What If (Celtic/BlackBird Mix) & Liar (Manic Depressive Mix)

[dontyourememberme]

Awesome version of What If =)

[BrainDeadIntellect]

I think it's amazing how you have a lighter song and then a really dark one on the same video. <3 It contrasts both eras; enchant and opheliac.

[LordKatzeify]

LOL willst du mich leiden sehn? unendlich leiden sehn? :D I laugh my ass off!

[kyle091223]

I do like the original version of liar and the manic depression of liar is really amazing too! :) I'll give this 5 stars and favorited.

[Liciatje]

Before I watched this video,, I totally loved What If Celtic Version... but I never knew there was a remix of Liar .. I don't really like it.. but Emilie is stil awesome<3

[Farewellloveable]

ah!!!!!!!! I don't like the german guy in it! It doesn't even sound like Emilie then it reminds me of that one band...that I can't remember the name of :p

[ProudToBeAPlaguerat]

it's the singer of ASP :3

[keiradomino]

Emilie and ASP together, what a beautiful combination! I love both so Liar is my favourite song :-)

[nygosona]

@ProudToBeAPlaguerat Yes,his name is Alexander F. Spenge-so the band is called "ASP"! He´s on the same record as Emilie,so they made this amazing song together... (-;

[Semirhage666]

Both are better than the originals, and the Liar one is the best remix ever!

[RoseandButterflies]

Now everytime I listen to the original Liar, I seem to always hear the German guy singing in my left ear. Odd... strange.... I don't know if it's good or not.

[evanescenthe]

I prefer the original version of LIAR, but that's however a good one.

[samara1313]

Nothing beats the original. :)

[Shinigamieyes666]

I listen to it for the first time,but sounds really deep.Her voice is so confusing,but beautifully confusing...

[mikebud420]

she got a great voice!!!! I dont hear her songs that much but i def hear Liar a lot ha ha. I really love Brandon Smalls remix of liar..... just cuz i like her yelling constantly and the music is heavier.

Although this is a great one as well.

[louiseduvee]

Gotta say these are the best remixes in general... Kudos to all you busy little synth bees!

Thanks much!

[spiegelnder]

Both songs that sound here are from my favorites.

And what nice versions!

I like them as much as the originals ^_^

(In the second one she had collaborated with ASP!?)

[gerymylove]

I totally agree, these versions are really really great...

and yeah, she did collaborate with ASP... And I quite like the result even though I don´t like ASP *g*

[Opheliac01313]

My favorite Song......

Emilie Autumn 4-ever

xD

[kevzgurl]

What a bebeautiful version of What If. I think I might like it better than the original.

[argentor16]

en fait j'ai trouvé, c'est mylène farmer en pire.

sa voix chevrotte, telle une pauvrette qui vient de croiser un exhibitioniste, et qu'a toujours pas compris commnt ça marche...

ridiculissime.

et le mot est faible

[ladybizkid]

this picture of her is so beautiful

[gueritaisabel1]

@ladybizkid Thanks you. Nah, jk. xD bUT YEAH, SHE DOES, doesn;t she?

[GothicBodomGirl]

The first is beautiful. The song has a lot of personal importance to me, so makes me all emotional to listen to how beautiful this is. *^^*

[LilMissLacy1128]

LOVE these remixes!! and she looks gorgeous in that picture :)

[ZeeULater]

I Adore them !

[aleciawells]

i love these remix's more than the originals!

[cross666fade]

I love that first pic of her! She NEEDS to wear her hair down more often in photoshoots. ;)

[PoisenMuffen]

The pic is a digital portrait...But yeah, she does need to wear her hair down more :)

[miekkiej]

Hail to emilie xD

[dangel6667]

wow thats just amazing, i love it :D

[rolipoli12]

i swaer i just started to cry. thats am amazing

[xXShayMarieXx]

I like this song better then the Orginal "What If" this is like my theme song, too =)

[xDeadxVampirex]

Love the picture. ^^

[CrMami]

who mixed this?

very nice.

[samara1313]

ASP made the Liar remix.

I dont know who made the What if remix..

[Tyraxio]

@samara1313 Emilie made most of the remixes herselv, the celtic What If too :-)

[tigerbaby6]

can u name the songs?

[AngelHael]

They're in the title... Pay attention. >.>

[tigerbaby6]

haha yeh i noticed aftr i wrote this.. >.> OOPS

[tigerbaby6]

she has a really pretty voice.

[KleinerFarbklecks]

yes :)

[BotoxEngel]

Its the singer from ASP!

[Leonie19]

Woah, this is a great mix of two great remixes of two great songs! ^^

[DarkCrow1303]

the voice of the man is like the voice of the singer of blutengel the voice man of course

[AlarminglyEnchanted]

-.-

i hope thats not the lame german band i think it is..

[samara1313]

Its ASP... ._.

[ChibiPandaAssassin]

german band?

[BlueSkiesSeven]

Asp is a german band.. and I think, they are great!

[smugbstard]

Me too ASP are stunning :o)

[laxbellexmort]

What exactly is being said in German? I suck at translating.

[sinathebeast]

he said : want you see me sorrow^^

[sinathebeast]

@ hellangel0990

[xxLacrymosa]

'Willst Du mich leiden sehen' means 'Do you want to see me suffering', and 'Unendlich leiden sehen' means 'To see me endless suffering'.

[SoffoO]

Do you think non-german people can read what they hear in the song?

[thexfallenxangel]

yeah, they can. some of my friends aren't german and they can read it. i'm german, so i help them out.

[SoffoO]

That's what I meant, you're helping them out :P

[hellsangel0990]

this is amazing. keep up the work! :]

[schatzy2]

sooo toll alle beide... freu mich auf den 27.12. wenn sie in der rofa ist!!

[poisondesires]

what a contrast between the two songs...

[xxLacrymosa]

'Unendlich Leiden seh'n' too.^^

I love the song Liar...I like the Manic Depressive Mix too, but the male vocals annoy me a bit.^^ I still like the original version better.

Does Emilie speak or understand German, too? She seems to be often in Austria & Germany, and now these German Vocals on Liar...

[Schattenhieb]

I love EA and ASP. ^__^

Willst du mich leiden sehen? <- thats german. ^__^V

[elecktra788]

this isnt the celtic mix of what if its the balck bird mix

[samara1313]

really`? are you sure? i downloaded it from a paysite :S

[elecktra788]

im positive

[samara1313]

ok.

[elecktra788]

your welcome

[uliduli]

naah, i'd say it's the celtic mix...got it on the a bit o this & that album...

[samara1313]

did u download it or buy it?

[uliduli]

i bought it^^.

[hellsangel0990]

What site did you get this from? i want it for my ipod :]

[hellsangel0990]

its the celtic mix. thats what she has on her itunes.

[uliduli]

Man, this manic depressive mix...i love it even more then the original version^^

[reflectionsfade3]

This versio f What If makes her even more beautiful.

[socialtiger]

this song is amazing!!!!!!

[misery667]

The gentleman on the LIAR: "Manic Depressive Mix" is the vocalist of a german band that Emilie Autumn likes very much called ASP,which happens to be a VERY GOOD Gothic / Alternative / Rock band if you'd ask me,they're one of my favorites too.

[MagnumRexx]

I love the Celtic mix --- and Emilie Autumn's look! I wish I took this photograph but I'd probably be trembling too much.

[AndrezaT666]

wow, i likey the liar songs. its sweet. reminds me of rammstien in a way.

[SoffoO]

I wonder who the guy is... Sounds really like Rammstein... Hmmm :P

[Karmamaid]

Yeah, I also wonder who this guy is who can remix this awesome song in such a shitty, poor and awful way. He sings like he never had any music lessons.

[uliduli]

mh, the guy's the singer of asp a german gothic band

[SoffoO]

Wow, weird... but great, haha! I think I like this Manic Depressive Mix...

PS: First Comment!