Added: 4 years ago
From: CarolineCalov
Views: 23,189
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (143)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • For a moment I thought that in 0:32 Emppu was going to make an split XD

  • Proud to see them playing in Copenhagen ^^,

  • i think she did a great job. But off cause she cant perform nemo as good as Tarja. Just like Tarja wouldnt be able to perform for example Amaranth.

  • Not bad, Annette is very good at singing. No, she is not Tarja, but Tarja is on her own now, and that, I think is for the best, and I also believe she is much happier this way. Tarja was not the only member of Nightwish, and most certainly not the most important one either, Tuomas proved that without a doubt. No, Nightwish will never be the same without Tarja, but they are still a great band.

  • this is not Nightwish :) this horrible fucking pop :)

  • Why isn't this complete? For God's sake, she was mostly on pitch this time! And it cuts off??? Blargh. Even though I'm not a fan of Annette's style, I'd have loved to have seen this concert. You were lucky to get to go. DPP is a great album! Nightwish is a great band.

  • NOBODY has the same voice as Tarja, but current Nightwish hasn´t got enough songs with Anette to make good concert, i think. Tarja´s songs singed by Anette sonds a little bit different, but NOT BAD!!!

  • årh det var nice aften!

    hahah det er mig og min venindes blomster der kommer flyvende på et tidspunk. ca midt i :b

  • De var så fede den aften :-D

  • Anette must find new songs to sing and stop touching songs like Nemo...songs whose Tarja sang before...She is not Tarja..and she will never be......

  • Why do people say that Anette is so horrible when singing the old songs? Sure, she might not be what Tarja was, but seriously! She does the old songs really well. I would like to see some of these fans to sing the older songs and sound as good as Tarja.

  • Lots of people had an emotional attachment to Tarja and aren't the types who are open to change. That or they simply prefer the operatic style.

    I agree that Anette is fantastic, even on older songs. And Dark Passion Play is my favorite Nightwish album. Listening to dark passion play, I can't picture Tarja's voice sounding good on any of the songs other than Poet And The Pendulum. The band is moving in a new direction and Anette is the better singer for the new sound.

  • I hate when Anette sing songs whose Tarja sang before.

  • Awesome singer live, why people compare he to tarja is beyond stupid! Tarja is amazing im her biggest fan I'm also an anette fan you have to appreciate them both in different ways you cant compare them there two different its silly too. Anette is an awesome singer live she gives me goosbumps and she hasnt been in the buissness at this level as long as tarja has so good on anette!

  • WTF has nobody told her that she sings horrible live?:-& she should stop singing the old song becase she doesn't have tarja's voice. I live some of the new songs but they cannot be compared with the old ones. too bad that tarja got kicked off. I wait for her ne solo album. the first was great:D:X:X:X:X

  • she's awesome live.

  • FFS someone tell her to not sing old songs , she sucks hard!!

  • Annette is good, sometime's she sucks and sometimes she doesn't, she adds a new element to NW, it's just Tarja was 10x better than Annette will ever be, but she couldn't sing an amazing song like Amaranth or The Escapist.

  • anette is so great <33

  • I agree, I miss Tarja, She had an AMAZING voice, this girl is just flat live...

  • jesus get over tarja! nightwish was great wiv her but times change! annette is fukin awesome aswell

    i personally prefer nw wiv annette :P

  • Whether she sounds different(a little flat) LIVE OR IN THE STUDIO, SHE  SOUNDS MILLIONS BETTER THAN THE OTHER SINGER. i COULD ALMOST NOT LISTEN TO NIGHTWISH BEFORE ANETTE

  • No...she is in NO way better than Tarja.

  • She's doing okay in this show (;

  • shes better in other songs but she should not sing this song

  • She seems okay in the studio tracks, but she is always singing flat when she is live. They should never have let the other girl go. She was always right on.

  • Well Tarja was gonna leave soon anway so there was no stopping it.

  • You are not Tarja.

  • I feel that the "sweet" voice of Anette fit quite good for songs like Nemo. When she has to perform more heavy songs is not exactly excellent, but here she's really good.

  • doesn't sound right )-; not enough power in the voice sorry thats my opinion.

    Doesn't mean I think Anette is a bad singer though, just not a good fit.

  • Awesome!

  • eh this suck,sorry :(

  • i wonder how tarja would sound singing annettes songs

  • She should sing like all that she sings

    Just Unbelieveble!!!

  • I think she sings this really well. Peple who dont' like it just aren't used to the new voice.

  • ffs i can hear this.. this song isnt made for anette she cant sing this song like tarja ! !

  • fà pietà!!! per nn dire schifo""

  • Tarja is gone.. still.. she was the best! but Anette is really doing a good job with the new songs! I like her.. just not for the old songs. she has a good voice.. but i doesn't fit Nemo.

  • Tarja had an opera Voice... Anette has a classical voice.. thus.. old song sound awkward with Anette. But I believe she's awesome in what she does.

  • That is what I've been looking for. Annette having a classical voice. She is great at what she does, though, isn't she? It's as if the writer wrote Tarja's songs FOR Tarja and none other, just like the songs Annette sings are written explicitly for HER to sing. They're made to be directed by her voice, you know?

  • exactly

  • yes yes yes...that's my nightwish...oh....i love them....they are great..more thaN GREAT..!!!!

  • shes to short at some of the word...

  • this song sounds different with anette ...she sings good but I think this song is for Tarja.

  • Stop talking bout Tarja... SHE LEFT THE BAND three, three, three, three YEARS AGO FOR F**K SAKE!!

    this farking tarja talk is getting really booooooooooooorrrrrrrrrrrrrrii­iiiiiiiiinnnnnnnnngggggggggggg­ggggggggggggg

  • I totally! She left as you said, almost 3 years ago, and Anette's been here close to one, so Tarja's not coming back, let's just MOVE ON, people! Appriciate that Nightwish still does good music (they do)

  • she was kicked :D

  • she didnt leave the band, she was fired by tuomas the keyboard player

  • I haven't listened to nemo for a while now and i have to admit that this is Anettes best attempt at nemo so far. I actually enjoyed this clip. :)

    And yes, this is coming from a HUGE Tarja fan.

    Maybe its time some other people stopped judging Anette and just listened to her sing with an open mind.

    I bet less than 50% of you even bought MWS. I did. Love it. Love DPP.

    Just chill out and listen like I did. You won't regret it. :)

  • lets think, if nightwish had started with anette, and change afterwards to tarja, would blackwhite321 say the same? that anette was the best and tarja simply sucked? hmm...

  • The fantards would yell: "wtf is this? get this opera bitch out of here! Nightwish is a metal band, not opera!!!!" with a lot more emotioncons and exclamation marks.

    It's all about the cult of personality, not the voice.

  • This is actually one of Anette's best attempts at Nemo

  • i actually like what anette did with this

    id love to see her to something like over the hills and far away or wish i had an angel

  • And yet you watch the video of her performing and choose to comment on it?

    So good to see that you know how to spell your beloved Tarja's name...

  • huahuha ur so damn!!! thats the best reply ive ever seen so far on youtube! greet man, great video!!!!

  • huahuahua ur the best man!!!!! thats the best reply ive ever seen so far on youtube! compliments man! reat video 5/5 definitely the best anette's attempt of a tarja song...

  • That's pretty pathetic if you ask me. Did you even try to listen to one song?? The Poet and the Pendulum is quite good. Not quite Tarja but nothing like Amaranth.

  • Well... Anette as a Nightwish singer, fine. I can bear that. But only when she sings the new songs. Anette can't sing the old songs, her voice can't be compared to Tarja's. I just don't like it when she thinks that she is as good as Tarja.

  • para anette tendrá ke ser duro cantar canciones de otra y encima sabiendo ke es una super soprano pero hay ke dejar ke cante a su manera las viejas canciones. GREAT ANETTE!

  • no espereis ke anette sea soprano! la nueva version está muy bien. voz grave!! de las ke me gustan!

  • OMFG... she just messed up the chours, that song is to much for her voice, all the old songs are to much for her voice, they most stop playing them.. and keep playing that new pop thing that they are doing now...

  • Tarja is better but this doesn't sucks!

  • wtf

  • too bad as a singer

  • :S

    :S

    :S

  • wtf

  • This is Ridiculous =S She Sucks!!!

  • acho que vou morrer!

    O thoumas está merecendo uma porrada na cabeça...será que ele está surdo?!

    Poe a mulherzinha para cantar as musicas novas...apenas isso...as musicas da epoca da tarja no passado!

    Esssa mulher não canta lirico...

  • wooooah, better than Tarja (sorry Tarja fans... I like her too, but I still like Nightwish)

  • Well, if you expect a non-classical singer to sing like Tarja, who is too different to sing anything else that this kind of music (just look up Tarja´s "smells like teen spirit" video and you´ll be rofl) and not  so good to sing just opera, you must be foolish. It´s all right Anette sings in a different way and I love it. I hope she ignores that rubbish. Anettes is more like a human being than like an ice cube. Put up with it,guys :-)))

  • too many tarjaolics written here.. very bad :( couse anette rocks :) really.. those who don't like anette and don't got a s**t to say other than 'anette sux' and that.. just shut the f**k up and listen to Tarja's numbers!

  • agreed! tarja come back! this girl CANNOT sing

  • Honestly, get a grip. Sure, you can like Tarja more than Anette, that's a matter of taste. But saying that Anette can't sing, is just ridiculous. She can sing very well, but no, she doesn't sing like Tarja. Deal with it.

  • thanks for that comment! I'm just trying to enjoy some nightwish videos without the whole annette versus tarja crap. Fans should just be thankful that the nightwish band itself is still alive!

  • Tarja come back !!!!!!!!

  • yes tarja is better, sorry, i just dont like this girl,

  • "This is me, for forever!" - Anette means it people! Anette is IN!! Tarja is OUT!! XDDDD

  • Anette's awesome live! In my opinion she sings Nemo perfectly :)

  • Anette has a very nice voice. I think it sounds better with the songs intended for her and not the ones Tarja sang.

  • I really hate tarjaholics :S ... I love this video.. and love annetes voice.. is amazing.. obviously is not better than tarja.. but still love her and the way she sings the old nightwish songs.. Nightwish doesn need tarja.. they needed HER VOICE .. just that.. She is an obsessed diva.. and YES there are more sopranos in the hole world but tuomas and the guys WANTED TO MAKE A CHANGE!.. please understand that ... i dont care if you dont like my opinion but is a free world :)

  • Bring Tarjs back!!!Please!!!Anette+Nemo=su­cks

  • Okay sucker.. if you have been reading the lyrics for " Bye Bye Beautiful" you might see what NIGHTWISH says to that shit you are saying

  • Anette is a good vocalist, but she doesn't have the range that Tarja had...she's not right for Nightwish...Tarja indeed couldn't be replaced, so the went in a new direction. As good as some of the material on Dark Passion Play is, Anette isn't right for Nightwish.

  • Why isn't she right for Nightwish? Just because she's not Tarja?

    Tarja is inreplacable, only because there doesn't EXCIST someone else with Tarja's voice.

    You can't replace something what doesn't escist.

  • Get over Tarja... she has turned it to an self-obsessed diva... that's the last thing that Nightwish needs... and for me... I only demand from Anette that she sings the songs with passion and she does that perfectly... so I'm more than happy

  • Exactly. Anette is fantastic.

  • she isn't an opera singer you idiot. She isn't tarja. Nightwish isn't doing these kind of songs anymore. It's true that nobody could replace tarja so they went in another direction, listen to the new album! It rocks!

  • o come on dud she never be like tarja....tarja have that powerful voice who give all the songs that beauty...

  • What's the big deal? She sounds fine to me.

  • I love them!!

  • Annette performed better when I heard her perform this in Cleveland, OH in Oct of 2007. She also did Sleeping Sun, and it wasn't bad for being radically different; she's definitely improving her live performance. I think it's pretty bold that they'd still perform the old songs.

  • Dark Passion Play is awesome!! i can't wait to go to their concert :D

  • ELSKER ELSKER ELSKER nightwish for meget!!!!!!!!!!

  • Hi there!

    As for me, Anette's much better than at first. If you listen to Dark Passion PLay, you know it's fantastic. Her voice in Meadows of Heaven is amazing. She only needs to get used to being on the stage - and she's improving quite fast!!!!!

  • Exactly! And does anybody remember how stupid Tarja looked on stage when Nightwish started out? It takes time to get into something like that!

  • I don't know your problem! her voice is good! don't hold on old things that tight

  • she sounds like shit....lucky i still have the tarja's copy of nemo

  • agreed.

  • BRING BACK TARJA!!!.

    a 5 year old sings better than anette

  • agree.

  • Barf!!! yieks!!! no taste in this shit, bring back Tarja!! OMFG!! NW is dead!

  • Dark Passion Play went double Platinum and you say NW is dead?! dude, get a new set of ears. They sound better now!

  • lol, better? platinum in finland thats logic.

  • Triple platinum. :D actually, more then triple, they sold 100000 copies in Finland. Then, there's platinum in Switzerland and Gold in Sweden, Poland, Austria and Germany. Not to mention the countless chart positions. Or 9th place in the United World Chart. So, I'd say, Nightwish are anything but dead. :)

  • You go dude :D

  • I think Anette's come along way. She's really improving as time goes on.

  • Anette is very good. They definitky did a great choice.

  • i mean voice not song*

  • Not bad, but actually this song is not writen for annette's song and u can hear it actually. but annyway, NW rocks forever!!!

  • wow anette forgot isn't All

    i wish is to dream again" no its "Oh How"

    but its so beautiful anyway

    P.S I WAS THERE AT 1ST LINE YAY

  • its accualy both but the other way around =)

  • i cant stand by!!! COME BACK NIGHTWISH!!!

  • Fan va dålig röst hon har den gammla sångaren var mycket bättre !

  • I think you should be proud that a singer from your country are now the singer in Nightwish,one of the worlds best bands

    And since Nightwish is from Finland,and I live in Finland,I feel honored ;)

  • tarja was a true woman, not a weeping willow, christ.And Annette can blow in birthday candels, no offence

  • i liked tarja more for this song.. why is anette moving like uhr NOT?!? almost standing still all the time.. maybe the clothes are so tight se can't move very well xD i'm very very glad that they still play the old stuff!!

  • Anette does Nemo excellently. Wishmaster is another story. And what are you talking about her not moving around? Tarja used to just stand there like a robot.

  • Tarja used a very much different way off singing, she couldn't run around that much.

  • This version of nemo is good, is very good,

    Anette did a very good job

  • anette has such a great voice! plus the fact that she doesnt look like a man gives her a huge advantage over tarja already

  • cruel, but funny : )

  • i agree too

  • Det var sgu et godt kamera du har der, min version af koncert optagelsen lyder af helvede til, men på den anden side, bare at være der var fedt :D

  • jeg var bare der inde på BACKSTAGE :D

  • heldige pølse :D

  • Anette is good, but not better than Tarja in this song IMO. But Anette is great in songs from Dark Passion Play...

  • Very nice. Do you have the rest of the concert as well? If so, could you upload Wishmaster?

    That was one of the highlights of the evening for me.

  • I'm sorry, I don't. I only captured this one on video, the rest of the time I just enjoyed the show.

  • Fair enough, just thought I'd ask. It was a great concert, thank you for letting me relive a few moments of it.

  • I agree

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more