Haha made you say something good about Archie...for once. He closes his eyes because he looks hot when he does, and it makes him connect with the song. When he opens his eyes, its like he's singing for the people and the cameras, when he closes them, he sings i just for himself. Again, all you talk about is Cook, Cook, Cook. Have an open mind, and give the others a chance. You have to have an unbiased opinion if you are going to do these videos! >:P
Jason had a hairball caught in his throat this week, well, actually, in my opinion; I believe since Hallelujah, the hairball began growing. And it seems that Brooke must have swallowed said hairball after Jason was able to cough it up--two of the worst performances of the entire season—in my opinion. How did they sneak by--everyone was so busy bashing beautiful and talented Kristy Lee and these two weak performers slipped past. Sad that they are in the top 5, isn't it?
wow you guys really suck. you sucked ass so bad i was cracking up the whole time. stop making videos and embarassing yourselves. wtf..a mother daughter combo. one word to describe this is LAME.
yea im gonna have to agree with skystring. i mean david cook is ok, however people judge syesha very harshly. she actualy has one of the best voices in the competition, defiantly top 3, he energy was defiantly high, before you decide to criticize people think of legitement criticisms other than "i just didnt connect with ____"
Two white none musically inclined morons... of course liked David Cook. And they said that Syesha was just ok.. Please don't critic or please place your KKK sign (instead of the American Idol flag) behind you.
who the hell died and left these two the official critics of ai? they're effin ridiculous!!! sayesha rocked tuesday nite. i've always thought she had a great voice, but her song choices are never good, except this week and the week she sang "if i were your woman." but we ALL know jason "spiccoli" castro should've been the one to go home this week.
Since the beautiful Kristy Lee is gone, İ wondered who you might select to bash. I figured it would be Syesha, since she is also attractive. At least this time you were honest about Brooke and Jason--the two worst performances of the entire season. And Brooke should have been gone long before and so should Jason. This is, so we are told, the top 6 of the best of AI--these two were far from the top 6--they simply were awful.
For people hating on the AWESOME due of Maddie and Janet, please STFU. They're funny, smart, and witty. In case you didn't know, they are giving their personal OPINIONS. You don't need to diss them if you disagree.
To Maddie and Janet, keep rocking and ignore the haters. You two are brilliant.
actually, syesha was barefoot last night. she didn't scuff the piano up at all with her "heels"... what were you guys talking about?! normally i love watching you guys but last night... you were a bit off.
I've seen U2 start again in concert...that's just out of touch with the fun of music concerts...I've seen all sorts of wild "do overs" by far bigger stars that Paula Abdul.
Your comments regarding this are off base...it came across professional. You might not like that personally, but it's been done countless times by the pro's and it goes over well..actually it seems so much more spontaneous that some adhere to perfect structure thing.
Does Jason suddenly become a handicap when he sings?
cuz he's always sitting down!!!
Anyways.. Jason's voice is weak and sounds like he's always forcing out each note (like i do :D). He's always sitting down which means he's not a good performer. He (or brooke)is going home tonight.
Plus... has anyone else noticed the pattern on American Idol?? a male goes home, then a female, then a male, then a female, then a male, then a female!!!
Brooke has to learn that if it is a sad song...DONT SMILE. I caught her again smiling and it ticked me off. Also, as someone who has been in musicals, you don't stop and start again
The best performance of the night goes to David cook for sure. He did great and so did Syesha and Archuleta. I REALLY didn't like Brooke but the rest did well :D
When they showed Paul Stanley, my hubby, who never watches AI, said "Is that his dad?" HA! And yes, he knew he was Paul Stanley. Haha. SO not David Archeleta's daddy.
I haven't seen that commercial that you were talking about. You may not know this, but Jason Castro had an IV stuck in him before and after his performance. He has been hospitalized this past week for being sick. Yet, he didn't even mention it on stage. Like the others have. For sympathy votes. You two play into the producers plan of manipulating video edits, and pushing certain contestants who have sub-par performances.
Oh, I was in no way implying David Cook. I give him credit also, for not mentioning it on stage. His illness was mentioned on the results night after the votes had been accounted for. I was talking about other contestants. I don't like pinpointing one person, so I'll just leave it at that.
i DO feel like Syesha is the most underrated contestant this year...
She definitely was the best of the night. She had the whole package, she really gave the performance of her lifetime!
David Cook was a very close second for me; the only reason I gave him second rather than first was because the ending of the song was a bit too overblown; the entire song he was showing this tender side, and he sacrificed that for the big notes at the end.
Morning Ladies!! Well here are my top 6 (1 being the best, 6 being the worst)
1. David C
2. Syesha
3. Carly
4. David A
5. Jason
6. Brooke
I was just so disappointed in Brooke, as musch as I love her, she was totally out of her element. David C! Wow! He can sing "Music of the Night" any time for me!!
I also thought the best performances were Carly, Syesha, and Davic Cook. Jason Castro was a train wreck, sorry, and I didn't think Brooke was good either... although the audience went crazy. I think Brooke is going home tonight.
Oh, and thanks for the review... we'll see what happens.
Jason should have listened to many more songs before choosing. He may not have had much time, but he could have asked a few opinions and then gone with Any Dream Will Do!
A Sir is a Knight. A Lord is an Earl or Duke. Webber was Knighted, so he is a Sir, not a Lord. When Christians call their God Lord, they are saying he is just above a Knight, but not as high as a Prince or a King. Lords are middle management and a Lord is doing the work for someone above him.
*raises her hand* Ok, Who called the Music of the Night thing? I totally did ^^. Yay for both Davids. They did great. I laughed so hard at the clip before Cook sang XD. NO ONE woulda been able to take that seriously!
I really wanted Brook to do well this week, but I must say I was disappointed and felt really awkward by her performance. I think she is gone tomorrow.
Pretty good singers remain, yet a little lacking on personality. I think it'll end up being a showdown between the two Davids. All in all, the entertainment value keeps me watching AI, and your recaps. Till morrow....
David A., Brooke, and Jason are basically doing what they always do which are the same performances every single time and boring me to death, so at least their consistent.
...The song is "Memory," not "Memories."
OpinionAM 2 years ago
You guys are so annoying! MY gosh!! :P
EandB5577 3 years ago
Haha..lasercats..only good part of the video.
Haha made you say something good about Archie...for once. He closes his eyes because he looks hot when he does, and it makes him connect with the song. When he opens his eyes, its like he's singing for the people and the cameras, when he closes them, he sings i just for himself. Again, all you talk about is Cook, Cook, Cook. Have an open mind, and give the others a chance. You have to have an unbiased opinion if you are going to do these videos! >:P
iDontGetIt4444 3 years ago
is this a mother daughter thing?
(btw you guys are really good at summarizing shows)
caroline9551 3 years ago
I noticed Paul Stanley in the audience too.
denwri76 3 years ago
OMG!!! how do u get tht backround??!!
cochanelco111 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jason had a hairball caught in his throat this week, well, actually, in my opinion; I believe since Hallelujah, the hairball began growing. And it seems that Brooke must have swallowed said hairball after Jason was able to cough it up--two of the worst performances of the entire season—in my opinion. How did they sneak by--everyone was so busy bashing beautiful and talented Kristy Lee and these two weak performers slipped past. Sad that they are in the top 5, isn't it?
ArmanValdar 3 years ago
wow you guys really suck. you sucked ass so bad i was cracking up the whole time. stop making videos and embarassing yourselves. wtf..a mother daughter combo. one word to describe this is LAME.
MegHassa 3 years ago
For heavens sake, people. If you think it's lame, then DON'T WATCH IT.
Honestly, Meg, by watching this and then calling it lame, just made you look lame too.
Kiioko 3 years ago
1. PigSlop says HE STARTED, CREATED AND BUILT THE YOUTUBE UNDERGROUND.
2. PigSlop says The NEW YouTube Underground are a bunch of COCKROACH TRASH STEALING BACKSTABBING MAGGOTS.
3. TheBeeOBee comments that BatTim CHEATED ON HIS WIFE at YouTube Gatherings.
4. BatTim says The YouTube Underground turned on HellionExciter, TheBoringDispatcher and PigSlop.
5. Gimmeabreakman says BatTim states that ALL OF THE YOUTUBE UNDERGROUND ARE BAD EGGS AND TO CLEAN HOUSE.
UTubeDrama website
Iiquidraza 3 years ago
chick on the right needs to keep her hair down...looks way better than that ponytail
Gaiapersephone 3 years ago
yea im gonna have to agree with skystring. i mean david cook is ok, however people judge syesha very harshly. she actualy has one of the best voices in the competition, defiantly top 3, he energy was defiantly high, before you decide to criticize people think of legitement criticisms other than "i just didnt connect with ____"
BkGraz 3 years ago
Maddie, ur really 17????
cardude527 3 years ago
Funny:
watch?v=13aJLD7xeFc
IPK12345 3 years ago
I think they are good and they are usually right on...good job ladies!
birddoggin1 3 years ago
Two white none musically inclined morons... of course liked David Cook. And they said that Syesha was just ok.. Please don't critic or please place your KKK sign (instead of the American Idol flag) behind you.
skystring 3 years ago
these girls got on my nerves badly!
ramsmanstl 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1. Semisnugzz BLACK RACIST YOUTUBE VIDEO GETS REMOVED due to TOS VIOLATIONS.
2. E-beggar PhilipDeFranco sXePhil makes MORE ASIAN RACIST JOKES.
3. E-beggar PhilipDeFranco sXePhil says YouTubers GAVE HIM and SPONSORED HIM $2,700 for the PKD Marathon.
4. Montagraph YT Partner says he will have TheSludgeReport2 (PERMABAN BillyBobJoe57) on his channel AUTO-PLAY.
5. Montagraph is into Anti-American Government Conspiracy Theories about Political Discussions on YouTube.
UTubeDrama website
BIuesLoyal 3 years ago
who r u guys a poor man's Loralei and Rory gilmore? And what qualifies u as music critics? Attend Julliard or some such?
madameks 3 years ago
who the hell died and left these two the official critics of ai? they're effin ridiculous!!! sayesha rocked tuesday nite. i've always thought she had a great voice, but her song choices are never good, except this week and the week she sang "if i were your woman." but we ALL know jason "spiccoli" castro should've been the one to go home this week.
deeknits 3 years ago
What is up with the head bobbing and the way you talk when you talk about black people? It is demeaning....
phlotis 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1. DanielsPengies says JipsiK is a DANGEROUS PREDATOR and CAN SNAP at ANY MOMENT.
2. Nerimon finally REMOVES HIS UNCOMBED MOP HAIR WIG and shows how bald he REALLY IS.
3. Spricket24 does a Google YouTube Public Service Announcement PSA video about Earth Day.
4. Tammpon says 800 YouTubers have UNSUBSCRIBED FROM HIM since he started the UNSUBSCRIBE PARTNER CAMPAIGN.
5. AmyAddict who plays RUNESCAPE and has her own CLAN CHAT on TIREXOR.
UTubeDrama website
soIdo11 3 years ago
This video is absolutely horrible.
docwolfe77 3 years ago
u guys suck. why dont you go up there and sing for yourselves. but yeah jason and brooke should just been eliminated long ago pah!
Me3nerved 3 years ago
And oh for your information, syesha was great. stop bashing her. Freak!
Me3nerved 3 years ago
OMG you guys so annoying. I mean criticizing people like your so good. Go to hell!
Me3nerved 3 years ago
Sorry, Jason, Soon....All Your Dreams are Dead!
Cute is getting him this far, but won't take him much further.
abasscase 3 years ago
did u guyz ask FOX permission for the rights to use the "American Idol" logo???
bcareful rookiez, theze greedy corporationz wont hezitate 2 sue ur assez...lol
BizzyBumpyWilson 3 years ago
its not the logo
we made it ourselves - look closely
Madrosed 3 years ago
sys david a c carly
stevenash1386 3 years ago
Talk about amateurs
ejbeaud 3 years ago
Since the beautiful Kristy Lee is gone, İ wondered who you might select to bash. I figured it would be Syesha, since she is also attractive. At least this time you were honest about Brooke and Jason--the two worst performances of the entire season. And Brooke should have been gone long before and so should Jason. This is, so we are told, the top 6 of the best of AI--these two were far from the top 6--they simply were awful.
ArmanValdar 3 years ago
to makes comments about something or somebody you have to really know about that issue, if you don´t please shut up!
Silviatube2006 3 years ago
you guys are always entertaining ^_^ keep it up
flipnchicago 3 years ago
it is actually "Memory" not "memories"
but i really appreciate the recap!! it is awesome
XmasWish 3 years ago
Who are these two second rate, trying hard wanna be? So cheap and boring. Wish you have a life.
asiancd4u 3 years ago 3
you two sound like you come straight from yonkers! lol
jppuertorico85 3 years ago 2
close - Queens :)
Madrosed 3 years ago
Madrosed
ok, sorry...i thought it wuz an exact replica of the logo, but urz just spellz, "O-erican dol"...lol...my baaad!!!
BizzyBumpyWilson 3 years ago
i HATED tonight's results. All of it. The bottom 2 and all
qg6ff 3 years ago 2
Brooke wins!
You fail at life!
DebMorganPD 3 years ago
Considering you guys enjoy the MOVIE version of the Phantom, you really can't judge others on their vocal quality.
Syesha was very animated, she doesn't need to over-do it. She's not Jim Carrey, people don't need to notice every single movement she does.
blo0dyme 3 years ago
I don't like David Cook.
da8c 3 years ago
fuck u two bitches!! who the hell are you to talk all that crap about the idol contestants... C'MON!!! Get a life!!!
raroru18 3 years ago
For people hating on the AWESOME due of Maddie and Janet, please STFU. They're funny, smart, and witty. In case you didn't know, they are giving their personal OPINIONS. You don't need to diss them if you disagree.
To Maddie and Janet, keep rocking and ignore the haters. You two are brilliant.
bakatais 3 years ago
Well, I hate everyone...except you two. I thought it was original and funny.
keep up the good work. It is easy for people to put you down, but you dont see them doing anything...
WhiteBull 3 years ago
wow...i can see a girl doing a show like this but the mom????wow, you have no life
xVenomFangx 3 years ago
actually, syesha was barefoot last night. she didn't scuff the piano up at all with her "heels"... what were you guys talking about?! normally i love watching you guys but last night... you were a bit off.
pabloreynoso 3 years ago
Shut up, if you don't want to hear their comments DON'T WATCH dumbasses.
hiroxiro 3 years ago
C'mon ppl STOP THESE VIDEOS, THERE SO STUPID.
I think you ppl have NO life
smileymiley123 3 years ago
fucking doumbasses
80pirt 3 years ago
I think you two should keep your comments to yourselves. Sorry.
Blondeathrt73 3 years ago
you guys are fucking stupid
mcrcjs 3 years ago
Jason was great last night, so stop hatin! I aint know it was from a freakin musical about cats either.
Z4noubia90 3 years ago
I've seen U2 start again in concert...that's just out of touch with the fun of music concerts...I've seen all sorts of wild "do overs" by far bigger stars that Paula Abdul.
Your comments regarding this are off base...it came across professional. You might not like that personally, but it's been done countless times by the pro's and it goes over well..actually it seems so much more spontaneous that some adhere to perfect structure thing.
sbcooler 3 years ago
My favorites last night were David Cook, Carly Smithson, and Syesha Mercado.
LKMOSCAR 3 years ago 2
jason waz really good!! i hav neva seen da commercials or da show o yeah!!!!!!
berrymonkey14 3 years ago
how did u know dat?!!!!
berrymonkey14 3 years ago
wow.
ilovehorses75309 3 years ago
I saw The musical Cats once. Also when Brooke was singing she was wearing a dress designed by Alice+Olivia it was like the one Anya from ANTM Wore.
GorgeousGals0421 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Self absorbed bimbos...
051038 3 years ago
haha i LOVE lazer cats!
david cook was the best last night.
chadbuff 3 years ago 2
scottypoe THANK YOU !!!!!!!!!
Rollyson09 3 years ago
Does Jason suddenly become a handicap when he sings?
cuz he's always sitting down!!!
Anyways.. Jason's voice is weak and sounds like he's always forcing out each note (like i do :D). He's always sitting down which means he's not a good performer. He (or brooke)is going home tonight.
Plus... has anyone else noticed the pattern on American Idol?? a male goes home, then a female, then a male, then a female, then a male, then a female!!!
weird....
TheTeenScoop 3 years ago
HAHA laser cat i saw that skit! it was funny.
good recap.
hannahx369 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf is that like her mom...who would make a youtube vid with their mom...this is retarded
*BROOKE IS GOING HOME
I HATE JASON CASTRO
xxlivxx3 3 years ago
Not everyone is a rebelious idiot that hates their parents.
plus... her mom is cool
but my mom's betta :D
TheTeenScoop 3 years ago
i can not stand david cook
scottypoe 3 years ago
wait that girls 17? u look way younger
pepsirocks94 3 years ago
Brooke has to learn that if it is a sad song...DONT SMILE. I caught her again smiling and it ticked me off. Also, as someone who has been in musicals, you don't stop and start again
TomCollinsgirl 3 years ago
The best performance of the night goes to David cook for sure. He did great and so did Syesha and Archuleta. I REALLY didn't like Brooke but the rest did well :D
J
FexyassJJ 3 years ago
Brooke needs to go home (I think). She's obviously not handling the pressure, and her performances have all been less than good other than Let it Be.
David Cook was stellar. I loved Syesha and Carly too. Sorry, but David A. sounded the same as he always does...boring.
FloatingGrin 3 years ago
Loved David Cook and Carly gave me chills! (for once) I think Brooke's a goner.
angs122 3 years ago
When they showed Paul Stanley, my hubby, who never watches AI, said "Is that his dad?" HA! And yes, he knew he was Paul Stanley. Haha. SO not David Archeleta's daddy.
angs122 3 years ago
brooke leave!!!!
cuteb25 3 years ago
I haven't seen that commercial that you were talking about. You may not know this, but Jason Castro had an IV stuck in him before and after his performance. He has been hospitalized this past week for being sick. Yet, he didn't even mention it on stage. Like the others have. For sympathy votes. You two play into the producers plan of manipulating video edits, and pushing certain contestants who have sub-par performances.
katelynsmith123 3 years ago
David C. didn't mention his problem. Ryan asked him about it and he downplayed it.
I am very sorry to hear hat Jason was sick. He seems like a very nice person.
tshughes123 3 years ago
Oh, I was in no way implying David Cook. I give him credit also, for not mentioning it on stage. His illness was mentioned on the results night after the votes had been accounted for. I was talking about other contestants. I don't like pinpointing one person, so I'll just leave it at that.
katelynsmith123 3 years ago
Oh, okay. I totally agree they shouldn't pull out symapathy tactics for votes.
tshughes123 3 years ago
Oh, both Jason and David C. were sick? And they mentioned it on results night? I must've missed it =\
ALienh018 3 years ago
david archuleta is hot and he is going to win american idol!!
spain4159 3 years ago
i DO feel like Syesha is the most underrated contestant this year...
She definitely was the best of the night. She had the whole package, she really gave the performance of her lifetime!
David Cook was a very close second for me; the only reason I gave him second rather than first was because the ending of the song was a bit too overblown; the entire song he was showing this tender side, and he sacrificed that for the big notes at the end.
3. Carly
4. David A -- Not his best
5/6: Brooke or Jason
pabloreynoso 3 years ago
Morning Ladies!! Well here are my top 6 (1 being the best, 6 being the worst)
1. David C
2. Syesha
3. Carly
4. David A
5. Jason
6. Brooke
I was just so disappointed in Brooke, as musch as I love her, she was totally out of her element. David C! Wow! He can sing "Music of the Night" any time for me!!
Much Love!!
Idoljunky32
Idoljunky32 3 years ago 2
I also thought the best performances were Carly, Syesha, and Davic Cook. Jason Castro was a train wreck, sorry, and I didn't think Brooke was good either... although the audience went crazy. I think Brooke is going home tonight.
Oh, and thanks for the review... we'll see what happens.
jodalita 3 years ago
Jason should have listened to many more songs before choosing. He may not have had much time, but he could have asked a few opinions and then gone with Any Dream Will Do!
Honestly!
RowanPrincess 3 years ago
Baby Archie dropped lyrics in the second part of the song last night. None of the judges said anything about it. Hello?
Question for Judges: Why is it okay for him to forget words but nobody else is allowed to do it?
Cook sang the H*LL out of his song. He was fantastic! Hot, hot, hot, hot, sexy!
tshughes123 3 years ago 4
David A. kept going and mumbled made-up lyrics--many didn't notice.
David C. sounded like bad karaoke. He should have changed the arrangement.
Samarachelle 3 years ago
You should say LORD Andrew Lloyd Webber.
sreanea 3 years ago
Yeah, what else? The almighty? The godly? Who cares? It's just a title.
Zigzag4me 3 years ago
A Sir is a Knight. A Lord is an Earl or Duke. Webber was Knighted, so he is a Sir, not a Lord. When Christians call their God Lord, they are saying he is just above a Knight, but not as high as a Prince or a King. Lords are middle management and a Lord is doing the work for someone above him.
WyattKaldenberg 3 years ago
Im so confused! I always agree with you both, but I have to disagree. Syesha had the best performance by far! I loved it. So did David C.
heathertoch 3 years ago 5
*raises her hand* Ok, Who called the Music of the Night thing? I totally did ^^. Yay for both Davids. They did great. I laughed so hard at the clip before Cook sang XD. NO ONE woulda been able to take that seriously!
RachiruJaganshi 3 years ago
I really wanted Brook to do well this week, but I must say I was disappointed and felt really awkward by her performance. I think she is gone tomorrow.
Pretty good singers remain, yet a little lacking on personality. I think it'll end up being a showdown between the two Davids. All in all, the entertainment value keeps me watching AI, and your recaps. Till morrow....
joemustang007 3 years ago 5
Brook must go home!!! lol
shortass1978 3 years ago
Top 3 performances are
Syesha
David C.
Carly
David A., Brooke, and Jason are basically doing what they always do which are the same performances every single time and boring me to death, so at least their consistent.
Didi91388 3 years ago 2