I've seen this once listed on Limewire as being sung by "Roger Waters, Trent Reznor and David Bowie" and am still kind of embarassed to admit that I thought it may be them all singing at the beginning in unison. XD But still, Gilmour, Mason, and Wright really give this song its soul even without Waters (and believe me, I'm a hardcore Waters fan and have been since I was 15). I wish to see it live someday, maybe with all the remaining boys playing together.
It's the best version because there is an ACTUAL scream for once! For years, I wanted the scream from the pin prick to be raw and searing, and I've finally found it! I can't believe I've been a Floyd fan all my life and never bothered to listen to this version.
Wow, I can't describe how awesome this version is. I love The Wall version, the PULSE version, the Live 8 version but this one is just so epic!! And it's my favorite song of all time
this is the best version, better than pulse, but pulse being a more popular concert gets a lot of atention, I`m sure many pulse fans (i`m a pulse fan) havent heard this version.
I've seen this once listed on Limewire as being sung by "Roger Waters, Trent Reznor and David Bowie" and am still kind of embarassed to admit that I thought it may be them all singing at the beginning in unison. XD But still, Gilmour, Mason, and Wright really give this song its soul even without Waters (and believe me, I'm a hardcore Waters fan and have been since I was 15). I wish to see it live someday, maybe with all the remaining boys playing together.
bl4nkd4hli4 10 months ago
The Solo of all solos!!!
Silence4Sounds 10 months ago
Love the intro chord...literally, a rush!
kragenra 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Das zum gottverfickten Teufel nochmal beste Gitarrensolo aller Zeiten!!!! UNBEFUCKINLIEVABLE!!!!!!
DopeDefconOne 1 year ago
Das zum gottverfickten Teufel nochmal beste Gitarrensolo aller Zeiten!!!! UNBEFUCKINLIEVABLE!!!!!!
DopeDefconOne 1 year ago
It's the best version because there is an ACTUAL scream for once! For years, I wanted the scream from the pin prick to be raw and searing, and I've finally found it! I can't believe I've been a Floyd fan all my life and never bothered to listen to this version.
Floydian6973 1 year ago
Yes, this is the best version. The harmony is breathtaking. I think I hear a violin in there, but I'm no expert. Musical poetry.
karma16ify 1 year ago
CONCORDO,ISSO É MAIS QUE MÚSICA, EU AMO DESDE 1994 COM O PULSE, OUÇO QUASE TODOS OS DIAS ANTES DE DORMIR.
PENA NUNCA TEREM VINDO AO BRASIL, ISSO É FERIDA QUE NÃO SARA. THE BEST SOLO OF ROCK HISTORY!!
catoigo 1 year ago
viciada !
amo completamente esta musica muitoooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!
love this song !!!!!!!!
perfect !
clauwiscas 1 year ago
If you want to listen to an other great version of this one, check the Live in Gdansk one, by Gilmour. Epic.
Pddc13 1 year ago
Wow, I can't describe how awesome this version is. I love The Wall version, the PULSE version, the Live 8 version but this one is just so epic!! And it's my favorite song of all time
comicbookguy90 1 year ago 2
@comicbookguy90 agreed
wirikuta14 1 year ago
the wall version just dosnt have the passion this has
spidereatsteddy 1 year ago 5
BEST LIVE VERSION !!!!! i cranked it up so loud the neighbors called
agordon321 1 year ago 7
this is the best version, better than pulse, but pulse being a more popular concert gets a lot of atention, I`m sure many pulse fans (i`m a pulse fan) havent heard this version.
wirikuta14 1 year ago
Best version ever!
ProjectVRD 1 year ago
I agree. It's better than PULSE version. It was this solo that got me into Pink Floyd. One of the best things that ever happened to me.
dragmio 2 years ago
best version ever.
the solo is EPIC
impulsoprog 2 years ago 2