Didn't actually see the Scrubs episode where this appeared, as pretty much everyone has mentioned. I did hear, feel, experience and understand the whole sentiment of this song through Peter's album (Scratch My Back) though.... try "Heroes" and "Boy in the Bubble" too - also good..... :)
I agree, beatyful scene, full of emotion, I've followed Scrubs since the begening and that song illustrate all the emotion I've felt at this moment. Absolutely brillant song.
monsieur PETER GABRIEL vous me touchez beaucoup! DIDIER D'AGOSTINO shamanRHYTHMAN batteur/compositeur et fan de TONY LEVIN vidéos sur YOUTUBE,DAILYMOTION.site internet :didier-dagostino-batteur.fr
@XTREMEGAMEPLAYS IMO there's no Scrubs if you don't have everyone (laverne's death was sad, but it was okay). They should have just ended with 8 and it would have been an ending that was nice and tidy
Why are the most ridiculous comments at the top? Delivering lines that low, yet with volume, is difficult, as anyone with performance experience will tell you. Peter Gabriel's performance here, as always, is amazing.
For all those that do not appreciate this intepretation of the song, relax, you have the other version. Do you really just want the exact same version? I like this. Such as the added female voice. The live strings. His concerts are always unique.
im trying to figure out how to get the strings music for this song!! HELP!! haha, seriously, i cant find it anywhere.. its like this song doesnt exist in sheet music universes across the galaxy...
Sorry Magnetic Fields... your version (which of course is the ORIGINAL) is quite good... but Peter Gabriels's cover version simply is the best... by far! I saw him performing it in Berlin at this very concert you can see in ths video... it was one of the most touching concerts of my life. My band and I tried to cover the song - you can hear it on my channel ;-)
@Villaamill "The book of Love = The Book of Poker" that's - pardon me - nonsense. there is more to love than just a card game. i'm very sorry for you if this is your true opinion :-(
I can't argue that this isn't typical Gabriel. We're spoiled by perfection. In the original version he is also just talking through the soft passages, a rare feat as who sounds that good without projecting their voice. That's a big part of his vocal style. This whole thing looked and sounded very informal. Their is no way Peter performs like this in front of 18,000 fans.
I understand my view re 'Book of Love' will be unpopular.Having heard Gabriel's studio version in 2004 - -i have had nothing but awe and admiration re this cover of the Magnetic Fields original...It's simplicity, absence of 'slush' enhanced by Gabriel's ..maturing voice-support the lyrics in a way that is unique for a love songs that are so often cliched. 'The New Blood Tour' -May>Europe & US-may not include Australia.-with regret.
im not mad, I just get annoyed with youtube and yahoo and all of the censorship these days, nobody can speak their minds any more, I'll be surprised if this one gets through,LOL
If some people would just understand that singers they grow old to like normal regular people and when they grow older there voice might become more broken but once again peter gabriel is really really good singer
@Ceryni i dont think you fully understand the emotion at the start, he is trying to convey that sort of boring and effortlessness that comes accross as is implied by the lyrics :)
This song will appear on Peter`s upcoming covers-album "Scratch My Back". It will also feature a cover of the Paul Simon-song "The Boy In The Bubble".
Love ...elisabeth.
APA590 1 month ago
This has to be the MOST romantic song EVER written! Hands down!
CrimsonBaby2007 1 month ago
Funny, sweet and 100% true. :)
ManeatingLemur 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song!!!!
Please check out my cover of this song if you're interested...
I'd love to have some advice ;)
Cheers
TheLargerSound 1 month ago
Didn't actually see the Scrubs episode where this appeared, as pretty much everyone has mentioned. I did hear, feel, experience and understand the whole sentiment of this song through Peter's album (Scratch My Back) though.... try "Heroes" and "Boy in the Bubble" too - also good..... :)
ttillyer 2 months ago
this was my sisters wedding song =)
Maisa91 3 months ago
I agree, beatyful scene, full of emotion, I've followed Scrubs since the begening and that song illustrate all the emotion I've felt at this moment. Absolutely brillant song.
TheTchou13 3 months ago
hes so amazing not many people can put a song into reality
Peacegirl82323 3 months ago
scrubs always manages to find a song which encaptures all of the emotions of the scene soo perfectly.
DanielGuidettiPED 4 months ago 7
hermoso, dulce, simple e irrepetible tema del gran Peter Gabriel......para que el alma vuele hasta donde nuestros sueños lo permitan.....
homsisser 5 months ago
Absolute an amazing song, what i guy. Scrubs indeed. Beautiffull schene, so delicate.
HomemadeIndie 5 months ago 2
Absolute an amazing song, what i guy. Scrubs indeed. Beautiffull schene, so delicate.
HomemadeIndie 5 months ago
SCRUBS 4 EVER ! ! !
Marlog1000 5 months ago
BEAUTIFUL!!!!!
1baratone 5 months ago
This song reminds me of the last Scrubs episode. And that episode always makes me cry.
CHVendel 5 months ago 2
This song always makes me want to cry. I love his voice more and more every time I hear him sing.
blinkinem 6 months ago 2
Who actually cried when this was played in scrubs
golfguyjack 6 months ago 12
i wanted that voice to be mine but it's in good hands
visitation2001 6 months ago 3
@visitation2001
I wanted that voice so badly, and it truly is in good hands... :)
QuitePictures 6 months ago
LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!
Alimac1112 7 months ago
I know about that book...my great love and I have read it and reread it throughout the years, and we find new messages every time we turn the pages.
Lana71744 7 months ago 2
monsieur PETER GABRIEL vous me touchez beaucoup! DIDIER D'AGOSTINO shamanRHYTHMAN batteur/compositeur et fan de TONY LEVIN vidéos sur YOUTUBE,DAILYMOTION.site internet :didier-dagostino-batteur.fr
dagostinoification 7 months ago
oh abi
andrespereyda 8 months ago
Amazing song.
svehlic 8 months ago
Gyönyörű!
Nektarin70 8 months ago
Peter Gabriel your voice is so sothing & pleasent
manchawy 8 months ago
this song makes me want to fall in love again! sigh!
miss42310 9 months ago 4
no Scrubs without JD!
XTREMEGAMEPLAYS 9 months ago 40
@XTREMEGAMEPLAYS IMO there's no Scrubs if you don't have everyone (laverne's death was sad, but it was okay). They should have just ended with 8 and it would have been an ending that was nice and tidy
sgtpepper1138 4 months ago 3
who felt like crying when this was played in scrubs
cal11182 9 months ago 197
@cal11182 i actually did! scrubs means so much to me x
cam2k4 8 months ago 2
@cal11182 i didn't just feel like crying. I cried my eyes out!
atomsolomon 7 months ago 2
@cal11182 I loved that part.
AllyMind5Star 6 months ago
@cal11182 I did cry when it was played in scrubs.
062829648 3 weeks ago
my heart want to leave my body...
thank you Peter for your song
ROBANUKA 9 months ago 3
i wish his face wasn't obstructed
pamelajenkins629 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i LOVE this song. Check out my cover
axeage88 10 months ago
his voice is perfect for this song !! :)
martin80361 10 months ago
Fantastic Song.
Thank you so much Peter, for this beuatiful, beautiful song.
BoondockSaint122 10 months ago
it's probably hard to sing with out getting emotional. I can't listen to it without tearing up, much less try to sing it probably
jellyfishstampede 10 months ago 3
SCRUBS!:) R.I.P<3
PrBaRcArDi 10 months ago 2
Still makes me weep every time I hear this piece.
Sandfluffymama 11 months ago
Maybe he still had the stick in his ass...before the surgery!!
theonlytruepunk 11 months ago
Sounds like he doesn't sing from 0:58 until 1:19 :DD
iliCoLaili 1 year ago
Why are the most ridiculous comments at the top? Delivering lines that low, yet with volume, is difficult, as anyone with performance experience will tell you. Peter Gabriel's performance here, as always, is amazing.
MrRussellwhitely 1 year ago 3
This is such a beautiful song, simple yet haunting. I love it.
carmeldip32 1 year ago
BEST!
GermanMeTaLGuardian 1 year ago
I think Peter Gabriel had the "fuck it, we'll do it live" mentality that day.
Hartsough18 1 year ago
For all those that do not appreciate this intepretation of the song, relax, you have the other version. Do you really just want the exact same version? I like this. Such as the added female voice. The live strings. His concerts are always unique.
dwade1962eagle 1 year ago 2
hat der mensch so viele tränen, die er beim hören dieses seelenkamms vergiessen kann ? ich streng mich an: aber ich kann nicht anders, es läuft.
schorschkoch 1 year ago
Gorgeous
abolocks 1 year ago
Is he singing with his daughter Melanie here? Regardless, this is completely beautiful! Love it!
synchroqueen77 1 year ago
I love love love how he brings out not only the beauty of the words, but also his heritage... Just absolutely stunning!! :)
etrefzger 1 year ago
gänsehaut und traurig aber innerlich glücklich <3
72GradCelsius 1 year ago
im trying to figure out how to get the strings music for this song!! HELP!! haha, seriously, i cant find it anywhere.. its like this song doesnt exist in sheet music universes across the galaxy...
mnuckoll 1 year ago
he really kills this live..........so beautiful otherwise
ontariochickie 1 year ago
the best
Moderntalker 1 year ago
Brings happy tears to my eyes. :)
iceprincess955 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry Magnetic Fields... your version (which of course is the ORIGINAL) is quite good... but Peter Gabriels's cover version simply is the best... by far! I saw him performing it in Berlin at this very concert you can see in ths video... it was one of the most touching concerts of my life. My band and I tried to cover the song - you can hear it on my channel ;-)
CarpeVitam1 1 year ago
Guys you have to remeber! It is damn cold their ofc he cant sing his best when he is freezing hes ass off
jonisen96 1 year ago
Best than original version far ..... Peter is the best ... genius !!!
HQartmusic 1 year ago
amazing! WOW ! ! !
Costigan8 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
just love it!!!!!!!! wow wow
beauter12345 1 year ago
I just love it!!!!!!!!
MrMesbahe 1 year ago
I'd say his voice was hurting. The chorus was the only part he really nailed.
sksranger19882 1 year ago
Kære Jørgen
Her er en kunstner jeg ved du kan lide.
Tror nok jeg flytter til Hans Tausensgade.
Smuk dag til dig fra mig.
Kærlig hilsen
Ditte Karina
Dittekarina 1 year ago
WOOO I was there!!!! WOMAD FTW!
americanmotherland 1 year ago
scrubs ftw :)
xxxFaulixxx 1 year ago
im very impressed
frankoramma 1 year ago
The book of Love = The book of Poker,
Villaamill 1 year ago
@Villaamill "The book of Love = The Book of Poker" that's - pardon me - nonsense. there is more to love than just a card game. i'm very sorry for you if this is your true opinion :-(
NikF92 1 year ago
well obvously he isnt going to do that amazing. hes getting older. but i still think he is amazing.
theused0321 1 year ago
wow this is pretty bad... the recording is one of my favorite songs.
bro2baseball 1 year ago
I can't argue that this isn't typical Gabriel. We're spoiled by perfection. In the original version he is also just talking through the soft passages, a rare feat as who sounds that good without projecting their voice. That's a big part of his vocal style. This whole thing looked and sounded very informal. Their is no way Peter performs like this in front of 18,000 fans.
SterlingRe 1 year ago
I like Peter Gabriel's music but this is just very below average, particularly the lyrics, but the good news is that it's a cover.
esca8652 1 year ago
el camino hacia el alma se recorre a cada momento a través de este hermoso tema del gran maestro Peter Gabriel.....una y otra vez.....
homsisser 1 year ago
Comment removed
Trishanelle 1 year ago
I understand my view re 'Book of Love' will be unpopular.Having heard Gabriel's studio version in 2004 - -i have had nothing but awe and admiration re this cover of the Magnetic Fields original...It's simplicity, absence of 'slush' enhanced by Gabriel's ..maturing voice-support the lyrics in a way that is unique for a love songs that are so often cliched. 'The New Blood Tour' -May>Europe & US-may not include Australia.-with regret.
Trishanelle 1 year ago
he sounded good
maxistheb3st 1 year ago
boring like hell. Where is the creativity? The rythm?
beezaar 1 year ago
Sniff sniff
jillreid72 1 year ago
Wher's the Peter of Genesis....?
ermannobraghiroli 1 year ago
hey i didnt know he was english
Xen1aserman 1 year ago
Wonderful song....
ZeroIllusion 1 year ago
Just a great song and a great take on it by Peter.
jwalsman 1 year ago
Srsly? It sounds like he's reading the passages between the refrain...
Saw better live performances
funnyfynn 2 years ago
This is good!!! ♥ X) yesssssssss!
Meezletoe 2 years ago 2
I was commenting on how old he was getting and it wouldnt post, lets see if this one does
smitchl100 2 years ago
That's cuz Youtube likes Peter Gabriel and saying the man is getting old, is a bad comment :p
LodemaiT 2 years ago
Well I didnt mean it in a bad way. I havenst seen him since i was a teenager and I was just making a statement.
BTW there are a lot more comments on youtube that are far worse than what I was writing
smitchl100 2 years ago
Don't be mad, I was just playing with you. He is indeed getting old but then again, we all are
LodemaiT 2 years ago
im not mad, I just get annoyed with youtube and yahoo and all of the censorship these days, nobody can speak their minds any more, I'll be surprised if this one gets through,LOL
smitchl100 2 years ago
Yeah man! Youtube comment boards are serious business.
robdorg 2 years ago
You're an idiot. What does age have to do with being able to create art?
jwalsman 1 year ago 2
Hey retard, try reading my posts and then making a comment.
I said I didnt mean it in a bad way. I havenst seen him since i was a teenager and I was just making a statement.
smitchl100 1 year ago
is youtube censoring now
smitchl100 2 years ago
test
smitchl100 2 years ago
è una canzone che fa sognare !! mette serenità...è una bella colonna sonora per una stupenda storia d'amore come la mia!!!
patty
ertyvcb 2 years ago
the NEW Peter Gabriel album "SCRATCH MY BACK" with "BOOK OF LOVE" - out middle of February in Europe, beginning of March in the USA : )
Cimbarius 2 years ago
such a beautiful voice Peter has, I could listen to 'just his voice', my fave since I was 14...long long time ago..lol xxx
susandan110 2 years ago
Does anyone know who that is singing with him?
I was wondering if it might be Sara Bareilles, it kinda looks like her.
blakeedwards1015 2 years ago
Thats his daughter Melanie.
hamilkarX 2 years ago 3
If some people would just understand that singers they grow old to like normal regular people and when they grow older there voice might become more broken but once again peter gabriel is really really good singer
songsinlife 2 years ago 3
Good stuff
Crimsonland1 2 years ago 4
One of my favourite PG songs. I've never heared the original but this is simply beautiful.
smileyartproductions 2 years ago 4
Peter Gabriel will play 8 concerts in 2010:
5 shows in Europe at the end of March, then later 3 shows in North America.
Cimbarius 2 years ago
Bravo
peregrinofino 2 years ago 4
Peter Gabriel can sing me anything. . .
Scrrrrrraaaatch My Back. . .bring it on!! : )
One tour date set so for in London!
makissoflife 2 years ago 12
So far in London! : )
makissoflife 2 years ago 2
shes off
masternate61 2 years ago
He's so much better live than the Magnetic Fields. ( btw... I can't believe Peter actually stayed in one spot for the whole song )lol...
castlekiller157 2 years ago
"Scratch My Back" - the NEW Gabriel-album featuring "Book of Love" will be released on January the 25th.
Cimbarius 2 years ago
I thought that I read on Peter's website that the album would be released February 15, 2010.
HonestCriticzzzzzz 2 years ago 3
that`s correct Honest.
Cimbarius 2 years ago
nice wen est echt live währe
MonnDevil 2 years ago
where would phil collins be w/o mimicking peter gabriel???
usuck247ha 2 years ago 4
yeah! i wish i could be there again my nerves were on fire!
steveinafrruit 2 years ago 6
one of a million voice!
moccabot 2 years ago 10
He's had better performances if you ask me, still nice though.
kontolraksasa 2 years ago 2
one of a kind voice.
xantiherox 2 years ago 5
Aaa very nice song its very nice i love it !! *__*
100samet 2 years ago 18
meh. don't like how he doesn't go up high at the end of the verses like he does in the recording. I think he was being lazy
iceman8067 2 years ago
its cos his voice has broken in the last twenty years dumbass!
Champagneheartbreak 2 years ago 2
The business!
bethelordjesus 2 years ago
maybe he decided not to give a crap that day, but I felt that the first few verses were just devoid of emotion, like he was just saying the lyrics.
Ceryni 2 years ago 10
I kind of know what you mean. He seemed to talk through the verses, really... but I think he's just forgetful :D
Jakks731 2 years ago 4
I agree.. especially "instructions for dancing " HAS to be sung..spoken thing takes away from the song's effect....
fraud1980 2 years ago 4
@Jakks731 man, i really liked the record, but this just didnt live up at all... especially the beginning.
DavidKneiber 1 year ago 3
@DavidKneiber I think he is doing a better version on the current tour. This was just the first live performance.
Jakks731 1 year ago
@Ceryni the lyrics of this song are to be talked... listen to the original. Peter does a good job!
vicarinatutugal 1 year ago
@Ceryni looks really really cold.. i mean you can see his breath!
Evicator 1 year ago
@Ceryni i dont think you fully understand the emotion at the start, he is trying to convey that sort of boring and effortlessness that comes accross as is implied by the lyrics :)
domdude5000 11 months ago
Peter Gabriel can sing me anything!! : )
Amazing performance!! Absolutely beautiful!
makissoflife 2 years ago 33
This song will appear on Peter`s upcoming covers-album "Scratch My Back". It will also feature a cover of the Paul Simon-song "The Boy In The Bubble".
Cimbarius 2 years ago
Peter is the man!
theodorougr 2 years ago 8
One of those singers who can sing live
3Johnnnn 2 years ago 9
BEAUTIFUL !!!. . . . . . . .
Cimbarius 2 years ago 2