Great job, Geoff! Love your comedic timing in this one! Spot on! Not sure which one of you guy's (or the entire team) came-up with this... but it's absolutely brilliant! hahaha!
@alexzinger123 ummm.......I am afraid the answer to your first wish would be that you are the only person alive. World peace is achieved, because you are all thats left. You will be the government, and you can have whatever flag you want. You will also be the dictator, and seeing as you are alone you can make believe that you have all the power you want. :) Nice wishes
@Zirus101 it was, he then proceeded to kill the fish with more conventional methods. the rule was no eating magic fish, not no wishing to eat magic fish
He should have wished to have the infinite wish rule to not be there and he can have all the fish sandwich and shakes as he wants thumbs up if you agree with me
Does this make anyone else want a milkshake and a sandwich? Also, if you can remove a wish rule with a wish, why not remove the no wishing for extra wishes rule, then ask for more wishes.
fuck asking for two milkshakes...i would wish for a magic milkshake machine that automaticly makes any kind of milkshake and the milkshakes that come out of it never melt...thats a good fucking wish
I like gutting fish I did a ton of that when I was camping I like cutting off the heads also I was gutting one it slipped out of my hands into the river I jumped in after it my shoe fell off and I had the fish I pit it on the bridge and caught my shoe lol I got really wet and had to change and after I changed it was raining hard grrrr but I got to stay in my own tent with my awesome puppy ok u caught me he's 11 and a day older then me lol
Vsauce Song :D
BionicChronicle 1 hour ago
I have the same damn fishin rod...
MrStubby1997 3 hours ago
this was the first ever rooster teeth short i watched and then i watched more
mrkhrules 11 hours ago
Can \I wish for more wishes? No? How about a wish for more genies? Or talking wish fishes?
zalom1modur 19 hours ago
.... now I want a milkshake
CheeseEAster 23 hours ago
@CheeseEAster Me too... Good thing there's a Steak and Shake just down the road from my house. :)
ReachIsBeast 16 hours ago
Great job, Geoff! Love your comedic timing in this one! Spot on! Not sure which one of you guy's (or the entire team) came-up with this... but it's absolutely brilliant! hahaha!
RyanLec84 1 day ago
i like his thumb tatto
345lol345 2 days ago
I'd wish for two Cokes and some chips.
Mazsk 2 days ago
if you could change the rules with a wish, why wouldn't you wish to be able to wish for more wishes...
zenthex1234 2 days ago
@MrStokesy1 haha yeah thats what i ment to type thanks for telling me
jimmythedoom 3 days ago
nice one, cool...
charissemaelucero 3 days ago
if i had 3 wishes i'd wish for:
wish for 5 million dollars-entire family would be set for life that wait that
a 2012 chevy camero all black
immorality at a young age! cuz lets face it, video games are gonna be amazing in years might as well be able to play em forever rite
jimmythedoom 3 days ago
@jimmythedoom immorality... you mean immortality...
MrStokesy1 3 days ago
if i had 3 wishes i would...
have 100 games of my esire
join rooster teeth
and then have unlimited wishes
TyandJustin 3 days ago
If i had 3 wishes i'd wish:
1. that justin beiber would be dead
2. that i could join rooster teeth
3. that i could buy a 1000000 $ computer
asulikit11 4 days ago
i wish for a million wishes
gir2120 4 days ago
My three wishes would be
1. wish for that sweet fedora hat I saw last week
2. A new set of knives
3. for you to like this comment
IchiR0kuden4sh1 4 days ago
lame
gir2120 4 days ago
@IchiR0kuden4sh1 WISH DENIED!
zenthex1234 2 days ago
If i had 3 wishes, one of them would to have infinite more wishes. XP
0terminater0 5 days ago
i want a strawberry milkshake now
KGforBWood 5 days ago
fucking huzzah!
YXxACExXY 6 days ago in playlist Season 2
instead of more wishes, cant Geoff wish for more magic fish?
97ngel 1 week ago
you wanna get fin fucked? >:O
chimamirezero 1 week ago
can i wish for no ending wishes?
RememberTheVault101 1 week ago
Unlimited Wishs
Hawkeyes1377 1 week ago in playlist Season 2
if i had 1 wish i would ask for unlimited wishes
DinoBeak 1 week ago
@DinoBeak or just keep the fish
DinoBeak 1 week ago
you know what I'd wish for, supermodels, lots and lots XD
RogueShadow21 1 week ago
I just noticed that sometimes Geoff's holding the fish with one hand, and then he's holding with two.
MossOwnsYou 1 week ago in playlist Season 2
control time
immortal
cant get hurt
DeZeroGravityStudios 1 week ago
@DeZeroGravityStudios no wait third would be like the guy in prototype
DeZeroGravityStudios 1 week ago
I wish I were richer than Batman.... Yup, I'm good.
DevilMalice 1 week ago
I wish i could live 1 day in Geoff's world.
Squish888 1 week ago
I would wish for dumbasses to shut the fuck up
guyspeedingbyou 1 week ago
2 strip clubs
the ability to become batman
immortality
darknessknows1235 1 week ago
Its a branzino or European seabass
untipable 1 week ago
I wish I could wish for more wishes.
I wish for more wishes.
I wish for 10,000 milkshakes.
batmanownsyourass 1 week ago
what fish is that?
MegaDangerXD 1 week ago
@MegaDangerXD My guess is that its a cod.
js00981213 1 week ago
i would totally do the same wishes!!
evilbrickproduction 1 week ago
this is what happens when geoff goes places alone. dam i wish i was like geoff.
TheJakeJarrell 1 week ago
if I had 3 wishes I'd wish for:
world peace
the world to be united under one flag, nation and goverment
and for me to be ultimate overlord and dictator of the entire world....with complete power over the dark side of the force....yea....
alexzinger123 1 week ago 62
@alexzinger123 Because, that always ends well
jwnlink1 1 week ago
@alexzinger123 same for me just number 2 would be.... humans have hyperspace(faster then light travel.....
iDugong 1 week ago in playlist Season 2
@alexzinger123 ummm.......I am afraid the answer to your first wish would be that you are the only person alive. World peace is achieved, because you are all thats left. You will be the government, and you can have whatever flag you want. You will also be the dictator, and seeing as you are alone you can make believe that you have all the power you want. :) Nice wishes
OlCapitain 1 week ago
@alexzinger123 Comunisim >:)
xKab01 1 week ago
@alexzinger123
Live the dream man. :D
Illevia 6 days ago in playlist Season 2
@Illevia The idiot who elects me as prime minsiter will regret it....
alexzinger123 6 days ago
andy the fish bomb lol
pizzaman727 2 weeks ago
Fish power
Bojorquez6435 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
or you can just wish for more Magic Talking Fish and get 3 wishes each..
Simple Right? XD
NetsikXD 2 weeks ago in playlist Season 2
Comment removed
XRad1at1on 2 weeks ago in playlist Season 2
Who needs sleep when there's Roosterteeth?
metalgearepic1 2 weeks ago in playlist Season 2
Hilarious!!!
chedrick78 2 weeks ago
This video made me hungry and thrsty
jorobotify 2 weeks ago
Why not wish for more magic fishes
cloakhawk 2 weeks ago
is the fish andy?
XpLiZiTcOnTeNt7 2 weeks ago in playlist Season 2
@XpLiZiTcOnTeNt7 thats just what i thought
"you can't make an omelet without blowing up a few eggs"
"i like eggs"
"me too"
TheDOMAN127 2 weeks ago
Since you wished for more wishes but it's against the rules why not wish it wasn't. :)
UnholyImport 3 weeks ago 54
@UnholyImport Hey, it's Geoff we're talking about...
19Royal94 1 week ago
@UnholyImport cause then wher would be the smoothies..
TEAMINORITYSPOWNAGE 1 day ago
who else went to get a milk shack after this?
Kamarkuzikitten 3 weeks ago
@wongrufus Vat19 huh?
jnmulevideos 3 weeks ago
Roosterteeth, why must you make me always want a sandwich...? XD
DarkGhostIII 3 weeks ago in playlist Season 2
fishing hook with a gummybear? who's thinking about vat19 right now =o
wongrufus 3 weeks ago
Its Like Geoffs brother
TylerDrift 4 weeks ago
Wait wat?
Wish 1: 2 Milkshakes
Wish 2: 1 Milkshake
Wish 3: Eating him wasnt against the rules
Wish 4: Talking fish sandwich
I THOUGHT THAT THERE WERE ONLY 3 WISHES
Caboose5011 1 month ago
@Caboose5011 the sandwich wasn't an actual wish, he just cooked him :-)
TuarenManners 4 weeks ago
@Caboose5011 no dummy widh 3 and 4 is just 1 wish
just like wish 1 2 milkshakes
pedrolioni 3 weeks ago
@Caboose5011 He only made three wishes. he made the sandwich himself-_-
JoeRobot17 3 weeks ago
@Caboose5011 he made the fish sandwich himself.
tennisplayer71 3 weeks ago
'Trout' Mouth *ba dum dis*
Bobo66712 1 month ago
he should wish 4 more talking fishes
dawg949 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
The beginning music is the same as Robert Llewellyn's "CarPool" series
Poxypriest 1 month ago
Hmmm, sandwich and no Burnie, WHAT IS THIS!!!
FullerAlpha 1 month ago
Lol
BLACKxMONSTER1 1 month ago
At frist I was like "DAMNIT GEOFF DON'T BE A FUCKTARD!" and then I was like "That went quite well accualy".
TheHiyy 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
i woulda wished for a 5 dollar shake, Pulp Fiction style.
limefish12 1 month ago
why not wish for more magic fish??
shiek150 1 month ago
lol i didnt think of a no wishing rule wish rule so we can do anything
tvgoing1 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
Wouldn't wishing for no rules be his last wish?
Zirus101 1 month ago
@Zirus101 it was, he then proceeded to kill the fish with more conventional methods. the rule was no eating magic fish, not no wishing to eat magic fish
bakumaster719 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
Reminds me of Andy. In the best way.
TheTaleOfSirRobin 1 month ago
this fish reminds me of andy...
bboymiilz 1 month ago
I would have wished for more magic fishes.
QuichKhast 1 month ago
vsauce music
nolemmingsplease 1 month ago
hmm...only 3 wishes? MORE WISH FISH!
Droopah1 1 month ago
Genius! :D
Cyanide & Happiness found a loophole in the "genie only grants 3 wishes" deal, though!
"I wish for more genies!"
Mayeur000Donz 1 month ago
Wow, Geoff really remindsme of Dewie from Malcolm in the Middle in this video
Postalbrush1 1 month ago
hm , does anyone know the song in the beginnig and end of the video ?
publicmasturbator666 1 month ago
not allowed to wish for more wishs why not wish for more magical talking fishe
theone89104 1 month ago
just wish for an everlasting strawberry milkshake
DeZeroGravityStudios 1 month ago
He should have wished to have the infinite wish rule to not be there and he can have all the fish sandwich and shakes as he wants thumbs up if you agree with me
Dcaipto40 1 month ago
did geoff just eat a raw fish?
BYoshi19 1 month ago
@BYoshi19 no he cooked it.
deathmakerXD 1 month ago
@deathmakerXD okay it looked like it was raw... :\
BYoshi19 1 month ago
anyone know the title of the intro and ending song? i might want it... ..
junfronda 1 month ago
@junfronda If you find out what it is, let me know, I like this music too.
FanAuthor1 1 month ago
He should of wished for the power to grant wishes
mynamesdonut 1 month ago
That really does seem like a nice day though
Bthakilla4rilla 1 month ago
Does this make anyone else want a milkshake and a sandwich? Also, if you can remove a wish rule with a wish, why not remove the no wishing for extra wishes rule, then ask for more wishes.
SelectHawk 1 month ago 180
@SelectHawk :C too much words make my thinkerbox hurts
chawnchuu 1 month ago 133
@chawnchuu Needs more bacon
MixmasterWright 3 weeks ago
@chawnchuu Nobody like this. keep it at 117
CrutialProductions 1 week ago
@SelectHawk it is hard for me because i just got my braces on and my teeth hurt
MultiAguaman 1 month ago
@SelectHawk You could also wish for more magic talking wishing fishes.
xXDb24x 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
@SelectHawk ...well played sir...
noname12327 1 month ago
@SelectHawk just wish for the mind erasing thing in men in black :3
gamelord002 1 month ago
@SelectHawk REALLY i could hav wished for it but that fucking fish pissed me off so much i just deep fryed it
albinomonkey27 1 month ago
@SelectHawk or ask for the ability to grant your own wishes
Hellgrinder0 1 month ago
@SelectHawk WISHCEPTION
MrDiglettdig 1 month ago
@SelectHawk or more fishes
ssamoyt18 3 weeks ago
@SelectHawk And while we're at it why not wish for more talking fish 2. You now ... for lunch
SCproductions12 3 weeks ago
@SelectHawk Or ask for more magic talking fish
skysthelimit112 2 weeks ago
@SelectHawk holy crap thats brilliant
SeargantSprinkles 2 weeks ago in playlist Rooster Teeth Shorts Volume 2
Comment removed
NetsikXD 2 weeks ago in playlist Season 2
ЙАААААААААААААААААЗЬ
X0l0Dok 1 month ago
i will sushi slap the shit out of u with my tail. lol
jjacosta97 1 month ago
how did he cook the fish, and where did the plate come from?
thedaniel234able 1 month ago
I'd like to go fishing with Geoff one day
91128man 1 month ago
Does anybody else want a full version of the intro song?
Kinda catchy.
NeptuneMS385 1 month ago
Awesome Video :D
OWN3DH34D5H0TZ 1 month ago
How about a tank full of magical talking fish that never die that do what you say all the time.
ZombieBros2121 1 month ago
fuck that fish
killerorange101 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
I absolutely HATE that Sony Entertainment Network ad
corporaldbag 1 month ago
wish for infinate money on a card what you don't have to pay taxes for!!
SuperPlasmaBlaze57 1 month ago
fuck asking for two milkshakes...i would wish for a magic milkshake machine that automaticly makes any kind of milkshake and the milkshakes that come out of it never melt...thats a good fucking wish
lordanikan3 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
swatiwawawa what a sand wich
nerfwar812 1 month ago
why not 1 wish that the infinite wish rule didnt apply 2 wish for unlimited wishes and so on
TheAwsomeguy9000 1 month ago
this episode was wierd...but funny nontheless
max0678 1 month ago in playlist Rooster Teeth Shorts Volume 2
He should have wished for more magic fish.
flipNese0822 1 month ago
wait why didnt he do this wish to remove the rule about wishing for more wishes than wish fore more
wowlagmaster 1 month ago
BOOYAH! FISH POWER!
FreddieTheMich 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
HEY! WHAT DO YOU KNOW? perhaps all the magical creatures we had on earth came across a dumbass like this and that's why we don't have them anymore!
makugx 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
Wow what a Nice Fish geoff should give him a Kick in his fishy ass
Battlefrontzocker1 1 month ago
geoff can fish!
...so that's how he feeds/keeps himself alive
rTin099 1 month ago
does geoff really have those tatoos?
NasHipHop1 1 month ago
geoff did what i would do, wish for food and milkshakes, i would wish for much more food though, MUCH MUCH MORE
jo64on 1 month ago
ANDY!?!?!
GumTreeGames 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
what if geoff wished that the rule against asking for more wishes didnt apply
Someonece 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
one of the tags is milkshakes XD
Loui12333 1 month ago
Why didn't he just wish for no rules, make another wish and then wish for more wishes? Infinite wishes!
asassajackal259 1 month ago in playlist Season 2
an average day at the pond
MrtheRhyan12 1 month ago
That sandwich looks delicious
zergki11ar 1 month ago
ANDY TURNED INTO A FISH?? WHY DID NO ONE TELL ME! *runs off to a nearby river
DeadFaceism 2 months ago
I would wish for more magic fish.
582Thomas 2 months ago
Man I could go for a strawberry milkshake rite about now
DemonicArtZ 2 months ago
Why didnt he wish that wishing for more wishes wasnt against the rules?
uClicked 2 months ago
@uClicked Exactly what I was thinking.
MarioBlast12345 1 month ago
@MarioBlast12345 Great minds think alike.
And Geoff does not have a great mind...
He is my favorite guy in Roosterteeth, though. If I could meet anybody there, I'd wanna meet Geoff.
uClicked 1 month ago
@uClicked Or maybe Joel. God dang I love him.
MarioBlast12345 1 month ago
@MarioBlast12345 Did you see him with the Button? He doesn't care about people!
...But he is HILARIOUS. Also as Caboose.
uClicked 1 month ago
@uClicked Caboose is my favorite character in Red vs. Blue. Love that series and him too.
MarioBlast12345 1 month ago
@MarioBlast12345 Fair enough. I personally like Geoff out of all of them, including Grif.
uClicked 1 month ago
das a good milkshake
NatzeeJew 2 months ago
Now I want a talking fish sandwich. :P :b
waternetgame 2 months ago
Gummy Bear With A Fucking Hook In It: Magical Talking Fish Love This Stuff
RvBBOY842 2 months ago
after watching this i looked down 2 see if there wasnt any strawberry milk shake to spill
hunowarrior 2 months ago
can i wish for more magic fishes
danny77666 2 months ago
way to waste half a wish fatboy
FreddieTheMich 2 months ago
were did he get the nread, the plate, and the knife?
CODWAL12DEN 2 months ago
I like gutting fish I did a ton of that when I was camping I like cutting off the heads also I was gutting one it slipped out of my hands into the river I jumped in after it my shoe fell off and I had the fish I pit it on the bridge and caught my shoe lol I got really wet and had to change and after I changed it was raining hard grrrr but I got to stay in my own tent with my awesome puppy ok u caught me he's 11 and a day older then me lol
SydneyMarie1311 2 months ago
is it me or dose that fish reminds me of Michale??
Youngblood430 2 months ago
vsacue flashback from the music lol
MultiRoflstomp 2 months ago
People realise that you are watching a COMEDY SKIT!!
TheFiirstDovahKiin 2 months ago
What is he wished to catch the fish again?
Theirry007 2 months ago
@ spelldragon101 cuz he does the voice for griff you fucktard.
kyle41798 2 months ago
I'd wish for another magic fish, use the other two wishes, and repeat with the second fish, and then I'd have unlimited wishes.
kyle41798 2 months ago
what was that song
georgeissocooollike 2 months ago
I would wish to wish for more wishes
SuperHaloreachmaster 2 months ago
Y U NO WISH FOR BOOBIES ლ(ಠ益ಠლ)
robloxgaara22 2 months ago
@robloxgaara22 -.-"
Lyricsdude11 2 months ago
@Lyricsdude11 :D
robloxgaara22 2 months ago
@robloxgaara22 He already has Griffon.
PIGIPIGISHOW 2 months ago