CoveMusic: there's no "bullhorn voice" when he leaves it!! Are you deaf or what?? Listen at 1:10, he's singing live, the voice is far from perfect, sounds very different from the studio track, and you can hear the mic popping when he falls and a change in sound (from the "basement"). I think they acted very professionally!!
@ecan yeah, what he said. people just like hyping up stupid shit. it pisses me off that over the years people have really hoped for STP to fail... pretty much as long as ive been a fan of the band ive noticed the backlash.
@mdf072 heroin puppets, i'm pulling your strings, twisting your mind and smashing your dreams, blinded y me you can't see a thing, just call my name and i'll hear you scream...lolz
Well, I'll not judge anything, but, fans normally accept anything that comes from theirs loved artists.
But one thing for sure, if I was in a show from my favorite band and discovered they're were not really playing I would be pi****, c'mon, it's a LIVE performance, that's why we go out to see our favorite bands, other way round just watch a dvd!!
And hey, shows are way too much expensive for us to be cheated!!
saw them in pittsburgh last night...EPIC FAIL SCOTT! You could not hear any vocals...either they need to hang it up or they need to fire their sound guy.
LOL, scott's back on the H, that's why he was booted from VR in case you didn't know. Slash and the others have been clean for years but scott just could not kick it...and there have been tons of complaints from both reviewers and fans from their previous shows after the reunion about his singing off key -- and looking wasted. It's really sad that it's come to this though -- search for their MTV unplugged shows, he sounded so amazing then...it's sad what he's become.
It's pretty damned obvious he's lip syncing in this one lol...he fucking falls off stage and you dont hear a thud on the mic or anything and he just keeps going...there's NO way anyone could do that, and I bet if you asked someone who was close and could see exactly when he fell off if he was still singing they would probably say no.
@surgeyX , this one, at least until he fell. And you do hear a thud on the mic. And everyone who was there and actually saw Scott said they could see him still singing, several of whom have posted on this thread. Like I said before, nobody records guide vocal tracks singing flat or with inconsistent volume.
Anyone saying that's lip synching is a total fucking idiot. I am a professional musician, and one thing I've learned about singers who use tracks is that the whole reason they use them is so they don't sound out of tune or have inconsistent volume. Notice that Scott's voice got quieter for the first few seconds, and he was a little out of tune.
So no, morons, it wasn't lip synching...it's what you call "professionalism."
I wasn't at the show but from what I've gathered on the internet the people in the middle of the stage front row could look left and see it all... All of them have clearly stated that he actually stayed on point the whole time. No lip sync or backing tracks. Check your facts before making a conclusion based on one shity video... When another video or better pics of this incident emerge, all you haters can get off his nutz! You guys will have actually proven how kick ass Weiland is. THUMBS UP!
@nephewofpop I always knew youtube comments were retarded, but you can't be serious? You are telling us to check facts when you admit you were NO WHERE NEAR the show? Wow. I'd point out the irony there, but I'm pretty sure you don't know what the word irony means. We are all stupider for having read your post nephewofpop. I award you 0 points, and may god have mercy on your soul.
they may have done between Theatre Of pain and Girls Girls Girls as thats the point of when they were at the pincle of drug use. Dont get me wrong or take offence im saying there is a high chance they dont anymore as they aren't drugged up anymore.
I wondered the same thing when I saw it happen. ( I was there too).
However, I did notice that he didn't get back on the stage until there was a break in the vocals, sooooo maybe he was singing from down there. Either way, it was still a really great show!
what a disgrace to the music industry these blokes are. LIP SYNCHRONIZING. Please do not beleive this BS that he fell off stage and KEPT SINGING bwahahahaha get real
the people in the front row cant even see him, how can they say they saw him keep singing. Look how hard he falls. When he would be hittin the ground, not even a second later he's singing perfect pitch not missing a note. yeah rite.
there is no way Scott Weiland, one of the best frontmen out there, is lip synching. The man is a true professional and obviously stayed down in the pit to finish the verse and THEN got back up on stage. He was singing & moving fine the rest of the show. I've seen STP & Scott many times and there is no way he is lip synching. Obviously the haters have not been to a show where he's changed the lyrics or sung differently from city to city.
there is no way Scott Weiland, one of the best frontmen out there, is lip synching. The man is a true professional and obviously stayed down in the pit to finish the verse and THEN got back up on stage. He was singing & moving fine the rest of the show. I've seen STP & Scott many times and there is no way he is lip synching. Obviously the haters have not been to a show where he's changed the lyrics or sung differently from city to city.
there is no way Scott Weiland, one of the best frontmen out there, is lip synching. The man is a true professional and obviously stayed down in the pit to finish the verse and THEN got back up on stage. He was singing & moving fine the rest of the show. I've seen STP & Scott many times and there is no way he is lip synching. Obviously the haters have not been to a show where he's changed the lyrics or sung differently from city to city.
I've seen Scott perform several times. He's slipped & hit hit head right in front of me and he kept singing. That's just how he is. He's a real rockstar. This man, is one of THE best performers!! He'd get slammed for "forgetint lyrics" or said the lines wrong... Now he's getting slammed for being a pro & continuing to sing?? You people are just too much.
Thank God he couldn't care less about what anyone thinks. A weaker person would've given up on trying to prove themselves to you people.
Yeah I agree, these people are just conspiracy theorists out to ruin his name. If you fall you can clearly still sing even though it would be pretty much impossible to talk properly, let alone sing. Even though the crew was helping him you could still sing. I mean, who needs a mic to sing right? Hell, if you fall and you're still singing in tune... you've gotta be great!
@MiniDiscProducer --- Hopefully this current misfortune will be set straight and made right in timely fashion..... Next they will be saying that he doesn't even write all the songs he takes credit for...
theres a playback, a low one tough. Its just like when you doubble vocals during recording sessions. You can hear that the first line after the fall is really low. Then he managed to sing otherwise everyone would notice. And then, the vocals get louder. The guy is talentes, everyone double vocals, including John Lenon and Kurt cobain. But they didnt do it live tough
Having been there, and seen and HEARD it, its obvious that some people don't have ears or were not there. While I will agree its hard and nearly imposible to hear in the video, those who were sober and there could hear the mic fall. I also happened to be at the end of the speaker stack and could SEE Scott singing behind the speakers. I ran over there because like many I thought it was strange to here him and not see him after that fall. I could see him singing, and oh yeah the bass sings too
I'm with MiniDiscProducer. The video may look deceptive, and it's unfortunate, but the people who were really in the pit when it went down know what's up. No way was there any inauthenticity to this performance, should have gotten a plaque for it... Definitely kicked ass, period. Take the word of people that were actually there who witnessed it first hand... Dude is for real.
I've seen STP several times live and Weiland's vocals always sound a little different show to show. He DOESN'T use backing tracks. I've seen him hoarse, sober, drunk, drugged, and perfect, and his voice is a bit different each way.
@gpz108 He did not use the bullhorn during the song, which explains the vocals staying the same. And there are pictures out where you can CLEARLY see Scott singing down there while security is pulling him up.
Idiots. I was at the show... in the pit. Not only does he miss a line in the second chorus (would that be on a back track too?) there is also no megaphone present (which tumbled to the ground when he did). Want further proof?
Hit these awesome pics up from the show. 2nd to last pic shows him rocking it out in the pit before the solo. Dude is a rock God. Deal with it!
LAME!! LMAO.....all those suckers bought tix to the most expensive karaoke show ever! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA Sucks cuz I was gonna go see em', but forget it now! LOL
Its hard to tell for sure. He's been singing and preforming for a LONG time. I doubt this is the first time he's even fallen while on stage or something has happened where he had to sing through adversity.
sucks if its true though, but you can't really tell.
He obviously isn't lip synching he just had to cancel the rest of his tour. I just saw them on 8/6 in Atlantic City and 9/10 in Newark and both performances were amazing, but there were times where he was too tired to sing a few lines here and there,so obviously he wasn't lip synching either time and he was just AMAZING! Rest assured STP fans our front man does not lip synch!!!!! BTW he has sanf Crackerman for 20 years now. You don' t think he can still sing it on the ground?????
SuperYAGB 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
when did he fall?
Oohlaful 6 months ago
Closing the case:
he was lip-syncing a backing track. This backing track is on a lower volume level and WITHOUT the Megaphone sound. of COURSE the backing track is without the megaphone…it’s safety! That way Scott feels free to use or not the Megaphone while singing the song, and that´s why you do not listen to the Megaphone while he is down( and that explains also why his voice volume drops a little during his time on the ground).[...]
junior311 8 months ago
@junior311
[...] An A picture of him with a mic on his mouth doesn’t prove anything. Except the fact that he was determined to mantain the lie. People say “look at this picture here…of course he was singing”. Well, this is at least extremely naive.
STP is my fav band since1993 and forever will be, no matter what, but Scott Weiland is sadly already dead and for sale. Let’s face it.
junior311 8 months ago
you heard the mic hit...would anyone actually think he had the mic on and not singing?
CourtyardPigeon 10 months ago
As I stated before I don't think he was lip syncing. However until you've stepped into his shoes. Don't try to cast stones. I would like to see you tour for over a year, working your ass and vocal cords every night.
lacysims88 10 months ago
I don't believe that he was lip syncing, but even if he did who the fuck cares? We know he can really sing, just listen to his unplugged concerts with STP. He's one of the best front men alive today. Scott has payed his dues, and doesn't have to defend himself to anyone.
lacysims88 11 months ago
@lacysims88 Doesn't matter. People pay to go see STP and hear them live. A recorded vocal track is not live. Save that for the pop stars.
rockon6191 10 months ago
plus... did any of the sensationalist drama queens who cried lip synching stop to think for a second that he didn't climb back up until a break in the lyrics? I mean there were like 3 or 4 dudes trying to help him up who just sat, staring at him. You don't think he was down there with one finger in the air saying "hold on just a sec?"
JaySchulten 11 months ago
i was there...and i was aroused
billyhay 1 year ago
ITS STONE TEMPLE JUMPERS :)
starring Drop Weiland
hahaha just joking
jetsonic69 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a fucking retard...
MrBlack666satan 1 year ago
he prob just kept singing when he fell... did you notice the singing got a shit ton quieter and less intense when he fell?
thisiswebbmaster 1 year ago
Go Vesuvias!
platypusboy 1 year ago
i was there an he wasnt on anything jus misjudged his step haha an cage the elephant was there too. badass concert
charliepacewasframed 1 year ago
lip sync
MarekSuro 1 year ago
And we all know that Scott is never the most sober man on stage, so the sync so persectly to a backing track would be even more obvious.
I reckon he was on the floor giving a smile and singing to the fans in the front row and just having fun with it...
MsBrit78 1 year ago
He could have completely carried on singing with that fall because he's done crazy dance and jump moves all throughout his career and I've always respected the fact that his vocals remain solid.
Also, look at the singin before the fall - you can tell when he alternates between the megaphone and microphone that thats his own voice, not a backing track, because his voice fades as he pull the megaphone away. Its too difficult to sync so perfectly if it was a backing track.
MsBrit78 1 year ago 3
man i thought this was a ROCK band... fucking shame.
wheresuritethumb 1 year ago
who cares scott weiland is the definition of a rock star
rollnalucky7 1 year ago 20
he was fucking lip sinking that fuck
ulas1986 1 year ago
Sorry pilot fans but he should of stayed with Velvet Revolver and the Greatest guitar player of all time
legenddaryslash 1 year ago
Who gives a shit, stp still rocks
caddiejd 1 year ago
Comment removed
therealcaptain40 1 year ago
I saw him last night in Charlotte: No lip-synching. When I was leaving I could only hear the monitors and not the instruments off the walls and could clearly hear that it was his voice and not the recording from 10+ years ago.
It's easy to be a hater.
boogy7777 1 year ago
Lip sync or backing track.....call it what you want, but wither way, its BULLSHIT! All these bands start their careers off by playing LIVE. No track in the background helping the lead singer get through the song. This goes for so many bands. As soon as they hit it big, for some reason they feel the need to have a vocal track playing behind them.
estek16 1 year ago
Oops. Sounds like it to me.
epsanchez1984 1 year ago
his mic wasn't turned on. if his mic was on then you would have heard the mic pop when he fell. also, if his mic was on you would have heard him hit the ground.
TopHatMOON 1 year ago 3
what a dick nose... ever hear of nirvana? fail.
EthanJaBlowMe 1 year ago
busted.
TopHatMOON 1 year ago
I love Scott!!At least he is a real man who gets up and goes on.He doesnt cry about it,i bet on it that the most off you losers would who are laughing about this.
Scott is HOT!!!!!!!!1
TheJisas 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Scott is the man!!
A REAL man who doesnt give a fuck about these fucking rumors!!
TheJisas 1 year ago
There's actually a difference between lip-syncing & the use of backing tracks. Lip-syncing is total production of vocals during a gig with the mic completely off & used as nothing more than a prop. Backing tracks are used to account for fluctuations in live vocals. ALOT of acts do this. Everyone from KISS to Eminem. I wouldn't go so far as saying Weiland was lip-syncing, but he was MOST DEFINITELY using a backing track. Doesn't make him any less of a pro than anyone else. STP is cool.
deadhenderson 1 year ago 2
If you'll notice, there was no megaphone on his voice after he fell. If he were singing to a track, the megaphone effect would still be there.
moode004 1 year ago 2
Scott Weiland Rocks Forever
youakio 1 year ago
he is a heroin attick! thats why all there shows are gettting postponed!
bwalexa 1 year ago
jesus fucking christ, who cares!!!
shaunarend 1 year ago
1:28 hahahahaha
incuboy1988 1 year ago
HA HA HA Milli Vanilli!!!!!!!!!!
secondglancemusic 1 year ago
He's still sexy
Firemansgirl54 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
People please...take a look at the opening song, heaven and hotrods at red rocks a month or so ago. Its clear that he totally screwed this song up and there were no tracks behind him at all. He's a freaking pro...even if he messes up the opening song at the best venue in the country...that's what makes him Scott.
TheTball1234 1 year ago
People please...take a look at the opening song, heaven and hotrods at red rocks a month or so ago. Its clear that he totally screwed this song up and there were no tracks behind him at all. He's a freaking pro...even if he messes up the opening song at the best venue in the country...that's what makes him Scott.
TheTball1234 1 year ago
@ilovethebrits
Yeah right. Good try.
MrLeagueOJustice 1 year ago
when he's sober he falls, go figure!!
txbnkr 1 year ago
You've seriously gotta be really ignorant to vocalism to think Weiland is lip-synching here. He even sings different notes to the one on the core CD, I laugh even harder at people who think that there's a Core album vocal backing track being played. You must seriously be out of your minds, or haven't listened to Core since it came out.
bestofthebox 1 year ago
@bestofthebox
What are you guys, hired by the band? Stop trying to play us for the fool you tools! STP got caught with backing vocal tracks!
MrLeagueOJustice 1 year ago
@MrLeagueOJustice your an idiot, Robert Deleo is obviosly singing, and scott even though fell is singing, why do you think he waited til the solo to get up moron
Metalstryke 1 year ago
@Metalstryke
Sorry, not fooled here. And ps, 'your' is spelled 'You're"
MrLeagueOJustice 1 year ago
@MrLeagueOJustice you don't know much about vocals if you truly think those are backing tracks.. hell, look at the video of maynard (of tool) fighting a fan onstage while singing the song pushit.. he still sounded nearly dead-on while putting a fan in a suplex wrestling hold. falling down and singing is much easier than wrestling and singing. scott weiland is a pro, 'nuff said.
bestofthebox 1 year ago
@bestofthebox
Yes Scott is a pro. I wont dispute that.
MrLeagueOJustice 1 year ago
Fail. Alice In Chains Much? lip sync fail dick face
EthanJaBlowMe 1 year ago
He kept singing! Scott Weiland is not the kind of frontman that would use lip sync. They waited to the solo of dean to pick him up, bcuz he stood down there singing !
DUKEMAGO812 1 year ago
@DUKEMAGO812
Fraid not.
MrLeagueOJustice 1 year ago
Glad Scott's ok. I love STP. Did he say anything about the fall after the song ?
7389 1 year ago
Hey it happens to the best of us. Take it in stride and keep going. Scott's vocal was not pre recorded. He likley landed on his feet maybe took a little roll. But this is a front man that is used to being active and moving around so I'm certain hes jumped at least this far before. Kudos for keeping it going.
ddsim2003 1 year ago
Well, in my opinion sirs, I really couldn't give a shit if he died falling off stage.... I'm sure ass hell glad that Paul from slipknot died... aweful people like Aaron Lewis, stp, slipknot, led leplin, the who, bb king, pink floyed, aaron lewis, lisa loeb, majic johnson, nuchekke spegetti. and once this fith. Long live the Joggulo Hollocaust. ... Sangri la mutha fuck, ect,ect. Seriously , i bet you all live in one big pool house mansion sippin on drinks like it anint no thang.... well naw what
EthanJaBlowMe 1 year ago
milli vanilli
SandyGdfwhat 1 year ago
what is this milli vanilli?
SandyGdfwhat 1 year ago
One of the best voices in rock in the last twenty years. Nobody can hardly touch his vocals, Chris Cornell and Weiland are in a league of their own.
cyberian2007 1 year ago
@cyberian2007 ya because others are GOOD
113XXX 1 year ago
He so was fucking singing on the ground I was 5 ft from him He is a true fucking pro! I came here to clear the air on this shit. Anyone else that was there will verify.
BDuv1 1 year ago 13
@BDuv1 Exactly. Had he stopped singing, the band would've stopped playing. He kept singing, and the DeLeos and Kretz took that cue to mean to keep going. Btw, every show (Vegas, even) that I've been to where something like this happens, and it turns out everyone's alright, the audience seems to love the performers even more. Audiences can be really cool sometimes!
adarkerlight 1 year ago
Lip syncing for sure but I know he has a great live voice so it doesn't really matter :D
BC721 1 year ago
He was lip synching.people. It's obvious. And if you want to throw bones over it I will pussies!
mcdee187 1 year ago
Also, when a band member falls of stage and potentially injures himself, you don't continue playing the song... You stop and see if he's alright to continue the show. The only reason the band is continuing to play the song is because if they stop, his vocals will keep on playing through the pa. But whatever man, this is common. It's no reason to stop liking STP.
RHCPfan 1 year ago
He's obviously lip synching. I'm a semi-professional musician and this sort of thing happens more often than you think. My singer in my own band contemplates lip synching anytime his vocal chords are feeling rough. People pay money to watch these shows so you obviously have to "perform" well. How could he possibly be singing perfectly in cue seconds after falling off stage? He should be gasping for air. Vocalists are frequently auto tuning their voices when recording and lip synching on stage...
RHCPfan 1 year ago
Anyone who thinks Scott lip syncs is an IDIOT.
Search for "Stone Temple Pilots Big Empty Jimmy Kimmel"
Suplexmachine 1 year ago
To use backing tracks the drummer has to play to a click track, this is when you know they are faking it by the drummers use of headphones. If you were to play this track along side other performance's and if they are bang on time its played to a click. But this is no good because you can not see scott after the fall, how bad was the fall he still could be holding the mic, its not impossible to sing into it.
CraigRattleHead 1 year ago
HAHAHAHAHAHA this is way too obvious
ToAscendUMustDie 1 year ago
badnews2008ad 1 year ago
I used to b a huge stp fan. Not anymore. They clearly got caught backlinning.
khoffman21 1 year ago
I am an STP fan, its really hard to argue the video evidence here. I can't imagine someone falling like this is being able to continue singing perfectly like nothing happened. And if he was fine enough to sing, why not get right back up?
dsgrce 1 year ago
Lip-sync? no
Playback? yes
nakedgunmusic 1 year ago
If STP is going to start lip syncing, I want lower ticket prices.
1965mcjohns 1 year ago
Radiohead
PuddleofChevelle 1 year ago
After Scott does a face first dive into the ground below the stage, the vocals continue without a hitch. I've seen STP 3 times since they reunited and half to say that those are his vocals continuing sounding as if they are off the Core CD. I know it's not Robert singing background vocals as Scott's are unmistakable. Also look at Dean Deleo throughing up his hands in frustraction at 2:49 toward the STP sound crew, while the guitar is still playing, in frustration that they did not stop the
1965mcjohns 1 year ago
After Scott does a face first dive into the ground below the stage, the vocals continue without a hitch. I've seen STP 3 times since they reunited and half to say that those are his vocals continuing sounding as if they are off the Core CD. I know it's not Robert singing background vocals as Scott's are unmistakable. Also look at Dean Deleo throughing up his hands in frustraction at 2:49 toward the STP sound crew, while the guitar is still playing, in frustration that they did not stop the ta
1965mcjohns 1 year ago
cocaine's a hell of a drug
RJ8812 1 year ago
If he was lip-syncing, don't you think the voice would sound the same as it does on the record? It doesn't make sense that he would record a vocal track pre-tour, why not just sing? I believe he doesn't use trickery. I believe Scott Weiland is an amazing singer, and perhaps has the professional attitude it takes to sing after falling. I am a little surprised that the band kept playing, though. Just seems weird.
pinkydisco81 1 year ago
1:27 ahah...poor scott....no playback... he is a superman that can sing the verse during the falling in the hole..
it's sad imagine that he was waiting the solo for coming back on stage....
danybr1 1 year ago
Scott doesn't lip sync at all, you HAVE to be kidding. I just saw them last week and was front center . . . NO lip sync. I love that he kept singing even from the pit.
ImWideAwakeNow 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Scott doesn't lip sync at all, you HAVE to be kidding. I just saw them last week and was front center . . . NO lip sync. I love that he kept singing even from the pit.
ImWideAwakeNow 1 year ago
Scott doesn't lip sync at all, you HAVE to be kidding. I just saw them last week and was front center . . . NO lip sync. I love that he kept singing even from the pit.
ImWideAwakeNow 1 year ago
lip synching??? No way. When he stood on the stage he mixed microphone singing with a megaphone. Please notice that after a fall he only sings to a microphone. And you can´t here megaphone. Get it??? Scott is the MAN.
fuckinlayne 1 year ago
@fuckinlayne Exactly right. Such an obvious point. Sad that it's lost on so many of these douchers that insist he lip synched.
adamf34 1 year ago
I like stp. But he was def lip synching.
matthewetchie 1 year ago
Play Back!
Alcaloid13 1 year ago
hahaha
luislpcity 1 year ago
Scott Weiland is a stupid motherfucker. Now everyone knows that he was lip synching lol
seaofmadness21 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Scot Weiland is a stupid motherfucker. Now everyone knows that he was lip synching lol
seaofmadness21 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Scott Weiland is a stupid motherfucker. Now everyone knows that he was lip synching lol
seaofmadness21 1 year ago
The other members were civering vocals for him. They don't lip sync, not even close.
Levirules 1 year ago
no offense but anyone who concludes that he's lip-syncing from this video is a) not an STP fan and wants the band to fail or b) likes to base conclusions on inconclusive evidence. this video doesnt show scott weiland lip syncing, nor is there any other indication of a vocal track.
did anyone consider the fact that after he fell he just continued singing? after all he didnt hoist himself back on to the stage until another break in the song.
illusionfly 1 year ago
the fag was lip synching.
dogtired75 1 year ago
sigh
Metalhead2399 1 year ago
in case anyone needed more proof of weiland sucking cock hard
Pissugar 1 year ago
dont forget guys, milli vanilli lip synched too
justinbenson6 1 year ago
lol BUSTED!!
tgrules565 1 year ago
the sound man forgot to cut the backing tape as he fell lol he is probably fired now poor guy!!
ryan25n 1 year ago
inconclusive if not slightly suspicious mmmmmmmmmm
ryan25n 1 year ago
MAKERTING
dacamoso 1 year ago
It's so obvious there's no playback that it makes me feel ashamed of those ones claiming there was a backing track. @CoveMusic: there's no "bullhorn voice" when he leaves it!! Are you deaf or what?? Listen at 1:10, he's singing live, the voice is far from perfect, sounds very different from the studio track, and you can hear the mic popping when he falls and a change in sound (from the "basement"). I think they acted very professionally!!
ecan 1 year ago
@ecan yeah, what he said. people just like hyping up stupid shit. it pisses me off that over the years people have really hoped for STP to fail... pretty much as long as ive been a fan of the band ive noticed the backlash.
illusionfly 1 year ago
@ 2:42 he somehow manages to make the "bullhorn voice" without the bullhorn?
CoveMusic 1 year ago
Where exactly did he fall? Backing track or not, its stupid to put something in the way of the performers.
colosalblack 1 year ago
he a freakin loser. that band sucks
PANSYCHRIS1920 1 year ago
im going to write a song about this and call it heroin puppet
mdf072 1 year ago
@mdf072 heroin puppets, i'm pulling your strings, twisting your mind and smashing your dreams, blinded y me you can't see a thing, just call my name and i'll hear you scream...lolz
Anticrombie918 1 year ago
Lol, what an idiot. Fail of a band for using lip syncing.
Henry14arsenal2007 1 year ago
Well, I'll not judge anything, but, fans normally accept anything that comes from theirs loved artists.
But one thing for sure, if I was in a show from my favorite band and discovered they're were not really playing I would be pi****, c'mon, it's a LIVE performance, that's why we go out to see our favorite bands, other way round just watch a dvd!!
And hey, shows are way too much expensive for us to be cheated!!
progshine 1 year ago
@progshine completly agreed
fede018 1 year ago
my least favorite grunge band is phony hahaha
vedicardi 1 year ago
saw them in pittsburgh last night...EPIC FAIL SCOTT! You could not hear any vocals...either they need to hang it up or they need to fire their sound guy.
jasemoto 1 year ago
LOL, scott's back on the H, that's why he was booted from VR in case you didn't know. Slash and the others have been clean for years but scott just could not kick it...and there have been tons of complaints from both reviewers and fans from their previous shows after the reunion about his singing off key -- and looking wasted. It's really sad that it's come to this though -- search for their MTV unplugged shows, he sounded so amazing then...it's sad what he's become.
surgeyX 1 year ago
@surgeyX , i thought he sounded pretty good in that clip.
JMillerbigass 1 year ago
@JMillerbigass
What? This one or the unplugged one?
It's pretty damned obvious he's lip syncing in this one lol...he fucking falls off stage and you dont hear a thud on the mic or anything and he just keeps going...there's NO way anyone could do that, and I bet if you asked someone who was close and could see exactly when he fell off if he was still singing they would probably say no.
surgeyX 1 year ago
@surgeyX , this one, at least until he fell. And you do hear a thud on the mic. And everyone who was there and actually saw Scott said they could see him still singing, several of whom have posted on this thread. Like I said before, nobody records guide vocal tracks singing flat or with inconsistent volume.
JMillerbigass 1 year ago
what song is this??
urgs14 1 year ago
@urgs14 , Crackerman.
JMillerbigass 1 year ago
i dont think he was lip syncing. they probably play his vocals behind his real vocals to fill it out better..
AntiVersion 1 year ago
Anyone saying that's lip synching is a total fucking idiot. I am a professional musician, and one thing I've learned about singers who use tracks is that the whole reason they use them is so they don't sound out of tune or have inconsistent volume. Notice that Scott's voice got quieter for the first few seconds, and he was a little out of tune.
So no, morons, it wasn't lip synching...it's what you call "professionalism."
JMillerbigass 1 year ago
@JMillerbigass HAHAHA
mdf072 1 year ago
@JMillerbigass
you must be some kinda special musician then.
CoveMusic 1 year ago
I wasn't at the show but from what I've gathered on the internet the people in the middle of the stage front row could look left and see it all... All of them have clearly stated that he actually stayed on point the whole time. No lip sync or backing tracks. Check your facts before making a conclusion based on one shity video... When another video or better pics of this incident emerge, all you haters can get off his nutz! You guys will have actually proven how kick ass Weiland is. THUMBS UP!
nephewofpop 1 year ago 5
@nephewofpop I always knew youtube comments were retarded, but you can't be serious? You are telling us to check facts when you admit you were NO WHERE NEAR the show? Wow. I'd point out the irony there, but I'm pretty sure you don't know what the word irony means. We are all stupider for having read your post nephewofpop. I award you 0 points, and may god have mercy on your soul.
AgentPothead 1 year ago
@MrEpiclyrandom But do Motley Crue really do it?
they may have done between Theatre Of pain and Girls Girls Girls as thats the point of when they were at the pincle of drug use. Dont get me wrong or take offence im saying there is a high chance they dont anymore as they aren't drugged up anymore.
MerryGuns 1 year ago
Only a cheap, half-baked atrist mime to his/her own songs :\
AnthonydWalsh 1 year ago
I wondered the same thing when I saw it happen. ( I was there too).
However, I did notice that he didn't get back on the stage until there was a break in the vocals, sooooo maybe he was singing from down there. Either way, it was still a really great show!
clarifier34 1 year ago
what a disgrace to the music industry these blokes are. LIP SYNCHRONIZING. Please do not beleive this BS that he fell off stage and KEPT SINGING bwahahahaha get real
Phazel1 1 year ago
I think those 5-6 stagehands know for sure.....
giantrobot9000 1 year ago
hhhahahahahahhhhahahah He Sucks!!
chomponthis13 1 year ago
the people in the front row cant even see him, how can they say they saw him keep singing. Look how hard he falls. When he would be hittin the ground, not even a second later he's singing perfect pitch not missing a note. yeah rite.
chasekitchens 1 year ago
Uh-oh spaghetti-o's!
Jashre 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
there is no way Scott Weiland, one of the best frontmen out there, is lip synching. The man is a true professional and obviously stayed down in the pit to finish the verse and THEN got back up on stage. He was singing & moving fine the rest of the show. I've seen STP & Scott many times and there is no way he is lip synching. Obviously the haters have not been to a show where he's changed the lyrics or sung differently from city to city.
sourgirl1991 1 year ago
there is no way Scott Weiland, one of the best frontmen out there, is lip synching. The man is a true professional and obviously stayed down in the pit to finish the verse and THEN got back up on stage. He was singing & moving fine the rest of the show. I've seen STP & Scott many times and there is no way he is lip synching. Obviously the haters have not been to a show where he's changed the lyrics or sung differently from city to city.
sourgirl1991 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
there is no way Scott Weiland, one of the best frontmen out there, is lip synching. The man is a true professional and obviously stayed down in the pit to finish the verse and THEN got back up on stage. He was singing & moving fine the rest of the show. I've seen STP & Scott many times and there is no way he is lip synching. Obviously the haters have not been to a show where he's changed the lyrics or sung differently from city to city.
sourgirl1991 1 year ago
Comment removed
sourgirl1991 1 year ago
I've seen Scott perform several times. He's slipped & hit hit head right in front of me and he kept singing. That's just how he is. He's a real rockstar. This man, is one of THE best performers!! He'd get slammed for "forgetint lyrics" or said the lines wrong... Now he's getting slammed for being a pro & continuing to sing?? You people are just too much.
Thank God he couldn't care less about what anyone thinks. A weaker person would've given up on trying to prove themselves to you people.
weilandfanmel 1 year ago 2
Scott Weiland has never nor will ever lip synch.
Loungefly37 1 year ago 2
@Loungefly37
Yeah I agree, these people are just conspiracy theorists out to ruin his name. If you fall you can clearly still sing even though it would be pretty much impossible to talk properly, let alone sing. Even though the crew was helping him you could still sing. I mean, who needs a mic to sing right? Hell, if you fall and you're still singing in tune... you've gotta be great!
Fudging conspiracy theorists... those fudgers.
cjk100000 1 year ago
@cjk100000 hahahaha conspiracy theorists.. are you some kind of junkie idiot?
And what if he is really lip synching? Its like an unfalsifiable hypothesis - cant prove it unless you ask the right man.
konkelberryfinn 1 year ago
@konkelberryfinn
Well I guess my sarcasm went over your head, can you not read the sarcasm that is dripping from what I am saying?
Epic fail.
cjk100000 1 year ago
@cjk100000 well you seemed really serious
konkelberryfinn 1 year ago
@konkelberryfinn
Well you interpreted it as serious.
I checked my post with my friend and he immediately said "lol @ sarcasm", so I know it wasn't a fuckup on my part.
cjk100000 1 year ago
I'm just gonna say he had a great recovery. That's why he waited for the solo to get back onstage, he was still singing.
IANicecreamCONE 1 year ago
I was in the pit about 5 feet from where it happened. Scott didn't miss a beat, he still rocks!!
BethisEvel75 1 year ago
Haters gunna hate. STP fucking rocks.
Mattmoo36 1 year ago
@MiniDiscProducer --- Hopefully this current misfortune will be set straight and made right in timely fashion..... Next they will be saying that he doesn't even write all the songs he takes credit for...
malocchio10 1 year ago
theres a playback, a low one tough. Its just like when you doubble vocals during recording sessions. You can hear that the first line after the fall is really low. Then he managed to sing otherwise everyone would notice. And then, the vocals get louder. The guy is talentes, everyone double vocals, including John Lenon and Kurt cobain. But they didnt do it live tough
guilhermecarneiro1 1 year ago
LOL 1:24
and RENAME VIDEO omg :)
33COOLMAN33 1 year ago
FRAUDS! They were bandwagon jumpin' grunge sell outs anyway so this is no surprise.
Radz117 1 year ago
Having been there, and seen and HEARD it, its obvious that some people don't have ears or were not there. While I will agree its hard and nearly imposible to hear in the video, those who were sober and there could hear the mic fall. I also happened to be at the end of the speaker stack and could SEE Scott singing behind the speakers. I ran over there because like many I thought it was strange to here him and not see him after that fall. I could see him singing, and oh yeah the bass sings too
contrascout 1 year ago
Change the name of the video!
Calvin0135 1 year ago
I know it's messed up BUT TRUE.
gitarman42 1 year ago
I was there he was not singing. I know it's messed BUT TRUE.
gitarman42 1 year ago
I'm with MiniDiscProducer. The video may look deceptive, and it's unfortunate, but the people who were really in the pit when it went down know what's up. No way was there any inauthenticity to this performance, should have gotten a plaque for it... Definitely kicked ass, period. Take the word of people that were actually there who witnessed it first hand... Dude is for real.
dumblove01 1 year ago 5
PLAYBACK
tiofela69 1 year ago
I've seen STP several times live and Weiland's vocals always sound a little different show to show. He DOESN'T use backing tracks. I've seen him hoarse, sober, drunk, drugged, and perfect, and his voice is a bit different each way.
smmforum 1 year ago
I love STP, but it's ashame most of the band members are assholes in person.
sniggity 1 year ago
@gpz108 He did not use the bullhorn during the song, which explains the vocals staying the same. And there are pictures out where you can CLEARLY see Scott singing down there while security is pulling him up.
HotelYorba101 1 year ago
Idiots. I was at the show... in the pit. Not only does he miss a line in the second chorus (would that be on a back track too?) there is also no megaphone present (which tumbled to the ground when he did). Want further proof?
Hit these awesome pics up from the show. 2nd to last pic shows him rocking it out in the pit before the solo. Dude is a rock God. Deal with it!
KjWar 1 year ago
@KjWar Where's the pics?
gitarman42 1 year ago
LAME!! LMAO.....all those suckers bought tix to the most expensive karaoke show ever! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA Sucks cuz I was gonna go see em', but forget it now! LOL
lilbonsaii 1 year ago
play back????
Kamilop 1 year ago
Comment removed
ERROCKER 1 year ago
Glad he's OK - saw them in Philly this year, AWESOME show.
disshoisgood 1 year ago
Its hard to tell for sure. He's been singing and preforming for a LONG time. I doubt this is the first time he's even fallen while on stage or something has happened where he had to sing through adversity.
sucks if its true though, but you can't really tell.
JohnnyDarko01 1 year ago
i love STP, but is clear that he lip-synced
fede018 1 year ago
Ashley Simpson didn't get away with it, neither will Scott Weiland. No excuse.
pissed7off 1 year ago
Vocal tracks fo sho. Busted.
creighton75 1 year ago