Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (273)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • love him <3333333333333333

  • Haha! He just can't stop smiling!!

  • great voice but this song is shit.... it's a typical tv-casting blahblah song which drowns his voice...

    this guy can do much better. get rid of those tv-guys and start something own...

  • 5: 33 cheryl and simon make such a cute couple!

  • WELL DONE

  • I love both versions of this song. Both Joe and Miley are amazing in their own ways.

    I've seen them both sing this in concert and they were both fantastic at it.

    I couldn't decide between either version because they make it their own.

    I am so super proud of Joe. He definitely deserved to win.

    His vocals are flawless and I can tell he'll be around for a long time!

  • AWWWW<3

  • he deserved to win..i new from the beginning!

  • joe is so much better than archuleta too :P great voice,great face ;)great personality,

    whoooo! love him so much <3 <3 <3

  • he's so hot :) he looks like a young james marsden

  • he is like the david artuleta of idol he is amazing take that cyrus

  • ill song he is better than miley at other songs but no this 1

  • stan walkers version is sooooooo much better than this one !!!

  • why is he singing miley song

  • any1 else think that louis is dancin like mr bean lol

  • hahahha yes

  • I always pause it before Rachel comes in and Kanyes the whole moment.

    Seriously bitch, you got eliminated early. You're lucky they let your Rihanna wannabe self on stage

  • Am so happy that the right person won...JOE..!! says best judge Cheryl Cole...love u both...Congs..!!

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE

  • joe was amazing best winner since leona i reckon

  • Aww, I love himm. <3

  • I can almost see it That dream Im dreaming but Theres a voice inside my head sayin Youll never reach it Every step Im taking Every move I make feels Lost with no direction My faith is shaking but I Got to keep trying Got to keep my head held high Theres always going to be another mountain Im always going to want to make it move Always going to be an uphill battle Sometimes you going to have to lose Ain't about how fast I get there, Ain't about what s waiting on the other side Its the climb
  • Joe, you "Climbed" the mountain and successfully reached the top by your stellar performances each week. You see hard work produces results. I rest my case. Good Luck Joe with your future recordings.

  • i lol'd that u think he's gonna actually read that :D

  • aww its cute when stacey goes and hugs olly at 2:56 there good together :D x

  • didnt simon and cheryl look like proud parents hahah:)

  • I love him , Amazing , I think this years X-factor gone so quick , I wish it was on everyday (:

  • OMG!!! i wz sooooooo exited wen he won i cudnt stop jumping on the sofa he rocks and hes voice is really nce and o lke hes version of the climb betta than mileys and ollys

  • his voice better than mileys but she sings this song better than him

  • Show McElderry??

  • luv u

  • i luv u joe xxxx

  • joe u rock!!!!!!

  • Congratulations Joe McElderry #1 where you belong. Looking forward to your CD being released here!

    Happy New Year from Australia.

  • what a finale. the crown went to a deserveing winner . all the luck in the world hinny. lets see you climb right to the top of the tree me mar used to say watch out for the quiet ones ,and she was right lol.

  • joee is aceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeee xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  • Sexyy (:

    Joee Foreverr!

  • HOT = ) =)

  • 0:52 HOT =D

  • i agree with u cookiecrumble. Lucy is so boring! shes nowhere as good as leona and would never make it in the us. Joe definatly has the potential to with his AMAZING voice

  • I believe that Lucy has more potential in making names in US.

  • Oh SHUTUP! Lucy is like out of the picture :/ go back to the 70's if you think LUCY has more potential :/ pathetic loosers! loooove joe :D x

  • well atleast she has originality..

    Looking at the million selling singers like rihanna, beyonce, lady gaga and thier style of catchy addictive music. sorry but i think joe cant fit in.

  • agree

  • Who says that ugly rock from the Band is No1...what a taste ....I can believe that

  • This is music to shit by.

  • 3:20 lmao

  • Comment removed

  • Amazing...I love it!

    Shame he didn't get no 1

  • aaww. i loved the bit where he laughedd.. bless himm ! soo glad hi won!!! i love him he is soo cute and even better in real life ;) xx

  • i think joe sang this song waiiiiii better than miley.......miley should be disapointed that un famous people can sing her own song waii better than her

    i think joes great at singing and he deserves to winxxx

  • @annie12100 Ya but hes a boy

  • lol, u can see simon is having fun stroking cheryl's shoulder! also, u can see stacey is the only one not hugging joe cos she is so jealous :(

  • All u haters!! HA u think joe is guna give a fuck what u think!? NO!

    and everyone who says he cant sing...Get a grip yes he can!! i think on this performence its the fact that he had won and still trying to get over that!!

    Joe ur amazing!!!

    makes me proud to be geordie!!

    GO JOE!!!

  • Yeah but Leona isnt singing in butlins lol

  • and she'll be the only one

  • my auntie Rachael charlotte field died april this year after fighting a heart problem and being a eperleptic she drown in her own bath and this is this song that my cuz abby got up and sang about rach every time i hear it i fill up and i feel rach near we love you rachy merry christmas babby girl this 1 is to you make it no1 this year pleaseeeee xxxxxxxxxxxxx :'-( ps rach please remember

  • This is a genuine and humble talent, lacking in so many these days.

    An asset to the music scene.

    I understand that it wouldn't suit drug users :lol: they can't fit in the world as it is.

  • LOL, joe sucks soz.

  • SOO GAY

  • stop singing with that constant vibrato in your voice... Arrrrrgh. So bloody irritating.

    Brits really disappointed me by choosing this twat as a winner.

    RATM ftw!

  • Seriously? This guy won? All you UK people need to google Australian Idol's Stan Walker singing this song to hear someone with a quality voice and good pitch control. This version.... karaoke much?

  • OK, I heard Stan Walker and sorry mate, Joe has a much broader appeal than Stan. Sorry....

  • and I am from the USA.

  • @chorin1979

    How silly, I'm an Aussie and Stan Walker is nothing special at all! and his first release only made #2 and now sits at #3 and in it's 4th week still only has 'gold' accreditation!

  • I wasn't talking about sales, I was talking about talent. Sales doesn't mean much these days - exactly the point that the guys from Rage Against the Machine were trying to make. My point was that for two guys singing the same song, Stan certainly has much better vocal control.

  • Now I can enjoy Xmas, No cheesy no. 1

    What a win!!!!!!!

  • hey guys check out my video of why im better than gay joe!

  • Joe seems like a nice guy, and this campaign was never against him. I didn't buy the RATM single or anything, but it is kinda nice for the No. 1 to not automatically be X-Factor. That being said, Joe obv deserves success, and as all his fans know, he shall have it! He'll get so much more than A Crimbo No. 1! :)

  • @PaulAnt2008 he doesnt deserve success, he hasnt written any material he didn't work hard to get signed by a record label, he went on a show which is basically a kareoke contest on tv

  • @fenderholic

    Yeah agreed ...

  • Joeee i love you...sorii you didnt get 2 christmas number onee..you realii shud havee..!!!Mii sister cryed!!:( wish you luck joee..i'll defo be buying your album xx

  • Fucking damn right he didnt get xmas no1 he is a pile of shit and your sister sucks dick.

  • @haznolly yhuu no what mate if yhuu aint got nuffin nice 2 say dont say shit..this video is 4 FANS not 4 dickheads like you!!!!!!!!

  • ♪♫El ES UN GRAN CANTANTE♪♫

  • great but i think mileys better

  • Needs more Tom Morello

  • Miley Cyrus is better

  • @Kat5099

    lol yeah that's sad xD

  • I am so happy he won

    he deserved it!!

  • Gay/Str8/bi who gives a shit the lill fecker can sing! unlike yer wan rachael grabbing d microphone from him tryin to get another 2 minutes of fame for herself, stupid tit!

    Must be a relation of Kanye West

  • joe is not gay. GET IT IN YOUR HEAD. and so wat if he was anyways? hes still a goood singer, and a good persson. so just stop wasting your time, its not gonna get him down. cos its not fucking true!!

  • i've seen all the x factors, something really different about this final. Really emotional theres something really special about this guy. Have to say i like RATM, but this campaign is just stupid, i'd understand if it was a shit version of a good song, but Joe is amazing and he does deserve to be number 1!!??! and lol, simon totally all over Cheryl during this song!

  • Joe McElderry is not gay. i seen in tha paper that he is having a break from "girlfriends" for the next year. so hope thats answred all off your questions.

  • Why do you say that? What is wrong wiht being gay ?

  • some of you people are so fu*cking stupid. If he is gay who the hell cares i dont, doesnt take away the fact hes an awsome siinger and a good guy? and stop hating rachel, saying nobody likes her??? i like her! and why is it so hard to believe shes happy for her friend? we always have to think someones doing something for the wrong reasons, and change the batteries on the gaydar?, grow up... LUV YOU JOE AND X FACTOR, AND YES! even racherl (L)

  • it was so cute when he was laughing :)

  • Yeah they should there humans too!!.. So what if he is!!..>:(

  • I loveee you =)

    people say he's gay ? is he ? :S

    x

  • rachel is so mean

    if anyone it should like olly or sstacey

    god shes never gonna be famous face it girl

  • let the girl man ,

    she was pulld in the emotions

  • Joe is just amazing :)

    But Rachel, Fuck off, she's just a bitch who is using Joe to make her 15 minutes of fame last longer.

  • its goin to simon either way!!!

  • RACHEL get the fuck over yourself LUV u didnt win, no one likes u hence u wer voted off weeks ago! how rude and arrogant to grab the microphone of the winner what a drama loving, attention seeking B I A T C H!!!!

  • P.S she must be a relative of kanye west!!!!!

  • RATM for xmas no1. Joe is a nice guy, but he doesnt even make any money from this record, it all goes to simon. So cast your vote and buy killing in the name of, to stop the x factor monopoly

  • JOE YOU'RE AMAZING!!!

    I LOVE YOU AND IM DEFFO BUYING THIS SINGLE!!!!

    And he is so cute!!! I hope he goes far!

  • ^^^spelling=gay

  • why does it matter whether he's gay or not ?

  • Because he is denying it. Which is a lie. And lies are bad. :)

  • Is he denying it ? when did he say that ?

  • Exactly final someone standing up for him!!

  • Thank You :)

    I love Joe xD

  • BUY RATM NOW!!! A purchase is a vote :

    -for real music by real musicians

    -for standing up for your right to choose and getting your voice heard

    -for the power of the British public to make a difference if we stand together

    -against the x-factor machine

    -against another x factor christmas no. one

    -against being force fed rubbish music

    -against the exploitation of the working classes for entertainment

    -not against joe mcelderry

  • FIt and an amaziing singer i luv him <3 x :)

  • boo.

    nothing against him personally, but x factor is stealing christmas number 1.

    Rage Against the Machine all the way!

  • what is this utter crap! not again.... i know which single im buying this year!

    RATM FOR NUMBER 1 ** RAGE **

  • well done Joe your so amazing the voice is killing me i can't stop watching keep it up all the best

  • he sudnt wear suits like dat closed and all makes him look to skinny

  • and I love you'r smile =) xox

  • omg he is so fit !!! and you'r voice is amazing like keep it up and u sing this song amazing ... xoxox

  • Vampire Teeth :);)

  • I can't stop watching you sing Joe , You are wonderful . God bless you !!!!!! Stay like you are DO NOT CHANGE !!! You are beautiful !!!!

  • joe mcElderry for number 1

  • love that bit at 2.21 when he smiles and looks really excited, like he truly cant believe it!!!! i

  • well done joe, love you!! im addicted to you, have to hear this song at least 20 times a day !!!!! best singer by far won xxxxxx have to say it sounds much better than the original miley version! love this video too, he is so cute and although extremely delighted to have won, still sang to perfection, just brilliant xxx!!

  • omg why is everyone being so harsh to rachel i think that was so nice of her and joe wasnt singing anyway, it made him beam, so how did she "ruin" his moment?

  • such a better version well done joe!!

  • WELL DONE, JOE. I said from that wonderful audition of yours that you'd win !!!

    Beautiful. CONGRATULATIONS !

  • Hated Rachel from day 1. she ruined Joes moment.

  • Muito bom!

  • i loved Joe from start, and olly was great but when i heard the winners song , it was defo a Joe song. if it had been more upbeat and olly cud of danced, maybe it wud of been different. So glad Joe won!!! hate Rachel for runin it tho !

  • Racheal ruined his moment.

  • I love Joe to bits and im soooo glad he won, although i was with Olly from the beginning but changed my mind half way thro the show cuz i noticed Olly could only sing fast songs and dance cuz wen it come to singing this song Olly couldn't hit da high notes and was out of tune. Joe sang it the best it even sounds better then Miley Cyrus singing it. Love you Joe and hope you stay on and continue ur career unlike the other contesents who we dont hear from any more. Love you :)

  • Comment removed

  • Rachel wtf she clearly just did that so she would get in the music video.

  • @Kadir853 no he is straight ^.^

  • is joe gay?????????

  • @Kadir853

    oh yessss.. everyone that can do something better than YOU has to be gay... If this guy is gay then I'm too...

    stop trying to enhance your pathetic life by goofing on someone but try to start something yourself...

  • rachel was soooooo anoyin only did it 4 attention! go joe u deserved to win and love u babe xx

  • It makes me laugh all the negative and nasty comments, but they all watch it. If u don't like don't watch, U can guarantee about 90 percent of the negative remarks are from people that haven't made it in the industry, either pop or musical theatre, because his voice is outstanding and nobody can take that away. Jealousy is a bad thing peeps.

  • watch australian idol's stan walker version, and compare.

  • rachel is a fucking retard

  • you all need to stop being nasty to joe tbff because i'd like to see you gettt up on stage iinfront of millions of people!!! leave him alone... theres millions of people out there who like him otherwise he wouldnt of won so why dont you grow up instead of puttin him down?

  • What a lame winner's song. Why a cover?

    I really don't like his voice, it is so typical boyband- and gayish.

  • He will be the next "Will Young" Gay. And not around for long.

  • tha cut a louis walsh @ 2:36 he's some fanny

  • they are all shit!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • LOL @ 3min 10secs. Not pre recoreded, much!

  • @ daddyjoe21

    Its pre recorded, but he was actually singing it, it was the backing music.

  • so poinless comparing ratm to x factor,there miles apart,i got all there albums and there leathal,there not main steam and that what makes them good,they sing to convey a message,this is a singing competiton,stupid making comparisons,i think the joe kid is talented,no rage tho

  • Joe is a good performer & singer but that is a truly fucking shit song. Why do they always release such crap songs? (ok hallelujah is a great song but they should have left that well alone).

  • @gextvedde

    WTF?

    This is an amazing song, nobody forced you to listen to it...

    Joe is amazing!

  • yeah cudnt agree with you more!

  • olly is well better

  • 1:34

    There Doin It

  • Sooooooooo happy he won he is a cuteee:)

  • I love This boy im glad he won i knew he was gonna win <3

  • love u joe!! u were always the winner in my eyes.

  • Joe - went through x factor did progressivly well and wins within a few months, whoopdy shit you won a game show.

    Rage- Been around for donkeys years working hard on tours making albums and freedom fighting. Fuck this joe kid Rage deserve it more anyway.

  • i love you , joe x

  • agreed- rage against the machine for number one- x factor is so commerical- this is crap- miley cyrus does it well- im not even gunan watch this- why shud x factor rule every christmas just because simon cowel buys all the records?

  • sack licker

  • @pingumeister i like to lick sacks

  • to all those negative comments towards joe/xfactor, i'd like to see you do any better! and if you even did enter... you sure as hell wouidn't get my vote.

    well done joe.

  • LOVE U JOE

  • its all about money to both x-factor and the recording companies. And the public are so thick that they buy into these types of scandals.

  • ha ha! your so "alternative".

    "Take it to the man, x factor is for people who cant think for themselves, Simon Cowell is the new Hitler" etc etc.

    And RATM? They need to understand what a melody is before anyone will like them. Ive seen them twice and they are SHIT!

  • Surely after You've seen them once u wouldnt want to see them again ?

  • can i get a key change.

    pathetic

    RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE

  • Why should this pathetic guy have the chance to have a number 1, its so pathetic. There are much better singers in the world than this waste of space. An artist makes their own songs not by mimicking another. its the same with all of the x-factor winner fuck you.

    RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE FOR NUMBER 1 CHRISTMAS 20091!!!

  • yes its so fake, at least ratm take on political matters they are the people, x-factor are just going to make shit loads of money for a momentarily thing they are controlled. at least make your own songs!

  • why shouldn't he get a number one ?? you say an "artist makes their own songs not by mimicking others" mariah carey and susan boyle have both covered songs and their 2 of the biggiest female artists out their so yh what your saying is Bullshit !!!! JOE FOR CHRISTMAS NUMBER ONE !!!

  • you daft cunt. rachels just happy for him

  • so glad joe won :) x

  • well done joe .....xxxxxxxxx

  • RACHEL STOP TRYING TO STEAL JOE'S