why couldn't God send all blessings directly? like heat without the Sun, guidance without prophets, etc.?! why did God ask people to ask Rasulullah SAW for pray for them to be forgiven? why did Allah twt asked people to use means to reach Him? I hope by answering these questions you get your answer.
ok, what you are saying is compelety against what prophit mohamad and ebrahim stood against, they both came to teach folks to reach god directly not through any meduim whether god or idole, please note what i just wrote , what shi do is exactly what idole worshippers did long ago, they prey to a dead man so that dead man talk to god for them,!!!, as if this dead man is kinder than god almighthy himself!!!!, ask god directly not a dead man that could not even prevented his own demise.
well in this Dua we just ask Allah directly but you didn't answer my questions!?do we know better than Allah&Prophet? if you ask a person 4 help is that Shirk? When Allah says don't call people who are killed in his path dead, were you absent on that lesson?! read Quran! what you heard has another meaning, Ask Allah directly or via the means(wasilah) that Allah has told you,healing is from Allah why do you go to doctors then just ask Allah!?learn the path from its source not second hand!
Hi, no asking a live person for help if he/she can provide it (considering you did all you can) is ok, but these shias gods are dead people and can do nothing for no one including themselves, look i know is hard to admit the truth specially if you have reminded yourslf a matter all your life, but the truth is that ebrahim,...mohamd all came to break idoles (live or dead)and talk to god directly, all you have to do is to think that is all, (no mediator in islam) simply ask god.Think .thanks
one needs to read the holy Quran and Hadith and see what Allah twt says, not making a religion in his mind and assuming that Islam is what HE thinks! Tawassul and asking others including people who are not alive is part of our religion&has always been,some misguided (or evil) people like ibn taymiah in the last few hundred years started making up religion which is what you see now in saudi,there are so many places that Allah orders people to go through other people rather asking directly
i was born in shia family and i always had question regarding the nonsense in both shie and sunii, i did read quran, and most hadith
are fabricated, beside do you think quran is not completed on its own right that needs amendments? think about it if you are after truth
(which i think you are) in any rate god gave all of us the most valuable tool that is brain, (not emams) and wants you to think not obey blindly. have a nice day.
if your brain's enough what's the point of Prophets?you read Quran so what's the meaning of Wasilah in Quran?why do we ask in our prayers every day to be guided to the path of "people who were blessed.." with all our brains how come we're getting nowhere and no answer to my questions !? i didn't make Shiaism the Prophet SAW mentions in hadith Ali and his Shias...if all Ahadith are fabricated what's your religion with a book that you don't understand?!YOU choose what you believe&I choose mine!
super human being in all culture for example greeek methology, or turks and persian methology, so these imams have similar story, they were human being
(by the way did they work, how come they had so many wives and childeren how did they support them think about it, or just they spent the heritance received from their father????!!!), i know is hard to think objectively but that is the only way to get close to the truth, and soceity has its own force toform people belifs.
but god clearly states in quran call me directly very clear message, no shafi, secondly your assumtion abour these imams are wrong therfore you end up with wrong conclusion, these imams were people like us , they would get angry, happy, sad,..etc, they were human after all, but since you shias consider
them like god ,you think they did not have these feelings and wrong thoughts , but they did and human being throught history have had tendency to creat
you know nothing about Imam AS! don't bother commenting on Islam or Shia. first find a religion and then talk about it. I know Islam better than you and what you know about your Comet or Kant! learn first then talk. Until then keep your ignorance to yourself
You are a true moslem and specialy shia, because you are not reasoning but insulting , is this what islam and shia teaches you?instead of getting angry simply use your brain that is all, but since you are not sure about your belife so you get mad, look think whatever you want to think and stay in darkness, i just tried to shed a light un to you dark world.
wow! you are have enlightened all of us!!!! we were all waiting for you to come and clarify what Islam and Shia were!!!!! fantastic now I'm not living in the darkness!!! Nobody's angry, you got what you asked for!
arguing is not my intention, as a matter of fact i was enlighthen by others such as tabari,kasravi, ali dasti, etc.., people who did investigate the history unlike people like you who follow blindly, and i am not alone lots of people think like me, because it is the fact oh history but is hard for you alike to digest but you may see the tunel be , why not god gave you brain too, as i said belive in whatever, i just wanted to raise your level of understanding no need to fight. thanks
i was right! you haven't read the holy Quran even once! so you have brain to listen to the some other losers but if one reads the book and though and did research that makes him misguided!! by the way I'm your age if your profile is telling the truth and I know about Islam more than you and your friends that you mentioned all together if that helps!
lollllllllll,why are you so mad,is ok relax, i dont realy know you level of knowledge about history of islam and sheism, but apparently you have lack of it since you dont know historian like tabari, kasravi or dashti,lolllllllll, otherwise you would not make comment like this (losers,lolllllllll, ), you dont act like your age , you should control your temper by now, if you have no doubt on you faith why do you get mad?i am not your enemy, i just have different point of veiw.relax.good day.
believe me i'm relax/enjoying thrashing you!about your losers:if u mean al-tabari:he spent all his life for islam/its history&died sunni!other iranian tabari was a poppet of communism!kasravi was opened his mouth too much&fadayian islam sent him to hell where he belonged!dashti like you never learnt anything about Islam but talked about it! ofcourse you're dashti's follower that's why you don't read Quran! losers! u see i know your imams but you don't know mine! u're too trivial to be my enemy!
full of inferiority complex , you folks live by hating others and can not live in harmony with them bunch of trouble makers and so fool hardy
and think you know it all,lolllll, yet are incompetent of carrying a simple conversation with the opponent but turn in any conversation to tiff or fight .
you folks needs to be kept in mental institution before harming yourself or others before you become another navab safavi .
oh yeah confused about your idiocy and of course hate people like you but better looking, always smart and nice smell and much more active than you and your loser friends, as my Prophet and Imams were, you dirty sod! why did you leave your beloved country you coward! I'm here as I'm so talented and in demand all over the world mr loser!
like you a typical shie and if you get a chance you kill like navab safavi who was ignorant, stupid and with an abject nature a killer , full of inferiority complex, ,and it seems like you follow people like him so you should share the same blood line,3) I am really ashamed of calling you an Iranian ,
you are too abject to be Iranian,4) you really can not distinguish between so called aema and historian and historical reference, that shows how
great! I pissed you off! what happened to "relax" no need to be ashamed as I dissociate myself from you and people like you. you're a puppet like your leaders!
lollllllllllllllllll, dissociate???/?looooooooooooooolllllllllllllllllllllllll, how old are you?lollllllllpuppet?/lollllllllllllll, my leadres?lollllllllllllllllllllllllll, you really are ignorant,lollllllllllllllllllllll
LoLLLL, get a dictionary before reading your res ponse
1)first of all learn how to spell and correct your lame grammar and spelling, 2) your ambiguous writing is telling me that you hate those who dont think
you are mentaly sick a person who wants to kill and hates others whom dont think like him and full of hate and inferiority complex and hypocret i can not find any world to describe him except he/she is mentaly sick that is all i can say you live in stupid land, i just waisted my time , dont write back to me again you animal.
when you finished with your "lolllllll" you might want to find some time to cry for yourself your loser kasravi/dashti..... friends
listen don't think i'm writing to you! you get it because you came to this video's comments, as i said before this is not your place, go and watch breast augmentation movie! no need for you to insult Shia/Islam and by the way, people like you are worse than animal: Surah A'raf verse 7
wow! you are have enlightened all of us!!!! we were all waiting for you to come and clarify what Islam and Shia were!!!!! fantastic now I'm not living in the darkness!!! Nobody's angry, you got what you asked for!
lollllllllll, ok my freind,first of all not all hadth are fabricated but i dont rely on it , but it seems like you folks do a lot, idole worshipperes in time of mohamad said similar say as shie, they said we dont worship them but they are "shafi" beacuse they are closer to god,...etc,
khodavada ghalbhaye ma ra be nore iman norani farma
SNA313 9 months ago
یا الهی و ربی من لی غیرک
shojaei81 1 year ago
kos nagu.heywan..riydam tu dahanet
mmnassl14 1 year ago
الخوف من الله
schoolprofessional20 1 year ago
sedaye binazir.haj mansour doset daram. kheyli kheili ziyad.
masoudghaani2010 2 years ago
alte Mist.passt nicht in dise zeit
mmnassl14 2 years ago
doset daram azizam.
masoud39jaan 2 years ago
khodaya be haghe in dua yek marge zodres be man bedeh. be haghe fateme zahra mano bebakhsh va bebar kheyli kheyli zood.
masoud39jaan 2 years ago
@masoud39jaan chera arezuye margh mikoni? az khoda naomid nasho, khoda bozorghe, chera narahati?
kuroshe1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
کیر خر تو کس زن منصور ارضی
cilrvo 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
حاج منصور ارضی يک خوار کسه مادر جنده است.
malavi2004 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
حاج منصور ارضی يک خوار کسه مادر جنده است.
malavi2004 2 years ago
Thanks..very nice..very nice
ericcalm 2 years ago
انشالله به برکت این دعای امام علی ع همه شیعیان پیرو واقعی باشند
atashoo 2 years ago
@atashoo shoma chand salete?
kuroshe1 2 years ago
maghe khoda morde ke az morde talabe komak mikoni, maghar moshreki?
kuroshe1 2 years ago
why couldn't God send all blessings directly? like heat without the Sun, guidance without prophets, etc.?! why did God ask people to ask Rasulullah SAW for pray for them to be forgiven? why did Allah twt asked people to use means to reach Him? I hope by answering these questions you get your answer.
hjvhr 2 years ago
ok, what you are saying is compelety against what prophit mohamad and ebrahim stood against, they both came to teach folks to reach god directly not through any meduim whether god or idole, please note what i just wrote , what shi do is exactly what idole worshippers did long ago, they prey to a dead man so that dead man talk to god for them,!!!, as if this dead man is kinder than god almighthy himself!!!!, ask god directly not a dead man that could not even prevented his own demise.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
well in this Dua we just ask Allah directly but you didn't answer my questions!?do we know better than Allah&Prophet? if you ask a person 4 help is that Shirk? When Allah says don't call people who are killed in his path dead, were you absent on that lesson?! read Quran! what you heard has another meaning, Ask Allah directly or via the means(wasilah) that Allah has told you,healing is from Allah why do you go to doctors then just ask Allah!?learn the path from its source not second hand!
hjvhr 2 years ago
Hi, no asking a live person for help if he/she can provide it (considering you did all you can) is ok, but these shias gods are dead people and can do nothing for no one including themselves, look i know is hard to admit the truth specially if you have reminded yourslf a matter all your life, but the truth is that ebrahim,...mohamd all came to break idoles (live or dead)and talk to god directly, all you have to do is to think that is all, (no mediator in islam) simply ask god.Think .thanks
kuroshe1 2 years ago
one needs to read the holy Quran and Hadith and see what Allah twt says, not making a religion in his mind and assuming that Islam is what HE thinks! Tawassul and asking others including people who are not alive is part of our religion&has always been,some misguided (or evil) people like ibn taymiah in the last few hundred years started making up religion which is what you see now in saudi,there are so many places that Allah orders people to go through other people rather asking directly
hjvhr 2 years ago
i was born in shia family and i always had question regarding the nonsense in both shie and sunii, i did read quran, and most hadith
are fabricated, beside do you think quran is not completed on its own right that needs amendments? think about it if you are after truth
(which i think you are) in any rate god gave all of us the most valuable tool that is brain, (not emams) and wants you to think not obey blindly. have a nice day.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
if your brain's enough what's the point of Prophets?you read Quran so what's the meaning of Wasilah in Quran?why do we ask in our prayers every day to be guided to the path of "people who were blessed.." with all our brains how come we're getting nowhere and no answer to my questions !? i didn't make Shiaism the Prophet SAW mentions in hadith Ali and his Shias...if all Ahadith are fabricated what's your religion with a book that you don't understand?!YOU choose what you believe&I choose mine!
hjvhr 2 years ago
super human being in all culture for example greeek methology, or turks and persian methology, so these imams have similar story, they were human being
(by the way did they work, how come they had so many wives and childeren how did they support them think about it, or just they spent the heritance received from their father????!!!), i know is hard to think objectively but that is the only way to get close to the truth, and soceity has its own force toform people belifs.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
but god clearly states in quran call me directly very clear message, no shafi, secondly your assumtion abour these imams are wrong therfore you end up with wrong conclusion, these imams were people like us , they would get angry, happy, sad,..etc, they were human after all, but since you shias consider
them like god ,you think they did not have these feelings and wrong thoughts , but they did and human being throught history have had tendency to creat
kuroshe1 2 years ago
you know nothing about Imam AS! don't bother commenting on Islam or Shia. first find a religion and then talk about it. I know Islam better than you and what you know about your Comet or Kant! learn first then talk. Until then keep your ignorance to yourself
hjvhr 2 years ago
You are a true moslem and specialy shia, because you are not reasoning but insulting , is this what islam and shia teaches you?instead of getting angry simply use your brain that is all, but since you are not sure about your belife so you get mad, look think whatever you want to think and stay in darkness, i just tried to shed a light un to you dark world.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
wow! you are have enlightened all of us!!!! we were all waiting for you to come and clarify what Islam and Shia were!!!!! fantastic now I'm not living in the darkness!!! Nobody's angry, you got what you asked for!
hjvhr 2 years ago
arguing is not my intention, as a matter of fact i was enlighthen by others such as tabari,kasravi, ali dasti, etc.., people who did investigate the history unlike people like you who follow blindly, and i am not alone lots of people think like me, because it is the fact oh history but is hard for you alike to digest but you may see the tunel be , why not god gave you brain too, as i said belive in whatever, i just wanted to raise your level of understanding no need to fight. thanks
kuroshe1 2 years ago
i was right! you haven't read the holy Quran even once! so you have brain to listen to the some other losers but if one reads the book and though and did research that makes him misguided!! by the way I'm your age if your profile is telling the truth and I know about Islam more than you and your friends that you mentioned all together if that helps!
hjvhr 2 years ago
lollllllllll,why are you so mad,is ok relax, i dont realy know you level of knowledge about history of islam and sheism, but apparently you have lack of it since you dont know historian like tabari, kasravi or dashti,lolllllllll, otherwise you would not make comment like this (losers,lolllllllll, ), you dont act like your age , you should control your temper by now, if you have no doubt on you faith why do you get mad?i am not your enemy, i just have different point of veiw.relax.good day.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
believe me i'm relax/enjoying thrashing you!about your losers:if u mean al-tabari:he spent all his life for islam/its history&died sunni!other iranian tabari was a poppet of communism!kasravi was opened his mouth too much&fadayian islam sent him to hell where he belonged!dashti like you never learnt anything about Islam but talked about it! ofcourse you're dashti's follower that's why you don't read Quran! losers! u see i know your imams but you don't know mine! u're too trivial to be my enemy!
hjvhr 2 years ago
full of inferiority complex , you folks live by hating others and can not live in harmony with them bunch of trouble makers and so fool hardy
and think you know it all,lolllll, yet are incompetent of carrying a simple conversation with the opponent but turn in any conversation to tiff or fight .
you folks needs to be kept in mental institution before harming yourself or others before you become another navab safavi .
kuroshe1 2 years ago
i can see you're full of love and logic!!!
hjvhr 2 years ago
ignorant and misinformed you are, a typical shie ,I should not expect too much from someone who affirm these nonsense ceremonies(sine zani ashura,
and all these nonsense or better yet preposterous act)5) if you hate west and western values what are you doing in England??? Land of infidel??
You folks are bunch of confused hypocrite and hate mongers,lazy and ugly in appearance, even your bad odor can be sensed miles away ,
kuroshe1 2 years ago
oh yeah confused about your idiocy and of course hate people like you but better looking, always smart and nice smell and much more active than you and your loser friends, as my Prophet and Imams were, you dirty sod! why did you leave your beloved country you coward! I'm here as I'm so talented and in demand all over the world mr loser!
hjvhr 2 years ago
like you a typical shie and if you get a chance you kill like navab safavi who was ignorant, stupid and with an abject nature a killer , full of inferiority complex, ,and it seems like you follow people like him so you should share the same blood line,3) I am really ashamed of calling you an Iranian ,
you are too abject to be Iranian,4) you really can not distinguish between so called aema and historian and historical reference, that shows how
kuroshe1 2 years ago
great! I pissed you off! what happened to "relax" no need to be ashamed as I dissociate myself from you and people like you. you're a puppet like your leaders!
hjvhr 2 years ago
lollllllllllllllllll, dissociate???/?looooooooooooooolllllllllllllllllllllllll, how old are you?lollllllllpuppet?/lollllllllllllll, my leadres?lollllllllllllllllllllllllll, you really are ignorant,lollllllllllllllllllllll
kuroshe1 2 years ago
LoLLLL, get a dictionary before reading your res ponse
1)first of all learn how to spell and correct your lame grammar and spelling, 2) your ambiguous writing is telling me that you hate those who dont think
kuroshe1 2 years ago
I hold the highest degree in English language you loser! and guess what!
you've made 86 mistakes in your comments so far! have you counted them?! I bet you can't count either!!!
hjvhr 2 years ago
you are mentaly sick a person who wants to kill and hates others whom dont think like him and full of hate and inferiority complex and hypocret i can not find any world to describe him except he/she is mentaly sick that is all i can say you live in stupid land, i just waisted my time , dont write back to me again you animal.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
when you finished with your "lolllllll" you might want to find some time to cry for yourself your loser kasravi/dashti..... friends
listen don't think i'm writing to you! you get it because you came to this video's comments, as i said before this is not your place, go and watch breast augmentation movie! no need for you to insult Shia/Islam and by the way, people like you are worse than animal: Surah A'raf verse 7
hjvhr 2 years ago 3
lollllllllllll, you are stupid , you are mentaly sick.
kuroshe1 2 years ago
you did not tell me, how old are you??
kuroshe1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow! you are have enlightened all of us!!!! we were all waiting for you to come and clarify what Islam and Shia were!!!!! fantastic now I'm not living in the darkness!!! Nobody's angry, you got what you asked for!
hjvhr 2 years ago
lollllllllll, ok my freind,first of all not all hadth are fabricated but i dont rely on it , but it seems like you folks do a lot, idole worshipperes in time of mohamad said similar say as shie, they said we dont worship them but they are "shafi" beacuse they are closer to god,...etc,
kuroshe1 2 years ago
the way you referred to our beloved Prophet SAW shows that you are not a real muslim! you didn't answer my questions because you couldn't!
hjvhr 2 years ago
Hi,
that is a good advice that people like yourself should practice, because apparently you folks made a religion of your self(sheisim),
i dont the person whom you mentioned but if he was against deadworshipness and asking daed man and prey to them i am with him 100%,
kuroshe1 2 years ago
i bet you haven't read Quran even once!
hjvhr 2 years ago
How old are you?
kuroshe1 2 years ago
اللهم صل علی محمد و ال محمد
اللهم ارحمنا و ایدنا فی هذه الدنیاالدنیه
خدایا ما را یاری نما که دعا خوان واقعی باشیم و از زروزیور دنیا خلاصی یابیم
0142a 2 years ago 6
اللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد ..
flana7 2 years ago 4
Thanks for your upload.
abbasalian 2 years ago
@abbasalian rasti shoma in dastanhaie ke in shakhs mighe bavar kardid?
kuroshe1 2 years ago