If he is as drunk as people are saying he is, this cover is pure brilliance, he is playing 2 instruments and singing, and for those who don't know that takes an incredible amount of ability.
AMAZING COVER! I'm a John Fru fan, so I know I'm biased, but you have to know that all the songs John performed this night weren't the best performances. He was drunk as a skunk like the rest of the crowd and this wasn't a planned show or anything. Most of the songs he played weren't recorded on album yet and the covers he did he obviously didn't "tour practice" for them if you know what i mean... Anyways this was a GREAT cover and truly unique touch to the original! Gracias Johnny...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I know if you cover iconic songs you take flak but this is .........wrong on every level. Did Someone from JD abuse him when he was a kid ? I have sung this song,this badly but I was 19, drunk,in my bedroom and I put the dog in the garden. If you know this guy, play him Travis doing Britney at Glastonbury. That, at least made me laugh.
He covering Joy Division is a bit like Radiohead covering Portishead just with greater amounts of energy. It is like the two greatest artistic acts by anything EVER coming together. There you can see, oh, john frusciante had his incredible knowledge about music from somewhere and got than further in that... when you think new dawn fades is a sad and beautiful energy at the same time... than check out Untitled 12 by this man and you see what even exaggerates that aspect to the fullest degree
@ husikamravedojo and Mooktopia: dudes, the red hot chili peppers cant touch joy division. thats quite right. but john fucking frusciante can easily. he is exactly the only artist of the universe who recorded even more powerful music than joy division so fucking shut up with your fucking stupid stereotypingcommenting. ian curtis would feel glad about this. you dont even deserve to listen to the last three songs of closer. you are the kind of guys that turn the album off from there onwards o_O
@srrdmalak Joy Division were poignant and touching, RHCP are petty and emotionally devoid, in my personal opinion. This cover wasn't terrible, but it wasn't anywhere NEAR Joy Division live.
every john-fan should check out Joy Division. I went the way like most of you did with being obsessed with the Peppers, than John and let me tell you. Joy Division beats the Peppers anyday. They touch you in a way John does. If you liked Johns early work you are in for a great surprise at that band ;)
@added23 sorry for hanging out a bit too much that bullshit-i-listen-to-way-cooler-music-you-guys-do ;) my fan-me had me there for a while. but anyways, it is obvious that there is aesthetic in music. you can call it beauty. and everybody as artist has their own kind of nature where he is coming from and in this nature some go as far as john frusciante and some others lets pick on justin bieber they are not trying a whole lot in music. they are presenting a fake image. id call them less good.
Not bad although /watch?v=O3OPzOx3kkg is way better, nearly perfect even, better vocals more consitant playing, overall a better performance then this song, i think he was really tired here.
well he does have a band, in case u haven't noticed. plus thats clearly not what frusciante's about if u listen to californication. what do you listen to? GN'R?
I'm a big JF fan. He's one of the best 'feel' guitarists in the world. But to be fair, this is pretty naff. To play what should be 3 guitar parts at once, live on an acoustic and sing is just too tall an order.
I'm also a big Joy Division fan and believe me, they were (musically)abysmal playing live most of the time. JD's & JF's live NDF are probably on a par.
But JD's studio recorded 'NDF' is a masterclass in how to express mood through music. No cover version yet has even come close.
Have you heard the Les Bains Douches live JD album? It's raw, fast and intense. Sure they weren't the greatest musicians but goddamn their albums are killer.
Yeah, I'm listening to it now. I was in a band in Manchester in 1983-85 and we did covers of New Dawn Fades, Shadowplay and Transmission. To be honest though I didn't think anyone outside of UK had even heared about JD. I was shocked when I looked on YouTube to see all kinds of famous musicians doing New Dawn Fades and Shadowplay. Good 2 C JD getting the recognition they deserve.
i would like to see all of you who are saying that john cant play, i would like to see how you play this song... assholes, just listen to the man and his music, enjoy, and if you cant just go away, nobody cares what you think...
Yeah, I know just what you mean : he sucks, he's tryna look cute, but what's really comin' is John Frusciante selling cookies door to door with the Boy Scouts of America.
They - all of them - should stop doing covers of New Dawn Fades, because they always fuck it up and - I suppose that's the whole point - in the fucking up process the meaning of NDF goes into the sewer. Especially :
Oh, so you left when Johnny Boy plays guitar vertically (gee, why, I wonder...).
Well, then you missed the bit when is screaming like a strangled chicken. Very artistic, very deeply felt, very moving ! It's just like the real thing. Just so.
(How on earth the fucking message got up there ? Pfff, heck...).
Oh, so you left when Johnny Boy plays guitar vertically (gee, why, I wonder...).
Well, then you missed the bit when is screaming like a strangled chicken. Very artistic, very deeply felt, very moving ! It's just like the real thing. Just so.
Watch his other performance of this, I love this one but the other John is really on top of his game.
aigmeyer 2 months ago
i love this man
musicgetsmehigh1989 11 months ago
at least he puts some emotion into it....even if he is is off his dial.
amazing to see the americans influenced by JD..if they made that plane they would've killed it over there...oh well.
joydivisionboy1 1 year ago 3
@joydivisionboy1 ....and here we sat on the tarmac, waiting for the plane to come.
painxtreme 1 month ago
I don't care if he was drunk. Most of use (myself included) couldn't play nearly this well stone-cold sober.
Very well done cover!
socialbenthos 1 year ago
John drunk? There are some dumb human beeings around.
ThePsergo 1 year ago
Purely excellence. Nothing can de-value this performance. This is a master at work.
danjama 1 year ago
If he is as drunk as people are saying he is, this cover is pure brilliance, he is playing 2 instruments and singing, and for those who don't know that takes an incredible amount of ability.
pricey4700 1 year ago
it´s so easy to see that he´s drunken
Janibreu96 1 year ago
AMAZING COVER! I'm a John Fru fan, so I know I'm biased, but you have to know that all the songs John performed this night weren't the best performances. He was drunk as a skunk like the rest of the crowd and this wasn't a planned show or anything. Most of the songs he played weren't recorded on album yet and the covers he did he obviously didn't "tour practice" for them if you know what i mean... Anyways this was a GREAT cover and truly unique touch to the original! Gracias Johnny...
tubeyoulube 1 year ago
done with feeling.
Fair play. As a Joy Division fan i enjoyed ! cheers John.
JIFFBAG 1 year ago 4
Well, anyone should be allowed to have a go at performing great songs like these IMO.
The real culprit, of course, is the person who posted this video ;-)
umfriend 1 year ago
Oh no.
karaloca 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I know if you cover iconic songs you take flak but this is .........wrong on every level. Did Someone from JD abuse him when he was a kid ? I have sung this song,this badly but I was 19, drunk,in my bedroom and I put the dog in the garden. If you know this guy, play him Travis doing Britney at Glastonbury. That, at least made me laugh.
theMacvarish 2 years ago
@theMacvarish damn you must have no soul or feel for music
funkit22 1 year ago 2
hahahahahahahaa! that was horrible i had to watch it again
EECIEI 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2:27 totally disgusting! His try to sound emotional ends up like the abhorrent bawling of a drunken fat hooligan.
And this fuckin' "YEEAAHA" - unforgiveable. Does he think he's gotta "rock" or something?
WHAT DID IAN EVER DO TO YOU TO MAKE YOU RAPE AND MESS UP THIS SONG LIKE THIS? HOW COULD YOU? HOW?
YOU FUCKED UP ONE OF THE GREATEST SONGS EVER WRITTEN!
Just give me thumbs down or reply if you agree.
Now I really gotta get some terpentine and a brush to scrub my ears.
FischermannsFreund86 2 years ago
He covering Joy Division is a bit like Radiohead covering Portishead just with greater amounts of energy. It is like the two greatest artistic acts by anything EVER coming together. There you can see, oh, john frusciante had his incredible knowledge about music from somewhere and got than further in that... when you think new dawn fades is a sad and beautiful energy at the same time... than check out Untitled 12 by this man and you see what even exaggerates that aspect to the fullest degree
checkoutniandra 2 years ago
@FischermannsFreund86 Thats a rly gd point
you cnt even attempt to play this song and get it anywhere near as gd as the original.
smithdj12 2 years ago
@FischermannsFreund86 you're an idiot.
danjama 1 year ago
a shame!
Ponpelino 2 years ago
Awesome!!
funkit22 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
me no likey
EECIEI 2 years ago
dont really understand why all the thumbs down for EECIEI , he didnt say anything offensive, he just didnt like it =)
sirdarkmion 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
epic gay
chaincells 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rhcp couldnt touch joy division in a million years and i think this cover is fuckin wank , fuck you
husikamravedojo 2 years ago
@husikamravedojo fucking agreed
Mooktopia 2 years ago
@ husikamravedojo and Mooktopia: dudes, the red hot chili peppers cant touch joy division. thats quite right. but john fucking frusciante can easily. he is exactly the only artist of the universe who recorded even more powerful music than joy division so fucking shut up with your fucking stupid stereotypingcommenting. ian curtis would feel glad about this. you dont even deserve to listen to the last three songs of closer. you are the kind of guys that turn the album off from there onwards o_O
checkoutniandra 2 years ago
@husikamravedojo please elaborate on this. tell me why. (rhcp couldnt touch joy division)
srrdmalak 1 year ago
@srrdmalak Joy Division were poignant and touching, RHCP are petty and emotionally devoid, in my personal opinion. This cover wasn't terrible, but it wasn't anywhere NEAR Joy Division live.
SirPwn4lot 1 year ago
this song is not garbarge i think this is a pretty sweet song.. he does seem tired just from watching this video.
esosa85 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
garbage
MrPropain 2 years ago
because it isn't the original?
RHCPh4x 2 years ago
JOYY DIVISION!!!
check out the videos of john, flea and josh klinghoffer - a joy division cover band called still
so so good
reads006 2 years ago
every john-fan should check out Joy Division. I went the way like most of you did with being obsessed with the Peppers, than John and let me tell you. Joy Division beats the Peppers anyday. They touch you in a way John does. If you liked Johns early work you are in for a great surprise at that band ;)
checkoutniandra 2 years ago 2
please dont even compare rhcp and joy division.. but i agree, joy division can depress you to a really high level
moloko89 2 years ago
@checkoutniandra music isnt a competition fagget.
added23 1 year ago
@added23 sorry for hanging out a bit too much that bullshit-i-listen-to-way-cooler-music-you-guys-do ;) my fan-me had me there for a while. but anyways, it is obvious that there is aesthetic in music. you can call it beauty. and everybody as artist has their own kind of nature where he is coming from and in this nature some go as far as john frusciante and some others lets pick on justin bieber they are not trying a whole lot in music. they are presenting a fake image. id call them less good.
checkoutniandra 1 year ago
Not bad although /watch?v=O3OPzOx3kkg is way better, nearly perfect even, better vocals more consitant playing, overall a better performance then this song, i think he was really tired here.
Leander0Fl0 2 years ago
i don't think it's pathetic. it's an original interpretation. of course the JD song has an incredible feeling but that's not that bad.
giupio88 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this performance is just pathetic compared to the original.
darcyw014 2 years ago
It's epic... I love this
pudgywudgy 2 years ago
yep...
MachinaEYE 2 years ago
John is great...
edsonfariade 3 years ago 2
This guy changed my life, he's the greatest! I like Joy Division too! And I did a (kind of) cover of this song
XguitarrockerX 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Typical guitard. "Who needs a band when there's ME?!"
skipp0023 3 years ago
well he does have a band, in case u haven't noticed. plus thats clearly not what frusciante's about if u listen to californication. what do you listen to? GN'R?
ChimpDotCom 3 years ago
really really not interesting...plus so many singers covered this song, but there's no cover that is actually interesting.
EmotionBleuPetrole 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WTF?
He really sucks, when he's covering this great song ;/.
Frusciante and Joy Division? No way ;/.
mari006 3 years ago
@mari006 Totally agree!
FischermannsFreund86 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is so lame. frusciante should stick with his own stuff.
itchyweasel62 3 years ago
not lame at all...he is playing the bass and the guitar from the original..its marvelous
hueldereich 3 years ago 29
fuckin ell he is an all thats some good shit right there
jaytotale 3 years ago
I'm a big JF fan. He's one of the best 'feel' guitarists in the world. But to be fair, this is pretty naff. To play what should be 3 guitar parts at once, live on an acoustic and sing is just too tall an order.
I'm also a big Joy Division fan and believe me, they were (musically)abysmal playing live most of the time. JD's & JF's live NDF are probably on a par.
But JD's studio recorded 'NDF' is a masterclass in how to express mood through music. No cover version yet has even come close.
AKAKArnott 3 years ago
Have you heard the Les Bains Douches live JD album? It's raw, fast and intense. Sure they weren't the greatest musicians but goddamn their albums are killer.
Samuel500 3 years ago
Yeah, I'm listening to it now. I was in a band in Manchester in 1983-85 and we did covers of New Dawn Fades, Shadowplay and Transmission. To be honest though I didn't think anyone outside of UK had even heared about JD. I was shocked when I looked on YouTube to see all kinds of famous musicians doing New Dawn Fades and Shadowplay. Good 2 C JD getting the recognition they deserve.
AKAKArnott 3 years ago
They were very good musicians.
frenchkids 2 years ago
Best performnce to this difficult song ever.
HerrvonFreizeit 3 years ago
wow. the vocals are pretty bad
hendrixfan143 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This guy really sucks
jorikcle 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i agree.
FallenCrimsonTears 3 years ago
thank you:)
jorikcle 3 years ago
just because YOUR ignorant and YOU can't appreciate this doesn't mean YOU have the right to bash him.
can you arrange three guitars?
my guess is not.
go suck a cock, eat shit and die.
peace love and empathy
littlexSTRUMMERxboy 3 years ago
i would like to see all of you who are saying that john cant play, i would like to see how you play this song... assholes, just listen to the man and his music, enjoy, and if you cant just go away, nobody cares what you think...
nikolicadj 3 years ago
its not his music joy division wrote the song.
FallenCrimsonTears 3 years ago
If comparing, I dont think he can cover the 4 parts with his guitar and voice, but the energy is still there..
ChubbyGibbons 3 years ago
I love how he does this song.
DesecrationSmile2012 3 years ago
Amazinggg voicee I must say.. May not sound as good as the real thing, but still :) :) Gooood cover
cytospaz 3 years ago
why cant you all just listen to the song, without being complete retards.
ButtFlutee 3 years ago 18
it would have been sooo much cooler and more of a statement if it was acapella
coldhandmurr 3 years ago
ur right, this is crap... he cant play guitar. he made some mistakes. Even I could hear that!
dikbick 3 years ago
"he can't play guitar"
you suck man
EasyBoys91 3 years ago 2
O I dindt know, thnks.... u suck John 2 much dude...
SanderBouwhuis 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this cover is so much better than the original,
he makes it feel the same but with so much more power.
jf cant play?
wtf are u on about
i addimit this performance is slightly slopey
but look at him, he would have been playing for ages that night, the poor mans going to be tired.
he is an amazing guitarist, im sorry if u feel different
suademember 3 years ago
You're a pottymouth :-)
inanenvelope 3 years ago
It's "you're". However, no matter how many names you call, the song was still ruined by this twat.
Julius314159 3 years ago
Jump off the cliff or something RJ. you're hopeless
notsokoolaid56 3 years ago
Kaka. 'nuff said. :-)
inanenvelope 3 years ago
The twat must have thought we would enjoy bleeding from the ears. Odd.
I was gonna say somethin' cute to our 2 Frush fans, but they've already called themselves 12cockready and justsocute.
Hi J., how was your cliff-jumping, nice or what ? Better than a Frush solo, I bet :-)
Now, If you will excuse me, I have smoking and fucking in the head to do. Anything, but Frush covering Joy D :-)
inanenvelope 3 years ago
inanenvelope, you just need to lay off whatever you're smoking because you are fucked in the head... enough said
notsokoolaid56 3 years ago 2
Yeah, I know just what you mean : he sucks, he's tryna look cute, but what's really comin' is John Frusciante selling cookies door to door with the Boy Scouts of America.
They - all of them - should stop doing covers of New Dawn Fades, because they always fuck it up and - I suppose that's the whole point - in the fucking up process the meaning of NDF goes into the sewer. Especially :
" Can't seem to feel it anymore.
It was me, waiting for me,
Hoping for something more. "
Just too relevant.
inanenvelope 3 years ago
LOL Nice.
Julius314159 3 years ago
Wish he would go back on smack and off himself.
Julius314159 3 years ago
what a terrible thing to say, seriously.
skubz 3 years ago
What a fucking mumbler! Way to ruin a great song John. I couldn't even make it through min. 2.
Julius314159 3 years ago
Oh, so you left when Johnny Boy plays guitar vertically (gee, why, I wonder...).
Well, then you missed the bit when is screaming like a strangled chicken. Very artistic, very deeply felt, very moving ! It's just like the real thing. Just so.
inanenvelope 3 years ago
(How on earth the fucking message got up there ? Pfff, heck...).
Oh, so you left when Johnny Boy plays guitar vertically (gee, why, I wonder...).
Well, then you missed the bit when is screaming like a strangled chicken. Very artistic, very deeply felt, very moving ! It's just like the real thing. Just so.
inanenvelope 3 years ago
prepei n'akouseis kai to gnhsio ton joy division
podosphaere 3 years ago
John Frusciante
se olo tou to megaleio!!!
beyondgirl 3 years ago
He was okay until he started to scream (supposing he is singing)
DiosYDiablo 3 years ago
his hair here is so cool
jez9007 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
why does this guy cover songs like Joy Division's New Dawn Fades, Radiohead's Lucky and was in a such a horrible band as Red Hot..?
florcure 4 years ago
what makes them horrible.. ?
listen2radiohead 3 years ago
amazing
funkymonk09 4 years ago 6
yeah cool.
ericakirkendall 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Great cover. Too bad his voice doesn't sound as great as usual on this :-(
CacheTaFace 4 years ago
also one of my favourites! i love this cover
annnelore 4 years ago 4
This is one of my favourites. He's such an amazing guy
Berthiethesheep 4 years ago 4
my favourite of john's covers..thx
rockinfreakapotamus 4 years ago 4
Amazing.
alxc 4 years ago 4