Added: 3 years ago
From: undermilkwoods
Views: 28,969
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (57)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm crying right now, I think it was beautifully edited. Amazing job, beautiful movie, beautiful song, perfect timing with the scenes... just beautiful.

  • Great job; good song choice!

  • wow! that movie was so touching and reminds us to be grateful for what we have...

  • this movie is one of my favorites and that song is just beautiful

  • This made me cry :(

  • I like the way you matched the images to the lyrics. Makes me want to watch Atonement again!

    I'll have to wait until I finish Shameless first! :)

  • Really love the video, great editing, especially at the end! :)

  • yeah, the last 30, 40 seconds really hit the nail on the head. great job.

  • that's great **

  • Romance Movie Contest 2009 Winner could be you!

  • love the movie loved the song love james mcavoy what more can i ask for i cred

  • This almost made me tear up. Such a beautiful song, such a beautiful film. This song fit so well, it could've been written for Atonement. Love Glen and Marketa. :)

  • Simply magnificent.

    Seriously. And once again I just got emotional because of this movie. And the song fits beautifully. Thank you for that.

  • that was beautifully edited although i have a suggestion if anyone wanted to make another one, keeo the same sequences as in this video but at the second chorus line, show the love scene intertwined with the scene where hes getting arrested, trust me it would look awesome! :) just a suggestion..lol

  • Why don't you do it? It does sound amazing!

  • Wow. I've never commented on anything on youtube, but the way you've edited this is wonderful. The parallels between words and visuals are so fitting without being cheesy and obvious. Well done!

  • i did not know this song before and now i can't stop listening to it.

    why do you do that to me?!

    it's maddening beautiful

  • the song is great,and so is the vid

  • Romantic - great job!

  • Just beautiful! I had never heard this song before watching this and now it is one of my favorites so thank you so much for that! Wonderful job!!

  • this is perfect 4 atonement! great job!

  • Great video. You edited it beautiful

  • great song, clips go really well with the clips

  • hauntingly beautiful

  • This is so beautiful!!! I loves this song, it makes me tear up everytime I hear it and with your wonderful video it made me cry full blown tears. The part where it says "You have suffered enough" and you showed Robbie was just so perfect. The editing was brillant and the ending was just so sad and perfect. Great work!

  • My response comes a little late, I'm sorry about that.

    I'm glad you liked it, and that my humble video has produced such an emotional reaction.

    Thank you.

  • its the song that won an oscar by marketa irglova and Glen hansard from the movie once.you must see the movie its great

  • That was so beautiful!! it made me cry perfect song to go with it too!

  • me too.

  • This is really good.

    I was watching it at my friends house only shes seen it before, so she skipped past alot of it to her favourite bits.

    Can anyone tell me;

    Do cecelia and Briony get on after Robbie is arrested?

    The ending is so sad,

    :/

  • No, Cecilia left her home after they arrested Robbie. The answered to her mother's letters like once a year - just for them to know she was alive. She refused to speak even with her brother to say nothing about Briony. No family, no friends. Just one person in her mind - this is how she died...

    p.s. I just read the book :))

  • Which did you like better, the book or the movie??? Books are almost always better, but I thought that they did an excellent job with the movie!

  • The movie is like the book come to life. I love both.

  • really wonderful job with the song choice and the editing! especially at the end. love it.

  • Brilliant editing, brilliant song choice This looks like the music was written for this movie. You are awesome!!

  • siiiiiiiiii, ahora lo entieeeendoo! :)

    y es muuuy lindo el video, me gusta mucho la cancion y me voy super contenta porque vi la pelicula, me gusto mucho, me puso muuuuuuy triste y la pienso ver de nuevo (no ahora, xD)

    espero ver maaaaaaas videos tuyos :)

    clara

  • Wow!!! This was really good!

    When I first heard Falling Slowly, I didn't like it very much, but it's grown on me!

  • Incredible video!You made me cry!

  • Wow!! That was amazing editing and the I liked the song.

  • Thank you :)

  • AAAH! Favourite song mixed with favourite movie!! How much better can it get??

    Mmmm... McAvoy.

  • Awesome video!

  • Al diablo con los spoilers! AMO tus videos!

  • cada vez me gusta mas este video, sin duda el mejor de atonement!!!

    yanina

  • me encnatoo eugee :) es muy lindoo enserio, aunq ya te lo dije jaja,

    pero la cancion re pega y nosee me re llega :)

  • wonderful

  • como siempre querida: amazing.

    ( y la canción es hermosa. )

  • Thank you for making this! I love this song :)

  • omygod that was incredible!! especially the end, thank you soooooooo much!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • beautiful job. i love this song!

  • La convinación Atonement/Falling Slowly me hace llorar... MUCHO.

  • great work!

  • scratch that i meant the writer....rem now its that irish guy and won oscar!

  • whats the name of this song again?

  • "Falling slowly". It's from the movie "ONCE" and it won the Oscar for the Best Original Song :)

  • I got emotional

  • So beautiful, thank you.

  • Oh my God I love this song!!!! GREAT JOB! 5 stars and added to favorites. I love the part where Robbie says "I love you" in the library.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more