Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,254)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song should be official, the feeling you get from it fits the story perfectly - both haunting and soothing.

  • I really want to sing this for my Music class assignment. I absolutely love songs that are both haunting AND beautiful. This is now my favourite song, closely followed by Pippin's song in LotR :)

  • I sang this in class I got thw wtf look

  • Oh my gosh, that was so beautiful! <3 I love it!

  • this song is the best!

  • just like i imagined it would sound like! if i hear other people their covers, they seem out of tune. thanks!

  • this song is sooo sad

  • I just wanna say this is THE BEST interpretation of this song. Hands down.

  • Memorized just like katniss and gale

  • WOW WOW WOW WOW WOW

  • Wow again! Everytime I listen to it it sounds better.

    My best friend also says thank you very much for making it :)

  • its too fast for my liking

  • Gives me the chills...*shudder*

  • truly the best version your talented this is amazing

  • AMAZING AMAZING AMAZING!!! Your voice is so good. I couldn't sing like that to save my life! It made me cry :'(. Love the Hunger Games XD

  • BEST VERSION OF YOUTUBE<3 

  • This song has been on repeat for about -checks watch- 2 hours now :)

  • This is so haunting and yet so beautiful!

    i can jut imagine Katniss singing it...

  • Jesus Christ this is beautiful

  • It semt a little fast....maybe if it was slowed down

  • Looks like President snow has 47 youtube profiles

    MUST REPORT PROFILES >_<

  • Only one word describes it. Beautiful

  • @gamecubeable I think you meant *considering* and I *WAS* a Twihard. not anymore. just too lazy to change my handle and I have vids I can't move over. And, look who's talking, Mr./Ms. I-have-an-outdated-gaming-syst­em in my handle. I complimented this video. wth is your problem?

  • this is also very pretty <3

  • why are both top commenter's YouTube names are to do with horses ??

  • I think it would sweet if they used your version in the movie and Gale joined in on the last verse

  • This song actually makes me tear up >.<

  • I think that the accompaniment from this video is the best out of all the versions, but I don't like the vocals.

  • Fucking awesome! Gives me the shivers..!

  • 0:00 - 2:10 - creepy, but i thought it was beautifully done :) the ending i loved ^_^

  • im no hater but i didnt really like this song

  • i sing this all the time now xD

  • 45 people have to go meet someone at midnight in the hanging tree. :P

  • When I read the book I cried at this part, and this sounds AMAZING, made me wanna cry too, beautiful, as sad and perfect as I imagined it.

  • This is what I sing in the shower. xD

  • This is perfect. They should sing it this way in the movie, don't you think? This is exactly how I sang it in my head as well..

  • Absolutely the best version I have ever heard. beautiful. I can totally imagine it being sung this way.

  • incredible!

  • simply perfection. 

  • 44 dislikes? NICE TRY PRESIDENT SNOW

  • Best version of "The Hanging Tree" i have ever heard.

  • This is beautiful, had to download it, thank you!!

  • I could totally see Katnis singing ts for Pollux when they were in the woods. The sad part in this scene for me was when she realizes Peeta was right and the birds do stop when she sings.

  • Wow this is exactly how I imagined it :o

  • i love the hunger games and this sounds fantastic I LOVE IT

  • omg!!!

  • Guitar chords please?

  • This one sounds more like a sea shanty than any of the others. Great vocals, but I didn't like the melody.

  • I love it!!! Even though it is sad it Is still amazing!!!!!

  • wow I love the part with the birds! where did you get it?

    

  • i love this version. i was watching all the other versions and they just didnt sound right. this is perfect. thank you for posting this:)

  • its funny this is how i sing it too.

  • awesome! the others' aren't half as eerie...i'm adding this to my playlist!

  • I really like this, but i think the actual sound should sound more eerie.

  • @iMaxRide na the eeriness of the song is how a child can sing it so joyfully even though the message is rather grim.

  • This is how I read/sung it in my head!!

  • one word: PERFECT

  • I want to cry,

    I can imagine katnis sing that ...

  • this book never got boring!!!!!!

  • best version ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! loved the book sooooooooo much, especially peeta he is so romantic

  • Absolutely gorgeous :) And LOVE the last part of the song.

  • I love this so song much! I hope it sounds like this in the movie!!!!!! :)

  • Such a hauntingly, beautiful song....

  • OHMYGOD this gave me goosebumps

  • perfectly eery and beautiful. I really would like to see this in the Mockingjay movie.

  • I love this song. Lovelovelovelovelove

  • this is the best song

  • they need to make a bird that acctual replicates human voices so i can sing this to them

  • i got bored with the book after (SPOILER SPOILER) peeta got "hijacked"

    it jsut kinda runied it for me she didint have as much

    fighting in her head and it wasent as fun.

    but nice song i really like it

  • I like adrisaurus's version better

  • Really good i can tell you put alot of work into this hope it goes good for you!

  • Wow, the melody as well as your singing fits perfectly the mood of the song. It's my favorite version of the hanging tree so far. I wished they would use it in the official movie for I'm quite sure I might be disappointed by any other...

    Your voice is very much as the one I imagined for Katniss, it's not so high but able to rise very beautifully, and your boyfriend's maches perfectly in the end. Very well done! <3

  • My friend and I sing this version all the time, creeping everyone out.

    Walking around school: Wear a necklace of rope side by side with me...

    Random teacher: O.o

  • 40 people are Peace Keepers, 1 is Snow, 1 is Coin, and 2 are just assholes.

  • @SaddleClub345 Nooo One is an asshole, the other is Katniss's mom, for making a song she forbid so popular! :)

  • @SaddleClub345 ok i get all of them but coin. i mean this song was a propo so shouldnt coin like it

  • @dudd343434 no cuz coin wanted to use capitol children to continue the hunger games so she needed to die to or all would be unbalanced

  • @SaddleClub345 LOL! xp

  • @SaddleClub345 1+1+2=40?

  • @gamecubeable ...it is quite obviously 40+1+1+2=44.there are now 46, but they took the 44 dislikes and split it up into 40 peace keepers, Snow, Coin and 2...(s)he should've put those 2 into Peacekeepers xD but using *current* dislikes, 44 people are peace keepers, 1 is Snow and 1 is Coin :P

  • @edwardcullenismybf COndiering your a twihard, nothing you say can be trusted.

  • @SaddleClub345 make that 43 peacekeepers 1 is snow 1 is coin and the other two are assholes that hate panem

  • Niceee

  • I got the book for christmas and didnt bother to read it untill january glad I read it cause now im soo friggin obbssesssed with it!!!!!!!!

  • 44 people are complete ASSHOLES

  • Without a doubt: the BEST version.

  • This is the best Hanging Tree version I've heard. 

  • I like this version better than all of the others, but could you put lyrics with it, if you have time

  • This is simply beautiful !!!!!!!!

  • love this one

    

  • Could you post up the guitar chords please?

  • This is what Peeta would sing if they hadn't saved him from Snow<3

  • @horsejumperdressage your comment just... broke my heart.

  • Love it! Does anyone know the name of the hunger games album

  • love

  • it's perfect i have no words... so much feelings

  • Woow O.o Amazing! Love it! ♥ :)

  • i keep listening to this <3

  • @TheIgDemon When you read the books, the first chapter of the first book is apparently very boring. Jussayin'

  • @miekka968 I have to agree, and I honestly think that it's boring up until the part where Katniss sees Rue in the trees

  • @miekka968 Well, so was Harry Potter's, but I managed to stick through it when it finally got good. XD

  • @miekka968 i had the book for a month and i was on page 2 the whole time, the first chapter is really boring.

  • omg I am so stupid in the mockingjay pin the mockingjay is stabing a arrow through the circle. the exact same way Katniss did in Catching Fire she fired an arrow through the force field THAT WAS THE SHAPE OF A CIRCLE. man I am an idiot

  • @AlphaWolf1415 actually you'd be surprised how small the amount of people who got that really are lol

  • I Love everything about this. It's a very eerie song, yet you made it sound good as well. Wonderful job! Best Version I've Heard.

  • You sound like someone from Blackmore's night.

    :D excellent job. I've had this in my head the entire day.

  • I haven't even read the books yet and I know what this song is about.

  • @TheIgDemon YOU NEED TO READ THE BOOKS...just sayin

  • @ilive2laugh1 My interest has been peaked, I won't deny it. The next time I stop at a place selling the books I will pick up the first book.

  • @TheIgDemon you won't regret it :)

  • my friend told me she was singing this 4 our talent show. i literally went crazy from excitment

  • Love it

  • @Teenagedream103. WOW, you are SOOO SMART. I LYK NEVER THOT ABOUT THAT BEFORE. U SHUD GET A MEDAL. -_-'

  • YOu must be PSYCHIC! This is exactly how I imagined it!!!!! Seriously it is so weird that it is the exact same as how I imagined!

  • "Wear a necklace of rope, side by side with me" That line...gets me everytime

  • But, this truly is incredible. A sad and beautiful song.

    Wonderfully sung, though :D!

  • I didn't even know this was in the Hunger games. I just happened to come upon it because someone quoted it in a conversation.

  • @Gerkenflauger Katniss sings it in the third book

  • i luv this song! my friend downloaded it on her mp3 (we're both Hunger Games fans) and we were just listening and singing along to it on the bus the whole way until it was my stop to get off, (which means we played it 7 or 8 times straight) weird thing is no one even paid attention to us, 2 kids singing along to a 'non-popular' song, I was kinda surprised we didn't get any stares but i don't really care anyway this is one of my favorite songs ever awesome job

  • amazing!

  • amazing!! its like an official song!! congrats :)

  • nice pelican.... amazing cover, very well done! :)

  • I love this song and Hunger Games is bess!

  • @Katrinann13 YDK!!!

  • This is beautiful! I love your voice, and the melody is perfect! Fantastic job :)

    I would love to do a cover of your version, is there any way you could send me the instrumental?

  • I keep listening to this and crying! D':

    This is so beautiful!

  • I love this song!!!!! :D I have heard it over 100 times :) It never gets old and it was posted on my b-day ty for sharing this song!

  • @MrsDreamer22 Tristian and Isolde

  • What's the name of the movie of the picture at 1:37 ?

  • @MrsDreamer22 Knights Tale

  • by far the best version i have found so far.

  • i love the mockingjay at 0:55 and at 1:07 where did you get it?

  • I've only found 2 versions of Hanging tree I like! This is one!

  • this is exactly what i thought this would sound like! Its just a good song :)

  • too much dubstep XD jk haha epci just pure epic. if epic was an element this would be pure epic haha

  • This is perfect just how imagined almost like a childs nursery rhyme

  • @kmpaint95 if this is a childs nursery ryhme alot of kids around the world must be crying this song is scary but beast

  • this is great but isnt the song suposed to be creepy? this is great no doubt but it doesnt match the lyrics that talk about suicide.

  • @davidlovestowrite this must be how kat's dad used to sing it... he sang it to katniss when they were kids... i think it was meant to be like a nursery ryhme...

  • wow, you guys really made an effort to make this video and it's music.. It's really good... I love what you did to the song from the book...

    @teenage dream103 wow nice, after i got the book i didn't bother looking at the cover i just read the book.. i took the time to look at the cover just now to see if i see what you see.

  • This is the best version I've ever seen. This time, it's not a whole bunch of notes randomly strung together, it's a *song*! :D Wow. Great job! (Note, I haven't seen them all, so no one get offended. But it would be amazingly hard to be better than this).

  • I love it and i luv the book

  • This is amazing!!!!! Your voice is beautiful!!!!!!!!!! I love this!

  • creepy... :D

  • is this the real song

    

  • Favorite version, amazing.

  • bless katnisses soul after she has endured all that she has.

  • I LOVVVEE this song specially the end guitar solo!!!! XD

  • ther german version is bether :C

  • Pretty creepy song

  • When I read through this part of Mockingjay today and heard this song I was playing it through my head myself. This version fit it well and sounds great! :) It has a way of being chilling yet amazing at the same time.

  • shivers down my spine

  • oh gosh... this song is creepy... I LOVE IT

  • Are you, are you Coming to the tree Where I told you to run, so we’d both be free. Strange things did happen here No stranger would it be If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree. Are you, are you Coming to the tree Wear a necklace of rope, side by side with me. Strange things did happen here No stranger would it be If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.
  • 37 dislikes. nice try President Snow..

  • @EstelaBlanco

    Not president snow! Katniss's mom Mrs. Everdeen!!!!

  • @sel1011001 true

  • @EstelaBlanco yeah i think Snow has 42 youtube accounts

  • @EstelaBlanco lmfao. yes. yes. yes.

  • @EstelaBlanco but hes dead?!

  • Really beautiful!! I really wanted to hear that song I could not imagine it only with the lyric

    Awesomw!

  • beautiful... no more needed to be said

  • you should do Rues Lullaby

  • i cant stop listening to it

  • You must tell me the notes/ music sheet thing for guitar and piano. genuis this is my absolute favourite of all the others that have been recorded C: <3

  • go on you tube on a different tab

    put on foresty mood

    play both together but foresty mood soft

    and thank me later

  • @izzytheausome11 soooo cool! Thank you (this is later)!! :)