Added: 2 months ago
From: JoshSaysStuff
Views: 861
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (83)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I don't approve of those parts of the fandom either, but all I have to say is that all fandoms do that. Slash pairings, freaky fanfics, gross fetishes, and character molding. All fandoms do it. It isn't unique to MLP FiM

  • i do agree about the whole lesbian shipping. not a big fan of it. all other shipping doesnt really bother me though

  • THANK YOU for Derpy about Muffins! My gosh there were other ponies speaking during the clip not just her..

  • I like Derpy liking muffins...muffins are good...and i like shipping but people "clopping" to ponies scares me TTnTT i do agree though, and i am also a brony...

  • THATS WHAT YOU GET FOR BEING ON THE INTERNET! Trust me it gets weird i know, but just the fact that it exist doesn't mean it isn't a part of the fandom that's locked away. Plus it's the internet people can do as they pleased. Even if it isn't totally SFW.

  • I agree 500% sir.

  • @Billsthenamefirst Well I agree 600%. Jelly? =3

  • I hate the show and toys so much its so annoying what ever game i go on people talk about it or have names to do with it Its fuckin annoyin

  • I agree with basically everything. One of the Internet rules says it best: "the more innocent something is, the more fun it is to corrupt it." I'm nots sure if that's the exact quote, but you get it right? And yeah. Shipping has gone too far with clopfics and stuff. I'm okay with them being "in love" in a fanfic or something. Yeah. We kind of need to steer back to innocence before we become Furries...

  • What have we BECOME!!! D:

  • Lol there are no problems.

  • aah shipping… tearing fandoms apart and giving them a bad name ever since…. pretty much the

    invention of the internet..

  • Comment removed

  • Kudos to you. Your the kind of people that make this fandom amazing. It's not only that you have logic, but arent afraid to point out the worst aspect's of something you are.

  • I haven't read cupcakes I almost watched the animation but it quickly started looking alot like a nightmare I might have, so I stopped and went somewhere else. I'll leave the really fucked off shit for my actual dreams where ponies a very very very rarely spotted and luckily so far have been spared my overly morbid imagination. Also, just on the sexual stuff, that to me, is like what it must be like to find out Santa is a fraud at like 5 years old on christmas eve. heart wrenching.

  • kinda unrelated but you were sayin it didn't have to be sexual and there was an add next to your vid that stated "only sexy is sexy" juss thought that was humorous

  • Also, what I really wanted to tell you was that I found MLP: FIM Valentine's Day cards and I'm going to hand them out to my friends next week :3 I'm also in my second to last year of high school xD I haven't handed out cards in years but I saw them and they were too awesome I couldn't resist :)

  • Hello, I am a pegasister. I appreciate that someone is trying to draw a line between fans and fangirls/fanboys with this thing. In my opinion, fans are people who love the show and understand the characters and try to portray them properly with their art/stories dedicated to the show. Fanboys/fangirls are people who are more interested in what the fandom has made the characters instead of the beauty of the actual show itself.

  • Damn, that's a nice set of guitars!

  • "Rainbow Dash is not a Lesbian.

    She is a Tomboy.

    She is a Cartoon Character.

    She does not have a Sexuality.

    Like...Are you kidding me?

    This is Stupid.

    She is a Pony!"

    Exactly what I thought!

    (still enjoy Fanfics and Shipping [minus Clopping])

  • I have to agree with everything you said, bud. Good stuff.

    With Derpy, though, I'm confused if it was really her who said muffins. If you look up the clip with that episode, it looks like either Colgate or Derpy said it. Your guess would be as good as mine. Either way, I love Derpy and pretty much all of the ponies. ^^

    Anyways, I don't really let what some fans do bother me, like with Berry Punch being a big drinker or Derpy being a muffin lover. Love and tolerance, man.

    *brohoof*

  • ...everypony knew about, if a piece of work makes alot of noise like cupcakes did, it is the one that will stay the most memorable, that's just how the mind works, you'll notice that another fanfiction that has emerged that is garnering just as much attention as cupcakes did is "my little dashie" which is a sweet story.

  • ... rule34 is "if it exists there is porn of it", this applies to MLP as well as unfortunate as it is, but on the flipside this applies to any and everything, believe me, i have seen rule34 of the strangest and most disgusting of things from teletubbies to dora the explorer (CANNOT BE UNSEEN OH GOD IT BURNS!) its just that MLP has become a huge sensation that these things are much easier to notice.

    cupcakes: it was latched onto because it stood out, it was noticeable, it was something that...

  • ... but i digress, the reasoning behind why a good chunk of the fandom considers these ponies lesbians, is simply because there are signficantly more female ponies than male ponies, in short, it's a running joke. as for rainbow dash being a lesbian, there is a constant war between those who say she is and those who say she isn't so her being a lesbian isn't even solid withing the fandom.

    rule34 (the sexual aspect you described): this is something you'll just have to deal with...

  • ... give derpy, i mean heck, her name (at the time) wasn't even derpy, it was "nameless pony" or possibly "ditsy doo" believe it or not, fan characters have close to no connection with the show because that's what they are, fan characters, so nitpicking over their personalities is fruitless to begin with.

    ships: first, and only cause it's bothering me, Derpy Hooves doesn't have a ship with anypony, she has a daughter and if anything she is usually tied, but unromantically, with Doctor Whooves..

  • ... naturally offend them, and should be met with a defence of the beliefs of values being assulted. this unfortunately can get out of hand and turn into hate as we are humans, anger is a part of our nature whether you like it or not.

    minor characters: you are right about the you nitpicking here, berry punch being a drunk, derpy not actually saying muffins, that's the thing about fandom, whether or not derpy actually said muffins is irrelevant, that is the aspect the entire fandom decided to...

  • very good video, expresses your concern very nicely, now for some counter points.

    ponybook: never heard of it so i can't say anything there.

    hating people who don't like us: you're referring to a group of bronies, not all, for the most part as far as i've seen, the very first thing a majority of bronies who encounter someone who doesn't know or doesn't like is to suggest watching it. there is a difference however, between "toleratation" and being a punching bag, hate towards a group will...

  • I found out about broines a few months ago and thought the whole concept of older men watching a show for girls was weird. So I said that I thought it was weird and all I got was hate. Therefor I thought broines and the show itself was shitty. Got around to watching an episode and loved it, all along these people could have told me to watch it.

  • 100% true we need to share this with the so called fans of MLP i think most of the fans on youtube are weird and just trolling

  • I agree 100% with your video!

  • by the way, THANK YOU. you said RD is a tomboy and i love you for it! i swear, people have forgotten the term "tomboy." nowadays if a girl happens to be tough and boyish, SHE'S TOTALLY A LESBIAN. not.

  • Derpy said muffins. they were looking at muffins when she said it. but they were all background ponies anyway and one of the other ponies in front her and slightly to the right moved their mouth at the same time. so i think they both said muffins. and i like how the Brony fandom is giving some of the background ponies some character. it makes them more interesting. :)

  • I thought part of being a brony is the fan-fics, you don't have to hate it?. And well for a Fandom built on older men and boys you will expect a lot of weird perverted stuff.

  • BROHOOFS to you man /)(\, and to all that dont get us...*calls Rainbow dash* "get the orbital friend ship cannon ready, NOOW!"

  • For some reason im felling like MLP is becoming like a new religion to me

    Why: i have a Computer background of fluttershy, my comps history is full of My Little Pony and i have a picture of AppleJack on my desk...*SQUEE*

  • hnng, "conteXt"

  • It's interesting to me to see a brony that's more normal.

    Let me put it this way: I am a bigger fan of the fandom than I am of the show. I watch the show because it's cute (etc), but also because it gives me the contest I need to understand the fan-made art, music, writing.

    "Cupcakes" is a good example. We have latched onto that and it alone has generated SO MUCH CONTENT. It's amazing.

    Hey, go look up "Beyond Her Tomb." It's moved really far away from the show. But it's still really neat.

  • I agree. On everything. Thank god my favorite pony, Applejack (don't hurt me for this), admins are awesome and stay in character. And yeah, pony porn is just.... no.

  • Finally a cool brony with enough balls to speak out!

  • JOSH REPLY TO TIS COMMENT PLOX ALSO HAI

  • JoshSaysStuff. Do better? U want me to troll u? I would suggest u put a hat on after u take a shower. Helped me brohoof.

  • @bubbaman11000 "Trolling" doesn't do anything. All I see on my side is text. So go ahead, I guess.

    Besides, I cut it. You can see that in my newer videos.

  • Nice helmet. But I agree with your opinions. Also Derpy did say muffins because they were looking at muffins. Watched every episode at least 3 times? Doubt it.

  • @bubbaman11000 My bad, then. No need to get all condescending over nothing.

    Also, insulting someone's looks? Come on. You're better than that.

  • @bubbaman11000 derpy, and 2 other ponies also said muffins at the same time, so you can't prove anything.

  • YOU ARE AWESOME! I totally agree. i'm a girl, but you're awesome. And I want to know why the current series doesn't have the mini-divisions of ponies like in the original! They had Seahorses! Flutter Ponies and stuff!

  • Comment removed

  • I also generally liked the "given" personalities to some of the main ponies (mainly Trollestia), because picking out little innuendos here and there is a lot of fun. XD

  • I agree with most of what you said, but I have to say that I love the more popular background characters. I always thought it was pretty cool to have some random pony in the background somewhere do the most insignificant thing, and just blow up in popularity. Take DJ Pon-3 (Vinyl Scratch). She had a three second appearance and was recognized as OC Weekly’s #1 cartoon DJ. That's awesome.

  • You make a ton of good points in this video! Except the part about the background characters - Lauren Faust and Co. actually liked how the fans could find the animation error in Derpy's eyes and the small quote in the episode that they actually made "Derpy" her canon name, despite the previous plans to make it "Ditzy." But I agree with you for the most part. I don't follow Rule 34, and I used to despise anyone who followed it. Then I became smart and thought, "LET THEM." Who cares anyways?

  • @3arlGray I agree, but it's more of an issue of giving the fandom a bad name by making it sexual. We don't want a ton of hate like some other fandoms do.

    And I like how we enjoy some background characters, but do we really have to make clopfics about them? That's the sort of thing I mean.

  • @JoshSaysStuff On a side note, what do you use to record? Do you have some kind of camera, or is it a webcam?

  • So, the Little Luna facebook page/the others associated in that group of her peers bother you too? I thought I was the only one. It's honestly very obnoxious how they act. :T

  • @GenoHasFury Oh, they're -horrible-.

    Those people really need to stop giving the show and the fandom a bad name. They're immature attention-grabbing youths (and sadly, some college students) that shouldn't have a following in any form. ._.

  • HOW CAN YOU NOT LIKE LESSON ZERO! its when they started their new animation techniques.

  • @CaptchaRescue But the character qualities were sub-par in the other five of the mane six, and the animation techniques were iffy at best.

    They made up for it in the Rarity episodes, though. :D <3

  • @JoshSaysStuff Yah but in the sisterhooves social rariry was asking applejack for advice on GENEROSITY... HER ELEMENT!!!!!!!!

  • Oh! And cheers for the heads-up about the pony FB drama. Yeah.. I'll definitely NOT be liking individual characters on FB now! Can't stand pony drama. >.<

  • PRINCESS MOLESTIA! AHahaha! XD Okay, that cracked me up.

    Oh and Derpy was looking at Muuufiiiiins. ;D

    Seriously though being a brony means different things to different people.. I don't call myself a brony (or a pegasis), just a fan. BUT I still love all the pony porn! XD

    Cool video though dude. I liked it. :)

  • ...I think you are reading my mind. As a brony, I feel pretty much exactly the same way. Some things are taken too far. -_-

  • @Jakah016 Yeah, every time I hear the phrase "wing boner" I want to punch someone. ._.

  • Most fandoms have its goods and bads, like ours, theres people who write gore and grimdark fics, and theres other who write with an actual storyline that explains things In their own image to others.

  • i am going to hurt your feelings

  • Applejack fans. I'm sorry, I understand you want to see an Applejack episode, but it doesn't mean you go whine on everything about it. Also, I agree Derpy isn't ALL muffins, but I believe it can be possible its what she said. The scene in question is when AJ "helped" Pinkie make the baked bads, so it may be that her being a derp, instead of cupcakes she said muffins. But as you said, shes still not muffin crazy. As for clop art, Bronies should look at Furries. Use them as an example...

  • @BillieDAwesomes ...of what the fandom can become. TLC was already looking at Bronies for a "My Strange Addiction" episode. Bronies can work hard to make them seem good, or they can not care and some channel will make a big documentary about grown men who fantasize about a little girls show. Fox News already compared them to grown adults who live their lives as babies, diapers, crib and all. I know Bronies will hate to admit it, but the two fandoms are very much the same.

  • @BillieDAwesomes Also, Rainbow Factory. It is amazing, its a Grimdark fic based off a song.

  • I'm a fan of time bubbles

    Doctor Whooves and Derpy but i don't like sexual pairings in MLP:FIM just cutesy Nose touching stuff

    But sweet apple massacer was terrible Dx

  • Fandoms become sexual because at one point or another, humans think of sex. It happens, get over it

    On a side note: all bronies are furries lol, but not all furries are bronies

  • @wolvesRsmexy I just mean the sexual aspect shouldn't be as overt considering that MLP characters are, more or less, ferals and wouldn't be as well-understood as regular anthro creatures.

  • @wolvesRsmexy True but not. I've come to believe that "Furry" is just a self desired label. No more than any other fandom. An average person may enjoy watching MLP on TV, but does it make them a brony? Or if a person watched some anime every now and then, are they an otaku?

  • I know what you mean, I reacently became a pegasister and half of the brony fandom disturbs me. I hope it doesn't get to the point where I leave the fandom... (I left Hetalia because of it's fandom) ._.

  • @BrittTaylor943 I know what you mean; Hetalia's fandom is a little out of control at times. That's why I could never really get into the show.

    Luckily, I find MLP:FiM to be a good show even without the fandom, so I'm stickin' around. :D

  • i have started watching friendship is magic but im not really a full brony i have seen the old series trust me it is sooooo bad i watched it when i was like 5 and it was shit

  • touhou is probably worse with all the Sexuality people added to it

  • Sexuality is totally overrated. That said, there will always be wierdos.

  • sorry for leaving all the comments i feel like a creeper now for not just putting one >.<

  • they have to be lesbian cus yuri gets more views than straight porn or yaoi :/

    also: Rule 34

  • just like there are bad furries there are bad bronies who i personaly dont involve myself with :)

  • .....Big Macintosh is best pony

  • Inmy opinion, its like: hey, the fandom is quite creative. giving entire stories for characters. i think with the cupcakes and grimdark part, is that many fans like to see the worldvof my little pony if it were in the real world. i do enjoy the grimdsrk part as far as violence and such, but pr0nies can be just creepy. but my point here basically is, hey. let the fandom be what it wants to be. you can choose to acknowledge certain parts or not. Oh, and also, First!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more