jedes mal wenn ich deine stimme höre bekomme ich eine gänsehaut...das schönste gesicht und die beste weibliche stimme meiner zeit...katie melua...top!
Also wirklich, wie kann man diese Leistung nur als negativ bezeichnen. Katie Melua singt dieses Lied mit einer Liebe zum Song, dass sich mir jedesmal sämtliche Haare aufstellen. Ich selbst singe dieses Lied seit vielen Jahren auf der Bühne und nachdem ich dieses Lied hier hörte, singe ich es nur noch im "Katie Melua"-Style. Das ist die grandioseste Version, die ich jemals gehört habe.
i love her.. why? because she is a king and queen and god and angel and woman and man... she is everythin and everyone in the world :) :) love her .. and her music :)
Eigentlich kann und darf jeder Song gecovert werden, nur wenn so eine scheiße dabei raus kommt wie die musik in den charts, dann ist das eine beleidigung für gute musik ... für den Rockn Roll !!! Doch wenn jemand wie Katie Melua einen Song covert, nicht um Geld zu machen, sondern weil sie die Liebe zu dem Song und zu einem der größten Musik legenden Bob Dylan der Welt zeigen möchte und sie es noch so wunderschön macht, dann ist das Toll.
God, shes so fucking BORING, and shit, but I bet she likes blowing in the wind. I wonder if she shaves her kebab, or if it's all poking out the sides of her knickers
@deliciousbass61 Sorry to disagree ...it's an unimaginative attempt at a forgettable repetitive song played on out of tune guitars. Wake up...this is sooooo ordinary.
@newmusikguy This song was deemed good enough to cover by the likes of Stevie Wonder, Elvis Presley, Etta James, Neil Young, Duke Ellington, all giants of the music world plus hundreds of others yet you think it's forgettable and repetitive? I think that shows just how worthwhile your opinion is in this discussion
@deliciousbass61 All that doesn't mean anything. All great artists have weak moments. For example, all of those artists you mention (except Elvis - I'm feeling brave) are awesome but not everything they ever did was awesome.
There's brilliant Stevie and terrible Stevie. There's brilliant Ellington and average Ellington. Get my drift?
I notice you didn't contest my opinion of Katie's bland performance on an out of tune guitar.
@newmusikguy I didn't contest it because I agree everyone's entitled to their opinion, I just think yours is wrong. I have no issue with you questioning Melua's performance, she's not everyone's cup of tea. But to question the song, which has gone down as a classic and will be considered a classic for many years to come, I find incredibly surprising. And yes artists will do songs they don't consider their best, but I think the list of artists that clearly think highly of it speaks for itself
@deliciousbass61@deliciousbass61 OK I take your point. We're allowed to disagree…history has shown some artists record bad choices hoping for a financial pay off. i.e. they go "selling out" etc I cannot believe Stevie or Ellington would record this folk song for its musical merit. These were simply lapses in their quality control... I certainly can see that Blowing in the Wind "means" a lot to people from that era, but as a piece of folk music I still maintain it's average at best.
Again I am surprised to see that cover versions are often better than original, and vice versa, many artists (like the wonderful Melua) are better as performers than as composers.
Katie is Georgian girl whose parent immigrated to the U.K. She is tallented, and socially engaged, as far as we can judge from the USA. I think this is a brilliant performance of her. Much appreciated.
what bobby dylan had sung effortlessly, this girl had to put so much effort
ashu0912 3 weeks ago
jedes mal wenn ich deine stimme höre bekomme ich eine gänsehaut...das schönste gesicht und die beste weibliche stimme meiner zeit...katie melua...top!
pRInsidious 1 month ago
WOW !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
deaner2122 1 month ago
I'd cum in her curls. right behind her back!
MrMattyvibes 1 month ago
@MrMattyvibes guess that makes you a w###er !
2674bobg 4 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
@MrMattyvibes you're an idiot
supducavi 2 weeks ago in playlist Liked videos 2
Get back in the kitchen, talentless woman/women.
MrMattyvibes 1 month ago
beautiful
steveliesky 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos 4
i want to f*ck with her voice
pawelkonieczka 1 month ago
Justin Sundercoe is playing
awma1975 1 month ago
este vídeo me lo recomendó el pana carlos altamiranda, tremendo profesor de inglés de la ciudad de Barinas, éxito mi pana
maxwell28389 2 months ago
how many times i must listen this song that it become bored for me? the answer my friend is that I DON'T know:))))))
misssally199114 2 months ago
@misssally199114
i'm well over a thousand--dr paul
weikert843 1 month ago
only lovely she can sing this song wow wow
karma230762 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
danken wir gott das er uns einen solchen engel geschickt hat ,... zum verlieben schön (stimme und frau )^^
dennisthemanic 2 months ago
danken wir got das er uns einen solchen engel geschickt hat ,... zum verlieben schön (stimme und frau )^^
dennisthemanic 2 months ago
Diese Frau hat eine grandiose Stimme. Danke.
xfilll 2 months ago
super
jsify1 2 months ago
georgian : )))
karlito2493 2 months ago
@karlito2493 ur mom
SkolisseDK 2 months ago
ich bin laktozeintolerant!
ProGangstaShit 2 months ago
Katie prolongs the legacy of Eva Cassidy. And that's fantastic
abcdefghi55378 2 months ago
Thank you for this video. I like the song better when singing by Katie Melua than by Bob Dylon
gabi925 2 months ago
great song and great performance by katie, she is gerorgian and i'm proud of her
anrimanu 2 months ago
Gänsehaut *-*
BadNenndorfBoy 2 months ago
Gänsehautstimme :)
BadNenndorfBoy 2 months ago
kate the best (L)(L)(L):*:*
nikamenejer 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up if you are greek!
ano0211 3 months ago
sex
cossackxxx 3 months ago
@cossackxxx what ????
anrimanu 2 months ago
awww რა კარგია :)
Ngujabidze 3 months ago
Just spent 2 1/2 years outide the wire. Thank you.
57869023 3 months ago
I could listen to that masterpiece all the time!
Nunek181 3 months ago
una diosa!!
MissEntelequia 3 months ago
incredible voice
daciansah 4 months ago
absolut superb
daciansah 4 months ago
YOCAG SAQARTVELOS SIAMAYE :*
Good Work From Georgia :*:*:*
n2rs4 4 months ago 4
I'm sorry but I disagree.. Katie has a beautiful voice but it just sounds "whiny" in this....It doesn't work for me
989Mojo 4 months ago
Moving
iskschoi 4 months ago
schönes lied und eine super stimme
egal1234100 4 months ago
une superbe reprise
nanymela 5 months ago
Fab!!!!
roleta301116 5 months ago
A voiced blessed by God amen
peters12ful 5 months ago
Katie zinterpretowała ten protestsong pięknie, ale niemcy niech lepiej milczą....
tomekkaczkowski 5 months ago
i love this song cause "how many roads must a man walk down before they can call him a man "
this is really excited question.and u never have answer exactly to explain it
so thats why i love song :X:X:X:X
hhoniez 5 months ago
This voice is like gold!
irishaccordion 5 months ago
hehe
aton2011amon 6 months ago in playlist Katie Melua u.a.
das ist erstklassig *-* :D =D
MHMicha 6 months ago
beautiful !
0werewolf0 6 months ago
Wundevoll *-*
Gänsehaut.
moos543 6 months ago
Wunderbarer Song mit einer traumhaften Stimme gesungen. Besser geht es einfach nicht.
breathcontrolking 6 months ago 2
Ich liebe dieses Video 3 mal;
Bob Dylan-Katie Melua und Drdental Thank you all.
Habe fast alle Covers gehört.
charleshenry1100 6 months ago
Also wirklich, wie kann man diese Leistung nur als negativ bezeichnen. Katie Melua singt dieses Lied mit einer Liebe zum Song, dass sich mir jedesmal sämtliche Haare aufstellen. Ich selbst singe dieses Lied seit vielen Jahren auf der Bühne und nachdem ich dieses Lied hier hörte, singe ich es nur noch im "Katie Melua"-Style. Das ist die grandioseste Version, die ich jemals gehört habe.
Hadley065 6 months ago
She could at least have learned the lyrics by heart, my god. Is that too much to ask when you sing a Dylan song...?
vittli 7 months ago
Sehr mittelmäßig :(
BinOnline1 8 months ago
@BinOnline1
musst es dir ja nicht reinziehen...finde, sie ist großartig..!!!!
tiecherle 7 months ago 2
@tiecherle Habe es mir nochmals "reingezogen" und bleibe bei meiner Aussage.
Katie zieht den Song auf "Musikantenstadl-Niveau" runter.
BinOnline1 7 months ago
@BinOnline1 Das nenne ich mal ernstzunehmende Kritik. Dein Kommentar zeugt von deiner überragenden Intelligenz.
Zergikun 6 months ago
Ein Wort genügt: "Gänsehaut"!!!!!
BachAlf 8 months ago
woo woo woo beutivul
fabiu541 9 months ago
hûhu_pásst_hïér_ñêt_rêìn_aba_ích_bïn_só_ëìñsãm_wîll_jëmánd_mit_míå_schrèíbën
BibiaTaynaia16 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BibiaTaynaia16 fick dich ey -.-
schwiizer0815 8 months ago 7
This has to be the best version of this song - I love it , can listen to it over and over again!
nsjnd22 10 months ago
I agree with kacker.
carlfrolberg 10 months ago
it´s to slow !! faster its bad
MrWurstbrot1000 10 months ago
it´s to slow !! faster its bad
MrWurstbrot1000 10 months ago
she makes me wanna cry for no frikkin reason...
hardyinc 10 months ago
This is just incredible.
leahintheskies 10 months ago
great
MightyMoses1910 11 months ago
nothing more nothing less! Just Awesome!!
thinkpack1 11 months ago
Just Awesome!!
thinkpack1 11 months ago
merci Nagui et son emission tatarata!
VINZZ78971 11 months ago
spiel das eben mit meiner gitach nach
sau korekt
skateter1 11 months ago
So sweet it is nauseating.
woland99 11 months ago
I know Bob Dylan perform,but I enjoy Katie's perform's
ignace7N 1 year ago
I know Bob Dylan'S perform but I very enjoy Katie's perform
ignace7N 1 year ago
hübsch mit b
Korsikamann 1 year ago 2
die schönste frau!!!!!! wie geht das dass jemand so hüpsch ist????
wuurstsepp 1 year ago
i love her.. why? because she is a king and queen and god and angel and woman and man... she is everythin and everyone in the world :) :) love her .. and her music :)
TheKatieink 1 year ago
gorßartig gesungen, wie immer. doch vielleicht ein zu fröhliches arrangement...
JohnnyLop87 1 year ago
Love her ö ♥
MinnaTM 1 year ago
Ihr habt alle keine ahnung ...
Eigentlich kann und darf jeder Song gecovert werden, nur wenn so eine scheiße dabei raus kommt wie die musik in den charts, dann ist das eine beleidigung für gute musik ... für den Rockn Roll !!! Doch wenn jemand wie Katie Melua einen Song covert, nicht um Geld zu machen, sondern weil sie die Liebe zu dem Song und zu einem der größten Musik legenden Bob Dylan der Welt zeigen möchte und sie es noch so wunderschön macht, dann ist das Toll.
MyWoodstock69 1 year ago 68
@MyWoodstock69 genauuu ;) so siehts aus und nich anders ;)
MissXGeorgia 1 year ago
Also Frau Melua mag ich sehr aber das hätte sie nicht machen sollen :-/
Drecksnick 1 year ago
@Drecksnick wieso das denn?
Minathrit 1 year ago
@Minathrit Das ist sicher gut gesungen usw usw. aber manche Sachen sollte/darf man einfach nicht covern!
Drecksnick 1 year ago
damn :D this is what i would call a VOICE
support voices, and be against computer garbage like gaga or kesha :D
RixxN 1 year ago
If I was stranded on a desert island with only one songwriter, I'd choose Dylan.
soin2top 1 year ago 2
es ist echt schön
EllilaZoe 1 year ago 2
i love it
iamladydada 1 year ago
oh,
da werden erinnerungen an den heutigen musikunterricht wach,
aber net umbedingt gute (;
2010zukunft 1 year ago
gutes video könnte so geil sein wenn ich jemand lieben finden würde
fannysification 1 year ago
@fannysification :D:D:D
bechtiful 1 year ago
God bless you,,,
TheCottinger 1 year ago
Супер!!!
briz999 1 year ago
iiiiiii haha wo bin ich hier gelandet
locke7811 1 year ago
*heul, heul* man is das geil
so schön kann ichs nich *grins*
liebe dieses lied, spiele gitarre
umruehren 1 year ago
Wonderful version !!!
LaurentziuRo 1 year ago 2
the girl has got it SIMPLE AS VOICE OF AN ANGEL
TONYIRISHPROUD 1 year ago 53
is she actually playing that guitar?
chandin69 1 year ago
@chandin69 yes she is. amazing right?
LoveGuitarS2 1 year ago
Nice one.
But Dylan's Version is better. His voice is inimitable.
PeaceFrog234 1 year ago
wunderbar!!! I love this girl. She is so excellent!!!!
YourPainkillerSxx 1 year ago
the guitar is not well tuned!!!!!!!!!!!
Maggie87ful 1 year ago
diesen Song vergisst man nicht Bob Dylan hat es nicht besser gesungen
ronny43ify 1 year ago
frauen an den herd!
DrSBecker 1 year ago
@DrSBecker ja sehr fortschrittlich *lach der neid ist eine schlimme sache
Ghostmod 1 year ago
wunderschöne Dame
wunderschönes Lied
:-*
subik90 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
♥Put ur hand on ur mouth
2.Wish into ur hand
3.Put ur hand in ur heart for five seconds
4.Put this comment on three videos
5.Tomorrow you will have the best day of your LIFE it really works
Meluial 1 year ago
wot a fantastic voice this girl has
TONYIRISHPROUD 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
She has the voice of an Angel!
kray9r 1 year ago
The loveliest performance of this song I've ever heard. Enchanting.
aeropostalesigns247 1 year ago 2
wonderful Girl... wonderful voice, beautiful face... the hair... WOW !!!!!
Pwn31337 1 year ago
I love this song :)
TheRhodan 1 year ago
wonderful, just wonderful <3
Kowalski2007 1 year ago
katie melua <3
diddydidntdo234 1 year ago
go away, she's not great enough to be allowed to sing this song
streuner 1 year ago
@streuner
she doesn't get the point of this song AT ALL. but the chinese bicycles were pretty
mareeay 1 year ago
@streuner yes she is!!!
Juliabb245 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God, shes so fucking BORING, and shit, but I bet she likes blowing in the wind. I wonder if she shaves her kebab, or if it's all poking out the sides of her knickers
thepaperlantern 1 year ago
@thepaperlantern lol..you are going to hell!
sonjaxfactor 1 year ago
Great cover of a fantastic song. Sorry but I think anyone who doesn't enjoy this really doesn't appreciate good music.
deliciousbass61 1 year ago
@deliciousbass61 Sorry to disagree ...it's an unimaginative attempt at a forgettable repetitive song played on out of tune guitars. Wake up...this is sooooo ordinary.
newmusikguy 1 year ago
@newmusikguy This song was deemed good enough to cover by the likes of Stevie Wonder, Elvis Presley, Etta James, Neil Young, Duke Ellington, all giants of the music world plus hundreds of others yet you think it's forgettable and repetitive? I think that shows just how worthwhile your opinion is in this discussion
deliciousbass61 1 year ago
@deliciousbass61 All that doesn't mean anything. All great artists have weak moments. For example, all of those artists you mention (except Elvis - I'm feeling brave) are awesome but not everything they ever did was awesome.
There's brilliant Stevie and terrible Stevie. There's brilliant Ellington and average Ellington. Get my drift?
I notice you didn't contest my opinion of Katie's bland performance on an out of tune guitar.
newmusikguy 1 year ago
@newmusikguy I didn't contest it because I agree everyone's entitled to their opinion, I just think yours is wrong. I have no issue with you questioning Melua's performance, she's not everyone's cup of tea. But to question the song, which has gone down as a classic and will be considered a classic for many years to come, I find incredibly surprising. And yes artists will do songs they don't consider their best, but I think the list of artists that clearly think highly of it speaks for itself
deliciousbass61 1 year ago
@deliciousbass61 @deliciousbass61 OK I take your point. We're allowed to disagree…history has shown some artists record bad choices hoping for a financial pay off. i.e. they go "selling out" etc I cannot believe Stevie or Ellington would record this folk song for its musical merit. These were simply lapses in their quality control... I certainly can see that Blowing in the Wind "means" a lot to people from that era, but as a piece of folk music I still maintain it's average at best.
newmusikguy 1 year ago
@deliciousbass61 I think we just better agree to disagree ok?
newmusikguy 1 year ago
sehr sehr gut! respekt!
Globe6533 1 year ago
9 milion "Blowing in the wind"
bwarezak 1 year ago
I love Bob Dylan.
I love Katie Melua.
beewright2604 1 year ago
lovely katie and thanks for singing with EVA
shifty39 1 year ago
ich kenne die nicht, aber sie singt sehr gut das lied von bob. echt sehr gut!!!!
Hakan7012 1 year ago
And there is Justin Sandercoe on guitar helping out. Nice version of this great song.
NearlyNormalSteve 1 year ago
Because she is Georgian !!! ;)
onoxubutia 1 year ago
eine Melodie die der Welt unvergessen bleibt Danke Bob Dylan
ronny43ify 1 year ago
@Gyphia
indeed
its all about massproduction and earnings. talents like katie is a rarity
pootubeftw 1 year ago
Bin stolz auf dich!! Nicht nur ich, sondern ganzes land, Georgien:)) warmatebebs gisurveb!! gmerti gfaravdes!!:))
ElizaKhujadze 1 year ago
wow, it's beautiful!
CherrySiingiingBee 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
how can a person sing so well and look so good?
bodruggelu 1 year ago
end gut voll schön
Bibione112 1 year ago
The sweetest voice I ever heard cover this song!
djl1098 1 year ago
great :) such a wonderful song, one the best songs ever
jks966 1 year ago
2:10 almost...
embran 1 year ago
rubbish worth shagging though!
rufusandburne 1 year ago
I am glad to share the same decades with that man. I think he's one of the greatest poets of our time. This one is as relevant as ever.
hanseroots 1 year ago
This is Great.
Prison46 1 year ago
Better than the original. And 'hello' to Justin Sandercoe on the acoustic guitar.
zalp66 2 years ago
go justin go
Live2PlayChannel 2 years ago
how... how can a person sing so well and look so good... :)
kacker1990 2 years ago 99
yeah...it's the whole package ;)
thecooker9 1 year ago
@kacker1990 because the ugly bitches who sing well won't get famous
ChiefWiggumBLN 1 year ago
@ChiefWiggumBLN
Who are you then-an asshole??
bowedmyhead 1 year ago
@bowedmyhead
Who are you then-a troll??
ChiefWiggumBLN 1 year ago
@kacker1990 The answer is blowing in the wind...
alkotinis 1 year ago
Again I am surprised to see that cover versions are often better than original, and vice versa, many artists (like the wonderful Melua) are better as performers than as composers.
Colonellucas67 2 years ago
absolutely beautiful interpretation
♥ i love this version so much ♥
thank you for - ✱ ✰ ✯ ✰ ✱
have a great christmas season
best regards Ernesto...
Gitarrencheck09 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Die ist absolut gängig
Sergey13841 2 years ago
@Sergey13841 write i in english the non german user are not able to read german!
(bin deutsch)
bofferlo 2 years ago
shes gorgeus
skt556 2 years ago 2
georgia for ever gagimarjos keti you are so biutifull girl and smart.
gagvimarjos 2 years ago 3
JUSTIN SANDERCORE playing with her in that video :P
midgard2k3 2 years ago 2
I think she does it better than Bob Dylan!
TheNaja12 2 years ago
Um, no. Especially when it comes to the point of such songs, you can never compare the writer and the interpreter.
ProfBoogeyChaos 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this sucks without end
Dimmulation66Sorrows 2 years ago
Katie is Georgian girl whose parent immigrated to the U.K. She is tallented, and socially engaged, as far as we can judge from the USA. I think this is a brilliant performance of her. Much appreciated.
ivpivivpiv 2 years ago 4
she´s honest
2eisenautos 2 years ago 5
yess...she is georgian, xD
and i'm proud.....cause i'm 2
magari xar!!
luv her sweet voice <3
llicious88 2 years ago
amazing!!!
sissi1975 2 years ago 5
keti , ulamasesi da unijieresi adamiani, mikvarxar usomod, gaixare
akulina1 2 years ago 4
kargi natqwamia, AKULINA1
haha sorry if it's not spelled right..
i see ur from germany
i'm from holland,i'm georgian myself but i was just a baby when i came here
greetz
llicious88 2 years ago
i really like her singing.
chibinski 2 years ago 3
Great Performance
Pacman8562 2 years ago 3
She has such an incredible voice...it gives me the chills whenever I hear her. She is truly blessed :)
Selinja 2 years ago 4
Same here. Amazing version.
JiS01 2 years ago
MERCI C'EST SUPERBE !!
rundavid22 2 years ago
She have a nice Voice and a Pretty Face.
But the Bob Dylan Version is Better, Bob Dylan voice is more Cruel for the Lyric.
NoNickNoKick 2 years ago
a young nana mouskori?
whiteliketar 2 years ago
probably
hswolfurt 2 years ago
Grandios!
sebastiangos26 2 years ago
歌声きれい。
qmjkb855 2 years ago
Großartig!
Hinterkaifeck 2 years ago