@KarlNerman Oh nom, I was actually visiting my grandparents. (Btw, my age on the YouTube account is wrong - I guess I wasn't so honest when I created it O,o) Back to the reply, I have a home in China (I am Chinese - Canadian XD), and I love classical music.
enjoyed listening to this peace. it made me think of a potential battle that was buliding up then it got very beautiful so maybe they resolved their differneces then they argued again. So human. Thanks for the tag. Kep composing wish you much success in the future.
A dramatic, thoughtful, wistful, evocative piece - all these emotions are there and build up to the original, abrupt ending. I love it!! Thanks for sharing.
@KarlNerman Very well performed, the style sounds like a mixture of Beethoven and Mozart to me. Good composition mate, loved it.
The only suggestion I can make is that the contrast between the variations be more dynamic and visibly different. For instance, the first and final progressions, have them inverted and mirror them opposite of each other, etc. Other than that, brilliant job mate.
You composed that, and in one day....impressive. But this image of the angel has had a profound effect on me and I add, a revelation. I am going to talk about it next book. I saw an angel restrain the devil...
As you may know I am not a fan of classical music in particular, but your compositions always manage to give me a pleasant feeling, so kudos to you :)
Thank you so much for sending this delicate and compelling work of beauty, and I really like the quote below from Victor Hugo sent by your friend. I love poetry, but there are times I just need to let music reign when I seek inspiration. Congratulations on your efforts. Lovely!
Very nice Karl. I enjoyed it a lot. I'd like to hear a version with shorter breaks so that the music flows more - might be interesting to see how that affects it, but that's just an experiment suggestion, not a complaint about the original!
Just listened to your collection on your site, I think anyone who could afford you would be mad not to seek out music especially created from you ... as they will kick themselves for not doing so when you are famous. Be Cosmic ...
@cosmicordering1 Many thanks my friend, very much appreciated! I dont charge a lot because I want anyone to afford my services, so I hope more and more will notice that!
My goodness you wrote this in one day, you are very talented. I will not be surprised if i go into the music store one day and see about five of your cd's in a row. You are going to be famous someday! GREAT JOB!
How so magnificent piano performance my dear!!! So exquisite music!!! So meaningful and inspiring!!! Very good work my dear!!! Bravo!!!! Thank you so very much!!!!
I liked the change, however I do find your entry into each gap is a little too rushed? I don't know, probably you like it that way, and the fact the first minute or so sounded less rounded than the rest of the piece.
However, i enjoyed this one, especially the middle 2 minutes. Similar to some piece from Chopin (don't remember which, I have the whole collection, and in the end they all sort of sounded the same O.o).
@BuggttiVeyronW16 Yes its supposed to be "rushed" at some parts, and dragging at others (played "rubato" as you would say in classical terms). Cheers!
This is a beautiful piece of work and your piano skills are something to be admired.
I wish the government would help to support talent such as yours instead of wasting it on death particle emitting machines called nuclear reactors. Billions of dollars for filling the earth with deadly radiation, but none for art and beautiful music!
Interesting choice in style. :) kinda like "stop and go." I enjoyed the variations very much! I liked how you filled the gaps with chromatics, it adds a much more romantic flavor to the piece! very nice rondo! you didn't over use the theme or branch of into completely new/unrelated territory(which I find to be kinda difficult). great job with this! I feel like you are changing style a little as you write more and more... ;)
excellente interprétation bravo
harrykasior 6 months ago
Just got back from China ^^, I couldn't access YouTube there :(
Wonderful piece, it's like a particular piece of J.S.Bach, or at lease the spirit is alike.
So good, I enjoyed it with my eyes closed.(Drinking green tea ^^)
BuggttiVeyronW16 7 months ago
@BuggttiVeyronW16 Glad you like it buddy!
I'd like to experience China sometime , I bet it is beautiful. :)
Did you walk on the Great Wall?
KarlNerman 7 months ago
@KarlNerman Oh nom, I was actually visiting my grandparents. (Btw, my age on the YouTube account is wrong - I guess I wasn't so honest when I created it O,o) Back to the reply, I have a home in China (I am Chinese - Canadian XD), and I love classical music.
BuggttiVeyronW16 7 months ago
Fantástico, parabéns!
vsbonvenuto 9 months ago
enjoyed listening to this peace. it made me think of a potential battle that was buliding up then it got very beautiful so maybe they resolved their differneces then they argued again. So human. Thanks for the tag. Kep composing wish you much success in the future.
berrywell26 9 months ago
@berrywell26 Cheers mate, I appreciate it!
KarlNerman 9 months ago
beautiful!!! wonderful! thanks for sharing!
pls continue sharing your music...cheers!
fortepianopresto 9 months ago
Surprisingly fun, and unexpected tempo.. glorious
1soulwonless 9 months ago
Congrats, Karl !!! Bravo !
Barisof 9 months ago
.....this is wonderful. Bravissimo!
36Siddhartha 9 months ago
@36Siddhartha Thanks my friend!
KarlNerman 9 months ago
Bravo!
halynamyroslava 9 months ago
Wonderful !!.
britoguzman 9 months ago
Beautiful !! I loved it!!
angelblue990 9 months ago
<3 absolutely beautiful & marvelous :) <3 it (: thank you so much for creating & sharing*^o^*
AphroditeEros33 9 months ago
@AphroditeEros33 Cheers! ;)
KarlNerman 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Beautiful composition.!Thanks!
bodoildi1 9 months ago
I like it!!
bratsheMag 9 months ago 2
Fantastic as usual Karl,loved it cheers D
daktucs 9 months ago 2
Belo som ao piano! Eu gosto!
cidinharissi 9 months ago
Beautiful composition.
hjzitc2010 10 months ago 2
Wonderful composition! Loved it!
Smiles
Veronica :-)
(sitting in for Bill)
BILLMCLEANJAZZ 10 months ago
@BILLMCLEANJAZZ Thanks! :)
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Good job:) Cool with the many variations of the main theme:)
ComposerLarsik 10 months ago
@ComposerLarsik Cheers mate!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Danke fürs Hochladen !
BPanther 10 months ago
BEAUTIFUL. THANK YOU.
viktor290290 10 months ago
Très belle composition et une belle interprétation. Félicitations. André
guyotville06 10 months ago
@guyotville06 Merci beaucoup!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
LOVELY!!!!
PEACE~ VESSIO
DJVMFVME 10 months ago
Maravillosa pieza.
Gracias x compartir
Felicitaciones y *********
Carmen
DesdeLoJondo 10 months ago
Thank you for sharing your awesome composition!
thumbs up for this tune that made me travel!
ichnilatis 10 months ago
@ichnilatis :) Thanks!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
A dramatic, thoughtful, wistful, evocative piece - all these emotions are there and build up to the original, abrupt ending. I love it!! Thanks for sharing.
unpodimusica1 10 months ago
@unpodimusica1 Thanks my friend, always a pleasure reading your comments!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Excellent Job!! Sounds Wonderful!!!
albatrosgrup 10 months ago
beautiful
toujours5e 10 months ago
nice one
VanooTV 10 months ago
lovely piece Karl,slightly atonal,nice,it's all in the ear of the composer eh?, and there is no accounting for everyones taste either.
zenbooter 10 months ago
@zenbooter Thanks! Yep I never write music with people's taste in mind, that's not how art should be made!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Adorable composition.Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful melody and music with us.
Best wishes,
Gabriella
blackvelvet74 10 months ago
@blackvelvet74 And thank you for your nice comment, cheers! :-)
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Beautiful video. Thank you for sharing! - Vesna Maria.
vesnamariasite 10 months ago 2
Som jag sagt förut, Stenhammarsalen väntar på din återkomst ;)
Tyrfingr 10 months ago 2
Very beautiful...thanks so much ! :)
zara2255 10 months ago 2
Very nice!
pianolover1004 10 months ago 2
Fantastic sounds... Thanks for the pleasure!
WhiteRosePl 10 months ago
very beautiful!!
tyetygon 10 months ago
Thanks, I like it...
annafascinations 10 months ago
Beautiful♪
toshiko2000 10 months ago
Excelente interpretacion musical, muy bella, saludos.
enriquejesus09 10 months ago 2
Wonderful Composition, Great Vision, Excellent job!!!
gteofan 10 months ago
@gteofan Many thanks!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
@KarlNerman Very well performed, the style sounds like a mixture of Beethoven and Mozart to me. Good composition mate, loved it.
The only suggestion I can make is that the contrast between the variations be more dynamic and visibly different. For instance, the first and final progressions, have them inverted and mirror them opposite of each other, etc. Other than that, brilliant job mate.
VladtheImpaler31 10 months ago
Una pieza hermosa
Gracias
gustavovv11 10 months ago
Wonderful!!!!!
giannimirizzi 10 months ago
Hi
A very beautiful music.
Thanks for sharing this!!
Cheers
Henry
Henry8860 10 months ago
GREAT :)
eliifelii 10 months ago
bello!
Graziana20111 10 months ago
Thanks Karl, for sharing this wonderful music.
My sincere compliments.
I will keep this in mind if I'll need some background music, will notify you.
Have a nice week.
Irene
zeroester51 10 months ago
@zeroester51 Thanks! Sounds good, just let me know if you ever need my musical services!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
lovely
ideagirlconsulting 10 months ago
Ich freue mich auf Ihre Leistung eine schöne Melodie zu hören. Vielen Dank! Yuri
WYurij 10 months ago
I enjoy you original composition.
Its very relaxing to listen to, and as for being repetitive.. It's perfect!
~ Lady M
goddessmelania 10 months ago
excellent composition!
ierogamos 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wonderful composition!!
fairycampanilla65 10 months ago
Wonderful composition
fairycampanilla65 10 months ago
very good!
franpanama 10 months ago
Beutiful :)
Ada859 10 months ago
Very nice piece, very calming.
BlueDotMusic 10 months ago
Nice and relaxing listening
Georg
georgswa02 10 months ago
You composed that, and in one day....impressive. But this image of the angel has had a profound effect on me and I add, a revelation. I am going to talk about it next book. I saw an angel restrain the devil...
vimana19 10 months ago
I love this one Karl, thanks.
vimana19 10 months ago
Thanks for the PM Karl.
As you may know I am not a fan of classical music in particular, but your compositions always manage to give me a pleasant feeling, so kudos to you :)
WhiteWolf1088 10 months ago
@WhiteWolf1088 :)
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Well Done, Karl !
Mozart would be pleased .. And Bethovet too, I hope.
Gusakov 10 months ago
Thanks so much !!! its very beatiful !
germantrade25 10 months ago
*****10! Fantastic!
flavinha39 10 months ago
beautifull music pieze thumbs up and thanx for sharing
enigmataxtreme 10 months ago
Quite a beautiful piece Karl. You have a wonderful gift that I hope takes you far. Thanks for sharing this.
Charonveritas 10 months ago
Excelente video!! Bellísima música y pintura!!! felicidades y dejo cordiales saludos!!Consuelo
Consuelo888 10 months ago
Karl; 1:22 - 1:37 is... brilliant... my humble respect....
(remember our 'bad start'?...: nothing happens without a reason..;-)
Baz
BazDaniZ 10 months ago
Beautiful, Painting & Music! Thanks for sharing.
helenogoncalves2 10 months ago
Thank you so much for sending this delicate and compelling work of beauty, and I really like the quote below from Victor Hugo sent by your friend. I love poetry, but there are times I just need to let music reign when I seek inspiration. Congratulations on your efforts. Lovely!
HerAeolianHarp 10 months ago
@HerAeolianHarp Thanks my friend, much appreciated!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
A very moving piece of music, congratulation! Jim
hasbeensinger 10 months ago
@hasbeensinger Cheers mate!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
5******
GilvanGouveaMerola 10 months ago
Thanks for sharing, Karl.
gerardbedecarter 10 months ago
Thank you for sharing.
BravuraK 10 months ago
I like it...Very good work =)
Dionysiusmucca 10 months ago
Comment removed
EmersonGene 10 months ago
Excellent! And I love the painting on the video--makes for a nice presentation!
EdmundStAustell 10 months ago
Really good :) well done!
elliekinzz1 10 months ago
Very nice composition! And beautiful music!
dordeacasa 10 months ago
Hi Karl!
Nice Rondo, your composition!
Best wishes
Thomas
anmeinersaite 10 months ago 2
Very good !!!
chitarreampli 10 months ago
What beautiful music! Congratulations! This is real music!
Thank you my talented friend!
Elegarret 10 months ago
Very, very nice!!!
fgerardohost 10 months ago 2
very sweet!!
merkywave 10 months ago
Very nice! *
33Roobert 10 months ago
Wonderful composition my friend, have a great sense of coordination!!
Abrabel65 10 months ago
is a fascinating composition!!
ZanthiaKhala 10 months ago
Hi Karl thanks for the video track I like!!Have a nice week
dusanka111 10 months ago
So interesting and awesome video, thanks for sharing , you have done excellent job.
ARTMASTERPIECESBEST 10 months ago
Absolutely wonderful! Thumbs Up!
ClaudioAlessandri 10 months ago
Very nice Karl. I enjoyed it a lot. I'd like to hear a version with shorter breaks so that the music flows more - might be interesting to see how that affects it, but that's just an experiment suggestion, not a complaint about the original!
Crowzena 10 months ago
Ottimo
decimaquinta69 10 months ago
the music is amazing, great job,
thumbs up
ChenWhiteHorse 10 months ago
Great piece of music.
dolmenentcom 10 months ago
Beautiful Music !
Bravo !
Let There & Everywhere Be LIGHT !
Peace, Love, Music & Rainbows !
Lot of SUN, Joy & Happiness !
To All, Now, Ever & Forever !
( : - )
coman4ero 10 months ago
Absolutely lovely :) Thank you.
EvolutionAvenue 10 months ago
I don't know much about the composition of music, only how it makes me feel, this said, I feel well and truly "Fired".
Delicious!
Eedgit 10 months ago
very nice
drnorris56 10 months ago
Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ♫♪ Music expresses that which cannot be said
and on which it is impossible to be silent.! ...Victor Hugo... ♫♪ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ~~~~
I'm glad you were not 'silent' Karl! ;-) This is a wonderful piece (as is everything you have posted on your channel). Keep up the good work!
DesertAnnie 10 months ago
@DesertAnnie Well said, Annie! Thanks!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Good job dude.
asf218sef 10 months ago
@CHRISSYGPIANOMUSIC Thanks, I sure will! But right now I have to make dinner! :P
KarlNerman 10 months ago
:) it's so amazing to know that you composed this beautiful piece in a day! What a talent! merci for shariing (:
AphroditeEros33 10 months ago
love it
Camille421ilvh 10 months ago
Just listened to your collection on your site, I think anyone who could afford you would be mad not to seek out music especially created from you ... as they will kick themselves for not doing so when you are famous. Be Cosmic ...
cosmicordering1 10 months ago
@cosmicordering1 Many thanks my friend, very much appreciated! I dont charge a lot because I want anyone to afford my services, so I hope more and more will notice that!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
It's a great piece...I really enjoyed this!!!
conroum 10 months ago
Wow, great stuff. I love composing too!
BoItonWanderers 10 months ago
My goodness you wrote this in one day, you are very talented. I will not be surprised if i go into the music store one day and see about five of your cd's in a row. You are going to be famous someday! GREAT JOB!
AngelicChibiVampire 10 months ago
@AngelicChibiVampire Thanks, I appreciate it! :)
KarlNerman 10 months ago
very very nice
CANOVALS 10 months ago
Complimenti!! Composizione molto molto bella!!
anonima8187 10 months ago
Très beau thème musical et les variations qui nous tiennent en haleine et suspend, mettent en rêverie voire méditation !
Félicitations et remerciements
Marie K
543693The 10 months ago
@543693The Merci mon ami!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
@KarlNerman
c'est moi qui vous remercie !! c'est très original et beau ! un piano qui questionne et répond ...il est merveilleusement bavard, un poète :-)
543693The 10 months ago
How so magnificent piano performance my dear!!! So exquisite music!!! So meaningful and inspiring!!! Very good work my dear!!! Bravo!!!! Thank you so very much!!!!
BlueAquaMarina 10 months ago
@BlueAquaMarina Thanks my friend!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
really nice composition......themes from chopin....i enjoyed very much....
success in all you take on karl.....
graham...
agapikochac 10 months ago
Thanks for sending this video to me. Great job!
BooksandMoreMe 10 months ago
thanks you sharing.... nice job and nice music :)
blancaluzdelsol 10 months ago
Buenísima interpretación, felicitaciones
AndresGabrielPal 10 months ago
Very nice, I like your music. Thanks....
11renn 10 months ago
I liked the change, however I do find your entry into each gap is a little too rushed? I don't know, probably you like it that way, and the fact the first minute or so sounded less rounded than the rest of the piece.
However, i enjoyed this one, especially the middle 2 minutes. Similar to some piece from Chopin (don't remember which, I have the whole collection, and in the end they all sort of sounded the same O.o).
BuggttiVeyronW16 10 months ago
@BuggttiVeyronW16 Yes its supposed to be "rushed" at some parts, and dragging at others (played "rubato" as you would say in classical terms). Cheers!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Splendid composition! ~~Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ Team Shelby Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ~~
4110fearnot 10 months ago
made in a day
thats amazingggggggggggggggggggg
ABUIK 10 months ago
Wonderful, fun piece.
Biffer5 10 months ago
Lovely comp, thank you =)
blossomingminds 10 months ago
Bravo!
bogdanovdanil 10 months ago
Beautiful composition and performance Karl!!!!
annemaree 10 months ago
Beautiful, thanks.
Teonareine 10 months ago
Such Precisely do you see this "Eternal Life".
Bravo !
Happy Eastern :)
NinoUrushadze1 10 months ago
Bravo!!!
borgoantico44 10 months ago
beautiful composing!
AnkeZohm 10 months ago
This is a beautiful piece of work and your piano skills are something to be admired.
I wish the government would help to support talent such as yours instead of wasting it on death particle emitting machines called nuclear reactors. Billions of dollars for filling the earth with deadly radiation, but none for art and beautiful music!
angelialvares 10 months ago
Csoda szép:)
kati1954 10 months ago
Amazing.
Happy Easter!
halynamyroslava 10 months ago
Wow amazing. I was expecting this to be a cliche piece but no! It was refreshing and unique. Thanks for sharing.
Atma01 10 months ago 2
@Atma01 I can assure you that you will never hear cliches in my arsenal. :P Thanks for the comment!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
@KarlNerman I see and subscribed because of that. Keep em coming.
Atma01 10 months ago
This sounds really nice - and interesting artwork to go along with the music! Thumbs up!
BaltimoreAndOhioRR 10 months ago
@BaltimoreAndOhioRR Cheers!
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Good job buddy :)
wonderingsoul11 10 months ago
Interesting choice in style. :) kinda like "stop and go." I enjoyed the variations very much! I liked how you filled the gaps with chromatics, it adds a much more romantic flavor to the piece! very nice rondo! you didn't over use the theme or branch of into completely new/unrelated territory(which I find to be kinda difficult). great job with this! I feel like you are changing style a little as you write more and more... ;)
TheGuyWhoJustShotYou 10 months ago
@TheGuyWhoJustShotYou Thanks my friend! Yes, I always try to move forward and diversify my music! :)
KarlNerman 10 months ago
Thank you!
adnor1946 10 months ago
Splendid as always my dear friend!
Happy Easter! =)
sandrateager 10 months ago
wonderful..thanks a lot my friend...^_^
ahmedelhoseney 10 months ago
Beautiful music! Wish you a bright future with you talent!
1monayoussef 10 months ago
good job friend!!
74chri 10 months ago