man i am so upset at why each video i see here is a damn fast version. Man, play Bach speed like his actual song piece, because I don't like hearing it in this such of a tempo.
This is the perfect tempo to play it at, just I think that this organist wasn't quite ready for it.
I think one of the reasons that a lot of people take this piece so slowly is because they can't handle the semi-quaver runs in the pedal. There is an anecdote that says that Bach was so skilled with the pedals that he could play them faster then other organists could play with their hands!
The problem with playing this so fast is that you miss out the pedal/left hand vertical harmonies, which tend to build up as you approach the climax of the fugue. Plus, it gets very hard to control. (As you found out).
Next time, have someone turn the pages for you and reduce the tempo by half.
I don't mean to be unkind. You have the technique to play this beautifully, and you can...but never at this tempo.
There were a lot of mistakes the organist made and I think it's due to the tempo he chose. There was actually never an exact tempo for the baroque period and the performer would (traditionally) play them at the speed that he interperetes as appropriate.
I actually have never heard anyone play this without making at least 2 mistakes. Even proffessionals struggle with this.
Quite fast, but it's rare to find an organ score with a tempo for this piece. I'm all for performer interpretation. What bugs me, though, is the fact that this is played HORRIBLY. It's quite easily the sloppiest performance of this piece I've ever heard. If you decide to play 20+ BPM faster than the composer's intended tempo, you should have the sense to make sure you're capable of doing it cleanly, even with performance nerves. If not, SLOW DOWN. Don't make Johann cry in his grave.
The tempo is supposed to be 120. This is only slightly faster than it was meant to be.
vitalxx 4 months ago
man i am so upset at why each video i see here is a damn fast version. Man, play Bach speed like his actual song piece, because I don't like hearing it in this such of a tempo.
gtran7 4 months ago
Who cares if this is fast, I can clearly hear the voices D:
GiovanniTancrediChan 4 months ago
Classic Music <3!
xxYdoxxx 7 months ago
THIS SOUNDS SO AWESOME FAST! Haters gonna hate, but this is excellent.
StopTheMoti0n 11 months ago
Fast isn't always better :(
UrSkulled 1 year ago 7
it sounded good to me ! that amazing how fast he played that!
tHEXxMiStAbROWNxX 1 year ago
This is the perfect tempo to play it at, just I think that this organist wasn't quite ready for it.
I think one of the reasons that a lot of people take this piece so slowly is because they can't handle the semi-quaver runs in the pedal. There is an anecdote that says that Bach was so skilled with the pedals that he could play them faster then other organists could play with their hands!
HARMONICO101 1 year ago
This is rushed. I seriously think it belongs at a slower tempo
dgjiephfurreighR 1 year ago
I think it sounds better faster!
stockmaster1982 2 years ago
Glenn Gould also rocketed through Bach.
The problem with playing this so fast is that you miss out the pedal/left hand vertical harmonies, which tend to build up as you approach the climax of the fugue. Plus, it gets very hard to control. (As you found out).
Next time, have someone turn the pages for you and reduce the tempo by half.
I don't mean to be unkind. You have the technique to play this beautifully, and you can...but never at this tempo.
sanjosemike
sanjosemike 2 years ago 2
There were a lot of mistakes the organist made and I think it's due to the tempo he chose. There was actually never an exact tempo for the baroque period and the performer would (traditionally) play them at the speed that he interperetes as appropriate.
I actually have never heard anyone play this without making at least 2 mistakes. Even proffessionals struggle with this.
Buurg 2 years ago 3
You took the description from the wikipedia article I started (-:
Biff947 2 years ago 2
everyone should watch to original J.S Bash Little Fugue in G minor
its better and more.... just more amazing
OIYM091 2 years ago
awesome music
letam67 2 years ago
Why so fast?
elamonty 2 years ago 12
thats actually the tempo for the song! lol
Tman2295 2 years ago
ah ok thanks, i always thought it was ment to be played at a slower tempo. hehe
i prefer the slower version.
elamonty 2 years ago 15
Bullshit!
It's also played awfully.
You should try to find Virgil Fox playing this piece, it's perfect.
stupidsquirrels 2 years ago
Calm down. Its just a song; clearly you havent been too the orchestra lately......
Tman2295 2 years ago
Absolutely too fast. Slow your tempo down to Quarter = 60 OR Quarter = 120. Sheesh
azworx 2 years ago
She really has to pee? lol
stupidsquirrels 2 years ago
@elamonty exaclty what i thought...
barba666ruiva 11 months ago
Awful interpretation! If you're gonna rush it then at least take care to play it correctly.
Terrible!
EP1997 2 years ago
I thought my version was quite fast.
The ending made me laugh.
Ty
thelord2000 2 years ago
so fucking fast. Calm that shit
R3dRum69 2 years ago 3
way too fast
dramamajor1985 3 years ago 2
Hearing the first theme, I'm thinking this guy is a maniac. Highfive for even getting through it at this tempo. Well done.
wbradfordsmith 3 years ago 2
Quite fast, but it's rare to find an organ score with a tempo for this piece. I'm all for performer interpretation. What bugs me, though, is the fact that this is played HORRIBLY. It's quite easily the sloppiest performance of this piece I've ever heard. If you decide to play 20+ BPM faster than the composer's intended tempo, you should have the sense to make sure you're capable of doing it cleanly, even with performance nerves. If not, SLOW DOWN. Don't make Johann cry in his grave.
mbychows 3 years ago
johann never wrote the tempo on any score
ilpredicatore000 3 years ago 2
Still better than George Ritchie, I have a set of CD's done by him covering all of Bach's organ pieces.
Unicronomicon 3 years ago
way to fast !!!
The worsdt I have ever heard
ArieVisker 3 years ago
well, it seems that you have trouble with just one set of keys, so I would like to see you work an organ...
So what if its a little fast?
IchEsseKindern 2 years ago
much too fast. just saying
captaincabeman 3 years ago
its not to fast thats how it played
IchigoSakura101 3 years ago
yeah actually. it is. were you born retarded or did you work at it? i had to play this song in orchestra.
captaincabeman 3 years ago
and i care?
IchigoSakura101 3 years ago
go play your rpgs you chink.
captaincabeman 3 years ago
There are a few errors in your play, but I hope most of them seems so due to the poor quality of the recording.
here are the obvious ones :
1'10''
1'25'' - 1'28'' is messed up :(
2'34''
2'38''
I've noticed a few more, but it is not easy playing in front a such crowded audience.
Great job =)
Xear0 3 years ago
very fast and rare organ sound.
WestMinst 3 years ago 2
pipe organ regular spead
IchigoSakura101 3 years ago