In order of dancing of the best in Indian cinema i would rate it as follows :- 1. Kumari Kamala ( Kamala Laxman) 2. Sayee Subbulakshmi sisters 3. Travancore sisters 4. Padmini on her own 5. Vyjayanthimala 6. Ragini ( Padmini's sister) 7. L Vijayalakshim 8. EV Saroja 9. Kum Kum 10. Asha Parekh 11. Waheeda Rehman 12. Meenakshi Seshadri 13. Komal Mahuvakar 14. Sridevi 15. Madhuri Dixit 16. Helen ( would be deserving a top spot also) 17. Shobana ( neice of Padmini) NO MORE
Lets not forget the Sayee Subbulakshmi sisters as well. Watch aplam chaplam and some others on yt and you will know what i mean. Padmini was more sharp in her dance moves, while Vjyanti was more graceful and agile..Both were good as can be seen in the one all time dance competiton between the 2 in Vanjikottai Valiban. But i must say that Vyjaynti had excellent facial expressions when dancing and that was one of the reasons she scored over the rest of them..but Kumari Kamala was still No. 1..
i think its unfair to compare two dancing legends. While Padmini belonged to the famous trio called Travancore sisters, Lalitha, Padmini and Ragini who were all accomplished dancers although Padmini was more popular as she did acting roles as well. Vyjayanthimala also was an established dancer and actress as well. while i agree L Vijayalakshmi was a super dancer those days, i believe still Kumari Kamala or Kamala Lakshman was the the best among them all.
Padmini was a good dancer but not so good as actress. She spoke with accent and quite bland in her facial expressions. Vyjayanthimala was more beautiful and better in dancing and was excellent actress as well. In facial resemblance B. Saroja Devi was closer to V. Mala than Padmini.
@bharath1957 Saroja Devi only took her acting seriously towards the near end of her career. Initially she was just a glam doll in most of the MGR movies, although almost all of her movies had memorable songs..she did good in Pazhum Pazhamum though..towards the end of 1968 she acted in K. Balanchander's Thamarai Nenjam in a solid role and went on to act in other good movies like Kuzha Villaku and so forth..but that was the near end of her career. she quit acting in 1972 post Pathu Masam Bandam
Waah! one of the few videos with 0 dislikes!..it deserves only likes! :) What a song..heard it on the radio aaj subeh and have been humming it since. :) It has a tinge of sadness..yet it is fast paced..and the uniqueness? a conversation between a young woman and a kath putli...and of course Lata Mangeshkar-Shankar-Jaikishen's wonderful combination! :) Vaijanthi Mala was lovely back then..vivacious yet demure n sweet :)
When this Picture was on set Mr. Amiy Chakrabarti )Pro.&dir.) passed away and News Paper wrote nice Headline - Dekh karbira Roya Amiy Chakrabarti soya.This moovie I saw in Kolkata (that time calcutta)& I lve since that time all songs composed by S J.
Hello, thanks for sharing that tit-bit..it's always nice to know about the making of such classics..especially since we hardly have any pictures and no videos of it.
OMG- I am just transported into another world watching this gem of gems. Vyjayanthimala is like a bird in full flight.....absolutely natural, fantastic, ethereal dancing....if there's a better dancer I am yet to see! Watch her in Naya Daur(ude jab jab) and we know we are witnessing a sublime art. Lata didi brings all emotions to the fore with that golden/fresh voice of hers in 50's....the music, singing, dancing all make us feel that we are rushing to a climax like a brook becoming torrent!
It feels nice to have such great expression & passion coming from younger generation for Golden Era music of Bollywood. Thanks for excellent response.
@Voltairec i accept that Vaijantimala was a great dance, but one actress was even better than her but she never got such fame and recognisation and her name was Padmini. they both looked like twins. so producers who did not have budget to sign V. Mala signed Padmini., thus she is better known as allibi of V. Mala
@gasperagacy Yup Padmini even looks more beautiful. But I would say L Vijayalaxmi trumps them all....she acted in many telugu movies and her dancing prowess is matchless. But V'mala was an exceedingly good actress in addition to the incredible dancing skill...that must have clinched it!
Thanks Bharat Desaiji, I m proud od S J - Sailendra-Hasarat-(Dattaram-Sabastian trheir asstt.) All made For ever songs, lyrics-Orchestra, interlude of other instruments all is "LAJAWAB" Thanks for upload. Batavia - New York
geetu humara jiwam bhi kuchh aisa hi hai. na jane jiwan me kon ,kahan, kyon, kaise mil jata ha jo nahin bhulata hi ek pal ke lye bhi.. kyon pyar hho jata hai us se. love u geetu.
Song, whether sad or happy, SJ could swing all over with fanstatic orchestrizaion and can comback right at the base/mood of the tune smooth as anything.......to continue........ tempo (sad or happy) a bi
S and J and the voice of the goddess. Can't ask for more.
91943 4 months ago
You are absolutely right.
BharatDesai6 4 months ago
Heart touching song.. supeb dance from vyajantimala ji..
Mr8802571340 5 months ago
Thanks.
BharatDesai6 5 months ago
wonderful show by vyjayantimala and great song by lata mangeshker
veroo5 6 months ago
You are right, friend.
BharatDesai6 6 months ago
Oops i forgot Rajshree another dancing wonder and Sandhya too..
tonynaso 7 months ago
Thanks for your all informative comments. All were entertainers & had their own fans.
BharatDesai6 7 months ago
tonynaso 7 months ago
Lets not forget the Sayee Subbulakshmi sisters as well. Watch aplam chaplam and some others on yt and you will know what i mean. Padmini was more sharp in her dance moves, while Vjyanti was more graceful and agile..Both were good as can be seen in the one all time dance competiton between the 2 in Vanjikottai Valiban. But i must say that Vyjaynti had excellent facial expressions when dancing and that was one of the reasons she scored over the rest of them..but Kumari Kamala was still No. 1..
tonynaso 7 months ago
i think its unfair to compare two dancing legends. While Padmini belonged to the famous trio called Travancore sisters, Lalitha, Padmini and Ragini who were all accomplished dancers although Padmini was more popular as she did acting roles as well. Vyjayanthimala also was an established dancer and actress as well. while i agree L Vijayalakshmi was a super dancer those days, i believe still Kumari Kamala or Kamala Lakshman was the the best among them all.
tonynaso 7 months ago
Padmini was a good dancer but not so good as actress. She spoke with accent and quite bland in her facial expressions. Vyjayanthimala was more beautiful and better in dancing and was excellent actress as well. In facial resemblance B. Saroja Devi was closer to V. Mala than Padmini.
orientlover1 9 months ago
@orientlover1
Very good observation. Thanks.
BharatDesai6 9 months ago
@orientlover1 B.saroja devi a junk actress
bharath1957 7 months ago
@bharath1957 Saroja Devi only took her acting seriously towards the near end of her career. Initially she was just a glam doll in most of the MGR movies, although almost all of her movies had memorable songs..she did good in Pazhum Pazhamum though..towards the end of 1968 she acted in K. Balanchander's Thamarai Nenjam in a solid role and went on to act in other good movies like Kuzha Villaku and so forth..but that was the near end of her career. she quit acting in 1972 post Pathu Masam Bandam
tonynaso 7 months ago
Waah! one of the few videos with 0 dislikes!..it deserves only likes! :) What a song..heard it on the radio aaj subeh and have been humming it since. :) It has a tinge of sadness..yet it is fast paced..and the uniqueness? a conversation between a young woman and a kath putli...and of course Lata Mangeshkar-Shankar-Jaikishen's wonderful combination! :) Vaijanthi Mala was lovely back then..vivacious yet demure n sweet :)
WorldOnWeb84 10 months ago
Excellent Observation & Expression For This Beauty Of A Song. I like Happy Version little more. Thanks for nice response.
BharatDesai6 10 months ago
All are UNIQUE in their own way. Thanks for response.
BharatDesai6 9 months ago
Eventhough I haven't seen the movie, I had cherished this song ( mainly happy verson), I enjoyed SJ's Music very much.
Udisubh 11 months ago
@Udisubh I too love SJ music. KathPutli was their Best. Thanks.
BharatDesai6 11 months ago
When this Picture was on set Mr. Amiy Chakrabarti )Pro.&dir.) passed away and News Paper wrote nice Headline - Dekh karbira Roya Amiy Chakrabarti soya.This moovie I saw in Kolkata (that time calcutta)& I lve since that time all songs composed by S J.
Vipin283 1 year ago 2
Fantastic input from your Treasure, Vipin ji. Thank you so much.
BharatDesai6 1 year ago
@Vipin283
heh!
Hello, thanks for sharing that tit-bit..it's always nice to know about the making of such classics..especially since we hardly have any pictures and no videos of it.
thankyou. :)
WorldOnWeb84 10 months ago
Sad version of the song. Very nice. Thank you for the upload.
Music: Shankar Jaikishan
Lyric: Shailendra
RealMusicKing 1 year ago 2
Yes, it is. Both versions beautifully expressed by V.Mala.Thanks.
BharatDesai6 1 year ago 2
wonder full song.wonderfull music o s-j.
sumitganguly14 1 year ago
@sumitganguly14 Yes, It Is Wonderful. Thanks.
BharatDesai6 1 year ago
OMG- I am just transported into another world watching this gem of gems. Vyjayanthimala is like a bird in full flight.....absolutely natural, fantastic, ethereal dancing....if there's a better dancer I am yet to see! Watch her in Naya Daur(ude jab jab) and we know we are witnessing a sublime art. Lata didi brings all emotions to the fore with that golden/fresh voice of hers in 50's....the music, singing, dancing all make us feel that we are rushing to a climax like a brook becoming torrent!
Voltairec 1 year ago 4
It feels nice to have such great expression & passion coming from younger generation for Golden Era music of Bollywood. Thanks for excellent response.
BharatDesai6 1 year ago
@Voltairec
Very well said! :) we all agree with you :)
WorldOnWeb84 10 months ago
@Voltairec i accept that Vaijantimala was a great dance, but one actress was even better than her but she never got such fame and recognisation and her name was Padmini. they both looked like twins. so producers who did not have budget to sign V. Mala signed Padmini., thus she is better known as allibi of V. Mala
gasperagacy 9 months ago
@gasperagacy Yup Padmini even looks more beautiful. But I would say L Vijayalaxmi trumps them all....she acted in many telugu movies and her dancing prowess is matchless. But V'mala was an exceedingly good actress in addition to the incredible dancing skill...that must have clinched it!
Voltairec 9 months ago
Thanks Bharat Desaiji, I m proud od S J - Sailendra-Hasarat-(Dattaram-Sabastian trheir asstt.) All made For ever songs, lyrics-Orchestra, interlude of other instruments all is "LAJAWAB" Thanks for upload. Batavia - New York
Vipin283 1 year ago
Thank you for you nice informative response, Vipin ji. Best Wishes.
BharatDesai6 1 year ago
This woman is incredible!!!
NoRegretsNot1 1 year ago
geetu humara jiwam bhi kuchh aisa hi hai. na jane jiwan me kon ,kahan, kyon, kaise mil jata ha jo nahin bhulata hi ek pal ke lye bhi.. kyon pyar hho jata hai us se. love u geetu.
gatuu1941 1 year ago
@gatuu1941 Who is your Geetu & How you want your Message to reach her?
BharatDesai6 1 year ago
Song, whether sad or happy, SJ could swing all over with fanstatic orchestrizaion and can comback right at the base/mood of the tune smooth as anything.......to continue........ tempo (sad or happy) a bi
Rmehtacpa 2 years ago 2
I agree, Ranjit Bhai. Thank you for nice response & love for SJ who are my Fav too. Best Wishes.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
Truly one of SJ's finest.
graphikamaal 2 years ago 2
You are absolutely right.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
Long live Shankar, Jaikishan, Shailendra and Lata . This is a gem in music.
buttegowda 2 years ago 2
You are absolutely right. Thanks.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
Vyjaybtimala played role of papet and this song's music used maximum orcastra by SJ its mile stone- nice words of lyrics
thanks upload good song.Vipin
Vipin283 2 years ago 2
Their Best as per SJ themselves. Thanks for nice response.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
Was the director of this movie Phani Majumdar?
iseeking 2 years ago
It was Amiya Chakraborty.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
wah wah An immortal MAGIC CLIP OF LATAJI-VIJYANTIMALA ON SHANKER-JAIKISHEN MUSIC FROM KATHPUTLI. Happy version is even more enchanting.
aceji 2 years ago 2
I fully agree with you. Thanks for nice response.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
Enchanting film song, haunting melody &
lyrics, splended voice of Lata + classical
dances by Vijayantimala. It's entertaining.
Radda001 2 years ago 2
Some body said that Shankar Jaikishan considered this as their one of finest creation. You rightly said it. Thanks.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago
Beautiful Kathakali piece by Vyjayanthimala...she plays out her minnukku role flawlessly...
mughaleazamfan 2 years ago
You are right. Thanks for your comment.
BharatDesai6 2 years ago