I had to laugh, its obvious Amy has chops and is vocally superior to what's her boring but to the untrained ear she sounds like someone blowing bubbles through her oatmeal. Ah....good old dead Amy. miss her for sure.
In my opinion Amy sings it better than Charlotte, because Amy sings it by her own way and thats why i love it and its better for me than boring Charlotte.
I really like the way Amy sings. She sings the song on her way and I find it good. I find that Charlotte has a trivial voice, without any charm whereas Amy. I love you Amy!
My god is that Charlotte Church who had a voice like and angel when young...... Wow she has grown into one buxom young lady...Wowww.... As for Amy i loved her but this is one of her times she was a little rocked..I still believe Amy Winehouse was amazing and had a very soulful retro voice.. If only someone could have affected her enough to want to change her life....
Amy fucks the song! But it doesn't matter. Amy was contra-alto and her style wasn't that. So it is normal. And seeing her like this just makes me smile. She's so cute, she tries but she can't do. Hahah, miss you so much Amy.
Poor Amy was soused to the gills! She could have out sung Church, but not here! Too bad she didn't show her what she had! She could have knocked this out of the park.
Charlotte Church: Amazing! Incredible vocalist! Amy Winehouse: Totally wasted! So sad. MJ must have been rolling in his grave at her screeching! The guy playing lead guitar is awesome! That lick is incredible! He is as good as Slash and Eddie Van Halen who played with Michael in the studio and Slash toured with Michael. I love MJ! RIP MJ! Deborah loves you in New York City always!
@jolliffe1977 you could've used even more exclamation marks, but it still wouldn't make you right. i agree she was obviously drunk, but if you had ears you could hear she is improvising and quite boldly. one has to have balls and a lot of talent to do that, especially to one of michaels songs. i supose you are one of the pepole who'd say thelonious monk is shit too cause you don't get what is what
@4everane! My ears are fine. I've got no problem when it comes to recognizing talent. I didn't find anything bold about Amy's performance of this song. It was terrible. I was never a fan of her's but that's not because I think she sucked as a performer. I never really gave her a good listen to. When it comes to improvisation I'm all for it. Some of the best guitar solos I've ever heard have been improvised. I just don't think she did well at all on this song. All bands have bad days.
WHAT IS WRONG WITH Amy Winehouse?? O my god, terrible!!! I dont understand Charlotte Church at all.... such a great singer sing with amy... come on....
no disrespect to miss church, but amy owns this song. it's easy to copy michael's exact melody like miss church, but improvising to michael, making the song her own like amy and still keeping the character of the song, now that's art. miss church is only holding amy back, it was a bad decision to put them on stage together, cuz they are so different, miss church is frigid, but amy had balls and so much soul.
@4everane She sounded like a drunken hobo choking on an old burrito found in the dumpster behind the Quikee-Mart. And if you'll notice, at about 0:16 she doesn't say words, she just sticks out her tongue and says mlahhhhgh.
When I first saw this (another video without names in the title) I thought someone jumped in and took over because Amy was saw smashed. Drunk as she is I impressed she remembers the words.
Lastima la banda, la cancion la hecharon a perder!!! la que mas o menos arregla la cancion es Charlotte, pero lastima que dejo de cantar el genero que la dio a conocer... lastimosamente creo que el cambio no le ha favorecido para nada. esta chavala Amy no canta!!! parece estar drogada que lastima, Michael Jackson se debe de estar revolcando!!!
@francisc18 k te crei es la mejor cantante del soul y de muchos estilos mal y aun k alla fallecido desgraciadamente vah a seguir siendo la mejor te guste o noh y todos sus seguidores la vamos a defender!!!
Both singers are amazing in their own right however, Charlotte blew Ami away in this case; but the two styles combines to make a legendary performance. Ami is awesome in her own right too, but struggled in this song to match the power and ease of Charlotte (not charisma).
The God honest truth is Amy was terrible for a lonnnnng time and people just let it slide. She was getting booed of stage, doing horrible performances, cancelling gigs, and when she DID do a show they were really chaotic (in a bad way). Think of her at the 4664 concert, she was a joke, that was one of many bad showings. No one stepped in to do anything, now that she's dead they are saying "oh she was tormented and sick, she was amazing" bunch of liars...
This was not Amy Whinehouse. She wasn't well, and anyone who watches her when she is well will know she is one of the greatest performers ever. This was a very very sad time for Amy.
stop saying amy was good, dont get me wrong because i love Amy to pieces, but this was terrible. just because she was amazing most of the time doesn't mean every performance of hers was perfect and this definitely wasnt
@heyitzmagz Amy sounds drunk. II have heard her when she not wasted, and she could blow! Amy had such talent but she didn't even know the words this song at all. She was a sad soul with talent! SMH. Charlotte Church is incredible. she can hit those high notes! She can sing anything. Opera, pop, rock, soul, she is amazing. Poor Amy. I loved her but she couldn't find any happiness so she drank herself to death! SMH. RIP Amy!
Amy was clearly off her face on something, but Charlotte Church still pales in comparison. She is a boring karaoke singer, whereas Amy was a fantastic jazz vocalist.
Anyone with an ear can tell that Amy is too shitfaced to even match a pitch. Charlotte sang the song, Amy stumbled around and tried to hold on through the haze. I guess that's worth something, but it's certainly not worth much. I feel bad for her in many ways, she made her life a complete trainwreck. This shows the divide between talent that's sober and talent that's killing itself with chemicals. I don't know how anyone can think "Charlotte sucks" here. Amy made an ass of herself on stage.
charlotte church singing , micheal 'the pedophile" jackson... talk about casting pearls before a swine... i know she can sing anything, she's amazing, but his crap... well, it's just that... crap!!!! uuuuuuugh'
You are so wrong! Amy sounds REAL, magnetic and it fits the song perfectly!! If you are talking about the voice, you don't know what art of music is!!!
I will never understand how her management or the people around her let her perform when she was pissed. They'd cancelled loads of concerts before, why not this one (appearance) and the Serbia one? Money grabbing cunts.
R.I.P Amy. Ignore the haters, it was never your fault. :(
@ZandraBson I know but I remember them cancelling three concerts in a row at Shepherds Bush Empire, I turned up for all three and they cancelled them all about an hour beforehand! This was 2006/7.
I truely believe that some of the people she ended up calling her "friends" (the people that let her go on stage in Serbia for instance) were just leeches.
to be fair i think that amy is fucking this up on purpose cos she know's that having a proper sound off with charlotte church is gonna be a tough win. atleast she can say 'i was shit that night cos i was pissed' or whatever.
Both of them sound amazing, but Charlotte was much better in this performance. Amy had much bigger opportunity of being much better but she didn't live up to her potential.
Poor Amy! even though she sounds awfull here, you have to admit she is having fun! at the end she is smiling very happilyt, rest in peace Amy. Charlotte sang very well here, and the guitar solo is amazing.
You know, I'm seeing something different here. If you'll reference Phoebe Snow and Linda Ronstadt singing "It's in his kiss," and compare it to this clip, you'll notice how, in both cases, the women have each others back. There's a comraderie there that women have sometimes that's appealing and moving.
@ChloeScaresYou She was on her way home from the pub. I like Amy Winehouse but come on: to ridicule her for being drunk during some performances is like pointing out the Pope is Catholic.
We all know that Amy was way more talented than Charlotte Church but in this particular performance Amy was just screaming and is really hard to understand anything she is singing, she was obviously wasted
et to de fel you better do my hair....yull wann c ur face u bet dispear......this is what i hear from amy when i listen to this....SO ANNOYINNG!!!!!!!1
When Winehouse had some weight on her and was sober her singing was impressive. Not after. Not here. And not a good choice of song either. Who put this together?
A sober Amy was mesmerising. I'd love to say an off her tits Amy was still better than Charlotte Church, but the evidence..... Oh dear. Awful choice of song for them both. Really only saved by Charlotte incredible jugs
Are you guys kidding? LMAO Your bias is showing, folks. Charlotte Church is carrying the whole song cuz Amy Winehouse isn't singing worth a DAMN! Must have been one of her bad days...
Man versteht zwar nicht soviel aber amy hat einfach die stimme wenn amy nicht mitsingen würde würde das lied gar nicht richtig herauskommen es wäre so langweilig und gerade amy bringt berge dort rein, die gewalt ihrer gefühle sie bringt da einfach was rein was den song raushebt
Amy's voice in this is husky and she have interrupted the song as a fighters type song. Actually she had the biggest range of any singer I've heard and have only listed to her since her death - shame.
It's funny I seen this video about a year ago and everyone was slagging off Amy and now that she has died, you're all praising her. We all know she wasn't talented but lets face it, she is awful in this video.
omg Amy is so badddddd.... rofl I'm sorry but I am not going to validate this awful performance just because she tragically passed away. Half the time you cannot even tell if she's on track with the lyrics. It's just horrible.
@SitDownAndShutup... Personality, yes - Amy had TONS of that! And you are right about her ability to sucessfully pull off alcohol-soaked scat - sometimes. Unfortunately, this performance wasn't one of those times.
Never realised that Church was a wannabee Winehouse. She looks and sounds so weak compared to AW. I'm not a fan of either, but Amy wiped the floor with her in this performance.
@graiguegirl I remember this Amy was very drunk tha'ts why Charlotte was looking at er like that. I thought she was gonna fall over when I watched this on Charlotte's show. Amy is such a rockstar. R.I.P
charlotte rules my world ..........
sommy38 1 day ago
It's sad but I can't help laughing till there is tears in my eyes :-p
oWASTINGTIMEo 2 days ago
Why doesn't Charlotte sing opera anymore?? Did she ruin her voice for it?
zucchini2007 4 days ago
anybody who thinks amy winehouse is talented.....probabley on the same crack she was on.
kingofrancho 4 days ago
diction amy. DICTION! :P
superficialwannabe 5 days ago
AMY SINGS ICREDIBLE!!!
kusmet4eto 5 days ago
I had to laugh, its obvious Amy has chops and is vocally superior to what's her boring but to the untrained ear she sounds like someone blowing bubbles through her oatmeal. Ah....good old dead Amy. miss her for sure.
kickback73 5 days ago
Charlotte church rocks. Amy winehouse not so much she seemed drugged or drunk her words were slurred. Tragic really!
gagirl3637 6 days ago
Yikes!
kittysimone 1 week ago
In my opinion Amy sings it better than Charlotte, because Amy sings it by her own way and thats why i love it and its better for me than boring Charlotte.
MrMichaelSVK 1 week ago
I really like the way Amy sings. She sings the song on her way and I find it good. I find that Charlotte has a trivial voice, without any charm whereas Amy. I love you Amy!
TheSimpleclaudia 1 week ago 2
Not for nothing...With all the amazing songs to cover...Even of M.J. why would you pick beat it........ kinda sucks......
jjnove 1 week ago
My god is that Charlotte Church who had a voice like and angel when young...... Wow she has grown into one buxom young lady...Wowww.... As for Amy i loved her but this is one of her times she was a little rocked..I still believe Amy Winehouse was amazing and had a very soulful retro voice.. If only someone could have affected her enough to want to change her life....
jjnove 1 week ago
Massaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa :)
nayanetolentino 2 weeks ago
THEY TOLD THE DONKEY IT'LL COMB MY HAIR
SoNDgs 3 weeks ago
Amy fucks the song! But it doesn't matter. Amy was contra-alto and her style wasn't that. So it is normal. And seeing her like this just makes me smile. She's so cute, she tries but she can't do. Hahah, miss you so much Amy.
tselekoglu 3 weeks ago
amy is still better than charlotte here singing!! charlotte sucks big time at singing alll the time
MorbidObsessed 3 weeks ago
Poor Amy was soused to the gills! She could have out sung Church, but not here! Too bad she didn't show her what she had! She could have knocked this out of the park.
MsMarvinsmom 4 weeks ago
guitar is amazing!!!
asilbaba 4 weeks ago
Great perform of Amy, Charlotte make me bore. If I want to listen the same song i play Michael Jackson version. You are stupid
sportexe1 1 month ago
@sportexe1 troll
gunfiremessiah 3 weeks ago
I like how Charlotte gives Amy a direct look when she sings "and their words are really clear so beat it" in the first verse.
LeonardoNasir 1 month ago
wow, that was really ghastly
heathcol1 1 month ago
Charlotte Church: Amazing! Incredible vocalist! Amy Winehouse: Totally wasted! So sad. MJ must have been rolling in his grave at her screeching! The guy playing lead guitar is awesome! That lick is incredible! He is as good as Slash and Eddie Van Halen who played with Michael in the studio and Slash toured with Michael. I love MJ! RIP MJ! Deborah loves you in New York City always!
debgirl12000 1 month ago
You can't barely understand what the hell Amy is even saying! At least Charlotte enunciated!
DarkElf116352 1 month ago
it sounds fake?
Lilacuno 1 month ago
amy foreverrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
alane797 1 month ago
Is it me or did they turn the volume down on Amy's mike about half-way through?
ChrisWere100 1 month ago
Amy is drunk as a skunk. Again.
Jeweledflame 1 month ago
Amy and Michae...R.I.P.
VityaPetryliak 1 month ago
someone wrote "best version ever"....
well, thats right!
thom2805 1 month ago
4everane! Are you fucking high!?! Amy owned this song? Charolette was holding her back? Art? Soul? Amy sounded like shit!
jolliffe1977 1 month ago
@jolliffe1977 you could've used even more exclamation marks, but it still wouldn't make you right. i agree she was obviously drunk, but if you had ears you could hear she is improvising and quite boldly. one has to have balls and a lot of talent to do that, especially to one of michaels songs. i supose you are one of the pepole who'd say thelonious monk is shit too cause you don't get what is what
4everane 1 month ago
@4everane! My ears are fine. I've got no problem when it comes to recognizing talent. I didn't find anything bold about Amy's performance of this song. It was terrible. I was never a fan of her's but that's not because I think she sucked as a performer. I never really gave her a good listen to. When it comes to improvisation I'm all for it. Some of the best guitar solos I've ever heard have been improvised. I just don't think she did well at all on this song. All bands have bad days.
derekjolliffe2011 1 month ago
WHAT IS WRONG WITH Amy Winehouse?? O my god, terrible!!! I dont understand Charlotte Church at all.... such a great singer sing with amy... come on....
CIVKANJE 1 month ago
I torment my cat and it sounds better than Winehouse. Winehouse is just wailing, off beat and out of tune. Pwned by Church.
DWGarvin 1 month ago
no disrespect to miss church, but amy owns this song. it's easy to copy michael's exact melody like miss church, but improvising to michael, making the song her own like amy and still keeping the character of the song, now that's art. miss church is only holding amy back, it was a bad decision to put them on stage together, cuz they are so different, miss church is frigid, but amy had balls and so much soul.
4everane 1 month ago
@4everane She sounded like a drunken hobo choking on an old burrito found in the dumpster behind the Quikee-Mart. And if you'll notice, at about 0:16 she doesn't say words, she just sticks out her tongue and says mlahhhhgh.
machturnip 1 month ago
is it just me, or was winehouse the only brit that had soul. miss church loses the meaning of the song.
madhoneydew 1 month ago
amy was good
anthonyrawly 1 month ago
difficult to masturbate to.
NadadouroDave 1 month ago
BTW Charlotte church is HOT HOT HOT.
Flashbagfolly 1 month ago
When I first saw this (another video without names in the title) I thought someone jumped in and took over because Amy was saw smashed. Drunk as she is I impressed she remembers the words.
Flashbagfolly 1 month ago
Comment removed
krzyzak06 1 month ago
@krzyzak06 You're hilarious! And by hilarious I mean not that funny.
drtaranto 1 month ago
Credit to Charlotte for holding this performance together. I love Amy, but her singing here is painful to watch
spider23000 1 month ago
To be honest they could've not let her on the stage.. that was done just for pure humiliation. :/
angierocks1234 1 month ago
Comment removed
Beyhudar 2 months ago
Probably the most talented and Gorgeous singers in the world, and a wino druggy joining her and ruining the song!
Davadoo 2 months ago
Terrible!
PFGiron 2 months ago
RIP Amy, Wish she would have gotten help after this performance anyone could clearly see she needed it!
lawolfhottiez 2 months ago
Lastima la banda, la cancion la hecharon a perder!!! la que mas o menos arregla la cancion es Charlotte, pero lastima que dejo de cantar el genero que la dio a conocer... lastimosamente creo que el cambio no le ha favorecido para nada. esta chavala Amy no canta!!! parece estar drogada que lastima, Michael Jackson se debe de estar revolcando!!!
francisc18 2 months ago
@francisc18 k te crei es la mejor cantante del soul y de muchos estilos mal y aun k alla fallecido desgraciadamente vah a seguir siendo la mejor te guste o noh y todos sus seguidores la vamos a defender!!!
seba1234my 2 months ago
Both singers are amazing in their own right however, Charlotte blew Ami away in this case; but the two styles combines to make a legendary performance. Ami is awesome in her own right too, but struggled in this song to match the power and ease of Charlotte (not charisma).
MostynDuVal 2 months ago
Winehouse was a good singer?? I doubt it
shaganou 2 months ago
@shaganou She was a bit drunk at the time. Not the best representation of her ability.
drtaranto 2 months ago
The God honest truth is Amy was terrible for a lonnnnng time and people just let it slide. She was getting booed of stage, doing horrible performances, cancelling gigs, and when she DID do a show they were really chaotic (in a bad way). Think of her at the 4664 concert, she was a joke, that was one of many bad showings. No one stepped in to do anything, now that she's dead they are saying "oh she was tormented and sick, she was amazing" bunch of liars...
whataboutredlorry 2 months ago
This was not Amy Whinehouse. She wasn't well, and anyone who watches her when she is well will know she is one of the greatest performers ever. This was a very very sad time for Amy.
sugarplumfairiie 2 months ago 2
Okay..I love Amy and Michael, but this was a fail. She was proably high or somethin.
MJLongLiveTheKing160 2 months ago
Normaal zingen kon ze niet als ze nuchter en clean was.
margaretha990 2 months ago
This song does not Amy Winehouse . A song is Micheal Jackson.
malyszaryczlowiek666 2 months ago in playlist Amy Winehouse
This song does not suit Amy's voice at all! Damn you Michael Jackson!
bgatzby 2 months ago
stop saying amy was good, dont get me wrong because i love Amy to pieces, but this was terrible. just because she was amazing most of the time doesn't mean every performance of hers was perfect and this definitely wasnt
heyitzmagz 2 months ago 12
@heyitzmagz well said
MsSmoopy 1 month ago
@heyitzmagz Amy sounds drunk. II have heard her when she not wasted, and she could blow! Amy had such talent but she didn't even know the words this song at all. She was a sad soul with talent! SMH. Charlotte Church is incredible. she can hit those high notes! She can sing anything. Opera, pop, rock, soul, she is amazing. Poor Amy. I loved her but she couldn't find any happiness so she drank herself to death! SMH. RIP Amy!
debgirl12000 1 month ago
this and Kanye on SNL doing 808s are the worst music performances on tv
TravisandtheRoc 2 months ago
honestly watch this with your eyes closed...sounds like a professional singer invited a handicapped person on stage at a fundraiser or something..
MelloYellow2099 2 months ago 36
@MelloYellow2099 To call Charlotte Church a handicapped person isn't that nice.
XidiotX 2 months ago
Amy was clearly off her face on something, but Charlotte Church still pales in comparison. She is a boring karaoke singer, whereas Amy was a fantastic jazz vocalist.
rzeczpospolitan 2 months ago
This is the worst piece of crap I've ever listened to. I also hate to speak ill of the dead so I'll leave it at that.
openmic76 2 months ago
Anyone with an ear can tell that Amy is too shitfaced to even match a pitch. Charlotte sang the song, Amy stumbled around and tried to hold on through the haze. I guess that's worth something, but it's certainly not worth much. I feel bad for her in many ways, she made her life a complete trainwreck. This shows the divide between talent that's sober and talent that's killing itself with chemicals. I don't know how anyone can think "Charlotte sucks" here. Amy made an ass of herself on stage.
bluetrane2028 2 months ago
charlotte church singing , micheal 'the pedophile" jackson... talk about casting pearls before a swine... i know she can sing anything, she's amazing, but his crap... well, it's just that... crap!!!! uuuuuuugh'
mccurryburg 2 months ago
You are so wrong! Amy sounds REAL, magnetic and it fits the song perfectly!! If you are talking about the voice, you don't know what art of music is!!!
axara006 2 months ago
I will never understand how her management or the people around her let her perform when she was pissed. They'd cancelled loads of concerts before, why not this one (appearance) and the Serbia one? Money grabbing cunts.
R.I.P Amy. Ignore the haters, it was never your fault. :(
LadyHarrington2k 2 months ago
@LadyHarrington2k I totally agree with u. But u cant always just cancel a show just like that, its not that easy.
I agree that its their fault and not hers. But they cant just cancel a show like that, its really hard.
ZandraBson 2 months ago
@ZandraBson I know but I remember them cancelling three concerts in a row at Shepherds Bush Empire, I turned up for all three and they cancelled them all about an hour beforehand! This was 2006/7.
I truely believe that some of the people she ended up calling her "friends" (the people that let her go on stage in Serbia for instance) were just leeches.
Anyway, R.I.P beautiful Amy. x
LadyHarrington2k 2 months ago
Amy stinkin up da stage!
mangalovahhhh 2 months ago
haha Amy was sooo wasted but her singing was original and she didn´t sound like Michael like the other girl did.Kudos Amy!
rbkspinoza 2 months ago
@kery23k...oh yeah...Amy truly gave him another interpretation, alright...now she for sure did that...I won't argue you with you there :/
DiscoDJAnn 2 months ago
amy horrible canta ,fuking
ventas83 3 months ago
Jesus Christ, Amy. Seriously?
qRaynep 3 months ago
To be fair, gutz, Amy is off her face.
porleen 3 months ago
to be fair i think that amy is fucking this up on purpose cos she know's that having a proper sound off with charlotte church is gonna be a tough win. atleast she can say 'i was shit that night cos i was pissed' or whatever.
gutz323 3 months ago
Isn't she drunk here?
witusKROPKApl 3 months ago
Both of them are singing a song that's not for their voice
andreadizon 3 months ago
Amy lookshot here...
irada20 3 months ago
sounds drunk as hell, but its still pretty good
reb1009 3 months ago
Amy is a great artist, and i heard her even drunk singing good, i don't know what happend her here!!!
mulli005 3 months ago
for those who dislikes amy's voice here... imagine frank sinatra singing beat it!!!! now you see this sort of songs is not for them!!! :D peace.
seandes2004 3 months ago
Haha you can totally tell that Church was a classical/opera singer with her stong diction =P
hudsonbeecham9898 3 months ago
It's not a great song for Ms. Church either, but compared to Ms. Winehouse here, she does have the voice of an angel (albeit perhaps a fallen one).
LTF6161 3 months ago
amy lazy a lot haha
AliceBlackMriwRonson 3 months ago
@AliceBlackMriwRonson indeed haha
MeeeeeMyselfAndI 3 months ago
Amy sounds horrible but charlotte sounds amazing
kittykat4able 3 months ago
Who the hell chose this song for Amy to sing? It's like asking Etta James to sing 'Pokerface'.
Alexdurrant7 3 months ago
what a weird song selection lol
MrAntLib 3 months ago
punk
atomicflashdeluxe 3 months ago
Oh dear God. Amy sounds awful.
rumsgoneforever 3 months ago
Both of them sound amazing, but Charlotte was much better in this performance. Amy had much bigger opportunity of being much better but she didn't live up to her potential.
nordicnine 3 months ago
Amy: sdisdodsfjdfidsfisdf HERE, dsfijdfogidfjg fogidjfgodifgjdf godfigjfg DISAPPEAR
guyverdio 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Poor Amy! even though she sounds awfull here, you have to admit she is having fun! at the end she is smiling very happilyt, rest in peace Amy. Charlotte sang very well here, and the guitar solo is amazing.
MargauxHemingway 3 months ago
Comment removed
MargauxHemingway 3 months ago
the best song ever Amy R.I.P
Alexios151 3 months ago
Fuck me she's pissed
alex1995raven 3 months ago
Omg what the hell is amy doing?
MrGamerzTube 3 months ago
I think Charlotte gave a nice bit of attitude here considering she's more classical etc.
Maekchuu 3 months ago
Esa drogadicta y esa alcohólica, son una pésima combinación
THEBLURCALIGULA 3 months ago
You know, I'm seeing something different here. If you'll reference Phoebe Snow and Linda Ronstadt singing "It's in his kiss," and compare it to this clip, you'll notice how, in both cases, the women have each others back. There's a comraderie there that women have sometimes that's appealing and moving.
goffredo29 3 months ago
looks like it was meant to be winehouse on her own till 15 seconds in when church has had enough of THAT and takes over
waylonsmithers68 3 months ago
in fact c/c has ruined the whole preformence singing so bvious and screaming...
nehc1111 3 months ago
Damn girl...
blubarry87 3 months ago
I love Charlotte's part in this... it's just a shame that that wasted whinehouse trash had no talent.
davedavedude 3 months ago
Wow she's terrible she sounds like someone singing on there way home from a pub.
ChloeScaresYou 3 months ago 10
those who happen to compare amy winehouse with anyone on stage in this video do not even know what is white and what is black. sorry for them.
Beyhudar 2 months ago
@ChloeScaresYou She was on her way home from the pub. I like Amy Winehouse but come on: to ridicule her for being drunk during some performances is like pointing out the Pope is Catholic.
arabiansanchez 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
RECEIVE/COPY A NEW BOOK (Donated)
Topics: HOW TO HAVE NO SADNESS, NO FEAR, NO ANGER, AND NO WEAKNESS Or How To Be Happy At All Times; Neuroscience, Governance, Debated Issues, Others
Websites:
you free web.com balancedway
announcements-balancedway.weebly.com
wix.com/balancedwaybalancedw/announcements-balancedway
You Free Web.com/announcements-balancedway
See pictures at figure4etc3.yolasite.com , figure4etc2.yolasite.com , figure4etc1.yolasite.com , or figure4etc.yolasite.com
TheServiceWeb 3 months ago
One is doing Kareoke, one is interpreting it her own way. I'll leave you to figure out which is which.
paulpeartsmith 3 months ago
wow. what a mess.
stomachfluid 3 months ago
hahahah Amy very cool xd
malyszaryczlowiek666 3 months ago
Amy my baby ;**
malyszaryczlowiek666 3 months ago
We all know that Amy was way more talented than Charlotte Church but in this particular performance Amy was just screaming and is really hard to understand anything she is singing, she was obviously wasted
dannilevil 3 months ago
et to de fel you better do my hair....yull wann c ur face u bet dispear......this is what i hear from amy when i listen to this....SO ANNOYINNG!!!!!!!1
TUBRAZNENPUK 4 months ago
Charlotte Church is a joke. I can't stand her. And she can't sing.
youloveme295 4 months ago
@youloveme295 charlotte can sing better than that shit cheryl cole
MsFanmail 3 months ago
not denying winehouse's talent (when sober) but she sounds horrendously wasted here.... church for once shows her up
floravevey 4 months ago
When Winehouse had some weight on her and was sober her singing was impressive. Not after. Not here. And not a good choice of song either. Who put this together?
probrojeffro 4 months ago
A sober Amy was mesmerising. I'd love to say an off her tits Amy was still better than Charlotte Church, but the evidence..... Oh dear. Awful choice of song for them both. Really only saved by Charlotte incredible jugs
christschinwon 4 months ago
Who's idea was this?
pretending2Bhuman 4 months ago
Amy sounds like she is challenged, poor thing!
tubebitch12 4 months ago
Is Amy drunk?
Arya2611 4 months ago
I'm sorry...No disrespect to the dead but Charlotte Church saved the day on this one because Amy sounds absolutely HORRIBLE here.
DiscoDJAnn 4 months ago 44
@DiscoDJAnn Amy gave him another interpretation! That means the star ! Amy did show that !
kery23k 3 months ago
really charlotte kicked amy's butt with this song I don't know what amy was singing and I think if michael heard her he would turn over in his grave
aligal14 4 months ago 2
... oh, and the backup singers...
hellnoidontwanna 4 months ago
Are you guys kidding? LMAO Your bias is showing, folks. Charlotte Church is carrying the whole song cuz Amy Winehouse isn't singing worth a DAMN! Must have been one of her bad days...
hellnoidontwanna 4 months ago
"You wanna stay alive better do what you can...." :(
R.I.P Amy.
LadyHarrington2k 4 months ago
Poor Charlotte having to work with Amy like that!
RIP Amy
brightonking69 4 months ago 2
lol amy's so cute <<3
hkhenry01 4 months ago
Anyway I really like Micheal J.'s version most of all. It is brilliant.
kaikokitosuris 4 months ago
Man versteht zwar nicht soviel aber amy hat einfach die stimme wenn amy nicht mitsingen würde würde das lied gar nicht richtig herauskommen es wäre so langweilig und gerade amy bringt berge dort rein, die gewalt ihrer gefühle sie bringt da einfach was rein was den song raushebt
TheWolkenstern 4 months ago
Amy personified rock and roll.
RIP babe
410mile 4 months ago
its not an amy song...lol...this is badd
WPLxochitl 4 months ago
Oh my!
Snotra 4 months ago
Amy winehouse is singing in crackhead language
ghettofreakshow781 4 months ago 3
@ghettofreakshow781 lmao!! yeah its out of tune at parts too
jhamblin23 4 months ago
Amy donne un espèce de renouveaux a cet chanson en lui sa voix si particulière.
RIP amy :'( <3
TheSurfeusedu40 4 months ago
Guys what the heck does the Reactions Tab mean?
katalyze87 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Some people want young white females to mix with non-white males.
I made a one-minute video highlighting a very tiny sample of race-mixing advertisements.
I love white people, and I am opposed to race-mixing. But I do not hate non-whites.
If you click on my name “autumntree2011” highlighted in blue below this comment, you can watch my video.
(I'm not a fan of Hitler or KKK.)
autumntree2011 4 months ago
Amy Winehouse dies.
I dont have to listen to this ever again.
Fair trade.
PonceParade 4 months ago
Amy was just a really amazing person and oozed character and warmth. <3 Amy
katalyze87 4 months ago
it was not a good pitch for amy - that's why she didn't sound as good
peprilen 4 months ago
Amy Amy Amy
OsieandMckim 4 months ago
Do you know how drunk Amy was this night and she still super smashed it. I love you Amy R.I.P
Buttercreamstasty 4 months ago 2
Charlotte sing like karaoke style.. Amy have personality
cavute 4 months ago 2
Amy's voice in this is husky and she have interrupted the song as a fighters type song. Actually she had the biggest range of any singer I've heard and have only listed to her since her death - shame.
Eileene89 4 months ago
It's funny I seen this video about a year ago and everyone was slagging off Amy and now that she has died, you're all praising her. We all know she wasn't talented but lets face it, she is awful in this video.
ColdoMarsh 4 months ago
omg Amy is so badddddd.... rofl I'm sorry but I am not going to validate this awful performance just because she tragically passed away. Half the time you cannot even tell if she's on track with the lyrics. It's just horrible.
KauPirate 4 months ago
charlotte...? weird
bearanda07 4 months ago
Amy was a natural soul singer; Charlotte Church is a classically trained soprano. I liked it.
brook900 4 months ago 2
This rulz!
xxxblasted77 4 months ago
Amy Winehouse really could rock with her rich voice :)
KatAnglesea 5 months ago
Charlotte Church ruined this live.... Amy is so much better.
MaryMaryMary36 5 months ago 4
@MaryMaryMary36 I'm afraid your wrong here!!!!! You can hardly understand winehouse. Her voice really isn't that great.
quinn244 4 months ago 18
@quinn244 that is the way she sang, her voice was amazing
ericallencurtis123 3 months ago
@quinn244 her voice is INCREDIBLE. granted this isn't a good perf. she was prob high.
kandiluvzu 3 months ago
@MaryMaryMary36 ... Amy is so much better than WHAT? Better than a person who is both drunk AND tone-deaf? LMAO
Whatever you may think of Charlotte Church, at least she and the backup singers are able to sing on key and have some vocal range.
hellnoidontwanna 4 months ago
@SitDownAndShutup... Personality, yes - Amy had TONS of that! And you are right about her ability to sucessfully pull off alcohol-soaked scat - sometimes. Unfortunately, this performance wasn't one of those times.
hellnoidontwanna 4 months ago
Never realised that Church was a wannabee Winehouse. She looks and sounds so weak compared to AW. I'm not a fan of either, but Amy wiped the floor with her in this performance.
AlanSturgess 5 months ago
charlotte looks at amy as if to say wat the hell is she doin !!!!! but at lest amy has style!
graiguegirl 5 months ago
@graiguegirl I remember this Amy was very drunk tha'ts why Charlotte was looking at er like that. I thought she was gonna fall over when I watched this on Charlotte's show. Amy is such a rockstar. R.I.P
Buttercreamstasty 4 months ago
charlotte is such a boring self indulgent twat, why was she ever given this show! Why did amy agree to doing this song with her.
THEBONEENGINE 5 months ago
If you took Amy's attitude and Charlotte's vocal ability, you'dve had one HELL of a cover. As it is, respectfully, this isn't very good, IMO.
JayIceColdD 5 months ago
@JayIceColdD That being said, the guitarist (whoever he is) freakin' NAILED that solo.
JayIceColdD 5 months ago