If you make the Lords of Kobal also be the Protoculture, it would be very easy to make Macross exsist as part of the BSG continuity. Cant wait for Battlestar Galactica: Of Blood and Chrome.
hey, what if a movei was made coneting the remasered BSG that conected it to Robotech? i could so see the 2 angels of Baltar and Caprica standing in the wasted earth saying "The cycle isn't broken" (If you've seen the last BSG episone and Robotech, you'd understand).
Kind of ironic that both have the same theme. Both have humans fighting in space and both are trying to get to earth. The Maross is like the Battlestar Galactica, VF-1 Valkries are like the Vipers.
In RDM's original draft of the finale, the Galactica crash lands in Central America
( before the last Ice Age ), and Present Day archaeologist uncover the ship.
"Someone is doing a new kind of survey of the mounds with some kind of ground-penetrating radar or something and lo and behold, we see the outlines of the Galactica still buried under the surface."
It was later decided that the end of the show to be directly related to us, not to a world where that event had occurred.
Pretty good. To bad BSG is on its last episodes or I'd say you have a position at their SFX dept. When oh when will a live action Robotech movie come out?
And you dont think Macross borrowed just a tiny bit from Battlestar?? Hmmm Lets see, A massive aircraft carrier in space that is defending refugee's while being pursued by a massive alien fleet. The first part of the show they are trying to get back to earth. Sounds like two of my favorite show's Battlestar and Macross.
Now I am not saying Macross ripped Battlestar or anything. But I am saying there might have been some inspiration.
Right, now "screw", as you say, Star Wars, seeing as it borrowed from just about every major Sci-Fi and Fantasy work in decades. I'm not sure why any of it matters, really. Each franchise is wildly different from the other. Weather is be a few passing, or dozens of similarity's, only the execution truly defines a a piece of work.
@twilightsol Actually, it wasn't taking from Yamato doing that, it was a more direct copy of 'Dogfights in space' based off of Dam Busters and similar WWII dogfight movies.
I think they all borrowed a bit from each other but back in 74-79 there was "Space Battleship Yamato" (started showing here in the states in 78 or 79 as "Star Blazers". It is practically the baseline of all the animation that followed and they all have similarities.
@twilightsol While there are some unique attributes that both shows shared, something must be said about the commonality that exists in all of human kind. While BG did a fairly good job of addressing those issues, Macross (at the time) delved even deeper. Having said that, the newer BG did a better job of tackling issues that might have been better left untouched back in 1980. With respect to the latest trouble Japan has had, I somehow believe that they, as a people, have a deeper view on life
@twilightsol There is only a three year difference between when the series were released, and anime, especially back then took longer to produce, if anything they were in creation at about the same time. Also there was no Youtube or even worldwide broadcast of shows for the most part. Most likely neither crew knew about the other. Most shows have been inspired or had elements pulled from others. In some ways Lost in space predates both and has the similar theme of trying to get to Earth.......
@twilightsol Macross (and possibly Galactica ) was partly inspired by Space Battleship Yamato (Star Blazers in the US) where a lone ship has to find a planet that has help for a nuclear-bombed (by aliens) Earth. That came out in 1974, though only 1979 in the US.
Heh, from what I've experienced, I've seen a cult of fans who overindulged themselves into de-constructing people's work without the makers' consent way too much, and TAdventurer fails to admit the problem. Harmony Gold's tampering of Macross has polarized the American culture if not the world.
From what I've seen in the past 2-5 years, the fan culture has unwittingly helped hollywood like Harmony Gold de-constructed artist's work without the artist's consent, and it's gone out of control. Macross is a victim of that problem, and TAdventurer fails to admit it.
Macross has been tampered once by HG, the American Robetech fans helped HG sabotage Big West from distributing Macross to North America which resulted in a messy lawsuit between BW and HG/Tatusnoko. now TAdventurer wants to cause more trouble by de-imagining Kawamori's work into the BSG version of Macross? I'm overeacting? I don't think so. I'm no slave to compromise. PS: re-imagining=de-imagining. It's a simple equation.
Don't be such a Macross fan boy. I like both Robotech & Macross. The truth is that HG got the rights fair & square. No stealing there...
Get a grip... =/
(BTW, Due to the Macross franchise being in legal hell in Japan, RIGHT NOW A ROBOTECH LIVE ACTION FILM IS A 1000 TIMES MORE POSSIBLE THAN A MACROSS LA FILM).
Being a fanboy has nothing to do w/ my protests. I'm an advocate creative and intellectual rights. You're wrong, HG got the rights from Tatusnoko without Big West's consent. Also HG didn't give the Ishiguro, Aramaki, or the others from Studio Nue credit for those 3 anime shows. WHERE'S THE HONOR IN THAT? I'm fed up of looking at artists being cheated out of their work, and I'm not going indulge on my petty greed for Robotech at the expense of Big West/Studio Nue's rights. It's unethical.
"Harmony Gold's tampering of Macross has polarized the American culture if not the world"
WOW... That officially makes you the most hardcore of hardcore Macross fans. Harmony Gold re-dubbing a cartoon has polarized the culture of an entire planet???
Yet you come to Youtube and watch content without royalties? You are agro and contradictory. You say American this and that ... it was not Americas fault that later versions of Macross were so poorly conceived. THAT is what I consider the crime ...
Becuase you whine about royalties, yet you come here and watch content royalty free.
If you'd like to make a point to people, study the way they communicate, otherwise you simply do damage. Your statements were follishly nationalistsic, and now nobody is listening to you. Please feel better, and partake in life with joy and purpose, not anger and self destruction.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Dude? WTF!? STOP RIGHT THERE! For one thing, me watching content on U-Tube is irreveleant to my argument w/ this subject. I just watch them and express my opinions about them and give them ratings whether I praise them or bash them. Just b/c I view something controversial like Robotech on U-Tube doesn't contradict my argument on this video, so you're foolishly out of context here.
You should also ask WHY the rights issue came up, do know how much money is required fro Macross7? More than any in history practically, and that series is very weak by comparison. Likewise, the only reason the 'Robotech" thing was pieced together was BECAUSE they were trying to get it to the american market. This was unfortunately THEIR doing, as a response to OUR episode requirements.
Re-imagining as you put it is the foundation of mental evolution. Your very appreciation is born of this concept. You can view this video in many ways, none of which are destructive. I was just telling a friend the other day that if liked the new BSG he should check out the old Macross, even though they are unrelated, I found this video to be a good, yet vague, representation of that very sentiment. No "de-imagining" here. I think the thoughts YOU have conjured up are more destructive than any.
Bravo
captiansimmian 4 months ago
how about battlestar frontier
legonakonow 4 months ago
I WANT CLASSIC THEME FROM '78!!!
KaptinKilla 6 months ago
If you make the Lords of Kobal also be the Protoculture, it would be very easy to make Macross exsist as part of the BSG continuity. Cant wait for Battlestar Galactica: Of Blood and Chrome.
dave19941000 7 months ago
@dave19941000 i cant wait for the movie and then the tv show that follows :D
skycaprob 6 months ago
looks alot like the old star blazers/ space battleship yamoto
BBUCKK44 8 months ago
wow, great editing mr. adventurer. it seems like something new, even though it's from 28 years ago. great work.
jagonation 9 months ago
Which bsg soundtrack did you use ?
whitemanstand72 9 months ago
@whitemanstand72 this music is from the opening sequence of the first season that shown in the US.
WesOrion 7 months ago
@WesOrion thanks i'' check but thanks
whitemanstand72 7 months ago
fuckin wicked
OmegaPrime78 10 months ago
Global = Adama
Misa = Duala
Hikauru = Apollo
Minmay = Tory because she is useless
Focker = Starbuck in man form
Spartanz1170 1 year ago 4
@Spartanz1170 Max Sterling = Constanza "Hot-Dog"
cmsahe 7 months ago
@cmsahe No no no, Max Sterling ( Max Jenius if you go by original anime) as Helo after all he does marry an enemy combatant no?
Spartanz1170 1 month ago
@Spartanz1170 yes you are right.I mentioned Constanza "Hot Dog" because he is an ace pilot just like Max Sterling is. Halo isn't.
cmsahe 1 month ago
Awesome!
stab74 1 year ago
Me Likey!
shininginshadows 1 year ago
hey, what if a movei was made coneting the remasered BSG that conected it to Robotech? i could so see the 2 angels of Baltar and Caprica standing in the wasted earth saying "The cycle isn't broken" (If you've seen the last BSG episone and Robotech, you'd understand).
dave19941000 1 year ago
The original poster is completely right...BSG's arrival from us Earther's view...it really hasn't been done.
lordisaiah 2 years ago
@lordisaiah It was, albeit in a parody that somehow got much of the original cast to pretend it was real for a while.
ctraver 1 year ago
Could you do the a theme switch up with the Macross theme on BSG?
RoyalKnightVII 2 years ago
Kind of ironic that both have the same theme. Both have humans fighting in space and both are trying to get to earth. The Maross is like the Battlestar Galactica, VF-1 Valkries are like the Vipers.
HiroSuen 2 years ago 4
Frak yeah!
Ponchoandy 2 years ago
In RDM's original draft of the finale, the Galactica crash lands in Central America
( before the last Ice Age ), and Present Day archaeologist uncover the ship.
"Someone is doing a new kind of survey of the mounds with some kind of ground-penetrating radar or something and lo and behold, we see the outlines of the Galactica still buried under the surface."
It was later decided that the end of the show to be directly related to us, not to a world where that event had occurred.
Shadamachaeon 2 years ago 3
Interesting premise. Unfortunate it wasnt filmed and put on the DVD set as an extra for those who would have liked that ending.
DeathscytheRick 2 years ago
wow thats word have been a hell of a twist at the end no think if we did do that and found a ship under the ground makes you think lol
thomasmiller1 2 years ago
You should use All Along The Watchtower to Macross
smcneal057 2 years ago
Pretty good. To bad BSG is on its last episodes or I'd say you have a position at their SFX dept. When oh when will a live action Robotech movie come out?
msudreaming 3 years ago
Supposedly Toby Mcquire is working on one as we speak, er, type.
Wether thats a good thing or not I'll leave up to you.
EVA01X 3 years ago
Great job on this.
sixpackgenius 3 years ago
this is great!
ozmorphus 3 years ago
5/5. Another thing common about Macross and BSG: "Top Gun" with a half hint of "Star Trek".
NavyTopGun1 3 years ago
And you dont think Macross borrowed just a tiny bit from Battlestar?? Hmmm Lets see, A massive aircraft carrier in space that is defending refugee's while being pursued by a massive alien fleet. The first part of the show they are trying to get back to earth. Sounds like two of my favorite show's Battlestar and Macross.
Now I am not saying Macross ripped Battlestar or anything. But I am saying there might have been some inspiration.
twilightsol 3 years ago 12
Do some research.... now which came out first? Battlestar or Macross or better yet Robotech
robcrob 3 years ago 5
Now screw all of those and you'll come up with Star Wars
robcrob 3 years ago
Right, now "screw", as you say, Star Wars, seeing as it borrowed from just about every major Sci-Fi and Fantasy work in decades. I'm not sure why any of it matters, really. Each franchise is wildly different from the other. Weather is be a few passing, or dozens of similarity's, only the execution truly defines a a piece of work.
ChainX 3 years ago 14
Star wars borrowed heavily from Space Battleship Yamato. AKA dogfights in space
twilightsol 2 years ago
@twilightsol Actually, it wasn't taking from Yamato doing that, it was a more direct copy of 'Dogfights in space' based off of Dam Busters and similar WWII dogfight movies.
VulpisFoxfire 1 year ago
battle star came out in 78 macross came out in 82. I was 5 years of age when Battle star. came out. BTW I am a Rapid Macross fan
twilightsol 2 years ago
True this is the u.s. spin after we bought rights too it but it comes from that jap one first.
starknight97 3 years ago
I like the video i gave it 5 stars but i have to say it "IS" a BSG rip off ...story line is way to much like BSG.
TrainingPython 3 years ago
Battlestar Galactica (Original Series) - 1978
Super Dimensional Fortress Macross (Japanese) - 1982
zinki120 3 years ago
I think they all borrowed a bit from each other but back in 74-79 there was "Space Battleship Yamato" (started showing here in the states in 78 or 79 as "Star Blazers". It is practically the baseline of all the animation that followed and they all have similarities.
Emptyshell2007 3 years ago
@twilightsol While there are some unique attributes that both shows shared, something must be said about the commonality that exists in all of human kind. While BG did a fairly good job of addressing those issues, Macross (at the time) delved even deeper. Having said that, the newer BG did a better job of tackling issues that might have been better left untouched back in 1980. With respect to the latest trouble Japan has had, I somehow believe that they, as a people, have a deeper view on life
CybershamanX 10 months ago
@twilightsol There is only a three year difference between when the series were released, and anime, especially back then took longer to produce, if anything they were in creation at about the same time. Also there was no Youtube or even worldwide broadcast of shows for the most part. Most likely neither crew knew about the other. Most shows have been inspired or had elements pulled from others. In some ways Lost in space predates both and has the similar theme of trying to get to Earth.......
Zhyntil 8 months ago
@twilightsol Macross (and possibly Galactica ) was partly inspired by Space Battleship Yamato (Star Blazers in the US) where a lone ship has to find a planet that has help for a nuclear-bombed (by aliens) Earth. That came out in 1974, though only 1979 in the US.
SantomPh 4 months ago 5
Awesome job. 5/5
MPilotVF1V 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey...American...go back to your BSG fetishism...stop tampering Macross...stay away from it.
Rodimus78 4 years ago
Wow, overeact much?
Unwiseone 3 years ago
Heh, from what I've experienced, I've seen a cult of fans who overindulged themselves into de-constructing people's work without the makers' consent way too much, and TAdventurer fails to admit the problem. Harmony Gold's tampering of Macross has polarized the American culture if not the world.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
From what I've seen in the past 2-5 years, the fan culture has unwittingly helped hollywood like Harmony Gold de-constructed artist's work without the artist's consent, and it's gone out of control. Macross is a victim of that problem, and TAdventurer fails to admit it.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
Macross has been tampered once by HG, the American Robetech fans helped HG sabotage Big West from distributing Macross to North America which resulted in a messy lawsuit between BW and HG/Tatusnoko. now TAdventurer wants to cause more trouble by de-imagining Kawamori's work into the BSG version of Macross? I'm overeacting? I don't think so. I'm no slave to compromise. PS: re-imagining=de-imagining. It's a simple equation.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
Don't be such a Macross fan boy. I like both Robotech & Macross. The truth is that HG got the rights fair & square. No stealing there...
Get a grip... =/
(BTW, Due to the Macross franchise being in legal hell in Japan, RIGHT NOW A ROBOTECH LIVE ACTION FILM IS A 1000 TIMES MORE POSSIBLE THAN A MACROSS LA FILM).
KronnangDunn 3 years ago
Being a fanboy has nothing to do w/ my protests. I'm an advocate creative and intellectual rights. You're wrong, HG got the rights from Tatusnoko without Big West's consent. Also HG didn't give the Ishiguro, Aramaki, or the others from Studio Nue credit for those 3 anime shows. WHERE'S THE HONOR IN THAT? I'm fed up of looking at artists being cheated out of their work, and I'm not going indulge on my petty greed for Robotech at the expense of Big West/Studio Nue's rights. It's unethical.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
"Harmony Gold's tampering of Macross has polarized the American culture if not the world"
WOW... That officially makes you the most hardcore of hardcore Macross fans. Harmony Gold re-dubbing a cartoon has polarized the culture of an entire planet???
Just...WOW...
thedougtime 3 years ago
Even though your comment is a sarcastic one, I'll take that as a compliment.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
ha ha ha. awesome. I was kinda thinking this guy was a little hardcore for a cartoon fan. And I just spent weeks making an Isamu Dyson 3DS Max model!
chillyche 3 years ago
Yet you come to Youtube and watch content without royalties? You are agro and contradictory. You say American this and that ... it was not Americas fault that later versions of Macross were so poorly conceived. THAT is what I consider the crime ...
Xto4 3 years ago
Agro?....yes. Contradictory? How so?
Rodimus78 3 years ago
Becuase you whine about royalties, yet you come here and watch content royalty free.
If you'd like to make a point to people, study the way they communicate, otherwise you simply do damage. Your statements were follishly nationalistsic, and now nobody is listening to you. Please feel better, and partake in life with joy and purpose, not anger and self destruction.
Xto4 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dude? WTF!? STOP RIGHT THERE! For one thing, me watching content on U-Tube is irreveleant to my argument w/ this subject. I just watch them and express my opinions about them and give them ratings whether I praise them or bash them. Just b/c I view something controversial like Robotech on U-Tube doesn't contradict my argument on this video, so you're foolishly out of context here.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
You should also ask WHY the rights issue came up, do know how much money is required fro Macross7? More than any in history practically, and that series is very weak by comparison. Likewise, the only reason the 'Robotech" thing was pieced together was BECAUSE they were trying to get it to the american market. This was unfortunately THEIR doing, as a response to OUR episode requirements.
Xto4 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
another thing, I like the US, I just hate the crap that I'm seeing here so you watch your FUCKING MOUTH of who you're calling a Nazi.
Rodimus78 3 years ago
Re-imagining as you put it is the foundation of mental evolution. Your very appreciation is born of this concept. You can view this video in many ways, none of which are destructive. I was just telling a friend the other day that if liked the new BSG he should check out the old Macross, even though they are unrelated, I found this video to be a good, yet vague, representation of that very sentiment. No "de-imagining" here. I think the thoughts YOU have conjured up are more destructive than any.
Xto4 3 years ago
Lonny
Xto4 3 years ago
muy bueno
Bardiel25 4 years ago
Habia mas donde quedaron los que le pusiste el tema original de Galactica?.....
drakarlocky 4 years ago
Hat's Off! Nicely Done.
russkeller 4 years ago
Haz mas!!...no te quedo nada mal eh! bien...
drakarlocky 4 years ago
Nice! XD! Would like to see it
daniellynet 4 years ago