I had never really bothered with Editors before this song, but a friend recommended it to me, and I'm so glad he did! It is such an amazing song, and I love the meaning behind it :) well at least my personal interpretation of it!
Simply put, I LOVE Editors & expecially this song! ♥
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Curse me all you want, but I think this a sh*t-boring song with meaningless cr*p lyrics. Just heard it on the radio and I thought it was The Killers (another band who should just go away).
@Geshreeyeh what's boring about an intricate riff, great drumming and a deep, soleful voice??? And ambiguous lyrics aren't meaningless- you're meant to decide what they mean for yourself...
@Geshreeyeh all the time i read comment like this i would like to ask that person what he listens to,what is not in his opinion boring shit and what lyrics are not crap,can you give us an example pretty please:)
@Scarletton Sure, seeing as you asked so nicely. Songs I have been enjoying recently include halleluhah and Hiding All Away by Nick cave and the Bad Seeds, Lavender Hill by The Real Tuesday Weld, Not the Same by Ben Folds, Dick Around by Sparks, Southside of the World by Bonnie Prince Billy and Love etc. by The Pet Shop Boys (oh, and Deeply Dippy by Right Said Fred).
@Geshreeyeh This song boring? That makes no sense at all. I totally agree with hugthepoobear! And the lead singers of the Killers and the Editors have completely different voices. You should come up with good arguments, otherwise you should be the one to go away.
If you don't like this song, why do you listen to it?
Why are all the highest rated comments related to the dislike button? How about we start giving the people who post the imaginative and articulate comments a bit of praise?
@lbomb8 i've editors live 4 times now, editors are one of weakest live bands ive ever seen and ive seen interpol. they are both as bad as each other live...
@cwebbfan You clearly have the intellect to outwit anyone on here! How could i pick a fight with a man with such intelligence!!! Of course i am joking!!! You're so fucking dumb the only benefit of your existence is you're a reminder to people they need to add a cabbage to their shopping list.
@blakscull , maybe not in this song but if you take "all sparks" you could play it with Joy Division "dead souls" and never notice the difference. Anyway i'0m not criticizing..actually i love them...i'm just happy this post-punk sound is back to new life.
Is it me or dont they sound exactly the same as Interpol. Both singers sound exactly the same as Ian Curtis out of Joy Division. Joy Division were great but this miserableist stuff makes me wanna grab my teddy and cry myself to sleep.
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT something bad will happen. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS ACTUALLY WORKS
I avoided this song for a while because my chief at work played this song just to many times.. but now i realize it was totally deserved. Perfect voice, perfect song..
What happened to Editors? I used to love their music, they were my favourite band. I saw them live at Leeds in 2008 and they were brilliant. Ever since their last techno inspired album I've just lost interest.
I usually like bands which change their sound and experiment like U2, Radiohead and Coldplay. Please Editors go back to the good ol' days.
@rad3212001 if ur going to make musical comparisons, i would say they r of the same genre as interpol and from there r.e.m and it all comes full circle seeing as r.e.m covered the editor's munich track on one of that awful jo whiley show's (may it rest in piece) live sessions a couple of years back, all ur goin on is singers voices havin similar tones
@rad3212001 im not trying to educate u so no need to prompt me with me telling u singers names, i guess though if ur going to be compared to anyone, theres no shame in being compared to musical icons, and it's all subjective isnt it, if someone compared them to abba, if they believe that, then its their view, its not wrong, sorry if i came across preachy, take care
It seems like I hear a lot of "the Editors are just a Joy Division ripoff"...Joy Division doesn't have a claim on a certain vocal style, and I personally much prefer the Editors' music, as do lots of other people.
@chrizmeister1992 werchter dit jaar! maar de maat die ik mee had genomen vond het werkelijk verschrikkelijke muziek (hij wist eigenlijk niet wat er nou verschillend was aan de nummers xD)
maar mischien houd 'ie wel van het nieuwe werk, of we gaan naar jack johnson = P
I heard this playing in a record shop and bought the cd. Pehaps, they were influenced by Joy Division, but they are fucking good anyway. And if you are going to be compared to someone, why not one of the most original bands who ever walked the earth ? Haha,in 10 years, someone else will be told they sound like the Editors.
I think Editors are greatt, I definitely hear the Ian Curtis thing about his voice, and the cover of "The Back Room" reminds me so much of Joy Division's "Closer" album cover.
I like 'Papillon' a lot, but Joy Division seems a little out of these guys' league. Editors songs lack a bit of variety, and the lyrics -however straightup- lack ingenuity and poetic worth. Just an opinion.
I can appreciate that they are talented musicians and make great music but the ripping off of Joy Division i can't forgive. Fair enough if they were inspired, but at least admit it - don't pretend you never heard of Ian Curtis. What a load of bollocks.
I'm 22 - not some old bitter diehard - and even I can see that JD are the true original sound and were also a much better band. This lead singer aint got shit on Ian!
where are they ripping off joy division? joy division dosnt sound anything like this, sure they have similar voice, but, dont blame him/them Tom was born with that voice.
there's also something to be said for the fact that we got what, 2 album and 4 years of activity out of Ian Curtis *cough* before I was born *cough*
I wouldt call it "ripping off" so much as being kindred spirits and being kindred spirits of a good thing, especially a rare and depleted good thing, is a grat thing.
138 people have an escaped rat at home.
Zeldafreakism 10 months ago
so amazing song i love this
vampiredamonericlove 10 months ago
singing style is very similar to ian curtis, really really captivating
newell123 10 months ago
grandi editors!bellissima canzone ,bellissimo video.
interpolik 10 months ago
when the time comes....
Atompunk 10 months ago
His Voice=Pure Sex.
MrSupermansgf 10 months ago
139 people don't like to race rats.
aakerlund199 11 months ago
what a voice
hEaTHy961 11 months ago
AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Shox2098 11 months ago
AMAZING SONG !!!!
TheSharonuppal1 11 months ago
that voice
JamesKAnalyzing 11 months ago
Does this remind of Lost to anyone else?
MrEjemploanonimo 11 months ago
the guitarist went to my school.trippy!
Mattseno101 11 months ago
Sorry to sound like a typical inarticulate Bieber fan, but I LOOOOOOOOOOOVEEE Editors.
Phleeper 1 year ago
amazing!!!! jedward fans dont like the editors FREAKS!!
scotiapug 1 year ago
this makes me wana watch donnie darko :/
arnold8100 1 year ago
which fucking knobheads don't like this ?
MegaSte1972 1 year ago
0:29 It always looks to me like Russell is grabbing a shotgun lol
LightsOfBohemia 1 year ago
I had never really bothered with Editors before this song, but a friend recommended it to me, and I'm so glad he did! It is such an amazing song, and I love the meaning behind it :) well at least my personal interpretation of it!
Simply put, I LOVE Editors & expecially this song! ♥
LilTwirlettexxx 1 year ago
such a marvelous voiceeee
jelkiii 1 year ago
Is this good? Nah. Great? Nah. Epic? OH YEAAH!
HelloIamBarnsy 1 year ago
SO COOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!
edenkazin 1 year ago
Its funny because i know Tom Smith's mum and dad personally. He looks nothing like them xD
lauramae1994 1 year ago
In the last years I didn't found something thet could be defined REAL music but Editors. Thank to them, I was rassured....music still live.
Tellthemoff 1 year ago
great rock'n roll in it, this is REAL music, and who does not agree can go and sell potatoes.
rmorcn 1 year ago
hate it or love it, and i sure as hell love this song.
dc0rleone14 1 year ago
I dance like a crazy person at the chorus, love this song sooo much.
MarisaShorty 1 year ago
seen them live last year...what a night!!! recommend them bigtime!
timmyaful 1 year ago
Fucking amazing!!! Yes He was in Interpol, Anyone who finds this boring, or a rip-off needs their head examined!!!!
MyDadsMusic1 1 year ago
wow
MarisaShorty 1 year ago
anyone noticed that they sound just like Interpol !?
marcinjbus 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Curse me all you want, but I think this a sh*t-boring song with meaningless cr*p lyrics. Just heard it on the radio and I thought it was The Killers (another band who should just go away).
Geshreeyeh 1 year ago
@Geshreeyeh what's boring about an intricate riff, great drumming and a deep, soleful voice??? And ambiguous lyrics aren't meaningless- you're meant to decide what they mean for yourself...
hugthepoohbear 1 year ago 2
@Geshreeyeh all the time i read comment like this i would like to ask that person what he listens to,what is not in his opinion boring shit and what lyrics are not crap,can you give us an example pretty please:)
Scarletton 1 year ago
@Scarletton Sure, seeing as you asked so nicely. Songs I have been enjoying recently include halleluhah and Hiding All Away by Nick cave and the Bad Seeds, Lavender Hill by The Real Tuesday Weld, Not the Same by Ben Folds, Dick Around by Sparks, Southside of the World by Bonnie Prince Billy and Love etc. by The Pet Shop Boys (oh, and Deeply Dippy by Right Said Fred).
Geshreeyeh 1 year ago
@Geshreeyeh This song boring? That makes no sense at all. I totally agree with hugthepoobear! And the lead singers of the Killers and the Editors have completely different voices. You should come up with good arguments, otherwise you should be the one to go away.
If you don't like this song, why do you listen to it?
Xehanort11 1 year ago
@Xehanort11 It was on the radio and I didn't have the option to switch it off. Get over it, it's just my opinion. Ignore me.
Geshreeyeh 1 year ago
I like turtles
rowanmcd 1 year ago
Rip-off merchants...
MCNOISE666 1 year ago
molaa!!
cArIsMaTic0o5721 1 year ago
this vid reminds me of muse- muscle museum's video cuz they r in neighbourhoods :P
st3voify 1 year ago
@st3voify Yeah xD I love both songs
PlugedInBaby 1 year ago
Released on my birthday? BEST PRESENT EVER!
mrtictac94 1 year ago 3
134 people missed the like button because they were being chased by the rats
xxlivenoworneverxx 1 year ago 5
i rember watchin this couple of years ago and i just thought, this band is something new something special.
lawrence096 1 year ago
This band is fucking awesome!!!!!!!!!!!
nelapsidarkangel 1 year ago
their best song
soweet4eva 1 year ago 2
the lead singer went to my school and his parents still teach there.
014538 1 year ago 2
Why are all the highest rated comments related to the dislike button? How about we start giving the people who post the imaginative and articulate comments a bit of praise?
zoopezoop 1 year ago 51
@zoopezoop Ooohhh the irony.
But yes, you're right.
WatchUProductions 1 year ago
@zoopezoop Well... thats because theres just not enough...
R3v3rs3s 1 year ago
@zoopezoop Is this Irony?
fgryson 1 year ago
How, in the name of god, can 131 people dislike this o.O... IT'S FUCKING GENIUS!
grasmaker 1 year ago
I love this song so much
SeriouslyRandom20 1 year ago
Tom has got the most beautiful voice I've ever heard! (and the face to die for btw) :o)
artia1982 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
MrStarbuck123 1 year ago 92
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrStarbuck123 wait.... she has a penis? :O
HARDCOREnl1337 1 year ago
@MrStarbuck123 he has a penis?
d4m1en 1 year ago 3
@d4m1en i don't think so
xoxNadeshxox 1 year ago
@MrStarbuck123 shemale alert!!!!!
HARDCOREnl1337 1 year ago
@MrStarbuck123 he doesn`t have any...
MexxColpeas 1 year ago
@MrStarbuck123 well there aint a bar any more so u can stop making shitty jokes
smelvin1994 1 year ago
@smelvin1994 I put that comment 3 months ago
MrStarbuck123 1 year ago
Tom is too amazing for words! But i must say I prefer him with a beardy thing... Moviestar handsome!
gurrflapoo 1 year ago
thts a feckin good circle
connorjoe4 1 year ago 4
Tom: Hey there, little girl. What are you drawing?
Girl: THE END IS NEAR! WE'RE ALL GONNA DIE!
Tom: Oh, ok.
LightsOfBohemia 1 year ago 6
@LightsOfBohemia
Oh, you kids with your Apocalypse and Doomsdays and baggy jeans
Madhijz 1 year ago
@Madhijz Lolpwnd XD
grasmaker 1 year ago
@Madhijz Hey Apocalyptica is a good band.
Michaelmop 1 year ago
@Michaelmop You probably missread my post
Madhijz 1 year ago
@Madhijz Oh, nvm then.
Michaelmop 1 year ago
@andromede06 Editors is not pop rock....
ClemCQD 1 year ago
if any1 knows the song on the CAMERA advert on E4 tell me it on ma channel plzzzzzz<3
xDaddyPuddingx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tuuuune
HighSeasons 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tuuuune
HighSeasons 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tuuuune
HighSeasons 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tuuuune
HighSeasons 1 year ago
tuuuune
HighSeasons 1 year ago
128 people surely missclicked, because this is freaking brilliant!
yoshigura 1 year ago 33
lol u said that 3 weeks ago and the song has now got 157 mil views hehe, awesome!
GeraldSilent2nd 1 year ago
@yoshigura SOME PEOPLE DONT LIKE HIS VOICE...... ITS TOO MATURE FOR THEM....
swsws7 1 year ago
I LOVE EDITORS!
jaigalaar97 1 year ago
@yoshigura
why, because it's turned into another suburban soft rock group? shit!
MothRoom 1 year ago
Who cares if interpol are better or not??
kaftoskaitsiou 1 year ago 5
@kaftoskaitsiou interpol's live show is weak. editors live shot..not weak.
lbomb8 1 year ago
@lbomb8 i've editors live 4 times now, editors are one of weakest live bands ive ever seen and ive seen interpol. they are both as bad as each other live...
robertgreally 1 year ago
INTERPOL IS MUCH BETTER!!! (so are the White Lies)
cwebbfan 1 year ago
@cwebbfan WTF has Interpol got to do with this??? Fucking stupid comment.
NHBEY39 1 year ago
@NHBEY39 Nige Hatch, stupid name
cwebbfan 1 year ago
@cwebbfan You clearly have the intellect to outwit anyone on here! How could i pick a fight with a man with such intelligence!!! Of course i am joking!!! You're so fucking dumb the only benefit of your existence is you're a reminder to people they need to add a cabbage to their shopping list.
NHBEY39 1 year ago
@cwebbfan they both have songs better then the others average....
EXLAsteryz 1 year ago
@cwebbfan then fuck off
AidanLod 1 year ago
@AidanLod eyeluvu1000 ?????
cwebbfan 1 year ago
fuckin great tune.
DanielMcDrtcomposer 1 year ago
brilliant at Glastonbury.... 'I keep up with the racing rats and do my best to win'
lauraheartsdmusic 1 year ago
Saw them live as a special guest at a Muse concert. Fucking great!
Spinoraptorrex 1 year ago 3
go editors :)
wouterbo1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if you like this, check out Dillon Campbell's "Absence of Lies"
SilverZipperRecords 1 year ago
@blakscull , maybe not in this song but if you take "all sparks" you could play it with Joy Division "dead souls" and never notice the difference. Anyway i'0m not criticizing..actually i love them...i'm just happy this post-punk sound is back to new life.
derfel1973 1 year ago
Comment removed
derfel1973 1 year ago
Saw them saterday @ MUSE they we're awsome!
Gr8 preformance and gr8 voice!
xDieNoob 1 year ago
I was the wednesday in the concert os muse and the editors played before and i can say that they are great band of music and they have a good direct
javipi92 1 year ago 2
with our chemistry lesson this video was used to show the eclipse.
well I never liked chemistry and I never will, but this song made the lesson for once nice to be in.
mauddios1 1 year ago
Is it me or dont they sound exactly the same as Interpol. Both singers sound exactly the same as Ian Curtis out of Joy Division. Joy Division were great but this miserableist stuff makes me wanna grab my teddy and cry myself to sleep.
mingpowman76 1 year ago
I'm here due to the complements they got for their performance in Israel, and now I see why!
AnAvailibleUsername 1 year ago
I actually don't know these guys...but their a side act at muse so im gonna check if their good :D
BKiller94 1 year ago 3
Amazing! (L)
xoLisan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT something bad will happen. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS ACTUALLY WORKS
JanLeonard91 1 year ago
I avoided this song for a while because my chief at work played this song just to many times.. but now i realize it was totally deserved. Perfect voice, perfect song..
Zyhro 1 year ago
the singer sounds alot like Depeche mode :P
YouSuckS4life 1 year ago
One of the most epic video clips ever... I just love it so much <3 And the song is so perfect...
zmuppetz2 1 year ago
What happened to Editors? I used to love their music, they were my favourite band. I saw them live at Leeds in 2008 and they were brilliant. Ever since their last techno inspired album I've just lost interest.
I usually like bands which change their sound and experiment like U2, Radiohead and Coldplay. Please Editors go back to the good ol' days.
120Vanquish120 1 year ago
That guitar. Rarely does a more pleasurable sound pass my ears.
TheGentlemansShadow 1 year ago
If a plane was to fall from the sky, how big a whole would it leave?
About a twin towers sized hole?
wardster10 1 year ago 2
This is just awsome. =3
Editors is one of the greatest rockbands :)
Lenjaful 1 year ago
one of the greatest guitar riffs man
ieldepiel 1 year ago
guitar is amazing ! this song is awesome
ALLNAMESAREALLREADYT 1 year ago
Simple Beutiful Song .... F**k The Gaga POP .... Rock Is Not Dead
BADAROSCKY 1 year ago
@BADAROSCKY YEAHH!!! Fuck the bitches like lady gaga
Rock rules
ohmiabelamadunina 1 year ago 3
Wow!! I love this Joy Division song!! Oops, I mean Editors.
rad3212001 1 year ago
@rad3212001 if ur going to make musical comparisons, i would say they r of the same genre as interpol and from there r.e.m and it all comes full circle seeing as r.e.m covered the editor's munich track on one of that awful jo whiley show's (may it rest in piece) live sessions a couple of years back, all ur goin on is singers voices havin similar tones
bryngOneOn 1 year ago
@bryngOneOn ........good point. Anyway, I love Joy Division and thought he sounded like the singer Ian Curtis....that's his name, right?
rad3212001 1 year ago
@rad3212001 im not trying to educate u so no need to prompt me with me telling u singers names, i guess though if ur going to be compared to anyone, theres no shame in being compared to musical icons, and it's all subjective isnt it, if someone compared them to abba, if they believe that, then its their view, its not wrong, sorry if i came across preachy, take care
bryngOneOn 1 year ago
@bryngOneOn ......I actually drink when I write on here...so no, I take no offense to anything, later man.
rad3212001 1 year ago
good
dezz1911 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
someone just told me theyve done an england football song-t-under the guise zx84 englands hall of fame,he reckons they wrote it?
joemcm1 1 year ago
Does anyone know where they filmed this? Looks like somewhere in SoCal.
ViraLights 1 year ago
I believe the vid was shot outside of LA. that's what was said in an interview
ramses86 1 year ago
It seems like I hear a lot of "the Editors are just a Joy Division ripoff"...Joy Division doesn't have a claim on a certain vocal style, and I personally much prefer the Editors' music, as do lots of other people.
lidstrom82 1 year ago
This is a good song.
Kikyuras 1 year ago
well, this is poetry!:) awesome!
Zangarmash 1 year ago
They remind me so much of Interpol I love his voice :)
NikkyMonroe 1 year ago 3
my knob is enormous
redragon200 1 year ago
Stunning.
AnnaDraconida 1 year ago
The little girl is so cute. I love that song, Tom Smith is awesome.
Marypeter18 1 year ago
Interpol and Editors are my favorite bands :)
SquallBerserk 1 year ago
i've seen them couple of days ago in antwerp they are awesome:)
chrizmeister1992 1 year ago
@chrizmeister1992 spelen ze nog veel van het vorige album? ben gek op on this light, maar die vorige blijft toch me'n favoriet ^_^
garfreeek 1 year ago
@garfreeek jaja ze spelen nog een hoop van het vorige album:) twas egt een geweldig optreden:) vn plan om te gaan zien?
chrizmeister1992 1 year ago
@chrizmeister1992 werchter dit jaar! maar de maat die ik mee had genomen vond het werkelijk verschrikkelijke muziek (hij wist eigenlijk niet wat er nou verschillend was aan de nummers xD)
maar mischien houd 'ie wel van het nieuwe werk, of we gaan naar jack johnson = P
garfreeek 1 year ago 2
@chrizmeister1992
chrizmeister1992 1 year ago
Wil iemand kaartjes kopen voor het concert in de HMH vanavond??
zoek op marktplaats naar:
5 Kaartjes Editors HMH Heiniken Music Hall 1 mei 01/05/10
eggevanderleij 1 year ago
This is an AMAZING SONG! His voice IS GREAT! I love it!
spunkyfunky587 1 year ago
tony, gracias.Sigue sorprendiendome..
bluemooncharo 1 year ago
I'll go see they.
lizardkingist 1 year ago
I heard this playing in a record shop and bought the cd. Pehaps, they were influenced by Joy Division, but they are fucking good anyway. And if you are going to be compared to someone, why not one of the most original bands who ever walked the earth ? Haha,in 10 years, someone else will be told they sound like the Editors.
theMacvarish 1 year ago
Wow, boring...
vds54r43 1 year ago
Something really draws me to this band...
LaLaurenMichelle 1 year ago
@LaLaurenMichelle I had the same feeling when I heard them for the first time..
Lolzorro 1 year ago
creepy ending...
MrMoneymadManiac 1 year ago
nice song
MrCotopaxi 1 year ago
just brilliant. . .
gundish 1 year ago
i like the song!!!
tim0371 1 year ago
the little girl look kinda scary but this is a cool video and tht kool cause the of eclispe
\;;/ (º.º) \;;/ rock lol
MrLiljoker013 1 year ago
eclipse XD!!!
basspad1986 1 year ago
I think Editors are greatt, I definitely hear the Ian Curtis thing about his voice, and the cover of "The Back Room" reminds me so much of Joy Division's "Closer" album cover.
mothershipmdear 1 year ago
i agree great voice brilliant live up their wiv doves
preadman83 1 year ago
This is their best song, it's SO powerful
deppaddiction 1 year ago
Why do they die at the end?
xD3MENT1Ax 1 year ago
becus everyone dies
knabbel1045 1 year ago
mm this voice)))
i like it)))
SilenceJude 1 year ago
buccigross , avery anyone?
rjets42 1 year ago
out of a rough 3000 people how could 199 people not like this song... =(
thekilladave101 1 year ago
I like 'Papillon' a lot, but Joy Division seems a little out of these guys' league. Editors songs lack a bit of variety, and the lyrics -however straightup- lack ingenuity and poetic worth. Just an opinion.
EatTheTele 1 year ago
nice song for sure
alkalinetrio751 1 year ago
thank You for Jarocin it Was reallly rock no matter what...Poland
00Franca00 1 year ago
editors, interpol and joy division nuff said
banditDOG11 1 year ago 5
@banditDOG11 omg i totally agree :D
bombifier 1 year ago
oh no i accidentally rated it 1* i can't cancel it it's worth 5*
Actually it's worth way more than 5*, but that isn't an option. :P
ddemonicflame 1 year ago 3
@ddemonicflame:
Never mind, the total is still close to 5*.
frijmann 1 year ago
I can appreciate that they are talented musicians and make great music but the ripping off of Joy Division i can't forgive. Fair enough if they were inspired, but at least admit it - don't pretend you never heard of Ian Curtis. What a load of bollocks.
I'm 22 - not some old bitter diehard - and even I can see that JD are the true original sound and were also a much better band. This lead singer aint got shit on Ian!
ArchangelProduction5 1 year ago
where are they ripping off joy division? joy division dosnt sound anything like this, sure they have similar voice, but, dont blame him/them Tom was born with that voice.
blakscull 1 year ago 52
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol if u cant hear Joy Division in Editors ur stupid as fuck
ArchangelProduction5 1 year ago
and you are saying that if it sounds similar its a rip off, im stupid? then i cant imagine what are you
blakscull 1 year ago
@blakscull
there's also something to be said for the fact that we got what, 2 album and 4 years of activity out of Ian Curtis *cough* before I was born *cough*
I wouldt call it "ripping off" so much as being kindred spirits and being kindred spirits of a good thing, especially a rare and depleted good thing, is a grat thing.
just my 2 cents.
MGWorldwide 1 year ago 3
@blakscull He was born with it? Shit, that must have been one manly baby.
peanutbrittle50 1 year ago
@peanutbrittle50 yes he was, scare the shit out the doctors
blakscull 1 year ago
@blakscull They say the same shit about Interpol, bands like these can't be compared.
SquallBerserk 1 year ago
@blakscull
Just totally agreed. Joy Divison was a great band though.
jesslin72 1 year ago
@blakscull their whole last album (I know this isnt on it) sounded like a joy division tribute, which is no bad thing...postscript IN MY OPINION
jonnylazer 1 year ago
@blakscull
No thery are not ripping from JD, they are ripping from the Chameleons but not as much as Interpol
Cosmopavone 1 year ago