JASON CASTRO - I SHOT THE SHERIFF TOP 4 [1 OF 2]

[smeexxiieegal]

i donnt think this ihs a good song 4 hymee

[hardheaded409]

Ok anyone who says this is a good rendition of the song has not listened to the original by the Great Bob Marley but then again i really didnt like the Clampton version either

[death2me123]

lame

[ashkobar]

Don't Sing it, if you can't. THIS IS SONG ARE EXCLUSIVES FROM RASTA PEOPLE

[seanmacman15]

uhhh no bob marley was about not just his own people but uniteing all the races he wouldetn wantt he song to be exclusive to one race dumbass

[singers333]

wow, calling someone an idiot on these boards, shows us just the kind of person you are. I would never listen to what you say. You do not respect others.

[singers333]

Jason went out his own way on his terms and pissed them off! Yay Jason you are my hero!

[onedropp]

he pissed them off cause he killed an amazing song and disrespected bob marley you idiot. if your hero is a bad performer on american idol you got a problem.

[ironlionzion365]

onedropp is 100% right man, horrible rendition of a great song

[joejonasfan226]

he says dont vote at the end

[blgatlc123]

omg i love when hes like "i was thinking bob marley!" i crack up everytime. i get to see him tonighttttt! i love him <3333

[Piazzollacosimo]

hes high

[DarkLordSauron2]

Jason is very talented but this was a mistake.  Simon went way over the top though. Thought at one stage he was going to put on a black cap and sentence poor Jason to death.

[tttss2008]

he had weak emotions,and no power behind his voice.i think it was terrible,it's true what bob marley said himself,"any musician can sing it. but,them don't know how to feel it".he shouldn't try to make his voice sound good,it's how you deliver!!!.castro u sucked.lol.

[genuinexheart]

Q: Clear something up:

Did you really mouth the words "Don't vote" when Ryan Seacrest was giving out your numbers Tuesday night?

A: I was saying, 'Vote,' and then I said it again. I was trying to emphasize that. I remember going and sitting down and thinking about it. That went through my mind, and I was like, 'Dangit.'

[tk409]

He clearly says "Don't vote". And we didn't.

[michaelhonscar]

Actually he said vote ,vote He stated so in an interview today with FOX that he said vote.So by not voting you let him down.

[dinah259]

If you look at his lips and think of the words, "Dont Vote!," then you'd see him say that...

BUT, if you think of the words, "Vote Vote!" and rewind it and look at his lips again, you'd think he says that instead!!

Wierd, huh??

Well, I think he says, "Vote for Obama," but then again, he could actually be referring to Hillary....Only time will tell.

[brkitdwn]

jason is so young and inexperienced.. but, he has a unique talent, look and stage presence.. just wait. he'll make it if he works hard.. and, he's certainly more interesting than the two davids.. he just needs to refine his skills a more.

[666boy11]

he was one of the people that i thought was going to win but he made a huge mistake trying to cover a bob marley song. this was the worse performance i've ever seen anyone do this far into the competition. that song is a classic and it should not be performed by almost anyone. bob marley perfected it and no one could ever do better

[antsme]

At the end Jason told everyone "Don't Vote"!

[michaelhonscar]

He said Vite not Don't vote.

[bobitsuki]

yes! freedom will come your way...definitely!

[facethesea]

they just don't know how to enjoy all those Marley and Dylan talents Jason gets...what they are interested in is just those "Comerical with a capital C"!

It's Ok,Jason, people Marley and Dylan are in the house of fame, but never will those stupid judges...

[crissy4jc]

Totally agree! There is no better word for the rest than: COMMERICAL!

[kb1g]

"Why are they being so mean to him?" because he is uninspiring, average, kind of a coffee shop singer. Not star material......ever. He has never done a song that is anything but a breathy karaoke version of the original. Let's get past the pain and let him go. It's gonna be Cook or Archuletta. Two of the best singers left. Archuletta did very well tonight. Not digging cook past couple of weeks. Staying in the low register a lot and very pitchy there.

[NSL4EVER]

Amen! This guy blows so much ass! How he and Brooke outlasted Carly and Ramiele and Michael Johns is ridiculous. America, or at least most people, are musically retarded and tonedeaf. That's why Supposed "artists" like Fergie, Danity Kane, and Miley Cyrus have jobs. kb1g hit it on the head, Jason Castro is just the next in the line of overacheiving mediocre singers, thanks to musically immature audiences, particularly teenage girls. At least David Archuleta can sing while having the girl fanclub

[michaelhonscar]

Ramiele was one of the biggest bombs of the season.

[CAPLOCK7]

Aw if only you weren't so shallow. MUSIC is NOT about how strong your voice is, it's about getting a feeling across. And you couldn't be more far off about Castro's fanbase.

[ladydisurfer]

That was terrible. What happened to him? He used to be so good.

[paspossible16]

sadly, i think its time for my fave to go home.

im kinda mad, but he rly didnt do his best tonight.

but top 4 is magnificent, and i know hell be around!