How good is this chorus hook? The band didnt really go anywhere but all the members are great in their other bands and Richard Patric can write hooks like nobodys business.
Wish these guys hadn't said "Goodbye" so soon! If the A.O.A. album had done better, they might've considered a followup. Rich, when STP goes on hiatus (whenever that may be), how 'bout grabbing the DeLeo brothers and that drummer and going into the studio again?
@lurch321 if they can get him away from Korn. he's the drummer for them now. i'm with you man. good thing i have the whole cd. listen to them any time.
Ya I like this song... I dig the tempo change into the chorus, it creates a different mood as the song profresses and then speeds up again to intensify the lyrics describing his pain... Great sound, great vocals and harmonies. 2006 release, but still as fabulous!
Great band but it really sucks that these guys never made it. If your gonna play some rock/alternative crap this is how it should sound! Bands like Nickleback need to just throw in the towel.
This band is way too good to have a life in the climate of the music business today, probably why they didn't last! Great song, playing and singing! Why can't more bands aspire to this?
Hey rock fans! If want some good rock music, check out some good old fashioned kick-ass Rock N' Roll. Just go to myspace and search Steeling Thunder. Thanks for the support and hopefully you guys like it. Long Live Rock!
"Falling Season" has performed with many nationals artists such as Switchfoot, 30 Seconds to Mars, Smile Empty Soul, Army of Anyone, Copeland, Shadows Fall, Hurt, The Exies and many more.
Dude, that's a good song. when I heard it the first time I was like "wtf is this how good can shitty pop alternative get I can't believe how much I'm liking this" then I check up on them and boom De Leo brothers and Filter members.
LOL you can see me for a nano-second at the 1:54 mark. LOL why I have a huge smile on my face i don't know. LOL. That was the best shoot ever. Patrick and the whole band are awesome!!! =)
Love this video... it is not overdone it is just perfect! I miss them... I love STP but they did a good job on this record. Deleo brothers rock my world.
I really loved these guys! personally I think their album was amazing! way better than VR to me and even right up there with STP on a few songs.. More than Love, Goodbye, Generation.. etc.. GREAT SONGS!
Few VR songs I like ALOT, and like 60% is the same annoying thing. Slash is a great guitarist, but his solos now sound all similar to each other. Great to see STP and Filter coming back. Although VR fans probably now hate Scott, I want him to leave VR. Scott hopefully will get at least 90% of his old voice. Chris Cornell after all is managing to do that.
AOA on the other hand put out tons of good songs, I prefer the really good VR songs but overall this is a better group. STP THE BEST!
Ray Luzier (drummer) is way too good for this band. the DeLeo brothers don't stand out as great instrument players although good song writers. Luzier should just remain as a seesionist drummer and play for whichever talent that requires his skills rather than commit to a band. drummers like him need as much exposure as they can get
IMO, right now these guys deliver the best. Every song was good and many were great. I can't think of anything they could have done better. They are all amazing and sound fantastic together. Bought this one and would love to hear another album.
Scott is only calling for a re-union tour, so i bet this band is going to come back. But i do agree with you, this band would be great if the band didnt go back to STP.
there is a kinda new song, its genre is rock, is starts with "hey goodbye..." and i dont know its name, and i want it on my playlist so bad!!!, any1 can help?
man i bought this album. this was probably best song on it. but it was a good album. i wanted to see these guys with another one but because they didnt sell many of this album they probably wont make another record. man i cant believe more people didnt buy this!!!
The video looks like STP's "Wicked Garden," but good song, nonetheless. I have the album, and the rest of it is good. Due to low record sales, AA might disband, which sucks, because it's been years since the DeLeo's have been part of a big band like this.
these guys rock shit live as WELL as in the studio put fucking fall out boy up to that test...! THIS is ROCK!! Sessions dot com shows what there made of!
A couple of other things, what the hell is with the gratuitous drum solo at the end? I know the guy played for Roth, but he should really leave the cock rock moves to those gigs.
And the name of the band is way too generic. I mentioned the band a couple of times to a couple friends (who know their music) and they thought it was the band with the dude from Blink 182, or some other band that they couldn't put their finger on. Not a good sign.
Kevinpalooza, while I respect your opinion, A bands name? come on, talent is the criteria, and these guys have it in spades. I dont give a shit if they called themselves Beatlemania or some other shitty name. The drum solo kicks ass, you cant compare this to"cock rock". Formulaic? Dont think so.What bands do YOU like?
for some reason i expected more from such a supergroup... it's certainly not bad, but rich ain't singing the same these days (too many cigarettes?) and the deleos don't seem to be riffing as hardcore as they did back in the day. rad drummer though. will have to see what else they put out....
PLEASE DON'T READ THIS. You will get kissed on the nearest possible Friday by the love of your life. Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However, if you don't post this comment to at least 3 videos, you will die within 2 days. Copy and paste this, to be saved
How good is this chorus hook? The band didnt really go anywhere but all the members are great in their other bands and Richard Patric can write hooks like nobodys business.
bunchups 1 month ago
Your a wanna be rockstar
jjoielz 6 months ago
Forced agenda in ya mom fat ass .......fuck u fag
jjoielz 6 months ago
18 people lack ears.
ForcedAgenda 7 months ago
@ForcedAgenda lol no they are in old folk's homes.
syfywashere 5 months ago
Stupid songe
jjoielz 7 months ago
@jjoielz Learn to spell...'stupid'.
ForcedAgenda 7 months ago
Naomy, crazy ass...No!!! if you wanna feel an orgasm..Goodbye !!!
grungeromexico 7 months ago
Wish these guys hadn't said "Goodbye" so soon! If the A.O.A. album had done better, they might've considered a followup. Rich, when STP goes on hiatus (whenever that may be), how 'bout grabbing the DeLeo brothers and that drummer and going into the studio again?
lurch321 8 months ago
@lurch321 if they can get him away from Korn. he's the drummer for them now. i'm with you man. good thing i have the whole cd. listen to them any time.
syfywashere 5 months ago
I looooove this song!!
crucifixxkiss 11 months ago
What a wicked-great blend of STP, Talkshow, & Filter. Really killer pool of talent, and fuckin' SLAMMIN' song!
Great riff. AWESOME solo.
Ray pounds the shit outta the drums.
Gorgeous vocals & harmonies.
Super fresh & unique sound (even though it's a few years old, and they're done).
Just simply ~ Bad ass.
runthemachine 1 year ago 2
Ya I like this song... I dig the tempo change into the chorus, it creates a different mood as the song profresses and then speeds up again to intensify the lyrics describing his pain... Great sound, great vocals and harmonies. 2006 release, but still as fabulous!
musicmydrug10 1 year ago
one of the best albums of the decade!!!!!!!
tonicstu 1 year ago 2
Great band but it really sucks that these guys never made it. If your gonna play some rock/alternative crap this is how it should sound! Bands like Nickleback need to just throw in the towel.
dontrickrollme 1 year ago 3
@dontrickrollme amen to that bro. at least i've got their cd and can listen to that 24-7.
syfywashere 1 year ago
This band is way too good to have a life in the climate of the music business today, probably why they didn't last! Great song, playing and singing! Why can't more bands aspire to this?
wonekawa 1 year ago
Thank goodness I bought their CD. Even though they broke up, I can still listen to them forever.
syfywashere 1 year ago
Is this the singer from Filter?
gillart 1 year ago 2
@gillart yea
JMorr1029 1 year ago
@gillart Filter's lead singer and the bass player and guitar player from Stone Temple Pilots.
amydawned 1 year ago
@amydawned and actuall drummer for korn :D
Mons0nify 1 year ago
oh thankfully the drummer is now with korn cause hes just incredible i wanted to her more beats from him.
AmbitiousMOnkey1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey rock fans! If want some good rock music, check out some good old fashioned kick-ass Rock N' Roll. Just go to myspace and search Steeling Thunder. Thanks for the support and hopefully you guys like it. Long Live Rock!
jinindy 1 year ago
Incredible drumming....
thestrawhead 1 year ago
i love this song, but the chorus makes everything else sound terrible
xomgcake666 1 year ago
I want to thank God and Youtube for safety mode
cxjiek 1 year ago
my band falling season opened for these guys back in 07. they were mad cool and they put on a HELL of a show!!!
drums6969 2 years ago
no.....u didnt quit trying to act all cool and shit
leghumper101 2 years ago
i'm just telling the truth leghumper. believe what you want.
drums6969 2 years ago
"Falling Season" has performed with many nationals artists such as Switchfoot, 30 Seconds to Mars, Smile Empty Soul, Army of Anyone, Copeland, Shadows Fall, Hurt, The Exies and many more.
silenc3x 2 years ago
Best drum solo ever (end of song).
leblanc999 2 years ago
nice drummer~
GoOMusIC1 2 years ago
it's about 3:21!!!!!!!!! \m/ (**) \m/
shyliekee 2 years ago
Comment removed
shyliekee 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dude looks like a fucking rooster
whySOmanyJEWS 2 years ago
Haha XD
TheAshleySpears 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well, he does!
whySOmanyJEWS 2 years ago
Diz Adeus tribalwars líder :p
Sem dramas please XD
lauuportugal 2 years ago
Damn, ive been looking for 2 years now on what the name of this song is. SSSSOOOOo glad i finally found it.
lol, what caught me on it was the yeah, ive got this feelin in my viens'. I really enjoyed that every time i heard it.
laffyta2 2 years ago
Luzier is an amazing drummer. It's a shame he had to join Korn.
BadMtrFngr 2 years ago
I agree
Boomoutgothelights 2 years ago
3:28 - look ma, one hand :-p
chilly2829 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what the hell were the de leo bros. thinking ..??this is terrible !!
blica1 2 years ago
Dude, that's a good song. when I heard it the first time I was like "wtf is this how good can shitty pop alternative get I can't believe how much I'm liking this" then I check up on them and boom De Leo brothers and Filter members.
They got me is all I can say.
SoilentGr33n 2 years ago
faggit
Boomoutgothelights 2 years ago
Are you kidding me? You can't even spell 'fagot'? LOL
NPWherritt 2 years ago
@NPWherritt No, I can spell " faggot". You can't.
Emmasunshine1 2 years ago
@Emmasunshine1 It's spelled "faggot" or "fagot". Look it up. Don't try and correct me when you don't know what you're talking about.
And just to let you know, "fagot" was first. Adding another "g" is pre-industrial english slang.
NPWherritt 2 years ago
I meant post-industrial. Excuse me.
NPWherritt 2 years ago
ray is awsome,and now in korn,he is killing the drums,play so fucking well!!!!
scarekrow666ghost 2 years ago
I love that reverse thunderbird.
twinkieramirez 2 years ago
Ray Luzier is F'ing amazing! I wish I could drum like that. 3:20 to 3:30! Awesome!!
kidyubyub 2 years ago
i really like what these guys have done. good music.
i like it.
girlstaley 2 years ago 2
sweet song need more music like this around these days..dean is a sick guitarist
collo777 2 years ago 2
LOL you can see me for a nano-second at the 1:54 mark. LOL why I have a huge smile on my face i don't know. LOL. That was the best shoot ever. Patrick and the whole band are awesome!!! =)
elizalove 3 years ago
Love this video... it is not overdone it is just perfect! I miss them... I love STP but they did a good job on this record. Deleo brothers rock my world.
crazydeka 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
visit my profile pls! check me out! msg me on M.S.N
msg me back Ci
papapopopipi 3 years ago
3:20 - 3:30 OH MY GAWD!!!!
kamranaladross 3 years ago
I'll miss them, they were great.
Nothingnonada 3 years ago 2
yo your cool great rocken music lol it your so sweet allsome this rocks alot well lol durona allways
grammaof3angels 3 years ago
So i was wondering, i know that STP has reunited for a tour, any word on a new studio album?
HelloFade2 3 years ago
Yeah as soon as they're done touring, they'll record an album for 2009
RageLinkinMashine 3 years ago
fuck yall otherwise. yer not wise. this was/is titts. religion in the moment form kids. gorgeous.
candi72481 3 years ago
i started liking them when they opened for tool! both amazing bands
:)
John123Z 3 years ago
Great song, and very high energy. two thumbs up
guitarfreakstyle 3 years ago 14
Goodbye, I wish you stay here, I wish you were Here... :(
JxSplit 3 years ago
amazinggg druming
dillon4545 3 years ago
I really loved these guys! personally I think their album was amazing! way better than VR to me and even right up there with STP on a few songs.. More than Love, Goodbye, Generation.. etc.. GREAT SONGS!
brandon9271 3 years ago
Have you notice all of these members are 37 or older? Rock on, old guys! Ray Luzier(drummer) kicks ass!
Konformation07 3 years ago 4
37 is old? Jeez...
drneuropsych 3 years ago
i meant in a "rock sense" its old
Konformation07 3 years ago
I was just teasing...since I am 37 and don't want to think of myself as old!
drneuropsych 3 years ago
wow nice dumming for 3:17 to 3:30
hg9338 3 years ago
This song is so freakin' awesome!
Too bad they didn't last long :(
Oh and the drummer's pretty badass
1254MAN 3 years ago 20
@1254MAN well, i'm kinda glad that richard's back with filter :)
i love this song, but filter's just more my taste of music.
realkontschi 1 year ago
@1254MAN Yeah he went to Musicians Institute, he plays with Korn now he used to play with David Lee Roth!!
6CHRIS6ROWE6 11 months ago
@1254MAN drummer plays for Korn now.
syfywashere 5 months ago
Patrick's voice make me want to pick up a gun and start a fucking revolution. It always has.
kaosdevice 3 years ago
Take a Picture acoustic cover anyone???????
click my name above...
radiopeace 3 years ago
i tried to read all these long comments but uh they are too lon- look a cookie!
toon101yo 3 years ago
Few VR songs I like ALOT, and like 60% is the same annoying thing. Slash is a great guitarist, but his solos now sound all similar to each other. Great to see STP and Filter coming back. Although VR fans probably now hate Scott, I want him to leave VR. Scott hopefully will get at least 90% of his old voice. Chris Cornell after all is managing to do that.
AOA on the other hand put out tons of good songs, I prefer the really good VR songs but overall this is a better group. STP THE BEST!
projektmachineshop 3 years ago
And yeah this is STP with a different singer.
projektmachineshop 3 years ago
um its not stone temple pilots
its army of anyone
not to be rude but
if u looked at the background of the video u would know that very well
but u did get the title of the song correct
it is called goodbye
mwahahahaha14 3 years ago
I know what the group is I meant by the way it sounds its practically STP with a different singer.
projektmachineshop 3 years ago
well its got the brothers from stp too. hence very similar sound . thats so awsome that stp is coming back i sure hope they hit Norcal in their tour
Imjustabirdy2 3 years ago
you could say VR is G n' R with a different singer too but they're not both bands are they're own thing
travman102 3 years ago
Ray Luzier (drummer) is way too good for this band. the DeLeo brothers don't stand out as great instrument players although good song writers. Luzier should just remain as a seesionist drummer and play for whichever talent that requires his skills rather than commit to a band. drummers like him need as much exposure as they can get
Shalomp 4 years ago
Hey, lets be honest about this..
Slash has never been interesting IMHO, of course depending of the ear that hear.
And Scott found out. (can't blame him) after the crap VR has come up with. No bells ringing, no saddles for the lucky ones.
SCOTT is the ROCK SINGER! (of STP!)
THE 2 BRILLIANT brothers Dean and Robert DeLeo has a phenomenal way of creating songs.
Though I'm 45, STP was/has the the biggest influence on my playing.
STP 2008 Ohh my god, it's almost too good to be truth. ;)
zrincx 4 years ago 3
I dont know im not digging this stuff as much as other things from the same people. Its just an ok song.
monkeybobaroo 4 years ago
yeah i agree with lily
Laain92 4 years ago
This song is very under rated.
megethealthy 4 years ago
tell me wut song is this "na na na na.... na na na na.... eh oh... goodbye.... " plz tell me this song.
chetan9612 4 years ago
I've always liked STP and found Filter to be really underrated.
This isn't too shabby. I've always loved Richard Patrick's vocals and for some reason always found him to be really sexy!
stargazerlily79 4 years ago
hey stone temple pilots return may 17th 08
in stadiumm colombus
matidesaloon 4 years ago
IMO, right now these guys deliver the best. Every song was good and many were great. I can't think of anything they could have done better. They are all amazing and sound fantastic together. Bought this one and would love to hear another album.
Dervaj 4 years ago
I wish more people knew about how sick Ray Luzier is...
AshesOfTheWake7 4 years ago 3
my OPINION,
frontman is a wieland wanna-be
dean and rob are trying to recreate the stp sound
STP was way better, much rather see them reunite, and make a new album
rattlehead244 4 years ago
This band deserved a better chance - I'd rather see them continue with this than go down the road with Scott again.
HRA2006 4 years ago 3
Scott is only calling for a re-union tour, so i bet this band is going to come back. But i do agree with you, this band would be great if the band didnt go back to STP.
589262004 4 years ago
sweet rithm xD
miechiviejo 4 years ago
and when the hell's the tour??????
oldkornlovinlady 4 years ago
man, Richard Patrick's voice is so killer!
oldkornlovinlady 4 years ago
dude, what a voice!
mhskeide 4 years ago
fu**ing drummer
Sonzil 4 years ago
It's a little "rock" for Richard Patrick. Not bad, but I love the multi-layered sound of Filter myself. He can do so much more..
tmofee 4 years ago
I liked Eric Kretz so much better than this technical sessionist, he had more blood and felling.
STP chemistry and videos are something really hard to achieve.
spiaggi1 4 years ago
talk show was a way better band
Sixx1985 4 years ago
Stone temple pilots meets filter, these guys are sick
RoosterChains1017 4 years ago 2
oh there HOT
catXXclaw 4 years ago
those drums at the end are BEAUTIFUL!!!
ace198999 4 years ago
i love this whole album! Army of Anyone brings the goods.
dustinwilder 4 years ago
GREAT!! But i like the song "Generation'' and Better place' more they have good songs dude.. Keep up:):)
V0lumen 4 years ago
WHERE IS THE T-1000? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
precastqc 4 years ago
lol!! Too funny.
cabbagehead8 4 years ago
This is a great song!
I think this one and "Stop look and listen" are my favs..
The album is great!
patotux 4 years ago
The album is really good, but I don't like the Filter-singer. STP should return...
fuzzblow 4 years ago
there is a kinda new song, its genre is rock, is starts with "hey goodbye..." and i dont know its name, and i want it on my playlist so bad!!!, any1 can help?
gostinkygo 4 years ago
man i bought this album. this was probably best song on it. but it was a good album. i wanted to see these guys with another one but because they didnt sell many of this album they probably wont make another record. man i cant believe more people didnt buy this!!!
astrofunkyness 4 years ago
the drummer is my teachers boyfriend
im tellin the truth
Sapphire4444 4 years ago
That drummer is really, really great.
austinbeat 4 years ago
This is just STP with the lead singer of filter! HA HA HA HA HA! Actually its pretty good!
VanCityKyle 4 years ago
The video looks like STP's "Wicked Garden," but good song, nonetheless. I have the album, and the rest of it is good. Due to low record sales, AA might disband, which sucks, because it's been years since the DeLeo's have been part of a big band like this.
I just hope that STP reform.
DavidsonTFP 4 years ago
this is a kick arse band! ;)
madmonkey756 4 years ago
first time ive heard there music. pretty gd actually
rocknrollpizzeria07 4 years ago
The singer sucks. But the band is okay.
LegendLayne 4 years ago
LOL
Collin360man 4 years ago
why does he say ' just wanna see your pizza' at 32 seconds?
sakenem 4 years ago
"Just wanna see you beaten"
Xzonnet 4 years ago
so much spam
SeanneryConnery 4 years ago
If you like A.o.A. Check out Rehearsals dot com, to see them in the studio live. It kicks ass.
sneakypeteandthefre 4 years ago
these guys rock shit live as WELL as in the studio put fucking fall out boy up to that test...! THIS is ROCK!! Sessions dot com shows what there made of!
guywithguitar 4 years ago
RAYS A REALLY NICE GUY I MET HIM IN VEGAS ..great
band...
rockondon 4 years ago
I FUCKING LOVE THIS BAND!!!! XD
they definitely don't get enough recognition
frogavenger 4 years ago
This song is just AWSOME!! IT RULES ;-)
googy1524 4 years ago
A couple of other things, what the hell is with the gratuitous drum solo at the end? I know the guy played for Roth, but he should really leave the cock rock moves to those gigs.
And the name of the band is way too generic. I mentioned the band a couple of times to a couple friends (who know their music) and they thought it was the band with the dude from Blink 182, or some other band that they couldn't put their finger on. Not a good sign.
kevinpalooza 4 years ago
Kevinpalooza, while I respect your opinion, A bands name? come on, talent is the criteria, and these guys have it in spades. I dont give a shit if they called themselves Beatlemania or some other shitty name. The drum solo kicks ass, you cant compare this to"cock rock". Formulaic? Dont think so.What bands do YOU like?
sneakypeteandthefre 4 years ago
Pretty formulaic, but the chorus isn't bad.
kevinpalooza 4 years ago
This song would be way better with scott weiland on vocals
alucard3000000 4 years ago
yeah right ..your just a bigger stp fan and im a bigger filter fan lol
rockondon 4 years ago
havnt heard a drum solo for a while wow
IGotThatOnFilm 4 years ago
My new favorite song.
leblanc999 4 years ago
a nice stp cover band....
Mad88666 4 years ago
this is stp mixed with filter who should
they sound like
crfrog2 4 years ago
its f*cking awesome!!! love this song its a big ass YEAH!!!
8617536 4 years ago
So f*#%&ing cool. A big YEAH!!!! form Colombia.
flasheffekt 4 years ago
FUCKIN AWESOME
incubrian 4 years ago
for some reason i expected more from such a supergroup... it's certainly not bad, but rich ain't singing the same these days (too many cigarettes?) and the deleos don't seem to be riffing as hardcore as they did back in the day. rad drummer though. will have to see what else they put out....
thQm3 4 years ago
yea. i miss how they sounded in Stone Temple Pilots but this is okay.
darthragar 4 years ago
This is some goooooood stuff!!!!
TheHypeBR 4 years ago
pinche rola sta bien vergas!! me gusta mucho ... la amo arrpas ( can you understand me ??) jaja
xpaulinox 4 years ago
SCOTT WEILAND SUCKS! GLAD HE'S GONE
maddadinbellville 4 years ago
so lemme get this straight... members filter AND stp?!?! 2 of my favourite bands ever. This band doesn't disapoint!
killslay 4 years ago
Way to go "Army..." Awesome!!!!!!!!
nismoblue 4 years ago
the drummer went crazy
CMuhamed 4 years ago
just 3 things : drummer is awesome, Great hit, *****
fldi 4 years ago
DaVoodooMon you just gave me an idea. somebody really needs to do a misheard lyrics on this song
overdrive82891 4 years ago
"Just wanna see your pizza" :D :D :D :D :D :D :D D: D: D: D: D: D: D:
PWNT PWNT PWNT PWNT PWNT PWNT PWNT PWNT
DaVoodooMon 4 years ago
i love it its awesome
whatthemuffin 4 years ago
jejeje patrick looks like rocky balboa
slash1986ve 4 years ago
If the music don't groove ...?
GFY1954 4 years ago
this song just rocks!!!!!!!!and whoever doesnt think like like me is a STUPID!
2lechera2 4 years ago
that's lovely. thanks for sharing.
a7xjunkiexxx 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE DON'T READ THIS. You will get kissed on the nearest possible Friday by the love of your life. Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However, if you don't post this comment to at least 3 videos, you will die within 2 days. Copy and paste this, to be saved
3mwicks 4 years ago
STP was good. Filter was great. Army of Anyone does very little for me. MORE FILTER!!
coppaphil 4 years ago
damn it. filter rocked way more :-/
taa41748 4 years ago
Ray Luzier Rules !!!
ventsintheedge 4 years ago
you're all crazy, this band rocks, especially the drummer, song transitions are killer.
michaelandbetty 4 years ago
Wow, that was really sub-par boring rock.
Maybe Richard Patrick needs to get back on the booze, because what he's doing ain't working
saigonshaun 4 years ago
HaHaHa...Just wanna see your pizza!!!
kate566 5 years ago
i wanna see YOUR pizza! lol.
Gwhiteh2 5 years ago
hehe
Qtwitdemeye 5 years ago
He says "Just wanna see you beaten" Not "I wanna see your pizza" lol, wow...
TallSexyGurl 5 years ago
this video music its cool but the sound is awful
abnerjb 5 years ago
why does he say " i wannah see your pizza?"
sakenem 5 years ago