Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (52)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song can be very happy and very sad at the same time and that's why it should be loved.

    I don't get the bashing. Yes, it doesn't live up to Gene Wilder- anyone who loves this song knows that- but it was a lovely and proper rendition and stayed close to true of the original. Beautiful job Glee, I enjoyed it and it touched my heart.

  • i like version better soley because i can hit these notes

  • i cried when this song came on call me wat ever but it was touching i just couldnt hold it in i cant imagine how it would be to lose a loved one

  • Saw this episode

    I almost cried. Its become almost impossible for me SERIOUSLY the tears always start but somehow the just dry up

    I wish I could still cry

  • Thanks for ruining it, pricks.

  • love this song

  • still give me chills every time.

  • Yup. I was bawling like a baby.

  • Interesting...I don't like their version - just came from the original version ... lol

  • Why does Glee feel inclined to ruin every good song ever made

  • @thegoldyshow i know it seems like they just pick random popular songs and cover them, but if you watch the covers within the context of the show then they make much more sense and seem to belong there. The people on the show never compare their versions to the original, they merely express that the songs they sing best exemplify the emotions they aren't developmentally ready (since they are children) to share.

  • @floydduhcat IMO the first season was like how you described it the most. The others...not so much XD Some of them really do seem random XD

  • @29Ocelot Theres TONS of this song on youtube, you just have to search and not leave annoying comments on others!

  • When they sang this and the tapes started rolling. I was balling, I could'nt stop. It reminded me so much of my grandmother. So innocent. I miss her so much, love you grandma.

    R.I.P. Nancy...

  • Yeah... I cried during this song. Won't even try to deny it.

  • God I wish my voice was like this..

  • This episode with this song and episode of Kurt's dad almost near death made me bawl.

  • It's so disappointing this is the only version of this song I could find on youtube.

  • They nailed it.

    

  • love this song anyway, but watching and listening to the funeral scene had me in floods! Been singing it ever since, annoying my kids.

  • who died???

  • @persnikity12345 sue's sister

  • @persnikity12345

    Sue's sister

  • This song makes me feel soo... i dont know but its just so pretty! If i get over 40 20 likes i ll do a figure skating routine to it!

  • Man, this is a powerful cover. I think I like this version better than the original.

  • I still love the original, but I like how Glee slowed it down. If the first line is at normal speed, it doesn't make sense to me.

  • OMG! SHIVERS WHEN I HEAR THIS SONG!

  • OMG! SHIVERS WHEN I HEAR THIS SONG!

  • ooo 11,000th person to listen to this, privileged ^^

  • i cried when this was on the show.

  • @iwansworld me too

    

  • I started to cry so much in this episode... :(

  • I cried when I heard this on the show <3 :') loved it so much

  • i adore this song!!!!Especialy with Kurt!!!

  • I cried when i heard them sing this...<3

  • Its a nice cover but as always Gene Wilder's version has something that can never be repeated love this song <3

  • im going to sing it for graduation !

  • i love this songg!! i started ta get tears in my eyes on dis episode!!

  • `I Cried in this episode. :'( It was so sad, I never thought we'd see Sue so torn up!

    Glee did one of the perfect covered of this, Once again! Excellent.

  • i cried.

  • :'( 

  • when finn says 'take a look' i actually die.

  • This song is so eerie, i absolutely love it! it brings me back to the days i would watch willy wonka and the chocolate factory at my grandmothers. i will forever love this song and i adore the glee version.

  • I love this

  • I love that they did this song and what they did it for was beautiful and unexpected.

  • this song made me cry ):

  • i would of never put this song to a funeral but for this it fit and i was tearing up so much !!

  • @megsbee1224 ok i love this song it is amazing and powerful but that song completly fits the funeral that they held and how do you now death is not just a world that is what you imagine your paridise to be no offence

  • @megsbee1224

    yes it was very clearly done

  • Kurt and Finn.

    Ohmygosh.

    Amazing.

  • This is a nice song... but it's so sad that they had to sing it in a funeral.

    This was meant to be a happy song.

  • amazing, the orchestration is epic....and their voices bring this classic to life again

  • This was a Nice cover of the best song ever.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more