Diana Vickers With or Without You X Factor 2008 Live Show

[OtakuJavier]

U2 Forever

[MrLisztomaniac]

Didn't really fancy it

[liabro]

HER HANDS ARE SO ANNOYING

But i like her singing

[Daftaffect]

so much prettier here!!!

[URno1REQUESTER]

Sorry, I tried to like her cover. But all I could hear was complete rubbish.=D

[Liamzki491]

@URno1REQUESTER well screw you this was awesome!

[anonymooseist]

If you can smile after singing this song, you're not singing this song. She smiled.

[Novinte]

Loved this style, like she came straight from Skins.

[Suse643]

I THINK IT IS AWFUL, NO FEELING AT ALL!!

[papcyrill]

she need more work,,, FAIL

[giovitara82]

That made me cry more then the original!

[xoxoAYEOOOxoxo]

beautiful voice <3

[jeezy9007]

yo if you are a singer add your video on to defSpot com

they supporting aspiring new music artists

[YouBritishTuber]

i hated her on x factor, but i really liked this song by her

[Shane444888]

butchered

[grace317]

I like her voice but I REALLY can't stand the yodel/hiccup at the end of almost every line. Even if that's her "unique" point.

[9A114N0]

@grace317 i think the hiccup thing is just enhanced by the microphone tbh it annoyed me aswell but i think its definately the microphone

[princesslol096]

he voice is good though some notes not so good. 

[jojogirl1000]

"you are the singing version of marmite" haha gotta love simon cowell

[TheUrbanrory]

she suits soft and emotional songs.

[emzemzz]

i wonder what she sounds like when she's not singing threw her nose..

[sheMan32]

I think her label has changed her changed her too much the only song on her album that resembles this diana is 'Notice' check it out is amazing!!

[Davedude111]

Diana you're a great singer but stop yodling!

[TomKennyIsLovely]

My favourite Diana Vickers song. She both softens and haunts the melody.

I prefer the more acoustic songs on her album (Four Leaf Clover, N.U.M.B), but the pop stuff isn't too bad either. I'm so pleased she's done well for herself :)

[LollingTimesTen]

Her new album is too pop-r&b, it doesnt suit her voice. Also, she looked better in dresses and quirky outfits. Can't help but think she'd had to change herself into a generic tart to keep up with the music industry these days :/

[cesasbo]

crap really

[dbackyardb]

this was good :)

[TheTrUeLoVeDoEsExIsT]

her hands really anoy me did she really have to move them that much?

[4EVAVIVALARAZA]

i think this song worked really good with her especially the with or with out u bit!

[EmmiJ82]

Love her now, but absolutely adored her back then! She was always my favourite to win! I love everything about her, her voice, her look, even the bare feet and the claw! This was a stunning performance. She is unique, and her voice is gorgeous.

[HaRdStYlE214]

it sound a little like shakira :)

[oo0abbie0oo]

is it just me or does she look a bit like ke$ha???

[moonlitshadow100]

@oo0abbie0oo maybe if kesha tidied herself up a bit then yeah, they'd probably look alike, come to think of it...

[Smileygirl207]

i love itt x

[OTHsmallvillefan]

this was the only week i liked her

[jacktee5]

I think she's a good singer however I don't think this song was suited to her voice at all.

[LizPer49]

kinda makes me remember amy whinehouse at the begining

gr8 voice

[BladeGuitarGirl]

2.02 = cute :)

[Reminisent]

I'd tap that

[ben250f8]

same

[xxRockst4r]

@Reminisent I'd rape that

[pixieclef]

i absolutely loved her on here. she was so lovely and pure, now everything she does is contrived and overthought. fucking waste. never mind her overwhelming cockyness these days.

[twilight1aholic]

i loved her when she was on the x factor.

this is the diana i loved she was quirky and had her own way of singing.

im not sure if i like her new look and all her new songs.

[cjovs208]

@twilight1aholic i agreee:)

[HollieCullen17]

i love dianaa!!!

[Ponylovere]

How to ruin a song... this is it

[XxTheUnmissablexX]

She would of nailed a cranberries song

[hautenarcissism]

@XxTheUnmissablexX ia so much. i'd of loved to hear her version of zombie.

[Beatmyguest001]

@XxTheUnmissablexX Oh. My. God.

I have ALWAYS thought she would have sang a Cranberries song perfectly.

[Pinguollie7]

she should have won, nevermind girl, shes done amazing, rock on girl u rule!!!!! xx

[frenchclaret32]

Love her and her hand movements, she is unique.

[Kimmehhhhhhh]

To think I saw her perform live when she was supporting Scouting For Girls :) Arh before I wasn't really interested in her music, and I saw her live and she surprised me in a good way!! I now own her album and love herrr.! x

[TheFlowerbudz]

Annoyin. Just No.!

[Fight0Tyranny]

What a beautiful unique voice, I love it! this is what we need to hear! something fresh, new and incredibly soulful!

[TwitterBug26]

Wow. Very impressed.  She's great.

[PretendPerfect]

nice dress and voice :D

[cassablanca20]

liked her so much in x-factor, but her album really dissapointed me :( such a beautiful voice goes to waste in bad music and terrible lyrics...

[Blazze6969]

shut up lewi

[Meenie92]

@Miss07Erinxx not really, but i suppose it helps

[PoppyProductions24]

My friend says I reminded me of her, but I hadnt watched X factor so I wasnt sure If it was good or bad. Now I know its very very very good :)

[JamieZeleneGlades]

@Miss07Erinxx That's not a very good argument. That's like saying maybe you only don't like her because you're not as "pretty". Quit being so immature. People like her for her unique voice and personality. It's refreshing. If you don't like her or her music, just don't watch and don't listen. What's so difficult about that? It's not as if she's forcing her voice down your throat. You have every option to switch to another page anytime.

[IckleMissVikki]

this made me love her.

[mikyfdh]

how is she like shakira? she's not trying to b sexy or any of that, she's being herself, ever think maybe her voice naturally does that?

[RayatoTV]

I live in the US and this was the clip that got me into X Factor. She is so good! I <3 her!

[imali249]

she sang this, amazingly.

[smexxage]

personally I think she has the most annoying voice ever!! Like a wannabe shakira!! Stop yodelling!

[Damiuss]

Her voice reminds me of Dolores O'Riordan, the lead singer from The Cranberries.

[thestateofman]

@Damiuss OH YES SHE DOES. I loved The Cranberries, too bad they disbanded.

[mollymermaid100]

She sung through her nose :(

[bodomboy22]

this girl is beautiful!!!

[donnakabab100]

Love her voice....sooo soothing !! She shud have won...cummon where are you now Diana ???? we want More xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[ninakicharm]

great! she kinda look like ashley tisdale!

:P

[MegaEmo94]

NY1 ELSE THINK SHE LOOKS LIKE A BLONDE CHERYL COLE??X

[jazzxoxm]

ilikethis:D

[JackHobbsMusic]

What's with the hands?

[simpleplansora]

she's talented ! I'd so buy her CD !

[SeriousBieberLove]

i adore this song..... :)

[TheSxcbiatch]

brill !!!!

[riddem82]

she sounds so much like shakira at some points in this video,  bloddy good tho (y)

[virionpaktori]

it sucks

[AlenaJolie]

I like her. I didn't care too much for her version of Hallelujah but I like her better here.

[13AlexeRock74]

what happen to her hair... damn

[lutherflipflops]

luvv u nd ur voice

[charliebabie2]

I sooooo wish she was the winner!

[Crazynu]

she sounds like Amy Winehouse..!

[clickclocks]

@Crazynu No she doesn't. She sounds nothing like her. What a stupid comparison.

[Crazynu]

@clickclocks ok.. dick she doesn't sound like Amy Winehouse. i am sorry..oh your name is not dick is it?..or are u just one of those heads??..oi i didn't follow up a freaking audiology degree before i comment on this. she sings great and i love her voice. i would compare anyone with her and you are not official to state i am wrong. stop trying to be a dick if your name is not ..

[Crazynu]

@clickclocks i didn't talk to you midget!

[clickclocks]

@Crazynu You did talk to me. You left a comment on a public web site for EVERYONE to see. I am a part of "everyone". Therefore, you were talking to me and I can reply.

[Crazynu]

@clickclocks so i say to everyone go screw your self..

[clickclocks]

@Crazynu Now you're getting it. Well done.

[kjturbospeed]

she seems somewhat fake

[LuisSantos1994]

¤ø„¸¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨ post to 9 other vids

¨°º¤ø„¸ Copy „ø¤º°¨ press F5 twice

¸„ø¤º°¨Paste ``°º¤ø„¸ OK

¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º look at ur background

[mekaththeoneandonly]

I think her voice is better when you really goes for it.

[benryanowen]

is it just me or does she sound like the woman from the cardigans? think about it

[drewe23]

actually she is number 1

[RihannaaObsessionn]

shes amazing!

[1997chloesmith]

Think she should have won, i think this song suits her perfectly xx

[xXSceneGirl56Xx]

i think she sings this song better than the actual singer who sings this song :)

[Montywhittle]

What an amazing career she's having? I think not....I heard her record company has already dropped her, O' well she can always be a captain on 'Bring on the wall' hahahaha, Like 90% of runts on this show yesterdays chip paper, never to be heard of again. This weird little wanna be fairy was on a TV program nothing more...good luck with Panto this year Diana.......

[twilightaddiction001]

i love love love love love her voice, and the song is just perfect! U2 is awesome!

[LittleBluePixie26]

im not a cheesy person normally, but i actually cried at my sleepover when she went out, kinda awkward

[JustJodie95]

simply beautiful.

so breathtaking.

she's amazing and unique and she deserved to win.

<3

[tinkthesinger]

This is to the best singer in the world I am your biggest fan ever, I cried when you got out for ages, I love you Diana Vickers With or without you and Man in the mirror are my best ones xxx

[OrlaithMx]

the xfactor contestants are way more vocaly talented than the american idol contestants were at this stage

[selvaescalada]

You're a beautiful and extremely talented young woman. I wish you the best from Canada. Oh boy, what a beautiful future you have. Don't blow it; don't change your humbleness.

[Ruth1988]

i hope she does releases this as a single!!!!! i'd buy it now!!!

[xfjjx]

i love diana :D

[tony21zd]

shit

[JustJodie95]

@tony21zd you're shit. diana is amazing.

[MariaRialas]

i love diana so much <3 <3

[StarJunkiexD]

this was her best me thinks (:

[BLACKESTANGEL]

I live in the US, so I never got to see X Factor, and am catching up on youtube with all the amazing singers that win. OMG, this girl has a beautiful and incredible voice!

[MistyMooWebShow]

simon your mushy peas Shes AMAZING how dare he call her marmite stupid mushed up pea bum chicken thing.

[4NEE]

Simon Cowell said she is like Marmite I think she is like gravy.................. you can not have a Sunday lunch with out it. TOP ACE GIRL so grounded and talented needs to really believe that she can be a concert filling artist on a huge scale. She so should have won X Factor so talented and "the hand" is so sexy and in touch with the music. Got the album on order got my ticket to her concert yeeeeee harrrrrrrrrrrr!!!!!!!

[rusticgirl145]

This girl has unexpectedly strong voice.

[TomBrandon121]

Loving Diana's debut single...

She should just ignore the pathetic haters... She's a very talented woman, and who gives a shit if you find her 'hand gestures' annoying..

[SuicidalBadgerz]

She'd be really good for a music track on a disney film or something. Or any film for that matter :)

[Drummully]

Dannii Minogue was so right!! Puppet show! Diana is really good though!

GO Dannii!!

[DazTubez]

SHUT UP DANNIE MANOUGE YOU POO!

[KirstySpencer1991]

If you're not a fan of Diana, wtf are you doing here?

Seriously guys. Just quit it. This was 2 years ago, get over it. She does hand gestures, sweet Jesus... so does pretty much every single singer on the planet. So shut up.

[kewliokate]

Love her so much should have been the winner! xxx

[sweetdreams1405]

@kewliokate If she had won, she wouldnt have had that much of a say in the songs on the album.

[kewliokate]

@sweetdreams1405 I know but i still reckon she was the best probs a blessing in disguise

[ramsen77]

i love (l) !!!!

[farhannius]

i hate that thing she does with her voice after each sentence like it goes up in pitch at the end, its SO annoying

[VemundVR]

YEah! Agree! Ugly

[MrLondoner1]

i donnnu man

i like her but not anymore

[manshark5]

I can't believe anyone is saying she's any good. I applaud her for trying as i would anyone, but singing is not her strong point. You can go to any Kereoke or amateur competition and hear much better.

[VemundVR]

@manshark5 So right.

[elanamiranda]

I love the way she sings (L)

[qmoroz]

To people who don't like her voice, dress, gestures:

go to The X Factor 2010, sing what you like and how you like, gesturing your way and wearing what you want, and if you are able to get at least final twelve, you'll be able to judge this song.

[jonatinho100]

stop all the hate message.

its her style to perform so shut the fuck up!

[chinkychinxs]

i love her voicee , i luv her dress to :D

[Daireoxo]

fucking hell. this sounds like shit in a microwave. please stop.

[Ela1337]

I actually love the dress

[starmaverick]

what the fuck is she wearing? i guess she's inherited a bad dress sense from Cheryl Cole

[starmaverick]

what the fuck is she wearing?!

[stefflonsche]

she's really cool, but i am so annoyed of her gestures! keep the hands calm girl ;-)

[misshenthorne23]

Diana is so good. And the song 'Once' is for someone that she loves and your saying it is a load of rubbish went that song proberbly has lots of centimental value :)

[33jenas]

I love this verson shes so amazing!

: )

[Dupske]

unique voice! Love it!!

[SarahJigglypuff]

"Once" (her first single!) is an amazing pop song.

[KileyLagan]

Absolutely beautiful!

[DearNGuyo]

beautiful voice! soo unique (: <3 , and i love her hair xD lolll, how does she do that? Ö! XD lolll

[rojaynee]

@DearNGuyo tease and spray hope tht helped

[BlueRush]

After this, she went a little too far in the inevitable pop direction, aka Simon Cowell's safe zone.

This was raw mesmerising beauty and I hope there'll be some songs like this on her album in April!

[ZoeIsLostAlone]

i remember watching this and being completely speechless. in my opinion this is perfect :) i really hope there's some songs on her album like this!

[Montywhittle]

@ZoeIsLostAlone My word, it doesn't take much to impress you does it.

[ZoeIsLostAlone]

@Montywhittle Was that comment even necessary? Music's all about opinions as i'm sure you know, i like her because she's different and unique, i'm all for anything that isn't like normal pop music (ie. JLS, cheryl cole). She's quirky and weird and i like it

[Montywhittle]

@ZoeIsLostAlone Unique? how? what because she walks around with no shoes on singing like a fairy on Helium.....how's that unique....more like pretentious. The whole point of YouTube is to comment, on what you think, like you have and to debate, otherwise there would be little point to YouTube. I just find it hard to relate when you said it left you speechless. To me she is a product of a Karaoke program, and yesterdays chip paper.

[ZoeIsLostAlone]

@Montywhittle well there is no one else around like her and therefore she is unique...

i'm clearly not going to agree with you, but i understand where you're coming from with the karaoke/x factor thing, i think they usually ruin singers... for example i liked her here ^^ but i don't like her new single because she's been changed by the x factor.. but hey you never liked her to start with :/

[grang710]

An amazing job of killing this song

:/

[Pinsair1]

Just amazing

[mitchellsmomma]

Finally, a song she CAN sing. She has a voice that needs original songs written for her, she's just not a "cover" artist.

[jonasbrotherslove06]

lol have you not heard her new song 'Once', it was written for her and its a load of rubbish :(

[Montywhittle]

@mitchellsmomma Written for her? Yes you are right, she couldn't write a song to save her little fairy wings, she is nothing more than a Karaoke fairy.......and will be forgotten and make no ripple in the British Music industry...

[123bamboy321]

@Montywhittle haha, " she will make no ripple in the music industry" yeaah its not like she had a number one ..... :/ move along douche bag, seriously

[Montywhittle]

@123bamboy321 What's this another pubescent teen?...a number one where Poland? or in the uk singles charts where you have to sell about 20 copies. Get real, she's going to win nothing, Grammy no way! Brit Award...no way! no one gives a shit about this odd bod in the music industry, yesterdays fish and chip paper. She's no writter, no producer, no muscian just a helium filled fairy.

[SunMarsPluto]

@Montywhittle gaga won grammy, britney won grammy but they both are shit.

[JamieZeleneGlades]

@Montywhittle Erm. *Cough*. Firstly, Diana's debut single and debut album both reached Number 1 on the UK charts. Secondly, she was the leading actress in West End's revival of "The Rise and Fall of Little Voice", winning a Theatregoer's Choice Award. That says a lot about "this odd bod in the music industry" (as you put it). And knock, knock. Not everyone who wins a Grammy or Brit Award is that fantastic either. If you don't like her, just don't listen to her music. Jeesh.

[oOoD4M4GEoOo]

she is so fit

[mory86]

love her !

[cose304]

r u chocking?!? cause ur not singing!

[tiddlywinks98712]

yea, but she has a fucking cool voice. thats what dumb xfactor lovers dont actually take into account...which is why lame, wet tissue joe mceldry won this year..

[Retrospective18]

LOL Joe Mcelderry. What a joke... He has a fantastic voice for theater but I for one cannot seeing him going very far in our charts.

(Though saying that, our charts are rubbish anyway)

Danyl should have won!!

Diana should have won the year before...

Grr....

Yeah I'm a little pissed about it.

[leeshiful]

@Retrospective18 exactly, didnt even get number 1 AFTER christmas x

[leeshiful]

@Retrospective18 but olly x OLLY x

[Retrospective18]

Lol Olly was good (and very cute) but Danyl had the best voice in that competition. Just look what he did to an unreleased Whitney Houston song. Outstanding!!

Joe lacked feeling in his performances. Danyl had tons of it.

[leeshiful]

yeah, danyl was the most comfortable and natural on stage and that song was very good! but im from essex so i am aa bit biased x lol x