So a load of you don't want a singer that's not Layne. Well, that's it then: No Alice In Chains. Done. Gone forever.
Is that what you want?
A band is the sum of it's parts; not just one person. They're still playing the songs people want to hear, but you all seem to want that to stop just because they've replaced Layne.
He's gone, but AIC is still here. And you're complaining? WTF?
Hell yeah, they're still here, and not with some bad replacement, this guy sings good. But this is old story it's allways like this, fans allways complaining. I would be happy to see them;)
it's easy for people to watch it on youtube and say 'the singer sucks, it was so much better with layne'. i was at this festival, and they were really good. Yeh its not quite the same, but he is a good singer. Listen to the singers of some other bands live. Also, Layne wasn't the only good member of AIC! the other guys in the band are still there and are still awesome. I really enjoyed their whole set.
I saw them when they played in Sweden at Hultsfredfestivalen. I was also dissapointed in the singer, but hey.. i dont think anyone can replace Layne. I do think that DuValle does a good job and that the band still has fun.
Better an Alice In Chains at the stage touring then just being a memory. Jerry Cantrell rocks like ever before!
That guy's voice is superb, i was at this gig, right down the front, and they were brilliant, the album should be one of this years best,this footage isn't great though, the sound isn't doing the performance any justice
Well if he was as shit as people make out , then band wouldn't keep him around would they. some people just can't accept change, i'm sure you'd be less annoyed if they had changed the name of the band
But i've seen them play with him, the bloke was brilliant, i'm sorry that you don't agree, i'm not going to try and convince you, as you've already made your kind up, so don't buy the album, don't go to the tour, just forget they exhist still, and enjoy the Layne stuff
Layne is the only , el unico que puede trasmitir exactamente el significado de esa cancion.El nuevo vocal es bueno , pero no tiene la personalidad como para llevar el cargo en AIC.
Someone with a creepy, haunting quality to their voice, like Layne had. Duvall lacks that evil, sinister vibe necessary for AIC. Also, it would be nice if the singer had a powerful scream. Duvall struggles on any AIC tune that had screamy-vocals in it. When Duvall screams, he sounds like he's dying of constipation.
I don't care if Duvall is a "good guy". That's not the issue here. My 98-year old grandfather is a good guy, too, but I don't think he should be the lead singer of AIC.
who ever this pubic haired singer is, he sucks balls, he is fucking up AIC legacy, they sould be ashame of each other, this is fucking horrible. Go fuck yourselves.
I fucking met DuVall. He is a great guy. I watched him sing with Alice LIVE FROM SIDESTAGE AND MET ALL OF THEM. He doesn't suck. You're just pissed because Layne is dead. Get over it.
Duvall does not suck. You haters just don't like him singing Layne's stuff. When they release a new CD, with new songs, then you can make a more acurate judgement.
And you my friend were probably never an Alice fan in the first place. What are you going to do when they come through your town? Drink hot chocolate with the old folks?
Ya no, I saw these guys live and Duvall did amazing. He almost sounded exactly like Lanye. Layne was the greatest... Ever. But the fact is that Layne is gone and Duvall is a great replacement. R.I.P. Layne.
Layne was an awesome singer but his demons brought the band down. Drug addiction is an extremely selfish and evil disease. AIC barely even played a live show after 1993 because of it. They had to drag Layne kicking and screaming to contribute on Tripod and Unplugged.
Though this song sounds weird without Layne, AIC had to move on sooner or later.
all i can say is it just dont work when layne sang down in a hole it was powerful stuff coz he was. the new guy has been in a few holes but just for digging reasons r.i.p layne
Everyone saying that Alice shouldn't be touring anymore, and that Will isn't Layne need to stop their crying: No one's saying Will is Layne. I will be the first to agree that the songs were better with Layne at the helm, and that it was his voice that gave them such power and emotion; but Jerry wrote ALMOST ALL the music (INCLUDING LYRICS) that Alice is popular for. It's much more his than Layne's, and he has every right to play again.
Alice was something very special with Layne Staley. He was a fantastic singer (one of the best of all time in my opinion), and a super cool guy; but he decided that drugs were his path, and they did to him what was expected of them. This isn't the bands fault.. if the guys want to play songs that they wrote, all the power to them. Jerry Cantrell is amazing: I wish I could see him with Layne, but this can no longer be a reality, so we make due.
Dave and Krist didn't try to reform Nirvana because Kurt wrote all the music, played guitar, and sang. To compare: Layne didn't write the music, he didn't play guitar, and he split lyric duty with Jerry. THAT, is why you can't compare a Nirvana reunion to an Alice one. If you can't accept the fact that the music is Jerry's and he has the right to play it, don't watch/listen to it. Will is no Layne of course, but we make due. Please stop crying! (Seeing them with Velvet Revolver Sept 7th)
This is blasphamy. I agree with one comment your so use to hearing Layne's voice follow Jerry's. It sucks so bad that Layne is gone. It makes you wonder if Jerry was going broke or something or he knows his solo career was hitting the shitter and he know Alice In Chains rakes in the money. I dunno but everytime I hear this new singer I hate him even more.YOU DONT REPLACE A GIFT LIKE LAYNE STALEY WAS TO EVERYONE!
I guess its so hard because Jerry is still Jerry and sounds the exact same. So your expecting Lane's voice to follow after it, but instead you get this, imo, terrible voice. Really wish they'd at least try and find someone to replace the current singer. Hell, I'd replace 'em if they gave me the chance.
hes... ok. this is one of the few times hes sounded ok. he blew man in the box, in my opinion. for everyone comparing him to layne, i understand, but layne was the only person with laynes voice, and he cant sing anymore. yeah, they could have done better picking, but at least theyre playing live. id see them (of course for jerry). this guy being in alice is like eddie vedder singing with queensryche though...
I'm glad they decided to start touring again. Layne's dead and all the fans and myself will miss him forever but people shud be grateful the others reformed to show a new generation of kids how good AIC are
Dude, they should have just left well enough alone. Looked back on the music sung by Layne. When Kurt Cobain died you didn't see Grohl and Novoselic trying to find another Kurt to take his place. They made compilations of his music and both went on in their music careers successfully. Cantrell should try something else. Not to revive AIC. It can't be done and it shouldn't be done.
I was there for that, and it doesnt matter that it's not Layne, no-one will ever replace him yeah that's obvious, but the guy singing did an awesome job and it was one of the highlights of the festival.
They really need to get away from playing the old songs. "Mr. Duvall" shouldn't be singing this. We're not fooled here. AIC of old is dead. Let's see something new, maybe something "Mr. Duvall" brings that is his own....
mr duvall has an inredible voice... the band could have picked anyone in the world and wouldnt have found a replacement for layne (because there isnt). I know that william is aware of this, but regardless, he sings the songs beautifully and i believe he does the songs justice. now, people who bash him for not being layne staley need shut the fuck up. he's not trying to replace layne, just trying to keep his memory/music alive.
Jerry wrote this song about a relationship he was in it wasnt specifically laynes. i was at download it was amazing williams does do the songs justice
mm just not the same at all. not the same emotion this is laynes song not williams i really think he needs to stop singing laynes songs. this song is laynes deep emotions not meant to be sung by a new singer
William has been singing AIC songs and backing Jerry for several tours now. He does his own great versions of these songs. I'm not sure what so many people have against him. This is the only way you're going to hear these songs live again. The crowd doesn't seem to mind. For those who say this is disrespectful to Layne, the band says the whole purpose of reforming is to celebrate the music and their departed friend. best, matt
All the good ones have to die..so sad :(
ncsweetpea 5 months ago
Phil Anselmo on stage ?
Feedek 5 months ago
Loving Phil Anselmo getting his groove on in the background......
thumbelina24 1 year ago 3
@thumbelina24 haha true, thats phil behind those marshall towers
average0citizen 1 year ago
So a load of you don't want a singer that's not Layne. Well, that's it then: No Alice In Chains. Done. Gone forever.
Is that what you want?
A band is the sum of it's parts; not just one person. They're still playing the songs people want to hear, but you all seem to want that to stop just because they've replaced Layne.
He's gone, but AIC is still here. And you're complaining? WTF?
HarryMuffUk 1 year ago
@HarryMuffUk
Hell yeah, they're still here, and not with some bad replacement, this guy sings good. But this is old story it's allways like this, fans allways complaining. I would be happy to see them;)
black16v 1 year ago
it's easy for people to watch it on youtube and say 'the singer sucks, it was so much better with layne'. i was at this festival, and they were really good. Yeh its not quite the same, but he is a good singer. Listen to the singers of some other bands live. Also, Layne wasn't the only good member of AIC! the other guys in the band are still there and are still awesome. I really enjoyed their whole set.
pazzmodium 1 year ago
without Layne it's not the same...
like Mike Star said "When Layne died Alice in Chains stay without Alice the band should be call Jerry Cantrell and Friends..."
Layne We miss you thanks for all..
I Remenber you always with your music...
regards from Venezuela
LUISPERCAK 1 year ago
I saw them when they played in Sweden at Hultsfredfestivalen. I was also dissapointed in the singer, but hey.. i dont think anyone can replace Layne. I do think that DuValle does a good job and that the band still has fun.
Better an Alice In Chains at the stage touring then just being a memory. Jerry Cantrell rocks like ever before!
CrazySheriff 2 years ago 4
That guy's voice is superb, i was at this gig, right down the front, and they were brilliant, the album should be one of this years best,this footage isn't great though, the sound isn't doing the performance any justice
ANDREWHALL28 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Well, the sound must be off on every Duvall in Chains video cuz he always sounds like shit.
deadviolets 2 years ago
Well if he was as shit as people make out , then band wouldn't keep him around would they. some people just can't accept change, i'm sure you'd be less annoyed if they had changed the name of the band
ANDREWHALL28 2 years ago 3
Keep the name, if they must, but find a great singer. Alice is a world class band...they deserve a world class singer.
deadviolets 2 years ago
But i've seen them play with him, the bloke was brilliant, i'm sorry that you don't agree, i'm not going to try and convince you, as you've already made your kind up, so don't buy the album, don't go to the tour, just forget they exhist still, and enjoy the Layne stuff
ANDREWHALL28 2 years ago 3
Well put, if you dislike DuVall stop listening to the new shit, but please stop trying to bash on him, we get the point.
Drumbuff 2 years ago
What the hell. I"m glad they're still trying but almost anyone would be a better choice than William DuValle
guitarkiller8969 2 years ago
Seconded.
Cradlestoner 2 years ago
there is something about Duvall that screams jackass.
nedak 2 years ago
Really bad. Jerry, you should've quit while you were ahead.
jkplpt13 2 years ago
a good song .. a good band ..
laynecool 3 years ago
Layne is the only , el unico que puede trasmitir exactamente el significado de esa cancion.El nuevo vocal es bueno , pero no tiene la personalidad como para llevar el cargo en AIC.
SoulOnFire7 3 years ago
I used to think will duvall was allright considering no one will ever sound as good as layne..... he murdered this song
splashmaster0 3 years ago 2
they should name their "new" group Chester the Molestor in handcuffs, cause they freakin molested this song.
ssgdigital 3 years ago
haha !
Cradlestoner 2 years ago
horrible performnce, comparatively.shit
heavybarz 3 years ago
il nuovo singer, oltre ad essere stonato come una campana, ha una presenza scenica ridicola...
gordianknot76 3 years ago
It's sad to see a great band turn into a third-rate, money-grubbing carnival act.
They couldn't even find a good singer. Or care to actually look for one.
Instead, we get this guy, with all of two octaves and a permanent frog in his throat.
I hope the money's worth it to you, Jerry.
devilcatgirl 3 years ago
yeah, i don't like duvall either, and even with the bad quality sound, he did sound good on this song.
and i dont think jerry is doing this for the money, alice in chains was one of those bands who cared more for the music, not for the money.
and their not a carnival act! wasn't this the download fest? your an asshole! you don't know what your talking about
Evanator45yK 3 years ago
idiot
rockincoffee 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this was a GREAT performance, he soudned exactly like layne!! unreal!
megafcukphil1 3 years ago
yeah there you've got a point
but then who you thought should be the singer of AIC?
BartCobain94 3 years ago
Someone with a creepy, haunting quality to their voice, like Layne had. Duvall lacks that evil, sinister vibe necessary for AIC. Also, it would be nice if the singer had a powerful scream. Duvall struggles on any AIC tune that had screamy-vocals in it. When Duvall screams, he sounds like he's dying of constipation.
deadviolets 3 years ago 4
aah come on
he's a very good singer
BartCobain94 3 years ago
Celine Dion is a great singer, but I don't want her singing AIC, either. It's more than just hitting notes.
deadviolets 3 years ago 7
@deadviolets We don't give a shit who you want singing AIC. Duvall was hand picked by Cantrell. You can go die...I'll enjoy AIC with Duvall. FUCK YOU
jb0Ogi3 1 year ago 2
Duvall is a good guy
and he's a good singer
haters are just fucking screwed up assholes.
I think layne is proud that AIC still excist!
BartCobain94 3 years ago 2
I don't care if Duvall is a "good guy". That's not the issue here. My 98-year old grandfather is a good guy, too, but I don't think he should be the lead singer of AIC.
deadviolets 3 years ago 3
who ever this pubic haired singer is, he sucks balls, he is fucking up AIC legacy, they sould be ashame of each other, this is fucking horrible. Go fuck yourselves.
afoolisharrangement 3 years ago
I fucking met DuVall. He is a great guy. I watched him sing with Alice LIVE FROM SIDESTAGE AND MET ALL OF THEM. He doesn't suck. You're just pissed because Layne is dead. Get over it.
Headbanger270 3 years ago
i was there. i thought this william guy isnt layne. they wont pull it off.. and you know what?
they fucking nailed it.
beautifully
mimirodjers 3 years ago 3
wen they played this in dublin everyone was singing it looking up to the sky and everyone was tearing up this song is beautiful
spudsucker 3 years ago
Duvall does not suck. You haters just don't like him singing Layne's stuff. When they release a new CD, with new songs, then you can make a more acurate judgement.
waverider038 3 years ago 3
when the new album does drop, the real feeding frenzy will begin. you'd better get your asbestos underwear ready..
deadviolets 3 years ago 3
And you my friend were probably never an Alice fan in the first place. What are you going to do when they come through your town? Drink hot chocolate with the old folks?
waverider038 3 years ago
i hate to break it to you, but the guys in aic ARE the old folks.
deadviolets 3 years ago
Just think, if more of us had bought Jerry's solo albums none of this mockery would be going on right now.
deadviolets 3 years ago 3
this fucker hurt in the ears... Then makes a poor imitation of Layne? ~_~ all this is for money and that sucks
OtherEdgar 4 years ago
if this was a cash grabthey wouldnt have duvall up there singing. they would have a layne-a-like up there
bigevil3x3 3 years ago
if u look closely near the drum set, ull see Phil Anselmo and Rex Brown
Hellrising75 4 years ago
I was there and the man is a fitting tribute to Layne.
captainpleasure 4 years ago
this guy doesn't sing bad, but it's not the same without Layne
R.I.P. Layne
Dinopaterno22 4 years ago 5
simply because layne is ireplacesable...
nativetongue00 4 years ago 8
i guess its better than nothin...
trenis 4 years ago
Was right at the front, fucking epic show!
mmmmathe 4 years ago
this guy ssux.....go home
nofukenway 4 years ago
this guy is pretty good! come to the uk guys! would love to hear these songs live as i was too young to see layne, makes me sad.
fckrocknroll 4 years ago
ver very good vocal...layne is gone...was the best..but this guy is very good
skukavi7 4 years ago
Layne cannot be replaced... Definetely...
rasanbg 4 years ago 5
Ya no, I saw these guys live and Duvall did amazing. He almost sounded exactly like Lanye. Layne was the greatest... Ever. But the fact is that Layne is gone and Duvall is a great replacement. R.I.P. Layne.
92Pinhead 4 years ago
I swear i would be a better singer for them than that lenny kravitz guy
sagebuzz 4 years ago 5
barely can say: miss layne.. hell
SABOSNAKE3 4 years ago
Layne was an awesome singer but his demons brought the band down. Drug addiction is an extremely selfish and evil disease. AIC barely even played a live show after 1993 because of it. They had to drag Layne kicking and screaming to contribute on Tripod and Unplugged.
Though this song sounds weird without Layne, AIC had to move on sooner or later.
DerekJeter 4 years ago
Alice In Chains boy...Miss Layne, but I am glad they are keeping his soul alive by performing..See you fokes Aug.20th
kevinAIC33 4 years ago
all i can say is it just dont work when layne sang down in a hole it was powerful stuff coz he was. the new guy has been in a few holes but just for digging reasons r.i.p layne
undrerdog 4 years ago
(Posted in 3 parts)
Everyone saying that Alice shouldn't be touring anymore, and that Will isn't Layne need to stop their crying: No one's saying Will is Layne. I will be the first to agree that the songs were better with Layne at the helm, and that it was his voice that gave them such power and emotion; but Jerry wrote ALMOST ALL the music (INCLUDING LYRICS) that Alice is popular for. It's much more his than Layne's, and he has every right to play again.
tcsMish 4 years ago
Alice was something very special with Layne Staley. He was a fantastic singer (one of the best of all time in my opinion), and a super cool guy; but he decided that drugs were his path, and they did to him what was expected of them. This isn't the bands fault.. if the guys want to play songs that they wrote, all the power to them. Jerry Cantrell is amazing: I wish I could see him with Layne, but this can no longer be a reality, so we make due.
tcsMish 4 years ago
Dave and Krist didn't try to reform Nirvana because Kurt wrote all the music, played guitar, and sang. To compare: Layne didn't write the music, he didn't play guitar, and he split lyric duty with Jerry. THAT, is why you can't compare a Nirvana reunion to an Alice one. If you can't accept the fact that the music is Jerry's and he has the right to play it, don't watch/listen to it. Will is no Layne of course, but we make due. Please stop crying! (Seeing them with Velvet Revolver Sept 7th)
tcsMish 4 years ago
This is blasphamy. I agree with one comment your so use to hearing Layne's voice follow Jerry's. It sucks so bad that Layne is gone. It makes you wonder if Jerry was going broke or something or he knows his solo career was hitting the shitter and he know Alice In Chains rakes in the money. I dunno but everytime I hear this new singer I hate him even more.YOU DONT REPLACE A GIFT LIKE LAYNE STALEY WAS TO EVERYONE!
LateralisUndertow 4 years ago
i agree whole heartedly. At least they could find a singer that sounded more like Layne instead of this off key dumbass.
BloodRavyne 4 years ago
I guess its so hard because Jerry is still Jerry and sounds the exact same. So your expecting Lane's voice to follow after it, but instead you get this, imo, terrible voice. Really wish they'd at least try and find someone to replace the current singer. Hell, I'd replace 'em if they gave me the chance.
MikeTeleto 4 years ago 2
He doesn't even sing it the same way as Layne. Sucks.
kaylahashbarger 4 years ago
omg, no he fucked up the song.
layne is irreplaceable
ticallionstallion316 4 years ago
without Layne this is only a cover of the real and legendary alice in chains, i miss Layne and Kurt, rest in peace my old friends.
bolonio1 4 years ago
No one has a voice layne!!!He's voice was so biutiful.
It's sad that he can't sing anymore XC
AstoriaTrooper 4 years ago
doesnt sound de same witout layne staley(especially dis song), in my opinion its not reall alice in chains witout him
coxy2u 4 years ago
hes... ok. this is one of the few times hes sounded ok. he blew man in the box, in my opinion. for everyone comparing him to layne, i understand, but layne was the only person with laynes voice, and he cant sing anymore. yeah, they could have done better picking, but at least theyre playing live. id see them (of course for jerry). this guy being in alice is like eddie vedder singing with queensryche though...
superpikle 4 years ago
When Bon Scott died, AC/DC went on...better than ever. When Cliff Burton died, Metallica struggled gamely on. Hopefully AIC will continue to grow.
brnleague99 4 years ago
I'm glad they decided to start touring again. Layne's dead and all the fans and myself will miss him forever but people shud be grateful the others reformed to show a new generation of kids how good AIC are
Verve20 4 years ago
Dude, they should have just left well enough alone. Looked back on the music sung by Layne. When Kurt Cobain died you didn't see Grohl and Novoselic trying to find another Kurt to take his place. They made compilations of his music and both went on in their music careers successfully. Cantrell should try something else. Not to revive AIC. It can't be done and it shouldn't be done.
kaylahashbarger 4 years ago
layne miss u this is crap sry
kurtcobainwillcome 4 years ago
Without Layne, it means nothing.
obiwon76 4 years ago
hes no replacement for layne
ATS1987 4 years ago
If you have a look near the amplifiers, you can see Phil Anselmo from Pantera there.
DanakaPUCK 4 years ago
I was there! I was near the front!
DanakaPUCK 4 years ago
I was there for that, and it doesnt matter that it's not Layne, no-one will ever replace him yeah that's obvious, but the guy singing did an awesome job and it was one of the highlights of the festival.
Niiikh23 4 years ago
good singer, but i still don't like him
Anthellios 4 years ago
OmgzErica and mikeh should be sure they know what they're talking about before they speak
drinkthewine 4 years ago
i dont think that anyone can replace LAYNE
s1matt 4 years ago
It was over 30 degs that day, but when they play this I got chills. Totally awesome thanks for sharing :-)
FlutterGrrrl 4 years ago
who is the singer
waiyang07 4 years ago
Google for a band called: "comes with the fall" . Its him =)
orangeedo 4 years ago
They really need to get away from playing the old songs. "Mr. Duvall" shouldn't be singing this. We're not fooled here. AIC of old is dead. Let's see something new, maybe something "Mr. Duvall" brings that is his own....
mikeh68 4 years ago
mr duvall has an inredible voice... the band could have picked anyone in the world and wouldnt have found a replacement for layne (because there isnt). I know that william is aware of this, but regardless, he sings the songs beautifully and i believe he does the songs justice. now, people who bash him for not being layne staley need shut the fuck up. he's not trying to replace layne, just trying to keep his memory/music alive.
ComaDivine313 5 years ago
Jerry wrote this song about a relationship he was in it wasnt specifically laynes. i was at download it was amazing williams does do the songs justice
softwhiteglow 5 years ago
Ya'll need to know that this was a tribute tour. No one was replacing layne.
Stantrell 5 years ago
mm just not the same at all. not the same emotion this is laynes song not williams i really think he needs to stop singing laynes songs. this song is laynes deep emotions not meant to be sung by a new singer
OmgzErica 5 years ago
shut the fuck up u cunt!!!!
theroosterisme 5 years ago
William has been singing AIC songs and backing Jerry for several tours now. He does his own great versions of these songs. I'm not sure what so many people have against him. This is the only way you're going to hear these songs live again. The crowd doesn't seem to mind. For those who say this is disrespectful to Layne, the band says the whole purpose of reforming is to celebrate the music and their departed friend. best, matt
dylanmoderntimes 5 years ago
either jerry couldnt find a singer like layne or he didnt want one
shawnmcnair1 5 years ago
of course its not gna sound the same fool
metalslug 5 years ago
eh it doesnt sound the same as back in the day with Layne....Jerry and the guys are still right on though.
fullmetalscar 5 years ago