Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (261)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • quite bad, but she's still my fav singer/

  • Don't get me wrong but I think in this video her voice is all over the place in the chorus but know when I look at her I think wow, she's improved a ton and I am a big Taylor Swift fan. All the girls in my class/form (I'm in year 7, in the UK) absolutely hate her but I love her!

  • Well, she has a cute dress...

  • Shania is way better!!!!!!!!!

  • guys this in 2009. this is a good performance, haters are just hating. thats it. Taylor swift has grown SO much as a performer since this performance, and still stayed true to herself.

  • What would you be without your band, tell me. Just another pretty girl, nothing special, no voice, no soul, no personality, no heart, just nothing. Nothing at all.

  • She can not sing! 

  • @kendawg19 she CAN CAN sing!

  • How many times does Taylor say and sing You Belong WITH Me here and they keep saying TO....even right after she told the interviewer the name of the song she screws it up. I hate these disrespectful ignorant fools they have interviewing Country stars when they come here.

  • Gaga doesnt lip sing

  • UH? You call this country? I call this poppish rock or something.

  • I <3 Taylor Swift! :D x 

  • nice girl

  • I love this band.

  • watch country my ass new version!

  • selena does not lipsing

  • @Trypheana5055 I know. But selena sucks live

  • @Bobbyxx00 haha too true

  • DEMI DOES NOT LIPSING!

    lov ya, taylor :)

  • She sounds great!!! I find it funny that I like Taylor Swift, and yet I don't own albums by her. Well I know the next few CDs I'll be buying...

  • Kitty Wells will always be the Queen of country

  • @camperJ Nah Dolly Parton lol

  • Taylor sucks. I'm sorry, but anyone who has their voice tampered with so much so that she sounds halfway decent does not deserve to be a celebrity. And to anyone who thinks she is a good singer: HAVE YOU HEARD HER SING LIVE??? Bleeding ears.. And she is NOT country. Maybe a few songs at the beginning of her career, but she is POP not country.. Her saying she's country is a disgrace to country music everywhere. Reba, Dolly, Martina, Carrie, and Faith are real country women. Nuff said..

  • was she TRYING an english accent at some points?

  • I think the problem with Taylor singing live is, that everybody expects her to sing like Rihanna or Leona Lewis, but their songs are just to different to compare them.

  • @xLovinLife no the problem with Taylor is that she just doesn't have a good voice nor can her voice convey emotion. I mean, that's what made all the legends so great. Celine Dion, Aretha Franklin, even John Lennon, they sing well and express emotion through their song.

  • OH DEAR! that is baaaaaadd poor Taylor :(

    i LOVE her and i've seen her live on concert the one she mentioned actually 23/11/09 and she was AMAZING but this is sooo bad :/

  • sooooo cute

  • y r ppl always sayin they cant sing live. no one can. its just a fact. so they need to leave them alone about it. If they worried about singing good live then they might as well as be standing still. Just leave them alone and let them sing and do what they want without being talked about

  • @JemiNlexStories wow...Reba McEntire can definitely sing live. Just look up a 2010 video of her singing live and you'll see. And there are a bunch of country artists that can sing live as well. Taylor cannot. and that's a fact.

  • @cuongoff No Reba can not. It may seem like it but she cant. Stop bailing on Taylor to make yourself feel good. Its stupid and immature. Grow up

  • @JemiNlexStories You can't compare Taylor to Reba. Reba is in a completely different league.

  • @whatsupfizznugget

    Not really. I'll compare who I want.

  • @JemiNlexStories okay then, i'll compare taylor's voice to that of a raging baboon in heat....

    bottom line is Reba > Taylor.

  • @whatsupfizznugget

    You can think what you want, You're jealous you cant sing, If you wanna make fun of someone you sing. You cant sing. Its a proven fact. people who make fun of people can't sing.

  • @JemiNlexStories Nice try, but when i decide to post some videos of my own work, you'll be the first one to receive a link to my page. toodles!

  • @whatsupfizznugget

    I wouldnt listen. You probably sound like a dying cow,

  • @JemiNlexStories Again, nice try, but I'd still sound better than her. Okay? I'm done. It was nice talking to you though.

  • @whatsupfizznugget

    Um no. You're not better than her.

  • @JemiNlexStories wow, still being assertive aren't you? since you couldn't possibly know how well i sing (unless you were creepin in my backyard), i'll just go on my way now. go away little girl!

  • @whatsupfizznugget

    1. Im not "little" and 2. If you could sing you would be found. Dumbass

  • @JemiNlexStories It was nice talking to you. I hope you live a happy life. :)

  • First time seeing taylor swift... hmmm really nice down to earth... keep it up.

  • THIS IS SO AMATEUR.... poor

  • i love taylor swift!!!!!!!! but live ?? im kinda glad now i couldn't get tickets at Manchester. ahh well, still amazingg!! xxx

  • u saying shes bad live? shes brilliant live what u onabout?

  • love her dress :)

  • ummm...big difference in cd and live...i think shes isn't that good live

  • atleast shes not lipsinging, like miley, or demi, or selena, and everybody else

  • Comment removed

  • @scottsommers07 demi never lipsyncs - listen to her live - shes incredible - a lot better than swift

  • @scottsommers07 Miley, Demi Selena and the rest of the Disney stars are not lipsinging! Try to watch some videos of the in Live. Where the hell did you get that?!

    :) ;) Paul Kantor

  • @scottsommers07 I'd rather she lip-sync. My ears are still bleeding cause she sucks so much.

  • some singer DO NOT LIP SING

  • some singer DO NOT LIPSINNG

  • @scottsommers07 wait...THEY LIMPSING? I thought they naturally sang like s**t

  • @scottsommers07 yeh miley doesn't lipsing douchebag X

  • @scottsommers07 demi & miley do not lipsinging but sel does

  • @scottsommers07 DEMI DOES NOT LIPSING! neither does miley or selena. get your facts straight.

  • @scottsommers07 uhhh, demi doesn't lip synch.

  • Emma said "you belong to me" instead of "with me" kinda easy mistake to make though :D love Taylor xo

  • I love taylor swift she was amazingg live she deserves all of the sucess she gets :D

  • when you sing your voice really is affected by the space you have in open spaces your voice sounds amazing but look at how much space she has

  • wats up with the gay comments people she's the best she on magazine everywhere u no this is her best year so plz dont ruin it for her she rock u guys r just jealous

  • omg her singing is terrible!!! on the cd she's great, but live.....

  • Shes good live i seen her in concert she was amazingg

  • well idk i like her,,is cool, she isnt a bad person

  • Wanker

  • y is she so skinny? not good

  • Shes not shes just tall so she luks skinny

  • shes terrible live :|

  • Go taylor!

  • Taylor's the bestttt!!!

    She's amazin' in concert!

    :)) xo

  • I love her dress!!

  • She sounds quite bad here but I still love her!

  • She sounds really bad live!

    :O

    i never expected she sings so bad live.

  • @LeoniexKuiper Have you watched any award shows??? She sucks

  • amazing!

  • MANCHESTER NOVEMBER 24TH SOoooooooooooooooo Excited :D :D :D

  • i expected more from her tbh, shes not good live at all im sorry but its the truth,

  • call of duty modern warfare 2 woopwoop xox

  • whats with the lowish rating, the performance isnt amazing but its not bad either :s

  • omg i missed this :'(

  • she sounds really bad?!

  • @jadeom Are you surprised?? Has no one watched any award shows??? Taylor sucks at singing!! They screw with her voice to make her sound half decent on CD's...

  • @10rebamcentire Have you been to her concert? She's actually really good live. You are an idiot if you judge people off shitty award shows performances, which are run by sound engineers who have no idea how everything should be mixed. Many bands like U2 refuse to do TV performances because they dont want their sound to be in the hands of some random sound engineer from the tv station. Taylor sounded amazing at the ACMs in '10 and '11, earlier ones she was just nervous in front of all her heroes.

  • GREAT TUNE T-BONE

  • I Dnt Understand Why they Swing the mic

  • shit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­

  • i can't believe she's 5'11

    she looks so petite.

  • Yyeah , me too . I know she tall but never think she 5'11 but she really 5'11 LOL :))

    She's so pretty & cute !!!!! But in this video , i dont like her make up (i mean the eyes , look so ...... have no idea (maybe only in my opinion)

  • how old is she?

  • 19, 20 in December. :)

  • She is 19.

  • is she actually singing?

  • BO jR RETAINS, TO THIS DAY, A CLASS OF BRITISH CITIZENSHIP

    HE IS NOT ELIGIBLE TO THE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES

  • her eyes are wierd

  • she has an ugly face

  • i wonder what u like...this girl is gawjuss...dont be jealous x

  • id like to stick my finger in her arse but her voice is not so great.

  • ugh...

  • it's country/pop.

    stop complaining.

  • Why do all US guitarists stand like they are taking a dump?

  • I've got a feeling they're not allowed to be taller than her or something. Help her stand out and all that.

  • LOL :) AMAZINGGGGGGG :)

  • WTF was country about that! very good voice though

  • mehh

  • ''Country'' or ''pop''?

  • um.. this wasn't too good. and i mean her voice in wembley.....? hmm.

  • i like her but she is the biggest star at the moment? Naaa she will never be as big as Dolly Parton "Queen of country!"

  • I don't think she's that good live singing this song. but other songs of hers shes good singing live...

  • NOOOOO HOW DID MISS THIS!!

    I love her so so much!! xxx

  • Okay...

    she's so not good live!

  • she looks weird not ugly but weird

    she looks like something is pulling her face back and making it tight

  • very good but funny wen she made her accent abit more country wen she sang " Girl like That" XD

  • that was awful :S

  • shes acctually quite good but she does allot of things with her arms and thats distracting.

    and btw shesn not that tall do u see how hight her heels are:)

  • My cousin is her biggest fan!!!!!!!!!! LITERALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!! TRUST ME EVERYTHING ID TAYLOR THIS AND TAYLOR THAT!!!!

  • did she get taylor to sign an autogragh on her stomach and then tatoo it on?

    if not then she isnt her BIGGEST fan

    :)

  • yes and everything in her room is taylor taylor taylor its crazy!!! by the way eight tattoos

  • shes pretty but the flick of eye liner looks dodgy

  • 3 guitars, a banjo and a bass? all they need is two guitars and a bass..

  • PEOPLE PEOPLE.

    she's not crap live, it's just GMTV'S awful sound system, thats why everyone mimes on there.

    WE LOVE YOU TAYLOR! <3

  • Why can't these these Brits talk out of something besides their nose? Chahts. ahh crahhhp. Aeeh. eww. Saahry, chahps. We left your warm beer and weak patriotism lahng ahgew.

  • We talk fine, thanks.

    Go learn to talk properly, instead of whining like a four year old.

    Cunt.

  • Who's the four-year old, eh, chap?

  • Not me. I'm 13, actually :).

    But, we don't talk out of our noses. You whine, so.

  • C'mon... our ability to laugh at ourselves proves we're human and not the stuffy stereotype.

  • I'm lost.

    What are you suggesting.

  • Its only a performen! Keep cool... Other make sex at the dancefloor!

  • go eat grass

  • what a childish reply.Guess you support animal abuse too then?

  • i think she did quite well.. i think the problem people is they want every performance to be as good as the studio version. GMTV don't have the resources to have full on bands on that tiny stage!! Plus how many records have you sold this year?

  • I love taylor swift she amazig i love her songsn . she ok likive. At least she sings live most people mime.

  • i think she sounds good live.and even though she doesnt always sound good live...its no big deal people. every singer has their off days ! u try singing early in the morning or when u have lost sleep...its not easy ! most of the time if ur tired or rushing a lot ur voice doesnt sound good. i actually liked that her voice cracked when she was singing ! it reminds me that shes human .if my voice cracks...its no big deal because taylor swift has her off days too

  • followers? i think just stating the obvious. im a huge fan of hers , but the fact is shes not great live!

  • she is, check out , MTV VMA awards, it's just GMTV's crappy sound system, thats why everyone mins on here.

  • What a bunch of followers, one person writes that she was bad live and everyone is now writing it. Very amusing.

  • She's not that great live, but I love this song, love her album, shes really pretty, her dress is lovely and she can sing her slow songs live awesomely ;)

  • okay, i'm a huge fan of taylor. sometimes she's not great live (okay, that's an understatement) but that's usually when she's running around the stage and jumping up and down, adding embellishments to her performance, etc. she's amazing here because she's standing still. she's HUMAN just like the rest of us. you'd be out of breath too if you were running around the stage. she always sings her slow songs amazingly, and like i said, her faster songs are much better live when she's standing still.

  • Comment removed

  • friggin love youuh taylorrrr!!!!!!!!

  • Taylor Swift ROCKS!! and i wish i watched this on tv :(

  • love this song.

  • Sometimes i think it depends on the song she's singing. Since you belong with me has kind of a fast tempo, it's harder to sing live and since she's human she needs space to breathe. She has done alot better performances when shes singing "fearless" and "tim mc graw" and she's good at "our song" aswell. I love Taylor and can't frikin wait until she preforms in Ireland.. Hopefully that will be soon.

  • i thought she was good

    i love her dress i want it!

    does anyone know where its from?

  • Get Taylor's blue floral dress from Australian designer Holly Chalmers

  • Pause at 3:49

    She looks funny. Haha.

    But anyway... watched the performance. Wasn't as bad as everyone was making it out to be.

  • I think she had a cold because she had one while performing in aus and sounded the exact same regardless still an amazing girl!

  • I dont like her makeup that much.

    I dont like what she did with it here. And her performance wasnt that great.

    Shoot, I totally expected more.

    But I love her anyways.

  • ew ew ew ew ew ew !

  • I Love taylor but that one wasn't that good

  • she's amazing:)!!!

    loveher.

  • i have nothing against taylor, but wow. that was horrible

  • Her eye makeup is horrendous.

  • she sings amazing live! but just this time shes messing up a lot for some reason :/

  • they're so big! and the girl is so british! ahh

    gotta love Taylor <3

  • I think she sounds great here! Yeah, she messes up in some places but otherwise she sounds great. :)

  • she sucks at singing live

  • she cant sing live

  • I LOVE the dress. And Taylor's just unbelivablie talented and gorgeous :)

  • taylor usually is better

    but i love 4:22 its funny

  • When i saw her live i thought it was much better than the Cd versions. I think sometimes it just depends ( and on what song she's singing). Sometimes she sounds amazing and sometimes not so much.