I usually don't mind anette singing...i mean obviously she can sing, but just with a different vocal style, but on this track, she sound dangerously like she is screaming...
Anette is... I'm sry but ony Tarja should sing the original songs. Anette cant sing what Tarja made great. I think Anette is okay but she cant replace Tarja. Somebody find away to get Tarja back on Nightwish.
esta chica no es para una banda de metal como la gente es re pop queda muy mal con la onda NW o Epica por dar otro ejemplo. Es de madera!!! Arruinó a la banda el boludo del tecladista!!!
She is not a very good singer. There is no contest. She sounds awful and I went to listen to something else with her. What are these guys thinking. It's terrible.
Misterwhite the retarded rabbit ... if i have a opinion then just stfu. I think like many others that tarja is more "nightwish" then annette but if you like to be a fucking retard and writing shit on internet then just stfu
No ... you were attempting to see if I was a suitable mate for you.
I'm not a suitable mate for you because I am intelligent, educated, well-bred, and I am clean.
You however are posting like the retard. If you weren't posting like a retard, I would have passed right over your posts instead of stopping to slap you around for a while.
yeah right ... be coocky over the internet dude, one day you will get your ass kicked and then u wish u wouldnt be a smartass... and bitch ? my opinion my words, dont like it ? well bring it on fucktard
If I had a nickel for every clown shoe that challenges me over the internet, I'd be richer than Bill Gates.
One day I'll get my ass kicked? I have spent 28 of the last 41 years getting my ass kicked by the best fighters on the planet. Some guys fish, some drink beer and watch football, some do woodworking. That is what I did for fun.
But you are changing the subject ... I am too smart, too educated, and too well bred to want someone like you as my woman.
I'm no Tarja fanboy, but seriously... the old songs won't fit Annete's voice.
At 0:23 I thought it was an Alvin & the Chipmunks concert. There's the bad recording to blame, but still...
0:51 ... she should have gone up a step. That's not just a bad concert to me, that's lack of rehearsals. Her range won't allow it? So she shouldn't sing this one.
Actually, if they stick to playing the new songs, maybe people will stop picking on her.
The sound on this video is REALLY bad. I was AT this concert, and it was a lot better than it sounds! She rocked this concert, shame the vids didn't reflect that. :( The one that came to Toronto recently (Sept) was even better! For people who say she sucks, please shut up until YOU hear her live. Thanks. :)
at least she's singing with her own style..not copying tarja..nobody can sing like tarja did.. tarja is tarja..anette is anette..this song isn't made for her voice..thats it..all the songs dat she sang in dark passion play album were so great..
You know i think this was the main problem. It doesn't matter if it is Anette or any other girl...people WOULD SURELY speak poorly of her only because Tarja got fired.
Is there any nightwish fan here? Or are you all only Tarja's fans? If this is the caze please move to My Winter Storm Land and leave Anette and Nightwish alone.
A band as good as this one should replace the lead singer with someone who fits the music. This girl's voice is too mild and whiny for the music. She might be ok doing something more ambient but not the music they perform. She just is a bad choice, nothing to do with the other girl.
Pobrecita =( a mi me da un poco de pena. Es demasiado dificil imitar a Tarja, su voz es demasiado "opera" y a Anette se le complica demasiado cantar las canciones de Tarja.
The new songs are better for her voice cuz there were made with her but I really loved Nemo with Anette it sounds very great, of course its not like it was with Tarja but SHE'S NOT COMING BACK! so let anette do their job and let tarja do her job too. they are in diferent places right now and non of this comments against her will get back tarja.
I'd like to see on of you tryng to do what Annete does.
I liked but she has to practice the old songs more
okey, she has a whole different voice but and i think she's doning a great job first to be there when almost nobody like her. she's brave and not everyone could stand something like this.
well... i don't disike anette. In fact i think she's a talented girl, BUT old Nightwish songs just aren't made for her! it sounds as if she was screaming in pain!!! if she now has a bunch of brand new songs written specially for her voice, in which it sounds way better... why can't she stick with them?? that way we could all sleep in peace and good old songs wouldn't be screwn up
I thin Anette only ruins the old songs.I guess that, with Anette, much more people would want to listen to Nightwish. Most of the time, Anette pronounces the words better than Tarja but here sounds the song by Tarja better. ''within'' is with the stress on withIN and not WithEN...
What's wrong with her?? why does she have to scream?? if she can't sing the old songs properly, wich she obviuosly will never can, she must only sing the new ones...and if the fans miss the old ones, well, Tuomas could have picked a singer (not a better, just a 'singer').
por lo menos respeten a tarja vieja pendeja deje de cantar las caciones interpretadas por tarja no se tire en los trabajos anteriores de nightwish, muerte a anette, que viva tarja
And to those who say she isnt as good as Tarja.. they're so different you cant compare them! they're both completely different styles and amazing at what they do. So none is better than the other
oh, I miss my fav group of all time, Nightwish.. I'm sorry, but w/o Tarja, this is no Nightwish..I find Dark Passion Play totally boring.. how can u compare it with Oceanborn??
well, i guess tarja would sound funny on some telephone from 1990, the sound quality sux. But i must agree, this song is meant for tarja, ans she sings it best, but anettecan sing amaranth and cadence of her last breath alot better than tarja would im sure.
Please don't judge her with a video of bad quality. I've still a hope that's gonna be a good gig next monday but it's hard to expect that after tarja... i'm so disappointed...
Don't take me wrong. I love Anette voice but she cant sing this ong. Her voice is two uncontrolled. She doesn't have the power of Tarja. But in Anette defence this was written for somebody else.
Yah I like the Tarja version better. She can't pull off that opera voice. *sigh* sometimes I wish Tuomas chose a different singer...one more like Tarja....but whatever. They're still good. =) They just sounded better with more progressive metal and less mainstream rock.
If Anette is screaming perhaps then Dio,Gillan,Coverdale...ec. are screamers too.I think in Rock music screaming is natural.Maby that don't work at the opera...
Anette has a very fun stage presence, and she did awesome on the vocals. No one is going to be Tarja... but she's not trying to. She's singing the songs her way, with her own style. So please, stop wasting your time and your breath bashing her.
I was at this exact show, I've been a nightwish fan since i was 11 years old (20 now), and i went into this concert with mixed feelings, i love tarja's voice i do, but there is no reason to be so hostile against anette.. its not like she has done anything to Tarja, and as someone already said, stop bashing anette and go listen to My Winter Storm, its out in stores already :P
no depth, the master of singing speaking. Honestly, if you claim something like that, you are not ready to be a singer. Because then you don't know anything about singing.
Btw, your new ever dream (karaoke) just sucks in the beginning. You're seriously out of tune. It doesn't go that way, you've changed the melody and that's not good because obviously you didn't mean it to happen.
I'm tired of everyone saying bullshits about Tarja vs Annette...they are different singers with different approaches, Annette just need time to get her perfect dimension with songs written for another person.
The new NW album is great and Annette have done a huge amount of work.
I too love Tarja but that's nonsense now, if you don't like it just listen to My winter Storm and don't break the balls:-)
No, I have to deal with superficial and judgmental assholes like you who think they know everything and feel superior to those who like Anette. If you can't hear Tarja sing off key at many live performances perhaps it's you who is deaf or just wants to hear what she wants to hear.
Judgemental much? There is yet to be a decent live video of Anette performing, so judgmental asses like you can actually form an opinion worth reading.
Anette!!!!
Que Hermosa, me encanta como canta esa cancion!!
La Amoooooooo!! Todaaaa Ellaaa!
NwDevotion 9 months ago
Is this even nightwish? OMG what a piece of crap they have become with anette...
SWE000FIN 1 year ago 2
OH - MY FUCKING - DEAR - GOD....
THIS IS A COMPLETELY TRASH... can't imagine how people can love that stupid girl with no voice, SHE'S ONLY SCREAMING LIKE A DRUNK BITCH.
whatever.. Tarja our queen foerever, NO ONE CAN SING THAT SONG BETTER THAN TARJA.
UltravioletSlave 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
HORRROR!!!TARJA ES LA MEJOR!
Tarja FoReVeR !!!!
mamacita dedicate a dar clases de canto a los sordo mudos no sirves pa esto¿¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
Tarja FoReVeR !!!!
Tarja FoReVeR !!!!
NarkasNezU 1 year ago
:O sound slike shes screaming
cher4995 2 years ago 2
she doesn't know to sing...
majaToUMaS 2 years ago
I usually don't mind anette singing...i mean obviously she can sing, but just with a different vocal style, but on this track, she sound dangerously like she is screaming...
natashtrad 2 years ago 3
Anette is... I'm sry but ony Tarja should sing the original songs. Anette cant sing what Tarja made great. I think Anette is okay but she cant replace Tarja. Somebody find away to get Tarja back on Nightwish.
ArmeyaSpiritsong 2 years ago 4
oh god this bitch even knows how to pronunciate... oh how this is terrible...
MarianeLee 2 years ago
WTF NO NO NO GOD THIS IS COMPLETLY SCREW >.>
ANETTE GO AND FIND A POP BAND THIS IS NOT NIGTHWISH...
my ears
lolalola46 2 years ago 2
aaaah f**k you Anette shouting b**ch!
one of my favorite songs has been killed with your voice =[
MortisisAmunet 2 years ago 4
Tarja FoReVeR !!!!
MajinLao 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay gay
hartiaxmototolita 3 years ago
shit anette.....were is this powerful voice of TARJA.......TARJA WE LOVE YOU !!!
Kellif78 3 years ago 4
now tarja sings this song..and it is just wonderfull
diana17rock 2 years ago
esta chica no es para una banda de metal como la gente es re pop queda muy mal con la onda NW o Epica por dar otro ejemplo. Es de madera!!! Arruinó a la banda el boludo del tecladista!!!
gonzometal2006 3 years ago
horrible
granbertanya 3 years ago 10
She is not a very good singer. There is no contest. She sounds awful and I went to listen to something else with her. What are these guys thinking. It's terrible.
Mollidew 3 years ago 2
she should sing new songs, not the old nightwish´s ones.
redmoonx 3 years ago 2
yeah she should i love anette but she shouldnt sing tarjas songs :P
Kaffepannan 3 years ago
REALLLLY???
Tarja wrote all those songs?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
MISTERWHITE111 3 years ago
are you retarded ?
Kaffepannan 3 years ago 2
Kaffepannan wrote: " are you retarded ? "
No ... why? Is that a precondition for socializing with you?
Sorry .... I have no interest in socializing with you.
MISTERWHITE111 3 years ago
Misterwhite the retarded rabbit ... if i have a opinion then just stfu. I think like many others that tarja is more "nightwish" then annette but if you like to be a fucking retard and writing shit on internet then just stfu
Kaffepannan 3 years ago
No ... you were attempting to see if I was a suitable mate for you.
I'm not a suitable mate for you because I am intelligent, educated, well-bred, and I am clean.
You however are posting like the retard. If you weren't posting like a retard, I would have passed right over your posts instead of stopping to slap you around for a while.
MISTERWHITE111 3 years ago
yeah right ... be coocky over the internet dude, one day you will get your ass kicked and then u wish u wouldnt be a smartass... and bitch ? my opinion my words, dont like it ? well bring it on fucktard
Kaffepannan 3 years ago
~~~~CHUCKLE~~~
If I had a nickel for every clown shoe that challenges me over the internet, I'd be richer than Bill Gates.
One day I'll get my ass kicked? I have spent 28 of the last 41 years getting my ass kicked by the best fighters on the planet. Some guys fish, some drink beer and watch football, some do woodworking. That is what I did for fun.
But you are changing the subject ... I am too smart, too educated, and too well bred to want someone like you as my woman.
MISTERWHITE111 3 years ago
I'm no Tarja fanboy, but seriously... the old songs won't fit Annete's voice.
At 0:23 I thought it was an Alvin & the Chipmunks concert. There's the bad recording to blame, but still...
0:51 ... she should have gone up a step. That's not just a bad concert to me, that's lack of rehearsals. Her range won't allow it? So she shouldn't sing this one.
Actually, if they stick to playing the new songs, maybe people will stop picking on her.
xkuei 3 years ago
hahahahahahaha!!!...OMG O_o dead for me...
sadrek 3 years ago
The sound on this video is REALLY bad. I was AT this concert, and it was a lot better than it sounds! She rocked this concert, shame the vids didn't reflect that. :( The one that came to Toronto recently (Sept) was even better! For people who say she sucks, please shut up until YOU hear her live. Thanks. :)
bagheera101 3 years ago
hey..
at least she's singing with her own style..not copying tarja..nobody can sing like tarja did.. tarja is tarja..anette is anette..this song isn't made for her voice..thats it..all the songs dat she sang in dark passion play album were so great..
shifayusz 3 years ago
A Anette precisa evoluir muito para chegar a ser vocalista da Nightwish. Não tem voz nenhuma para este tipo de música.
Ziegler27 3 years ago
those notes were really difficult for the natural voice. and she did not pull it off as always.
she should improve her discipline as a singer.
oriongrip 3 years ago
You know i think this was the main problem. It doesn't matter if it is Anette or any other girl...people WOULD SURELY speak poorly of her only because Tarja got fired.
Is there any nightwish fan here? Or are you all only Tarja's fans? If this is the caze please move to My Winter Storm Land and leave Anette and Nightwish alone.
melnnix 3 years ago
A band as good as this one should replace the lead singer with someone who fits the music. This girl's voice is too mild and whiny for the music. She might be ok doing something more ambient but not the music they perform. She just is a bad choice, nothing to do with the other girl.
Mollidew 3 years ago 3
it's orrible ù_ù
KiraYoshida 3 years ago
You guys are so estupid... judging her just because of a bad concert. F%$# OFF _|_
Natyb82 3 years ago
she is totally out of tone :S... I think she has a nice voice, but...... omg! this is such an awfull... err... that.
fallinginblue 3 years ago
Pobrecita =( a mi me da un poco de pena. Es demasiado dificil imitar a Tarja, su voz es demasiado "opera" y a Anette se le complica demasiado cantar las canciones de Tarja.
OrinMasteR 3 years ago
Anette ruined this song for me. TARJA was so much better So much better.
kalkalone 3 years ago 4
anette is crap. don't spam, you know it's true
Lyenna1993 3 years ago
Fuck you fag
Turdman12 3 years ago
"anette is crap. don't spam, you know it's true"
you're the one spamming crap, asshole.
YulieAna 3 years ago 6
ok now i hate anette more than ever!
she performes this song really bad. everyone can sing better than her!!!!!!!!!
afedikoxalarwse6178 3 years ago
The new songs are better for her voice cuz there were made with her but I really loved Nemo with Anette it sounds very great, of course its not like it was with Tarja but SHE'S NOT COMING BACK! so let anette do their job and let tarja do her job too. they are in diferent places right now and non of this comments against her will get back tarja.
I'd like to see on of you tryng to do what Annete does.
I liked but she has to practice the old songs more
chemicalxfairy 3 years ago
i think eeryone is so hard at Anette
okey, she has a whole different voice but and i think she's doning a great job first to be there when almost nobody like her. she's brave and not everyone could stand something like this.
chemicalxfairy 3 years ago 2
well... i don't disike anette. In fact i think she's a talented girl, BUT old Nightwish songs just aren't made for her! it sounds as if she was screaming in pain!!! if she now has a bunch of brand new songs written specially for her voice, in which it sounds way better... why can't she stick with them?? that way we could all sleep in peace and good old songs wouldn't be screwn up
Greenillusionist 3 years ago
I thin Anette only ruins the old songs.I guess that, with Anette, much more people would want to listen to Nightwish. Most of the time, Anette pronounces the words better than Tarja but here sounds the song by Tarja better. ''within'' is with the stress on withIN and not WithEN...
But that are little details
BELLATRIXfreak 3 years ago
What's wrong with her?? why does she have to scream?? if she can't sing the old songs properly, wich she obviuosly will never can, she must only sing the new ones...and if the fans miss the old ones, well, Tuomas could have picked a singer (not a better, just a 'singer').
She sucks.
Timelessdarkness 3 years ago
sing isn't just scream. Someone bring back Tarja to nightwish
Ramwen 3 years ago
"Someone bring back Tarja to nightwish"
You could try, but she will be kicking and screaming because she loves her solo career.
YulieAna 3 years ago
por lo menos respeten a tarja vieja pendeja deje de cantar las caciones interpretadas por tarja no se tire en los trabajos anteriores de nightwish, muerte a anette, que viva tarja
aleja8818 3 years ago
anette suck !!
anette let tarja sing it!
you act and sing like brtney !!
Invicible91 3 years ago
Tarja was great, but Anette is a good singer to!
SaraLovesPanic 3 years ago
I wanna cry!!! I mean... annete is not that bad, she's just diferent.... But why does she have to sing the old songs?
inesxana 3 years ago 3
my fave nightwish song...
loving annette.
And to those who say she isnt as good as Tarja.. they're so different you cant compare them! they're both completely different styles and amazing at what they do. So none is better than the other
XoXo
JxL483 3 years ago
Annete Sucks!!
crimsomnia20 3 years ago
oh, I miss my fav group of all time, Nightwish.. I'm sorry, but w/o Tarja, this is no Nightwish..I find Dark Passion Play totally boring.. how can u compare it with Oceanborn??
crimsomnia20 3 years ago
she is only shouthinngg bbööĞĞKK!! ... TArjA !! TARJAAA!!
Bastilaceres 3 years ago
well, i guess tarja would sound funny on some telephone from 1990, the sound quality sux. But i must agree, this song is meant for tarja, ans she sings it best, but anettecan sing amaranth and cadence of her last breath alot better than tarja would im sure.
7h380x 3 years ago 2
Nightwish died.
LadyMithrain 3 years ago
Check the facts and use your brain before you post bs.
YulieAna 3 years ago
Annette Stink!!! Tarja is a REAL singer!!!!
tataharriette 3 years ago 5
HORRROR!!!TARJA ES LA MEJOR!
Puebla1694 3 years ago 5
horrible voice
Isanan 3 years ago 5
she sings like a dick, nightwish without tarja are DEAD, fuck them, they play a shit too, nightwish is a SHIT
puzzyBoy 3 years ago 3
i dont like this vocalist :/
CheoMoggu 3 years ago 4
Ohhh.. Now I'm depressed... I need to make myself a cup of Earl Grey and play the latest Britney's CD. For god's sake, do they really mean this?
d3gn4hc 3 years ago 4
"It doesn`t really matter is video low or high quality..."
Yes it does, all i hear is squealing, not singing, compliments to the poor quality.
"There is thousends of Tarja`s live, low quality vids on youtube"
Yeah, and most of them are professionally made. Still, she sounds off tune on many of them.
"Also, it isn`t biggest problem her voice, acting, or looks, she is NOT metal singer"
Are you saying Tarja is? What does opera have in common with metal?
YulieAna 3 years ago
WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kotipeltus 3 years ago 3
WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kotipeltus 3 years ago
Tarja come back please, this sucks
SHOT HER PLEASEEEE
fdorr 3 years ago
Please don't judge her with a video of bad quality. I've still a hope that's gonna be a good gig next monday but it's hard to expect that after tarja... i'm so disappointed...
Bwitched0 4 years ago
SOMEBODY SHOT HER PLEASEEEE I CANT HANDLE IT ANOYMOREEEEEE....
i like the drunk cat btw :D
unbeaten123456 4 years ago 2
Why dont you shoot your self? Or dont listen to this..
Zeliziouz 3 years ago
Oh my god... What was that!?! A drunk cat??
san00mia 4 years ago
It makes me cry :(
AlexMiedema 4 years ago
omg!she sings like a cat
enauruka 4 years ago
hihihihihihi
bboyhelix 4 years ago
she does not sing, you're wrong, she wails!
crimsomnia20 3 years ago
anette need new song for her, no repeat old songs, she can´t be compared with tarja... diferents voices...
aofv17 4 years ago
Jesus, so fake.... I can perform better :))
AntzLord 4 years ago
I am so sorry for Nightwish.. I think I can sing better than Anette too...
crimsomnia20 3 years ago 3
Don't take me wrong. I love Anette voice but she cant sing this ong. Her voice is two uncontrolled. She doesn't have the power of Tarja. But in Anette defence this was written for somebody else.
duchessofwonders 4 years ago
Does she really have singing Classes? O.O
She forces her voice... X.X
BaroqueAngelus 4 years ago
oh my god, don't force her to sing the old stuff
ZoidyCze 4 years ago
She changes the tune! :-( It loses that epic touch...
BlackFiresong 4 years ago
I miss tarja...
Jonjondaleprechaun 4 years ago
i trie to listen to it but she overdid it here
knightcmc 4 years ago
I doesn't even sound like the old awesome She's My Sin...
From all the old songs i've already heard Anette singing, this is the one which turned worse.
AkaiSoul 4 years ago
i fully agree with you. i saw them live in San Francisco, she did great on wishmaster and nemo, but not this one.
lantasea 4 years ago
i dont like her voice at all its like 2 loose anyways tarjas voice is way beter
nidiyare 4 years ago
Well, at least she can scream...
Timelessdarkness 4 years ago
Yah I like the Tarja version better. She can't pull off that opera voice. *sigh* sometimes I wish Tuomas chose a different singer...one more like Tarja....but whatever. They're still good. =) They just sounded better with more progressive metal and less mainstream rock.
vectorcri 4 years ago
Omagad...
Hang yourself Anette ;)
Minaita 4 years ago
well, at least she doesn't dance like tarja
lupuscrystalus 4 years ago
Esa tipa es un asco, su voz es horrible.
Winyfhet 4 years ago
Shes just screaming @_@ she cant sing =x
babiS2buh 4 years ago
If Anette is screaming perhaps then Dio,Gillan,Coverdale...ec. are screamers too.I think in Rock music screaming is natural.Maby that don't work at the opera...
RockSidi 4 years ago
This audio is horrible!This band sounds 10000000000000 times better in live!
RockSidi 4 years ago
It's Horrible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Beatrux 4 years ago
I think I will have to kill myself.
Bomboss 4 years ago
Have you done it??
Hoodalf 4 years ago 2
Anette has a very fun stage presence, and she did awesome on the vocals. No one is going to be Tarja... but she's not trying to. She's singing the songs her way, with her own style. So please, stop wasting your time and your breath bashing her.
euphoriastragedy 4 years ago 5
I was at this exact show, I've been a nightwish fan since i was 11 years old (20 now), and i went into this concert with mixed feelings, i love tarja's voice i do, but there is no reason to be so hostile against anette.. its not like she has done anything to Tarja, and as someone already said, stop bashing anette and go listen to My Winter Storm, its out in stores already :P
euphoriastragedy 4 years ago
This does make her voice sound better.
But I personally think she just sucks.
Theres no depth or anything to her voice.
I love Nightwish, regardless.
But She should stick to the songs written for her.
Not Tarja.
v.v
IceQueenElle13 4 years ago
no depth, the master of singing speaking. Honestly, if you claim something like that, you are not ready to be a singer. Because then you don't know anything about singing.
Btw, your new ever dream (karaoke) just sucks in the beginning. You're seriously out of tune. It doesn't go that way, you've changed the melody and that's not good because obviously you didn't mean it to happen.
summershine89 4 years ago
it's beacuse she can't sing them. check out she is my sin in hamburg, it really sux
knavis15 4 years ago
i love Anette :)
valerio0824 4 years ago
I'm tired of everyone saying bullshits about Tarja vs Annette...they are different singers with different approaches, Annette just need time to get her perfect dimension with songs written for another person.
The new NW album is great and Annette have done a huge amount of work.
I too love Tarja but that's nonsense now, if you don't like it just listen to My winter Storm and don't break the balls:-)
dragobleu 4 years ago 2
No, I have to deal with superficial and judgmental assholes like you who think they know everything and feel superior to those who like Anette. If you can't hear Tarja sing off key at many live performances perhaps it's you who is deaf or just wants to hear what she wants to hear.
YulieAna 4 years ago
Judgemental much? There is yet to be a decent live video of Anette performing, so judgmental asses like you can actually form an opinion worth reading.
YulieAna 4 years ago
how can people be so critical on a video that isnt perfect quality.
Sidderzx 4 years ago 2
i htink this quality improves her voice...
knavis15 4 years ago
she's improved live.
ranakatina1004 4 years ago