Joy Division - Walked In Line (Perfect Audio)

[logochrist]

UGLY STUPID VIDEO WITH A GREAT GREAT SONG !!!

[AintHome000]

Love the drums in this song

[chuckLIDDELLisgod]

anyone know the context of the picture at 2:38?

[StriiderFRL]

@chuckLIDDELLisgod just people standing in a line/group

[chuckLIDDELLisgod]

@StriiderFRL yeah but whats with the gas masks, it looks like something from WWII or something

[StriiderFRL]

@chuckLIDDELLisgod It's WW1 related

[62pickup]

@chuckLIDDELLisgod

I don´t. however the left used the picture for their album titeled gas mask witch was a greeat hiphop album :)

[FlamencoBelgian]

Stupid pig is walking in line ...



[FractalBolt]

The pictures make no sense

[eyehategod8]

why did you have to make it into a slide show the akira poster was just fine

[ukusapillage]

jou division ss women that were there to please the ss men, perfect aryan nation, actually the nazi army had 250.000 half jews so was hitler part jewish

[coteboop]

????

[Afereth]

great song

[pazalama]

sta regacho el video!!!!!!!!jaja pero la rola es buena pinxe we puso imagenes nomas a lo pendejo jajaja

[ironx00]

Leftist always jumping the gun! Altruistic bull shit! DO The research idiots Fucks...fuckin' politics from dumb people commenting from their asses! Every band has "shock value" KISS, Marilyn Manson...et al!

[newfuckingwave]

@ironx00 agreed. everyone trying to sound like the ultimate authority on the human condition because they caught schindler's list on tv. and i'm in no way down-playing the horrors of the holocaust. i just can't stand people who ramble on about it constantly to further their OWN agenda

[kongomueller1]

horrible version, messed up :p

[streetwalkcheetah]

best version :-)

[iEatBoneDust]

Thanks, you just reminded me why I need medication. A cat's asshole? Really? ..........

[thedarkglobe]

Thank you!!!!!

[Nega888]

Bad video, GREAT Song!!

ty for up

[Cleggy238]

27 people didn't walk in line.

[AvntXardE]

sadly the fascist band von thronstahl covered this masterpiece and turned it into political garbage.

[farbrorbla]

Stupid video on a great song. Secondly the song is not a anti-war song in any way. Its a comment to the facism of the Third Reich

[tomasaki22]

0:18 my favourite actor from Scarface!!!

[ancientcommodity]

i got fired for listening to KKK took my baby away...by the Ramones...they thought I was affiliated with a racist organization...some people are so paranoid...what can you do...and joy division is named after what the Nazi's call a group of captive women held for the purposes of satisfying the soldiers...it doesn't mean they support it...just like being catholic doesn't mean your condoning pedaphilia..its just ok to do if your a priest.. funny how society is fucked up...

joy division's the best!

[ancientcommodity]

i got fired for listening to KKK took my baby away...by the Ramones...they thought I was affiliated with a racist organization...some people are so paranoid...what can you do...

[butobuto1]

respect

[MrSeanhinchley]

wtfs a halo pic doing on a video of this awesome band?

[Stalinsurfstheweb]

0:20 its Tony Montana!

[CloserEternity]

From what I've read about Ian Curtis and Joy Division there is absolutely no proof whatsoever that Ian was a nazi, but he had a great interest in history and german culture and that's probably why he used references to nazism in his music. Also, Joy Division/Warsaw was a punk band and part of the punk image was about being provoking and shocking and what is more provoking than using references to nazi germany?

[BlitzoftheReich]

I admitt lots of their lyrics have to do with Nazis but I do not think and can almost certainly deny them of being Nazis....

Long live Joy DEVISION!

[steu968]

@BlitzoftheReich I thought Ian was a clever man. If you see the movie "Control" you can realise that he used to read books and listen to good music. And that's it's completely against the nazy culture.

[BlitzoftheReich]

@steu968 don't base facts on movies. Much rather do it on documents, but yes he did love to read and had an interest with Germany a lot, like me.

[steu968]

@BlitzoftheReich I work with German companies since almost 20 years. I appreciate their style of life. They are polite and they respect nature and enviromment. I can't say the same for their recent history.

[ravenouscolonelhart]

@steu968 actually many of the top nazis were very well educated and into art and stuff, though of course crazy as hell, and of course the movement as a whole was about as anti-intellectual as possible, like fascist movements always are. JD's use of nazi imagery was only when they were a punk band, because lots of punk bands tried that kind of thing to be offensive/controversial, but since JD is remembered and lots of other bands from that period aren't people get the wrong impression.

[monia25cimka]

Niesamowity bass...:):)

[BogIslandCasual]

BANGIN CHOON as we say up north :)



[JSalomez]

The title - perfect audio. I don't like joy division in perfect audio. Joy Division = RAW ...

[B0YC00T13Z]

lol wtf snorkeling i am so confused mannn

[combatfront]

This video is so retardet I can't stand it!

[OneWayeditz]

Best band ever

[sturmer100]

Perfect Audio?!?

[wisprworld]

If you don't like the video then don't watch it. Video is crap by the way but at least you made an effort.

[ivanovickr]

(Perfect Audio) tu puta madre pendejo pinches imagenes sin centido IDIOTA si te gustan los video juegos metelos por el culo pinche gekitode seguro eres de esos pendejos que conosieron a joy por le film de control

jajajajajajaj

[AlfonsoLatorreTViral]

fuck them all!

great song, thanks for posting it! nobody should give a fuck about the pictures...

[gosiewski]

love the piccy of the massive shark! i get i btw.

[sk8ermoose9]

Great song. Thanks for posting, but what is that a picture of at 1:26?

[Keltic619]

next time just do every1 a favor and put the album artwork

[erwinkoslowski]

yeah, unbelieveable bad video... song`s burning though

[MarcoGelido]

Una de mis favoritas, pero y esas fotos?

[NecroFrost1990]

Be honest dude:

You were high when making this video))

[Darkangeldeea1987]

('@') Oink Oink!

[sanpedrohustler]

SMALL SMALL WORLD

I WAS SURFING THE WEB & WOUND UP HERE

WATCHED THIS VID

AND AT THE END I FLIPPED MY LID

I THOUGHT MY COMPUTER FLIPPED TO MY

SCREEN SAVER (THAT'S COOL)

[GitanDemon]

The worst shit ever in video......... Good song

[ScotteDio]

Great song, but crappy pics.

[rickzbc]

Great song and amazing pics!!

[NEOMASOCHIST]

Rest in Peace IAN CURTIS

[francast404]

bizarro el video pero bueno

[Limetalimetalimeta]

great song from my favorit band... WHY these pics god hell piggy monkey shit??? !! Go to heal! You are out...

[icd0123]

the klip is a piece of shit!

[isgoloskokov]

Bush suxx

[haylin13]

WHY TE DOG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[32stardust]

great song

[0ink01nk]

great song, stupid vid

[32stardust]

yea.. have not noticed the pics just heard the song :)

[MrChattyO]

Joy Division had nothing to do with Nazism. People need to do their research before posting such idiotic comments. Obviously taking the SS imagery the wrong way!!! The name was obviously for shock value at the time I am assuming? They don't have a single pro Nazi song or white supremacy song!!!

[scheisslogin]

they didn't have to do much research if they only thought one second about the lyrics they are listening to.

[Kraftysot]

@MrChattyO Joy Division has everything to do with Nazism, in so much as that the band is dedicated to anti-fascism and uses imagery from the Nazi's in a way that says "Never Again". The name Joy Division itself, is an ode to that time. The Joy Division was a military division of prostitutes the nazi's used to keep their officer pool happy. Its meant to show the sick and depraved nature of the Nazi's. The song Dead Souls is about the people the nazi's murdered, and how Ian cant ignore it.

[Madowstone]

@Kraftysot blablabla. Rigth or Left both are a pest.

[Kraftysot]

@Madowstone You can ignore them, but they dont ignore you.

[Madowstone]

@Kraftysot i don´t ignore them I fight them other fucking extremists on a daily base .

[33BottlesOnMyDesk]

@Kraftysot u talk utter fuckin shit u neo nazi delusional fuckin inbred cunt

[Kraftysot]

@33BottlesOnMyDesk You didnt actually read what I wrote. Win.

[tetrahydroscope]

@Kraftysot I'm sure he had difficulty ignoring the holocaust of Dresden.

[Kraftysot]

@tetrahydroscope So did Kurt Vonnegut...apparently firebombing is pretty bad.

[Kodos777]

@Kraftysot

The Joy Division was not a military division. They were female concentration camp inmates, who were often used as a reward for other inmates who served as informants for the SS. The SS had a seperate brothel with german prostitutes because they considered the inmates to be "unclean".

[sharkiethepoet]

@MrChattyO Ditto. It's like calling Pink Floyd Nazis for "The Wall" or even taking Biafra's "California Uber Alles" out of context. I sware, people should read up on Joy Division and this song before getting diarrhea of the fingertips!

[Nochibou1]

@MrChattyO

It is you who is wrong the name joy division is based on a porstitution wing from a nazi concentration camp and this song talks about concentration camps, so yes joy division has to do with nazism he wrote about it.

[Zyklopz9]

@Nochibou1 Exactly right-- at least somebody knows what the hell they're talking about!

[Knudthebrute]

@Nochibou1 if anything this song would be a criticism of the way the nazis behaved and justified their actions. so yes they did write about nazis. but hardly in a flattering way

[DSXmachine]

@MrChattyO Don't get too fucking excited over it.

[beelzabubba]

@MrChattyO - Exactly, J.D. was anti-nazi... just read the lyrics and it should be clear.

[farbrorbla]

@MrChattyO

Exactly. Just like most punkbands at the time. Sex pistols even had svastikas on stage and on clothing but no one is accusing them of being nazis today.

[roddy76to86]

@farbrorbla

Lots of punks wore swastikas at first just for the shock value. Then when real neo-Nazis tried to start infiltrating punk the swastikas and any other Nazi emblems were dropped like a hot potato.

[badsign1980]

masons? what does it have to do with the bobbies? very confused ppl...

[RussianCivilian]

Warsaw version was better I think

[Muppio]

I like the Warsaw (pre-JD) version better.

[PsychoBisket]

ive got better audio than this >_>

[cadavernl]

Then upload it yourself. ;)

[paolorossifan2006]

@cadavernl it would have been good if joy division had recorded a version which had parts of this version and sections from the warsaw recording. both the warsaw version and this version are great in their own way. if elements of each version had been combined (i.e the guitar solos of the warsaw one and the marching drums of the joy division recording), this song may have gained greater recognition

[drunichs]

awesome.

[mafflud]

2.37. where does the picture of everyone wearing gas masks come from ?

[thereagauze]

@mafflud world war I picture of a village in france as far as I remember.

[Hwral]

These random pictures don't do justice to the music of Joy Division. They could've been used for a Metallica track just as well. Keep the pic of Ian and leave out the other bullsh*t.

[Thumelikar]

The Version of "Atze Hatatitla" sounds better ....

[beefygoblin]

isn't that a pro nazi version by some german band?

sucks ass. The whole point of the song was lost on them.

[Thumelikar]

@beefygoblin

No ... just provocation. Nothing else. Search and listen ...

[00ludovan00]

great song, thanks!

but

the pictures are really bad......

[ellabella111]

No need to look at the picz if you do not like them, am I right?

[fkkstrandwixer]

which fuckin cunt did use this child fuckin bastaed pictures for a joy division video?

burn him!

[greenghost2008]

i like this video but ur post made me luagh so i gave ur comment a thumbs up.lol

[TheSnario]

la qualità dell'audio è perfetta ma il resto...lasciamo perdere free joint snario

[UnholyPanda13]

LePig is leawesome.

[itsthearistocrat]

Great song!

Worst Pictures ever. LePig102 you must be disturbed you have a picture of a cats arsehole in the video!

How hard would it have been to just put a single picture of joydivision in the video ?

your a twat!

[87AlExlopez]

Fuck them stupid monkeys piggy keep on postin good music

[LePig102]

haha ty, ur awesome

[halfcabdisaster7]

Cheer up Lepig, the video was alright.

[thehourglasses]

Really shit video... great song!

[LePig102]

Soon im gonna go to the effort of taking down these songs and replace the audio with the sound of dying cows, The only reason the shitty pics and so called video are on here is so anyone can listen to the song that dnt have it, Its not grateful to not read descriptions ect and say the video is shit when ive took my own time to share these few songs

Go fuck yourselves u ungrateful horrible fucked up monkeys, Keep your opinion to yourself if its gonna offend sombody u fucking Idiot!!!!

[LePig102]

Its about the Song!! u Retard, not the shitty pictures, how can that be so hard to understand ????

i didnt upload this to impress anyone with director skills or to debate whether its a good Video or not, Its just suppose to be clean Audio!!!!!

Why would anyone have to explain that ???

(im bangin my head against the wall I Dnt Get It)

[jip1000]

so why the pictures?

[LePig102]

lol wow

[xfirebomb]

@LePig102 Go PIG. Fuck 'em!

[sebsdadez]

@LePig102 for what it's worth mate unless i see it's a live performance or original video... i'm on another tab playing scrabble on facebook or some shit like that, good quality audio is what i'm after - so cheers :)

[blackdeathgrind]

@LePig102 i think people want to know why you would string together a bunch of pictures that have nothing to do with the song.... u Retard, how can that be so hard to understand. and there's no such thing as perfect audio on Youtube.

[Kacen]

@LePig102 Yeah, but it's kinda distracting. Could have just put a still album cover is all.

[flukeazoidfoe]

non plussed with the vid but hey, the tracks great

:0P

[kennyrayl]

i liked the warsaw version of this song way better imo

[GottSeinHofnarr]

keylogger -.- ich hab sowas nie geschrieben..und wenn dann nicht hier -.- hass

[ikeano29]

if you notice anybody that complained about the video dont have any of there own uploaded. its all about the MUSIC anyway not the gloss

[iankoool]

très cool !!! thanks !!!

[aiwass]

Who cares about the pics?? is about the song you dont even have to look at the pics just listen to the song!! these ppl want everything make your own video at least he took the time to upload the song i would like to see you do it better.

[LePig102]

lol we shouldnt even need to point that out but some people just dont get it.... Shame

Im thinking they either really really stupid or just upset and bored and need to complain about something or shit on someone in some sense lol They Freaks!! Unhuman at times :(

[LePig102]

Dont bother watching the video without reading description and then saying the video sucks,Its not a video as such,just something for some people to look @, They are off my PC which made it quick N easy Nothing Special!!!

Random shit comments will be deleted,if not all

so dont bother

[LePig102]

Thats the actual recording.......

U cant get much clearer on a youtube video.

now i cant even thank you for pointing that out because u had No need to actually point it out!!

And i suppose u can always listen to your own perfect recording if u have 1 which i doubt because u was here listening to this version...

be grateful for that atleast u

Horrible Cunt!

[mikebulzary]

i kinda like the images...

[stillentranen]

dear lord.... the song is ok, but the video.... sucks :S

[LePig102]

k thanks.........

???????('@' )

[gronkipoo]

wow i'm really fan of joy division

[LePig102]

average human waste..............

i need to stay away from comments, i get toooo wound up at So called average people's comments, not saying theres any fresh 1s here but ya know..

[theodoros44]

what the fack is this????stupid pics .......for a perfect song.......

[Raffyka84]

i thiks silly images don't respect the poetry of the JD song...

[LePig102]

lol, anything else negative u feel like sharing ??

Wish i could auto block random stupidness so i dont get all angry over some close minded comments :(

"You dont have to watch the video, its just uploaded for people to listen too if they dont have the song, its as fucking simple as that!!"

and alot of the images do have a slight meaning to them, u just dont get it

[Raffyka84]

bla bla bla... words...

[SonicYouth808]

1:01??

[karziflora]

Why do ppl have to complain? Just be thankful that someone uploaded a beautiful song for JD fans.

Thank u LePig!!! Love the pics btw.

[mrzilla]

good song, i dont get why there is photos of dogs arseholes and wierd shit.

[LePig102]

Im pretty certain although could be wrong, i put in the description something along the lines of, Just random pictures off my PC an excuse to upload a song!!

if u like then its nice to say so, if you dont keep it to yourself unless ive offended u & something needs clearing up.

Or be an asshole like the kid underneath :) and try to provoke some sort of reaction to fuel your pointless n shitty life

Thanks for the normal comment,

Its appreciated alot ('@' )

[mrzilla]

Silly photos, shhhh

[knownpleasures]

ah no thats a bit harsh good song and video

[LePig102]

Thanks for the normal comment,

Its appreciated alot ('@' )

[knownpleasures]

no worries mate a lot of weirdos on utube!!

[3rwinAlvarado]

this song is great but the pictures are stupid as fuck, you ruined the song

[LePig102]

Are you fucking retarded ????

How can pictures ruin a song.....?

Your clearly a stupid cunt listenting to shit you dont understand!! or u would quit that ego and stop making stupid attention seeking comments ,Go suck a dead dogs dick u lifeless shit

Also your suppose to read the descriptions on videos so u dnt get anything twisted u ignorant fuck!!

Btw i like the pics thats why I put them in,I couldnt give a fuck what your small mind thinks,

This is why i delete comments like a Tw@!!