This is very good performance. Pollini did great job. There are very few vids with this study on Youtube such well played as Pollini did. Once more, Great performance!!!
sorry pall - I had the opportunity to listen to great pianists and yes I pretend that I can compare: of all pianists I've heard in my life (I'm 56 now) there are a few that left a permanent superb impression on me and there I'd like to name Mauritio Pollini as a living legend. He plays Chopin and Schuman as no-one-else.He plays it so well that in the same moment as you look at him you'll see Chopin. He is unique phantastic, my english is unfortunately too bad to put him in the right light.
@gentenaarinzweden I like the complete set of chopin etudes by pollini the most (as the whole set). But he is not superb in about any piece he plays. For example, nobody can play this etude as one flow to the coda as Richter did
Maybe I'll get a girlfriend if I learn this song. Pretty impressive. I'd like to know the fingering for this piece, like how it's supposed to be executed.
why the heck didn't the owner make this available for mobile. I mean there's way more reasons to be paranoid about someone ripping it on a desktop. Mobile, not so much. please explain. All that does is sacrifice convenience and ability to share. So why bother to publish at all. My friend shated.. I... what? I can't do anything.
Strabiliante e trascinante lirismo, denso di fiammeggiante e vibrante densità sonora e timbrica. Cantabilità spiegata e quasi delirante in altissima velocità !!! Nessuno può reggere un tale devastante confronto, per non parlare della poesia del virtuosismo e della lirica interiore del componimento !!! Tutti gli altri spariscono, impietosamente schiacciati dal confronto con un inarrivabile e stratosferico Maurizio Pollini, in particolare stato di grazia divina !!!
@TheonHafet300 *gives you a high-five* I love Kingdom Hearts Concert Paraphrase on Dearly Beloved! It really does sound similar to this song's arpeggios!
The funny thing is that playing the correct notes in this piece is rather easy. Telling a story with this piece, on the other hand, is a different subject.....
this piece is so visceral and primal, you can feel it in your gut. you can feel why they call this etude "ocean." and i agree about pollini being an incredible performer for chopin's etudes. i know too little to say how he stacks up to others, but his ability to take all that technique gained from decades of study and translate every ounce of it into pure expression is absolutely breathtaking.
This performance is broad and deep, rich and intense, full of strife yet completion...one of the best i've heard. Pollini's phrasing and weightiness never fades throughout the piece -what energy and drive. I think i held my breath the whole time, then gasped at the end!
Just curious, has anyone heard Guiomar Novaes play this? We have her recording of the Etudes on record, but this one was sadly not recorded.
I love all Pollini's performances, but for this particular etude, my favorite by far is Cziffra's - he *really* bangs this one, which just suits it imo. Worth a listen, I'd say!
This is a very beautiful interpretation, but you gottta check this one played by Valentina Lisitsa here /watch?v=RFPcy2h-H9E She's astonishing, and Bösendorfer she plays on makes this etude sound even better.
Nadie supera a pollini tocando a Chopin. Esta obra junto al preludio no.24 son las que mejor recogen el espíritu agitado, pasionalmente intenso y aristocrático con el que Chopin componía, reflejo de ese oscuramente romántico mundo interior suyo.
Yes, I agree. Pollini performs it wonderfully! Other pianists exaggerate one detail or another. In Pollini's performance there is a perfect balance in tempo, stresses, in many-many important nuances.
It is awesome but I do have one problem with these Pollini Etude recordings: the sound of it is just a little too harsh to my tastes. I prefer a warmer sound.
Oddly enough I think Valentina Lisitsa's interpretation is the most convincing since Cortot's. Pollini, Horowitz, Arrau--though their interpretations are without a doubt transcendental--don't have that perfect articulation of the bass melody and soprano echoes.
The old masters could play Chopin in a way that no contemporary pianist will ever be able to. But when it comes to the etudes, today's master technicians dominate.
its good to study these, both the music and the great interpretations. check out ashkenazy its a bit slower but you can hear so much in it, its like the tempo gives it something more, i like this but the Ashkenazy will always be my favorite
Pollini doesn't own the preludes and etudes. And he'll never do that. Cziffra owns them.
The only two etude, who are better played by Pollini then by Cziffra, are this one and op. 25 no. 7.
But again, Pollini absolutely doesn't own the etudes, really! His technical performance is almost perfect, but boring. Not emotional. Listen to Cziffra, he'll make the etudes really emotional for you.
? Have you heard Cziffra play Chopins 1st etude? He plays it soo fast and uncontrolled, you can hear the mistakes he makes (he gets "stuck" on the high notes, and changes tempo). On this one he plays it well, but not as well as Pollini. Pollinis better. Cziffra probably would have thought so as well.
@Theonedue Maybe you think Cziffra plays uncontrolled and fast, but he's the only pianist who can FEEL the composer in his soul while playing. He's absolutely better then Pollini and other pianist. Like Cortot said: "It doesn't matter if you make any mistakes. If you can bring about something with the music, then you're a incredibly good pianist." And he's right. Always.
@0angeplume0 - Unfortunatly we can't tell who could play better. It's amazing enough that Pollini could play this, but even more amazing that Chopin could write this.
So how many mistakes can a pianist make without detracting from the music? 7, 8, 15? Cizffra not only made a significant number of mistakes, but he changed tempo during the piece as well. His interpretations might in some cases be better than Pollinis, but Pollini has better technique and makes less mistakes than Cizffra on Chopins 1st etude, and probably others. Besides, classical music is best when it is played as written. I'd rather listen to a perfect recording than a interpretation with mis
@Theonedue Ok, it's right that a pianist doesn't have to make too many mistakes, but I don't know what you're talking about at all. I've listen to the etude again, played by Cziffra and I didn't can hear a mistake. And classical music is something you have to feel, not to make perfect. If you think like that, you don't know what classical music is! And Cziffra's interpretations are ALWAYS better than Pollini's.
I'm learning this piece now! I started off blocking the chords, and it's not to hard to learn the notes and the patterns, but it will take a long time to get up to speed. It's a very fun piece!!!
This is very good performance. Pollini did great job. There are very few vids with this study on Youtube such well played as Pollini did. Once more, Great performance!!!
MaslAlek 4 weeks ago
sorry pall - I had the opportunity to listen to great pianists and yes I pretend that I can compare: of all pianists I've heard in my life (I'm 56 now) there are a few that left a permanent superb impression on me and there I'd like to name Mauritio Pollini as a living legend. He plays Chopin and Schuman as no-one-else.He plays it so well that in the same moment as you look at him you'll see Chopin. He is unique phantastic, my english is unfortunately too bad to put him in the right light.
gentenaarinzweden 1 month ago
@gentenaarinzweden I like the complete set of chopin etudes by pollini the most (as the whole set). But he is not superb in about any piece he plays. For example, nobody can play this etude as one flow to the coda as Richter did
BlazeKenny 1 month ago
i love it
ioana1256 2 months ago
the intro is similar bliss by muse
muserdave 3 months ago
@muserdave you mean, intro bliss by muse is similar to this intro ;)
rallasclandestinas 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I sail into the ocean.
apluspianist 3 months ago
takes.
Theonedue 3 months ago
Maybe I'll get a girlfriend if I learn this song. Pretty impressive. I'd like to know the fingering for this piece, like how it's supposed to be executed.
ericisindebt 4 months ago in playlist ericisindebt's favorites
The best way to get a girlfriend is to look like a supermodel. Trust me.
Theonedue 3 months ago
why the heck didn't the owner make this available for mobile. I mean there's way more reasons to be paranoid about someone ripping it on a desktop. Mobile, not so much. please explain. All that does is sacrifice convenience and ability to share. So why bother to publish at all. My friend shated.. I... what? I can't do anything.
Cyberchipz 4 months ago
Pure Brilliance is the only thing you can describe Chopin's Work as, simple perfect
chrissyluvspeace 5 months ago
does the melody line around 0:25 remind anyone of tchaikovsky's trio?
randomdude1020 5 months ago
When Chopin or Liszt played this piece, this is what it sounded like.
Theonedue 6 months ago
@Theonedue You're that old? :O
addeex1 5 months ago
@Theonedue How do you know?
Jarnobh 3 months ago
This is a very great performance of this etude, one of the best imo.
Zoldi77 7 months ago
mind blowing....this Etude is as fresh as it was 170 years ago...
and Pollini is KING.
otavioandradas 7 months ago
Strabiliante e trascinante lirismo, denso di fiammeggiante e vibrante densità sonora e timbrica. Cantabilità spiegata e quasi delirante in altissima velocità !!! Nessuno può reggere un tale devastante confronto, per non parlare della poesia del virtuosismo e della lirica interiore del componimento !!! Tutti gli altri spariscono, impietosamente schiacciati dal confronto con un inarrivabile e stratosferico Maurizio Pollini, in particolare stato di grazia divina !!!
darkblueangel1956 7 months ago
Comment removed
lllmozartlll 7 months ago
This performance has real depth and real class. A great performance of a great piece.
simondurrant1 7 months ago
I finally understand why youtube has bad grammer 1 DISLIKES?? it should be more than one if there is an "s"
But don't mind that, youtube got calculating problems too. there should be no dislikes as it is so beautiful
TheSoken123 7 months ago
@TheSoken123 1 person dislikes ;)
MKA829 7 months ago
@TheonHafet300 *gives you a high-five* I love Kingdom Hearts Concert Paraphrase on Dearly Beloved! It really does sound similar to this song's arpeggios!
BreAnakyh 7 months ago
Comment removed
TheEvilEmporerBunny 8 months ago
This is an amazing recording! It took me on the second watch to be able to follow the music haha AMAZING!
612curtis 8 months ago
lols i like this interpretation but still i prefer Cziffra's version unfortunately.
DunNotCome 8 months ago 3
Pollini is the best interpret of chopin's etudes ever. I play on piano since I was 5 and I've never heard better interpretation from anyone...
richie00lama 8 months ago
@richie00lama Then you have to listen to Cziffra.
Jarnobh 3 months ago
Comment removed
mspianosoul 9 months ago
@mspianosoul Yes you are
sebastianrc 8 months ago
The funny thing is that playing the correct notes in this piece is rather easy. Telling a story with this piece, on the other hand, is a different subject.....
RoellW94 9 months ago
KINGDOM HEARTS CONCERT PARAPHRASE!!!!
TheonHafet300 10 months ago 11
Sorry but anybody plays this etude like Pollini, also the new talented net women
homonovus6 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this piece is so visceral and primal, you can feel it in your gut. you can feel why they call this etude "ocean." and i agree about pollini being an incredible performer for chopin's etudes. i know too little to say how he stacks up to others, but his ability to take all that technique gained from decades of study and translate every ounce of it into pure expression is absolutely breathtaking.
kreesu 10 months ago
Comment removed
begemotnozri 10 months ago
Too easy. I composed this with Mario Piano.
PirateReviewer 10 months ago
100'th like :)
iDanielVideo 11 months ago
WONDERFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =D
Dante121892 11 months ago
This performance is broad and deep, rich and intense, full of strife yet completion...one of the best i've heard. Pollini's phrasing and weightiness never fades throughout the piece -what energy and drive. I think i held my breath the whole time, then gasped at the end!
Just curious, has anyone heard Guiomar Novaes play this? We have her recording of the Etudes on record, but this one was sadly not recorded.
Katheryne
ProLifeMontanaLass 11 months ago 3
The most elegant and accurate performance.
geostoi 11 months ago
I love all Pollini's performances, but for this particular etude, my favorite by far is Cziffra's - he *really* bangs this one, which just suits it imo. Worth a listen, I'd say!
8Ho03EdONl1liL 1 year ago
OMG
sttar1982 1 year ago
The best Version :))
hideharumijahir 1 year ago
@hideharumijahir
This is a very beautiful interpretation, but you gottta check this one played by Valentina Lisitsa here /watch?v=RFPcy2h-H9E She's astonishing, and Bösendorfer she plays on makes this etude sound even better.
MikeKushnir 1 year ago
@MikeKushnir No!
hideharumijahir 1 year ago
Whatever it is, Pollini has got it! The concise, expressive playing is the best I've heard. Excellent performance!
goldie0800 1 year ago 2
Pollini is the God of all pianists
gipsymustang 1 year ago
Nadie supera a pollini tocando a Chopin. Esta obra junto al preludio no.24 son las que mejor recogen el espíritu agitado, pasionalmente intenso y aristocrático con el que Chopin componía, reflejo de ese oscuramente romántico mundo interior suyo.
astronomo16 1 year ago
Yes, I agree. Pollini performs it wonderfully! Other pianists exaggerate one detail or another. In Pollini's performance there is a perfect balance in tempo, stresses, in many-many important nuances.
ProzrevshujRomantik 1 year ago 3
the only mistake i heard was after 2:29 :D
sychokillin 1 year ago 5
@sychokillin It got incredibly sloppy then
mrgouls 1 year ago
i LOVE the flow in Pollini's version! shear brilliance.
iWillBlockYou 1 year ago 2
I don't think I'll ever get tired of listening to this interpretation...
devoludo 1 year ago
before i die i want to learn this song, hopefully ^_^
qwerty1234524 1 year ago
@Temporum91
The older one was deleted.
NjallPiano 1 year ago
Remember the "expand" button ;)
newFranzFerencLiszt 1 year ago 12
It is awesome but I do have one problem with these Pollini Etude recordings: the sound of it is just a little too harsh to my tastes. I prefer a warmer sound.
tweriovnzxclb 1 year ago
@tweriovnzxclb i agree
Deredbaron 1 year ago
How coincidental, the theme at the beginning of the Etude is used in Kingdom Hearts 2 during the final battle against Xemnas!
SqueekyMonkey101 1 year ago
@SqueekyMonkey101 that's not a coincidence, that's an artistic choice
macari65 1 year ago
Hm. Reminds me of Liszt's Transcendental Etude No.6 a bit, no?
Zsup 1 year ago
@Zsup A little bit yeah, although I think Liszt's is more inventive. It's hard to choose between the two!
devoludo 1 year ago
Oddly enough I think Valentina Lisitsa's interpretation is the most convincing since Cortot's. Pollini, Horowitz, Arrau--though their interpretations are without a doubt transcendental--don't have that perfect articulation of the bass melody and soprano echoes.
The old masters could play Chopin in a way that no contemporary pianist will ever be able to. But when it comes to the etudes, today's master technicians dominate.
inblahblahland 1 year ago
franz how did ur old account get banned?
xxxxx123456789xxxxx1 1 year ago
its good to study these, both the music and the great interpretations. check out ashkenazy its a bit slower but you can hear so much in it, its like the tempo gives it something more, i like this but the Ashkenazy will always be my favorite
anonymousQ45 1 year ago
the best on youtube...the best anywhere.
kiitoob 1 year ago 6
What an interpretation! Much more soul and refinement than Lisitsa!
Allegro11Maestoso 1 year ago 2
POLLINI OWNS THE ETUDES.
BleedingLlama 1 year ago 54
Comment removed
BiniJH 1 year ago
@BleedingLlama
Pollini doesn't own the preludes and etudes. And he'll never do that. Cziffra owns them.
The only two etude, who are better played by Pollini then by Cziffra, are this one and op. 25 no. 7.
But again, Pollini absolutely doesn't own the etudes, really! His technical performance is almost perfect, but boring. Not emotional. Listen to Cziffra, he'll make the etudes really emotional for you.
Jarnobh 4 months ago
? Have you heard Cziffra play Chopins 1st etude? He plays it soo fast and uncontrolled, you can hear the mistakes he makes (he gets "stuck" on the high notes, and changes tempo). On this one he plays it well, but not as well as Pollini. Pollinis better. Cziffra probably would have thought so as well.
Theonedue 3 months ago
@Theonedue Maybe you think Cziffra plays uncontrolled and fast, but he's the only pianist who can FEEL the composer in his soul while playing. He's absolutely better then Pollini and other pianist. Like Cortot said: "It doesn't matter if you make any mistakes. If you can bring about something with the music, then you're a incredibly good pianist." And he's right. Always.
Jarnobh 3 months ago
Just few days ago I started with all op. 25.. Gift from my prof. for this semester.. :)
Of coarse I played many of them before... but never in a row as 1 composition..
Happy Chopinizing myself.. :p
dusanholy 2 years ago 2
Undoubtedly, nobody can play this piece better than Pollini.
JohnChanJohnChan 2 years ago 66
@JohnChanJohnChan Chopin could! >:)
tOtAlLyInLoVeWiThEd 1 year ago
@JohnChanJohnChan Maybe Chopin can? well could have
PlatyMoos 11 months ago
@JohnChanJohnChan
Chopin himself can't play better than Pollini too?
0angeplume0 6 months ago
@0angeplume0 - Unfortunatly we can't tell who could play better. It's amazing enough that Pollini could play this, but even more amazing that Chopin could write this.
MusicIsMyLife6991 6 months ago
@JohnChanJohnChan pssh. i know a guy... CHOPIN. ohhhh, burn.
RadioCity96 5 months ago
@JohnChanJohnChan Oh, yes! Someone can! Cziffra can do that!
Jarnobh 3 months ago
So how many mistakes can a pianist make without detracting from the music? 7, 8, 15? Cizffra not only made a significant number of mistakes, but he changed tempo during the piece as well. His interpretations might in some cases be better than Pollinis, but Pollini has better technique and makes less mistakes than Cizffra on Chopins 1st etude, and probably others. Besides, classical music is best when it is played as written. I'd rather listen to a perfect recording than a interpretation with mis
Theonedue 3 months ago
@Theonedue Ok, it's right that a pianist doesn't have to make too many mistakes, but I don't know what you're talking about at all. I've listen to the etude again, played by Cziffra and I didn't can hear a mistake. And classical music is something you have to feel, not to make perfect. If you think like that, you don't know what classical music is! And Cziffra's interpretations are ALWAYS better than Pollini's.
Jarnobh 3 months ago
Tragica nostalgia di Chopin ... è uno studio fantastico eseguito egregiamente da Pollini
:-))
robertoladisa 2 years ago
I'm learning this piece now! I started off blocking the chords, and it's not to hard to learn the notes and the patterns, but it will take a long time to get up to speed. It's a very fun piece!!!
jsnivepiano 2 years ago 2
Absolutely beautiful! Seems easy to learn the notes (same pattern), but difficult to polish and perform well (like many of the etudes).
I'd love to learn this one.
OrangeSodaKing 2 years ago 2
A great etude.
TheCinemaization 2 years ago
I'm learning this piece right now and it's kicking my ass! lol. Amazing interpretation *****
Toxxic88 2 years ago
best interpretation ever
sklenickajan 2 years ago 2
Imagine giving this guy a 5 hour energy before a concert O.O
BruceLeeKills1 2 years ago 3
Simply magnificent!!!!
sevcik2 2 years ago 5
jesus O_O
amazing...
Agiyi 2 years ago 2
Very good!
Paige886 2 years ago 2