Oh it just sounds like exactly the same tone as on the record, but I can never get the right tone. Maybe it's because I'm playing it on a guitar with humbuckers?
its either in f# or capo'd on the second fret, same thing...just preference. id rather tune down because you've got more range on the neck but it takes more time
I just like to say how impressed i am with this. this is the most spot on cover of this song. May I ask, how did you end up figuring out the main guitar line on the chorus under the never ending reverb? :)
to people going on about the capo, you do need the capo, the song isnt fully barred, there are certain open notes that need to be open on 2, not neck.
All these people saying TUNE TO THIS or PLAY THIS GUITAR... wannabe's who have no idea of the fact that the player and their fingers make the sound, not the guitar
Johnny played it tuned to F sharp and started it on the 7th fret normally. It comes out in the same key when you play it on the 9th fret - the capo on 2nd is for the open note on the high E string that you can play instead of the 11th fret on the G string that is on some tabs. It has a better jangley ring/ more smithsy sound plus you can keep it ringing whilst playing on the G and B strings so it makes a nice harmony.
@kralle333 In an interview J. Marr once said he used to tune his guitar up a whole step to F sharp, until The Smiths got a record deal and he could afford a capo ;)
@TheKontosuburbian Why would it ? The original was recorded on a 54 Tele, Johnny has toured it playing a Les Paul Custom & many other guitars. I think you have conned by the Top Of The Pops video.
The audio doesn't seem to match the video when you are playing the bar chords during the chorus. Your index finger goes on frets 5 and 7. But in the audio, you seem to be playing on frets 6 and 8.
@Pulseczar1 yeah there's usually a slight delay between sound and audio, my mate gets it when recording live. something to do with speed of light and sound or some sciency stuff like that
Watching these sort of videos really helps you appreciate the kind of effort the artists put in and the skills they must have to compose the music in the first place. Impressive playing!
Excellent ! ok QUESTION to all advanced guitar players. When you go to see a live band, do you pay more attention to the lead guitarist than the singer ? just curious
If thats a serious questions, here;s a serious answer. When I listen to tunes, I don;t listen for lyrics; it's the guitar parts I go for. I can;t recite lyrics, but I can play by here and recite tunes really quick.
im not an advanced guitar player, i suck actually but when i see a band live i watch the guitarist almost the whole show. i saw tool recently and was just amazed at adam jones playing it was awesome to see it so close.
Most (but not all) guitarists just focus on guitar and the guitar parts. They don't pay much attention to the lyrics at all. To test this, just ask a guitarist to play from a certain part of a song using the lyrics as a reference point. They can also get confused as to where in the song they are during rehearsals despite the verse and chorus lyrics not repeating themselves at all throughout the song. . This is not meant as a criticism, a lot of musicians tend to focus on just their part.
I agree with some posters below. Learn to play it by ear bar by bar. It will help your ears, your memory and technique far more than any tab can. Most of the tabs I've used were not as accurate as the versions I learned by ear.
Top Quality. I need to learn this to play with my covers band and if I get anywhere near it as well as this I'll be more than happy. Now how do I slow this stuff down...? :-)
It's only when you hear others attempt to play Smiths songs that you realise just how talented a guitarist Marr was/is. You did a great job by the way, thanks for showing us how it's done.
i dont't know that tab that you said was accurate doesn't sound anything like this. its just the third section where you go down to the fifth fret that i cannot get down
freakin awesomeee i keep watching this over and over again
regulusamelius 1 week ago
Awesome!
SilentAssassin333 3 months ago
I have been listening to this all week long, can't get enough of it
basverhage 3 months ago
What effects are you using in this because I can't get the right effects for this song at all.
Guitarfan1995 4 months ago
@Guitarfan1995 No Effects, Just clean guitar sound from the amp..
sonofdrcross 4 months ago
@sonofdrcross
Oh it just sounds like exactly the same tone as on the record, but I can never get the right tone. Maybe it's because I'm playing it on a guitar with humbuckers?
Guitarfan1995 4 months ago
@sonofdrcross
Also, what's the tuning?
Guitarfan1995 4 months ago
Johhny Marr is a god damned genius. Well played!
vonalxao1 4 months ago
its either in f# or capo'd on the second fret, same thing...just preference. id rather tune down because you've got more range on the neck but it takes more time
hurpaderpp 5 months ago
amazing
mattyp3400 5 months ago
Please make a video in which you demonstrate the tuning for this one?
Saesangism 5 months ago
best cover i've seen
balor7 5 months ago
I just like to say how impressed i am with this. this is the most spot on cover of this song. May I ask, how did you end up figuring out the main guitar line on the chorus under the never ending reverb? :)
2ixkarmaxi2 6 months ago
to people going on about the capo, you do need the capo, the song isnt fully barred, there are certain open notes that need to be open on 2, not neck.
Chizzbuut 6 months ago
Bloody brilliant
TheMoylesee 7 months ago
Smooth bro
darshia33 7 months ago
This is really good :)
PaiganGibbons 7 months ago
Nice job!!! I like your style. I´ve recorded some Smiths covers myself. Check it out, please, if you can. Take care.
mccacaia 8 months ago
Nicely done. This is the best cover of this song i've heard so far. What tabs did you use for it ?
daninuk 8 months ago
great cover! :)
JudgeYourself53 8 months ago
My God! Not even I can play this song like this. Will have to study this more closely. Nice job man!
EWOKSR 8 months ago 2
All these people saying TUNE TO THIS or PLAY THIS GUITAR... wannabe's who have no idea of the fact that the player and their fingers make the sound, not the guitar
JakeandLouis 9 months ago
Nine people haven't got a stitch to wear.
PotterPurbright 10 months ago 2
You tore this up - nice job man!
petermanning1 11 months ago
the single version is about half a semitone flat from d. i used audacity to change the pitch so i could play along.
sammarshall20 11 months ago
nicely done! :)
nitemare125 1 year ago
very well done!
tylerkershaw 1 year ago
Great playing mate - true to the original sound and feel. Lovely old job
Captainsbrass 1 year ago
That wos cool as fuck m8! Johnny marr would even be impressed!! ;-)
Sneakerpimp79 1 year ago
Spot on mate, well played!, your right Johnny tuned up to F# for the first 2 albums.
heale1 1 year ago
Great stuff, I like all your uploads
charmingmancunian 1 year ago
fucking brilliant!
BenWallace335 1 year ago
Comment removed
MultiGalack 1 year ago
Probably the best cover of this I've seen on Youtube so far.
john25992 1 year ago
good stuff, just keep wanking and your get the chords perfect...
MrAxo83 1 year ago
Well done my friend. Good stuff (from an "old" bloke that's seen 'em a couple of times live)
ComoParkStudio 1 year ago
fuckin nice one mate
taitlawrence 1 year ago
can't fault it :)
CojakUK 1 year ago
great tone too
ballersack 1 year ago
Great cover, most definitely the best I have seen about. Also thanks for the link to the smiths on guitar thing.. it was rather informative.
Nikki1234300 1 year ago
holy poop. nicely done
ThatsaCryinShame 1 year ago
Beautiful.
davinissim 1 year ago
hi is there anyone in lincoln uk who can give me guitar lessons
?
vinnie01 1 year ago
let it ring, brother.
desertgeologist 1 year ago
by far the best sound iv heard in youtube.........tip top buddy!!
weejoesoap 1 year ago
nice
creedencelearwater 1 year ago
one of my favorite riffs ever. Nice job man
nirvanalives89 1 year ago
Very Impressive....=D
puffpuffyogi 1 year ago
thats mint mate ! really good !!!! top work
ringostarr1962 1 year ago
nice dude
GazzaGlitta 1 year ago
Best version on the web period. You should have your own band sir
fcossy 1 year ago
is that a squier?
iThinkThisIsBrandon 1 year ago
Theres no reason to have a capo on
kralle333 1 year ago
Johnny played a lot of songs with guitar tuned up to F sharp. I just used a capo instead, Trust me on this my friend..
sonofdrcross 1 year ago 50
This has been flagged as spam show
@sonofdrcross You dont play any open notes in the song, which means that the capo does nothing
kralle333 1 year ago
Comment removed
kralle333 1 year ago
@kralle333 Capo essay:
Johnny played it tuned to F sharp and started it on the 7th fret normally. It comes out in the same key when you play it on the 9th fret - the capo on 2nd is for the open note on the high E string that you can play instead of the 11th fret on the G string that is on some tabs. It has a better jangley ring/ more smithsy sound plus you can keep it ringing whilst playing on the G and B strings so it makes a nice harmony.
flowerpower168 10 months ago 4
@kralle333 In an interview J. Marr once said he used to tune his guitar up a whole step to F sharp, until The Smiths got a record deal and he could afford a capo ;)
TheTenderhooligan 8 months ago
@kralle333 Trust the man ya prick.
xquickstrykex 5 months ago
very well played
kazmolt 1 year ago
Great job man!
i7vSa7vi7y 1 year ago
this is flawless. i listen to this and fall into euphoria. love <3
ashleyborges16 1 year ago
thank you for this video, it has really helped me get this song right.
Hexonox 1 year ago
God i could jerk off to this
Modzio666 1 year ago 41
@Modzio666 I did.
john25992 4 months ago
That's awesome man. Nice job
weblogik 1 year ago
I love your shirt.... oh yea and props lovely song.
Hexonox 1 year ago
amazing, loved it :)
cheers from an italian-irish kid :)
p.s. : how long have you been playing?
FraBrett2509 1 year ago
Seriously absolutely perfect. How the fuck did you do that?
ButThatBelt 1 year ago
you're reeeeallllly good! great stuff!
darkanddiamondzz 1 year ago
Damn you are good!!!!
Thanks
pesf69 1 year ago
What Guitar Is That
iThinkThisIsBrandon 1 year ago
Superb!
fragueti 1 year ago
before i die i'm gotta leran how to do that........
forceratio42 1 year ago
sorprendente.....donde puedo conseguir esos acordes,,,bye
Stefidiaz 1 year ago
No one was writing any guitar lines like this..completely original. Almost like Marr was writing horn parts and playing them on guitar.
Only way to get this sounding closer is electric 12. But damn fine playing.
cranie4 1 year ago
Great cover, mate! A Rickenbacker would be more suitable for this song, though.
TheKontosuburbian 1 year ago
@TheKontosuburbian But I don't have a rickenbacker :(
sonofdrcross 1 year ago 19
@TheKontosuburbian Johnny used a Telecaster to record the lead line to "This Charming Man". Often mistaken for a Rickenbacker !
robbieonguitar 1 year ago
@TheKontosuburbian Why ?? Johnny played the original on a 1954 Fender Tele, a Strat would be a closer sound than a Rickenbacker.
Coppertunes 1 year ago
@TheKontosuburbian Definitely doesn't sound like a Rick on the original.
tbaier101 1 year ago
@TheKontosuburbian Why would it ? The original was recorded on a 54 Tele, Johnny has toured it playing a Les Paul Custom & many other guitars. I think you have conned by the Top Of The Pops video.
A Strat is closer to a Tele than a Ric.
Coppertunes 11 months ago 4
@TheKontosuburbian thats wierd because Johnny recorded it with a tele.
skeeterd5150 6 months ago
@TheKontosuburbian Marr played this on a strat, not a ric.
spmcd2001 5 months ago
Nice hand work
jamiroquai81 1 year ago
very nice cover, gonna learn this :)
saaaywaaat 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Are u gay? Nope or Yep plz xd
Eltroim 1 year ago
Nope, What has that got to do with anything?
sonofdrcross 1 year ago 2
@sonofdrcross oh come on have some humor
Eltroim 1 year ago
@Eltroim That was completely random, what did you want the lad to say?
TheKontosuburbian 1 year ago
@sonofdrcross hes probably referring to the homoerotic lyrics of the song, as if anyone who enjoys the song must be gay because of them.
rupertacdc 1 year ago
@Eltroim What a weird ass comment to ask. Funny though
cazulu3 1 year ago
@Eltroim what a jackass comment
justinwiggy 1 year ago
@justinwiggy oh bite me. Mind ur own life.
Eltroim 1 year ago
@Eltroim i'd rather not bite you thanks...not into that kind of thing gaylord
justinwiggy 1 year ago
Well played mate
john25992 1 year ago
very nice, sir.
RunawayRocky 1 year ago
Hahaa, I've also got a white strat and a fender champ amp, also the skill to play that song. How amusing is that..
Tasuja 1 year ago
About as good as TCM could be played, in my opinion. Thanks for linking to the blog!
smithsonguitar 1 year ago
superb, make it look easy!
GlasgowSkate 1 year ago
is 0,07 - 0,09 just a slide? i cant get the feeling right
Eltroim 1 year ago
tabs m8!! pls need soooo badly.. damn nice like u! u would be the answer to get it right finally pls!
saopaulo2000 1 year ago
Excellent. Best "This Charming Man" I've seen on here.
grantrmiller 1 year ago
Wow fantastic 5 stars!
phulme61 1 year ago
what is the tuning that your playing in is it standard?
snelly69 1 year ago
im pretty sure i work with this guy.. if so he's in a band called The minutes.. check em out. they're no smiths though =)
thedonkiluminati 2 years ago
Is anything!? :-)
subby33 1 year ago
great job my friend! what a nostalgic song this is, really enjoyed that ******, Al
Alan2496 2 years ago 4
Tabs? Pretty please???
cossatotfalls 2 years ago
damn, this is heeeeeeella good he even gots the shirt and everything!! tell me you got flowers in ur back poket
dusterfiend73 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
aderueda 2 years ago
dyou need to alter the tuning if you're playing with capo on 2nd mate?
listenupuk 2 years ago
nope
sonofdrcross 2 years ago
okay thanks it just sounds a bit like it clashes when i play it to the track, maybe the tone of my guitar
listenupuk 2 years ago
@listenupuk You don't even need a capo I learnt it in E standard
ontherush77 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
How's it going Johnny ?
cambofrog 2 years ago 2
will you marry me?
letmeloginyoucunt 2 years ago 4
love the way you let it ring.
desertgeologist 2 years ago
yeah i'd say this is the best cover on youtube!
sonictronn 2 years ago 2
dude i loved it , keep on doing what you do best (which is i assume the guitar) xD
oinsaneheroo 2 years ago
fooking good playing mate. Smiths =r 1 of my fav bands ever
mattylad68 2 years ago
I LUV DIS SONG
ivanerdotcom 2 years ago
Was the audio track for this video done in a single take?
Pulseczar1 2 years ago
Yep
sonofdrcross 2 years ago
The audio doesn't seem to match the video when you are playing the bar chords during the chorus. Your index finger goes on frets 5 and 7. But in the audio, you seem to be playing on frets 6 and 8.
Pulseczar1 2 years ago
Played live to song..
sonofdrcross 2 years ago
Yeah, I was playing those chords wrong. You're right. :)
Pulseczar1 2 years ago
@Pulseczar1 yeah there's usually a slight delay between sound and audio, my mate gets it when recording live. something to do with speed of light and sound or some sciency stuff like that
jedj6 1 year ago
yeah this is really good, probably the best cover on youtube
domclaudevandamme 2 years ago
Very nicely done! You da man!
Erikboklund 2 years ago
Wow!
d4prince 2 years ago
The best! very good, man!!!!
gioarcanjo 2 years ago
this ir really gd sounds brill :D
xXxCantStephxXx 2 years ago
A "ROUGH STAB"?? Are you kidding? That was spot on! That was really really good, mate....
jetterra 2 years ago 22
well done mate, bang on! nice sound on the strat too!
BareSuspect 2 years ago
Really good - thanks for helping unravel the mystery of some of Marr's best playing!
sparrow040 2 years ago
Watching these sort of videos really helps you appreciate the kind of effort the artists put in and the skills they must have to compose the music in the first place. Impressive playing!
nichoji 2 years ago 2
flawless man 5 star!
GlasgowSkate 2 years ago
Johnny Marr is the best guitarist ever. Congratulations for your guitar work, man.
Marinhoalvesdasilva 2 years ago 3
amazing
haydenisace 2 years ago
Excellent job!
gretscher 2 years ago
keep up the good work
DirtyDubsteppa 2 years ago
swweeeet
AniMalta85 2 years ago
how do you omit sounds from recordings,ie guitars,vocals,ect.???
ureadmymind 2 years ago
wow! just amazing!
HowToLootBrazil 2 years ago
AWESOME! the chorus is most impressive!
BradyA1124 2 years ago
Bastard (said in envy)
beelzebozos 2 years ago 2
ROUGH! what you talken about that was freaken amazing!
buru44 2 years ago
Nice job fella!!!
silencekid999 2 years ago
you sound great. I'll get tired of this song one day..
caFexpo00 2 years ago
:O
tab? please?
the tabs i've found are like a lot more simple than this, this one has loads of nice little fills in it
and actually fits better
5*
K0O0l 2 years ago
awsome!
weezer1fan 2 years ago
That was rad. Period.
TheOCDan 2 years ago
lush
harshshark81 2 years ago
Simply awesome fella...well done
yeovil50 2 years ago
totally fucking awesome man..you fucking nailed it dude!
did you get some tabs or sheet music?
bigbigsound 2 years ago 7
Very well done mate, keep rocking!
TheSneakyScotsman 2 years ago
FungasUK ur a gay coz u dont apreaciate the music get instrumentals then init!
Hendrixknowsbest 2 years ago
Excellent ! ok QUESTION to all advanced guitar players. When you go to see a live band, do you pay more attention to the lead guitarist than the singer ? just curious
VikingThor1 2 years ago
If thats a serious questions, here;s a serious answer. When I listen to tunes, I don;t listen for lyrics; it's the guitar parts I go for. I can;t recite lyrics, but I can play by here and recite tunes really quick.
FungasUK 2 years ago
im not an advanced guitar player, i suck actually but when i see a band live i watch the guitarist almost the whole show. i saw tool recently and was just amazed at adam jones playing it was awesome to see it so close.
charliegrs 2 years ago
nope the whole band ..thats why you go see a band not a solo act
StellYourSkyes 2 years ago 2
yep lol dusn tevery gutarist
assasinberg 2 years ago
Most (but not all) guitarists just focus on guitar and the guitar parts. They don't pay much attention to the lyrics at all. To test this, just ask a guitarist to play from a certain part of a song using the lyrics as a reference point. They can also get confused as to where in the song they are during rehearsals despite the verse and chorus lyrics not repeating themselves at all throughout the song. . This is not meant as a criticism, a lot of musicians tend to focus on just their part.
ExternalInputs 2 years ago
What a perfect representation. Thanks!
I agree with some posters below. Learn to play it by ear bar by bar. It will help your ears, your memory and technique far more than any tab can. Most of the tabs I've used were not as accurate as the versions I learned by ear.
Skaliwag66 2 years ago 2
Top Quality. I need to learn this to play with my covers band and if I get anywhere near it as well as this I'll be more than happy. Now how do I slow this stuff down...? :-)
andybltt 2 years ago
sorry to spam but check out my version:D obviously no where near as good as this but if you have the time please take a look :)
thankyou:D
samnninty 2 years ago
Now this more like it...
CindyTalk 2 years ago
damn how did Marr come up with that shit? Amazing....
superawkward 2 years ago 24
awesome job! :D
BEaFOOLitsCOOL 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Play a telly or rick. Not a good sound with that. No offense
telrickka 2 years ago
Thanks for the advice. i don't have a tele or ric
theminutes 2 years ago
this video motivated me to try again to learn this song. thank you
erikoismies 2 years ago 3
whitch guitar is this ?:)
Vincentocrippling 2 years ago
It's only when you hear others attempt to play Smiths songs that you realise just how talented a guitarist Marr was/is. You did a great job by the way, thanks for showing us how it's done.
Vulchid 2 years ago
nice playing i like it :) can i get a tab of this from you? :) i just subscribed to you videos :)
24242009 2 years ago
amazing , a very hard job congratulations, GREAT! MAN
aguacan 2 years ago 2
where can i find a good tab of this?
halfs09 2 years ago
thats real good playing
nycpunk09 2 years ago 2
thats a pretty good cover man, keep it up! i like it
Laurz1233 2 years ago
amazing cover 5 star :)
gertrudethestoner 2 years ago
i dont't know that tab that you said was accurate doesn't sound anything like this. its just the third section where you go down to the fifth fret that i cannot get down
wschutt3 2 years ago
Are you playing through the Fender Champion 600 in the background for this song?
Satanicm0nk 2 years ago