To My Peaceful Muslim Friend

[skinnyjohnsen]

Great video and great band. I just googled The Frames, never heard about them before, but it sounds beautiful. Thanks ;-)

[AishaBad]

There is only two states muslims understand .Dal al islam ,that where there is islam and Dal al Haab that where there is war .

Muslims will live in peace with you just so long as you understand who is the boss .

[AishaBad]

Very lovely .Unfortunately it will never happen .Islam is beyond reformation .

Islam was hatched by a killer . I have been made victorious by terror .I live under the shadow of my spear . The words of the prophet .

The very nature of islam is war not peace .

The only hope is for muslims to leave islam .

[Seleucus84]

Maybe you should look harder. See for example the millions of Muslims in India who protested the terror attacks in Mumbai on their holy day EID.

The question is why wasn't this on any of the major news networks? But they choose to cover one forum post about south park...

[leicaholt]

@Seleucus84 Yes, I am aware of that. I cannot be certain though why the muslims' anti-terrorism protests are not receiving the media mileage they need. They are miserably overlooked, almost deliberately it seems, and eclipsed by the much too vociferous extremists. I cannot say, too, that it is all just a matter of perspective seeing the relationship between the muslims and the rest of the world is getting worse. The moderates do need to take them to task

[Seleucus84]

@leicaholt

Of course the moderates must to speak out. But too many people believe everything they hear about muslims, yet they know nothing about them.

[iamterrentia]

Yeah, the moderate muslims have fears of the, relatively large minority of political islamists. It is this group that is 'policing' their own for any too outspoken against the issues concerning Islam, the Hadith and Shariah Law.

[FredrichNietzsche25]

Very Beautifully Done Good Job

[leicaholt]

@FredrichNietzsche25 Thus spake Zarathustra :P Thanks, mate.

[masticina]

Seems the moderates are fearfull of speaking up

I guess their more extreme brethen have already killed their own brothers so far to silence them. It is not the outsiders who can change Islam. It is the Muslims may the friendly moderates find their voice.

[leicaholt]

@Nessrriinn Thank you, too, Nessriinn. I've seen some of your videos and you do add a very poignant dimension to the subject of Islamic extremism.

[Vogter2100]

Beautifull video :) Thank you!

[leicaholt]

@Vogter2100 Cheers, Vogter :)

[fireeyedb0y]

I'm a bit too wasted to read all the text in your video right now, but what an amazingly heartfelt song.

[THEGREATESTUMMAH]

Prophet Muhammad is not God,He is a servant and the last messenger of God.We don't worship Muhammad.I condemn terrorism in all its forms.The west should also consider its foreign policies.

[leicaholt]

@THEGREATESTUMMAH Yes, you are right indeed. It should be "prophet", not "god". Thank you. As about the foreign policies of the west, I can't help but see how asymmetrical (to say the least) the response of the Muslim extremists is towards imperialism. I don't see how waging holy wars and regarding non-Muslims as infidels can advance a dissenting position against foreign policies.

[QueeeeNoftheHonEBZ]

@leicaholt no, you had "god" right. there are muslims could claim that muhammad was just a man, just a prophet . But then man would go on to follow that man's example as it its perfect. they then deify the man by being insisting that his likeness never been drawn. They idolize the man and they peg their god every time they say his name, bring peace and blessing upon a dead man. Even saying Shahada

[QueeeeNoftheHonEBZ]

1/2 of the declaration requires that you accept allah and the other, you must accept muhammad. sound like mindless worship of a man to me. islam has many prophets and the others dont have nearly as much consideration being given to them as muhammad. MANY muslims follow Sunnah, which is the living habits of muhammad. so its not about following quran and allah's word but muhammad is the standard to meet. muslims say nothing (muhammad was just a prophet)

[QueeeeNoftheHonEBZ]

but their actions demonstrate something else. But i do agree, somewhat, with Thegreatestummah. muhammad was not god but he was not a prophet etiher. he was just a man who is now dead. and 1.8 billion are being lead by the nose by the ramblings and habits of a dead man.

[leicaholt]

@QueeeeNoftheHonEBZ thanks for the insight, mate. yes, calling Muhammad a god not a prophet is a subconscious impulse; much like Christians see Jesus not as the son of god but god himself. how does one take the god out of men who proclaimed they're the embodiment of god?