"I Dreamed A Dream" Mash-Up: Patti LuPone vs. Susan Boyle

[gavyj5191]

LuPone. Duhhh.

[broadwayloverny10]

Why even ask? You know the answer is going to be the woman who doesn't just sing it but also ACTS it making the performance even more heart felt and powerful. Yes Susan did an amazing job. But when it comes to Broadway songs most women that preform them act them whether in theater or just a concert. So of course Patti freaking LuPone wins!!

[deanlett]

even with patti's recording in poor quality to susan's there is NO comparison. i love me some patti :)

[lanibestofalldivas]

goosebumps at 2:40 onwards

[euqip]

May God bless Susan Boyle. I hope she is able to regain some normalcy to her life. I worry that her "Britains's Got Talent" experience may wind up being detrimental.

Comparing Susan to Patti is not right . Susan is an unusually talented non-professional. Patti is a mega star, and one of the greatest "Broadway" singers ever. She can give you chills with this song, and any other, even after singing them a million times. Susan and Patti should both be admired for what they are.

[hillevifan]

Patti LuPone is better, because...C'MON shes Patti FREAKIN LuPone!!!! No one will EVER top her in this song! Susan's is great don't get me wrong, but I mean, Patti will always be a notch above the rest!

[Michel301168]

Susan Boyle is a good notch above.

[UveBeenLuPwned123094]

no competition. lupone obviously. she's an ACTRESS.

[epoxsam]

to my shock, i think susan's performance is better than patti lupone.. there's more WOW factor in susan's..

[christinedaae101]

The song isn't about WOW factor, it's about a woman's emotional turmoil.

[operastar1994]

Patti For me Susan is great but u cant compare patti she is a Broadway diva

[x3MamaRose]

I love Susan, but Patti is still the master of this.

[Mimbomime]

(end part of my remark below) The question is, will Susan have the same longevity in career to Patti? I wish Susan every bit of success, but only time will tell.

[Mimbomime]

There is NO comparison from the original performer! Susan Boyle is fab, but Patti LuPone is a trained experienced professional ACTRESS. The pain and struggle that EVERY professional performer goes through 4 yrs b4 reaching any notoriety is NO match to a secret weapon (no ref. to previous person's remark) that Susan Boyle had & 4 surprising people on a major British PEAK VIEWING talent show.