I am so glad that Jennifer Hudson was eliminated from AI with this song, because it showed how utterly pathetic the call in judging was. She took this Manilow song which is one of my faves, and absolutely brought it to another level. She might have tightened up a bit, but this is really one of those definitive AI moments. She went beyond AI at that moment, and I'm glad she was voted out with this performance, because all it showed was AI is a joke and real talent won't be recongized.
Clearly, this is a "before it's time" moment. The level of where she was then was too good for American Idol. Which is why the producers decided to vote her off the show. In my opinion, she was too good for American Idol.......
It seems the judges seldom give anybody a standing ovation on AI. For years, the judges on AI have blathered on endlessly about, "making the song your own." Yet, when someone does just that, as did Hudson in this performance; one would think the judges would have showered her with accolades. Instead, their critiques were positive, yet perfunctory. AI has run its course & is irrelevant. On the other hand, Hudson is an excellent singer & will be going strong long after AI has faded into oblivion.
@peachorchard I hope you said that because she went on to win multiple awards for her performance, not because you have some incredibly ridiculous notion that she's a bad singer...
@RegineNoelle23 You people really need to STOP! I did say that because if she did win she may not be where she is today........GOSH!!! And if you must know I am a HUGE Jennifer Hudson fan!
if not for a blackout Jenn Hudson whould have gotten more votes then Fantasia and the season 3 outcome whould have been all diff....but looking back i think her earlier exit made her stronger and more successfull
The reasons the judges sat there is because they didnt want her to win really. everyone was already invested in fantasia. which is cool...lol cause God had more for Jenn. 5 years from now...theres gunna b 'where are idol winners now' ...and its gunna b pretty funny. but Jenn...is blessed and highly favored. God knows best!
did she get voted off after this performance? can't recall.. well, if i'm not mistaken.. so sad she was out of the competition so fast but there's a reason behind it! simply God had more plans for her. DREAM GIRLS! wohoo0o0o!
@iMacsteven she did but it was because the night of the vote, there was a huge blackout around the Chicago area which killed alot of her votes, she landed in the bottom 2 with Fantasia, without that blackout who knows who whould have won
performances of the last few seasons don't capture this amazingness, yet some get standing ovations. Lol. OKAY. If J Hud were on season 10 she'd no doubt win.
HUGE THUNDERSTORM IN CHICAGOLAND AREA THE NIGHT OF THIS BROADCAST . MOST ALL PHONESLINES DOWN . THEREFORE NO VOTES COULD GET THROUGH FROM JENNIFERS HOME TOWN AREA OF CHICAGO , TEXTING WAS NOT AN OPTION AT THIS TIME WITH IDOL .
The reason Jennifer was voted off was not because she wasn't good it was because that night there was a blackout in Chicago so we couldn't vote for her. And people also thought that the 3 divas were safe so other places didn't think she really needed alot of votes. But she's still a superstar.
This was a very unique and beautiful arrangement for Jennifer, and she should have never been voted off. She should of actually won the American Idol that year. I was so upset when she had to leave, because she continued to get better and better every week, and I looked forward to what she was doing next. LOVE HER! ! ! !
Jennifer sang this so beautifully. It was flawless. I was really pissed when she got voted off the show after this song. Simon didn't care for her. I guess she showed him.
One of my favorite Barry songs and I agree with Barry-she took it all the way. It gives me chills. She is an amazing talent and I'm so glad she got what she deserved.
I had a big argument with my family because I told them that Jennifer was the best singer but they insisted Fantasia and Latoya were better. I couldnt understand how anyone could hear this voice and think anyone was better. They have now come around to my way of thinking.
She is one of the best artistes AI has ever produced and I am so happy that her elimination made her one of AI's best success stories.
@qCLEFJones they was not divas. Malinda Lakeisha & Jordin had nothing & I mean nothing on Fantasia Latoya & Jennifer. Season 3 of American Idol had the best female singers ever to sing on that stage.
oh I agree...I was just saying that this wasn't the only battle between of divas (replying 2 some1 else's comment)...fantasia, latoya, and jennifer were definitely collectively better than melinda, lakisha, and jordin...
stupid song that got her eleminated i love how she sound but i hate that song just for her and my idol looks great sounds great just perfect ms. miya aka lil jhud
The reason is because they were splitting the vote. It should have come down to Latoya, Fantasia, and Jennifer ... unfortunately they all three appealed to the same demographic so the vote was split and Jennifer and Latoya were voted off before their time.
try to compare regine velasquez and jennifer hudson version of this song youll see what i am talking about. this is classical not an rnb type of song.
except that barry manilow who wrote the song loved jennifer's rendition so much he invited her to sing with him the next day on the Today Show. jennifer put an r&b spin to the song but still retained its power and emotion. regine just sang the song pretty well (not great but well), nowhere near as good or original as this rendition sorry.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
jen hudson ovesung this sing that pretty much killed the message of it. for me i thought a song as sincere lile this should never take on the way jen did because its untouchable and already beautiful for her to take on a song as untouchable like this would just be a blasphemy to everyone who loves the song.. regine sung the song from her heart you are numb if you didnt feel that and this one was just a trainwreck compare to regine's version
You coundn't be more wrong. Jennifer sang to the strength of her voice. Barry Manilow himself helped to arrange this & said that he couldn't do what she could with the song. He was almost speechless with pride and this is HIS song. Jennifer has a special type of voice which helped he to win her Academy Award & Grammy. Songs are subject to interpretation. I felt this version much more. She was the best singer on Idol and she should won. The only reason why she didn't is because God had better.
i agree w/ renzy79. This was the moment when I knew Jennifer was a superstar talent. She took a sappy Manilow song and made it the anthem it had the potential to be. a classic performance
this is good but not great. not just her best performance.. she should have sing "if i should love again or sandra intead of this since this song requires more emotion that shouting and screeching, that obviously she failed to give.
This was undeniably one of the 5 best idol performances ever. I mean, ever. But Jenny had the last laugh. Ask Taylor Hicks if he'd like an Academy Award and a Golden Globe in exchange for his "Idol" crown. LOL
i will NEVVVVER forgot seeing this live!!!!! I LOVE JHUDSON!!!!
Xclusivenig9a 3 weeks ago
I am so glad that Jennifer Hudson was eliminated from AI with this song, because it showed how utterly pathetic the call in judging was. She took this Manilow song which is one of my faves, and absolutely brought it to another level. She might have tightened up a bit, but this is really one of those definitive AI moments. She went beyond AI at that moment, and I'm glad she was voted out with this performance, because all it showed was AI is a joke and real talent won't be recongized.
LiamForeman 3 weeks ago
OUR TRUE AMERICAN IDOL SHE SHOULD HAVE WON BECAUSE WHERES FANTASIAS CAREER ???? ILL WAIT
BADBOY0542 1 month ago
Legends are never duplicated, but stars are born daily. You are a legend Ms. Hudson. I pray that you remain humble and grateful.
sexycubanchocolate 3 months ago
I would say again one of the best performance by this diva. She took this song to another level people. The power of her voice is just outstanding.
sexycubanchocolate 3 months ago
WHY was she eliminated that night?? that's absurd..
3333alex 5 months ago
Clearly, this is a "before it's time" moment. The level of where she was then was too good for American Idol. Which is why the producers decided to vote her off the show. In my opinion, she was too good for American Idol.......
notabadguy06 5 months ago
And this was the song that got her ELIMINATED on American Idol! Can you believe it? lol
princeace3000 5 months ago
It seems the judges seldom give anybody a standing ovation on AI. For years, the judges on AI have blathered on endlessly about, "making the song your own." Yet, when someone does just that, as did Hudson in this performance; one would think the judges would have showered her with accolades. Instead, their critiques were positive, yet perfunctory. AI has run its course & is irrelevant. On the other hand, Hudson is an excellent singer & will be going strong long after AI has faded into oblivion.
twowaystreet101 7 months ago
tasia and jhud are both talented. it would be cool if they faced each other in the finals.
mrkgt12 10 months ago
Thank God she didn't win!!
peachorchard 10 months ago
@peachorchard I hope you said that because she went on to win multiple awards for her performance, not because you have some incredibly ridiculous notion that she's a bad singer...
RegineNoelle23 5 months ago
@RegineNoelle23 You people really need to STOP! I did say that because if she did win she may not be where she is today........GOSH!!! And if you must know I am a HUGE Jennifer Hudson fan!
peachorchard 5 months ago
if not for a blackout Jenn Hudson whould have gotten more votes then Fantasia and the season 3 outcome whould have been all diff....but looking back i think her earlier exit made her stronger and more successfull
MsSparklesNGlitter 11 months ago 3
The reasons the judges sat there is because they didnt want her to win really. everyone was already invested in fantasia. which is cool...lol cause God had more for Jenn. 5 years from now...theres gunna b 'where are idol winners now' ...and its gunna b pretty funny. but Jenn...is blessed and highly favored. God knows best!
GetLikeM390 11 months ago
try regine velasquez version and compare who's the best ithink she made it over and annoying but all the way i love jennifer's voice
reoblight 11 months ago
did she get voted off after this performance? can't recall.. well, if i'm not mistaken.. so sad she was out of the competition so fast but there's a reason behind it! simply God had more plans for her. DREAM GIRLS! wohoo0o0o!
iMacsteven 11 months ago
@iMacsteven she did but it was because the night of the vote, there was a huge blackout around the Chicago area which killed alot of her votes, she landed in the bottom 2 with Fantasia, without that blackout who knows who whould have won
MsSparklesNGlitter 11 months ago
Search for Regine Velasquez's version,so much better than this!
VibesAndLiveleeShow 11 months ago
performances of the last few seasons don't capture this amazingness, yet some get standing ovations. Lol. OKAY. If J Hud were on season 10 she'd no doubt win.
seventeenboi 11 months ago
incredible
seventeenboi 11 months ago
She really captured me with this performance. Amazing range, pitch, vocally she is amazing
sanggurl16 1 year ago
HUGE THUNDERSTORM IN CHICAGOLAND AREA THE NIGHT OF THIS BROADCAST . MOST ALL PHONESLINES DOWN . THEREFORE NO VOTES COULD GET THROUGH FROM JENNIFERS HOME TOWN AREA OF CHICAGO , TEXTING WAS NOT AN OPTION AT THIS TIME WITH IDOL .
unjaded2 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
it still baffles me to this day that she was in bottom three after a performance like this...
totallygothboy 1 year ago
it still baffles me to this day that she was in bottom three after a performance like this...
totallygothboy 1 year ago
That voice is A GIFT - no two ways about it.
beefmageditor 1 year ago
beautiful!!!!!
meeka276 1 year ago
Hallelujah, Hallelujah, HALLELUJAH. You're right, Barry. She took it straight to the stratosphere. 1:35, wow. Just WOW.
TommyGDub 1 year ago
How dare she sing like that?!?! And im guessing that ONE person missed the "like" button!
gampsterofgamp 1 year ago
I heard that some parts of America had typhoon that time,so some votes had never arrived to save her...
osha90210 1 year ago
jennifer has a qift too me she wonn
mzkayla10 1 year ago
Christ Jesus, Hallelujah! That was fucking INCREDIBLE, my gawd. That triple key change - I almost pee'd my pants! What a voice. Amazing.
TommyGDub 1 year ago 5
love it
GregC5471 1 year ago
how could she possibly have been voted off that week?
KrisAllisonKelly4evr 1 year ago
Besides some oversinging, it was good.
curlingiron7658 1 year ago
The reason Jennifer was voted off was not because she wasn't good it was because that night there was a blackout in Chicago so we couldn't vote for her. And people also thought that the 3 divas were safe so other places didn't think she really needed alot of votes. But she's still a superstar.
cherita18 1 year ago 2
This was a very unique and beautiful arrangement for Jennifer, and she should have never been voted off. She should of actually won the American Idol that year. I was so upset when she had to leave, because she continued to get better and better every week, and I looked forward to what she was doing next. LOVE HER! ! ! !
Barrybaby100 1 year ago
Wonderful! I Love Jennifer Hudson, she is beautiful voice!!!!
Lucassobreira1 1 year ago
Jennifer sang this so beautifully. It was flawless. I was really pissed when she got voted off the show after this song. Simon didn't care for her. I guess she showed him.
Theresidentassistant 1 year ago
One of my favorite Barry songs and I agree with Barry-she took it all the way. It gives me chills. She is an amazing talent and I'm so glad she got what she deserved.
ssblklyn 1 year ago
I had a big argument with my family because I told them that Jennifer was the best singer but they insisted Fantasia and Latoya were better. I couldnt understand how anyone could hear this voice and think anyone was better. They have now come around to my way of thinking.
She is one of the best artistes AI has ever produced and I am so happy that her elimination made her one of AI's best success stories.
stacymala 1 year ago
OMG are you kidding me? she got eliminated from this performance! How could she of lost? American idol voters are unfair
LoboAscuridad 2 years ago
Absolutely loved this performance
agentcheeks007 2 years ago 3
great comment paula..you sucked as a judge
BigPostal 2 years ago
The judges should've gave her a standing ovation. Idk why they just sat there and talked
Sohot87 2 years ago 19
This has been flagged as spam show
watch REGINE VELASQUEZ WEEKEND IN NEW ENGLAND ( highest version ever!!!)
clutch0007 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
watch REGINE VELASQUEZ WEEKEND IN NEW ENGLAND (highest version ever!!!)
clutch0007 2 years ago
The only season with battle of the DIVAS
jaderrw 2 years ago 3
@jaderrw what about Melinda vs. Lakisha vs. Jordin...that was sorta a battle between divas too...
qCLEFJones 2 years ago
You're probably right, but I never felt Jordin as a DIVA. She can sing but she didn't have the diva attitude for me. dunno.
jaderrw 2 years ago
@qCLEFJones they was not divas. Malinda Lakeisha & Jordin had nothing & I mean nothing on Fantasia Latoya & Jennifer. Season 3 of American Idol had the best female singers ever to sing on that stage.
qua2324 1 year ago 2
oh I agree...I was just saying that this wasn't the only battle between of divas (replying 2 some1 else's comment)...fantasia, latoya, and jennifer were definitely collectively better than melinda, lakisha, and jordin...
qCLEFJones 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Regine Velaquez' version is alot better. But JH's version was OK.
anteroseros 2 years ago
not really though she has very little soul in her voice, too much technicality, nice try though sweetheart =)
Randalina1 2 years ago
stupid song that got her eleminated i love how she sound but i hate that song just for her and my idol looks great sounds great just perfect ms. miya aka lil jhud
miyalashay 2 years ago
wow!!! shes really great
vprowess 2 years ago 3
scarry!
alexies4u 2 years ago
Comment removed
lilseaxydee 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I THINK THE RIGHT PERSON WON
lilseaxydee 2 years ago
man, i remember watching this. amazing, i was so shocked when she got eliminated that week. but oh well.
effinpeaz 2 years ago 2
.she has a unique unbelievable voice.
lilbroxavier 2 years ago 10
Wow, she's amazing
How could America let her leave before DeGarmo and Trias??? I Just can´t get it... I mean, She is defenetely one of the best singers from season 3.
This season finale should have been Hudson vs Barrino, and Jenny should have been the winner.
Kab0087 2 years ago 4
The reason is because they were splitting the vote. It should have come down to Latoya, Fantasia, and Jennifer ... unfortunately they all three appealed to the same demographic so the vote was split and Jennifer and Latoya were voted off before their time.
sfphilboy 2 years ago 2
but jst thiunk of her now...how mujj she has accomplished!!!!
she is amazing and idol was a stepping stone
DJFITTLER 2 years ago 2
ive seen her film dreamgirls definetely i can say that she deserves to win that oscar awards, shes a better actress than a singer.
acs26 2 years ago
try to compare regine velasquez and jennifer hudson version of this song youll see what i am talking about. this is classical not an rnb type of song.
acs26 2 years ago
except that barry manilow who wrote the song loved jennifer's rendition so much he invited her to sing with him the next day on the Today Show. jennifer put an r&b spin to the song but still retained its power and emotion. regine just sang the song pretty well (not great but well), nowhere near as good or original as this rendition sorry.
ferosha99 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jen hudson ovesung this sing that pretty much killed the message of it. for me i thought a song as sincere lile this should never take on the way jen did because its untouchable and already beautiful for her to take on a song as untouchable like this would just be a blasphemy to everyone who loves the song.. regine sung the song from her heart you are numb if you didnt feel that and this one was just a trainwreck compare to regine's version
acs26 2 years ago
You coundn't be more wrong. Jennifer sang to the strength of her voice. Barry Manilow himself helped to arrange this & said that he couldn't do what she could with the song. He was almost speechless with pride and this is HIS song. Jennifer has a special type of voice which helped he to win her Academy Award & Grammy. Songs are subject to interpretation. I felt this version much more. She was the best singer on Idol and she should won. The only reason why she didn't is because God had better.
renzy79 2 years ago 23
i agree w/ renzy79. This was the moment when I knew Jennifer was a superstar talent. She took a sappy Manilow song and made it the anthem it had the potential to be. a classic performance
bristolstomp 2 years ago 4
It's called soul!
TDoeful 2 years ago
this is good but not great. not just her best performance.. she should have sing "if i should love again or sandra intead of this since this song requires more emotion that shouting and screeching, that obviously she failed to give.
acs26 2 years ago
Hey, this is America. It's a free country and you have every right to be wrong. :)
beefmageditor 2 years ago
God, Simon has aged so much in just a few short years.
beefmageditor 2 years ago
This was undeniably one of the 5 best idol performances ever. I mean, ever. But Jenny had the last laugh. Ask Taylor Hicks if he'd like an Academy Award and a Golden Globe in exchange for his "Idol" crown. LOL
beefmageditor 2 years ago
i hate the part when she almost shouting and screeching..
acs26 2 years ago
Which part was that? LOL I don't hear it at all. I hear an amazingly powerful vocalist hitting notes in pitch-perfect form.
beefmageditor 2 years ago
the end note
acs26 2 years ago
Wow, I've never heard anybody "shout" or "screech" with perfect vibrato before. LOL
beefmageditor 2 years ago
HAH - me neither. Or pull off a triple-octave key change. But hey, maybe I'm on crack.
TommyGDub 2 years ago 4
The vocal is good but this performance lacks of emotion. i couldnt feel the longing and the pain the song was exactly trying to convey.
acs26 2 years ago
Lacks emotion????? What color is the sky on the planet where you live? LOL
beefmageditor 2 years ago
I agree man.
sixfobrutha 3 years ago
because of the "split of the vote"
lilbroxavier 3 years ago
this is my fav from her and i still dont get how she lost after this!
bananacraz06 3 years ago 5