I was re reading batman knight fall and i noticed something in "part 2 : who rules the night", selina kyle tires to get on board bruce waynes private jet (that is travelling to santa prisca) . When alfred meet selina kyle they act as if they haven't met her before and try to get her off the plane. This did'nt quite make sense since bruce wayne and selina kyle had a relation ship in long halloween. But in this scene in knightfall it was obvious that they hadn't met before...????
hey man thanks for this video batman has always been my main superhero but this year i just bought arkham asylum(fucking excited as hell for arkham city)then i really got into batman more than before and just yesterday i bought year one so now im just gonna collect,im maily interested in the 1st few years so thanks again i wrote down the important ones this really helped
That could be case, after all like he says in killing joke...... "if i'm going to have a past, i perfer it to be multiple choice"....... like in the dark knight where he told many people multiple origin stories of "how he got his scars".
@marvelbrothers well thing is that there a "new Joker origin" every few years. the way i see it is all of them are canon but none of them tell the full story. its the only way for me personaly to resolve the issue of multiple joker origins with out just picking one
Is Batman Lovers and Madmen (a Batman Confidential storyline) considered non-canon? cos Joker's first apperance in this timeline is "the man who laughs"
@andrewcutter2 cos after all like he says in killing joke...... "if i'm going to have a past, i perfer it to be multiple choice....... like in the dark knight where he told many people multiple origin story of "how he got his scars".
i know they are more stand alone stories but it would be great to hear when you think stories like deathblow: after the fire, Absolution, Secrets, joker and arkham asylum take place. hell even the alien and predator ones!
keep up the good work! some ones got to do it if DC themselves won't! x
:/ i will never get the batman full collection :( i kind of sad cuse i am a hardcore batman fan i love batman since i remember but with all those comics i think i will never make it :( but i been watching your reviews to get the most significants ones :/ u.u
@ANTIcoFilms Modern continuity includes parts of the bronze and silver age. the first crisis is remembered different then how it happen. i believe its referred to as the anti matter crisis. i didnt include the crisis in this time line because its batman only.
hey i am total noob to the crisis stories but i have been reading batman comics for the past couple of years....and i was under the impression that to reboot the batman series they did crisis on infinite earths, and then year one came out....what do you mean by your comment about including the bronze and silver age?
@lscudder1901 although batman year one came out after the reboot, many of the silver and bronze age comics are still canon and set after year one. think of year one as a retelling of batman origins rather than a restart
@andrewcutter2 ah...so then why exactly did you place crisis on infinite earths when you did? and at what point would i read the other crisis stories? i plan on reading the books you listed in this video in the order that you did, but i am interested in the multiverse events things like 52 and zero hour and what not.
@lscudder1901 coie would fall some where before the killing joke. zero hour after prodical, infinate crisis after war crimes ad well as 52 after war crimes. final crisis after rip
hey andrew, idk if this is true but i herd bout a comic book that batman confronts the ghosts of his parents and goes toe to toe with the devil himself.. idk, thought id ask you.
hey andrew, i wanna subscribe to a batman comic but idk which one. i want one where batman is bruce wayne, alfred is still the butler and everything is just original.
Thanks for your hard work on the timelines, I don't have nearly as many batman tpbs like you, nor will I ever get them all. But for the ones I do have at least now I can put them in the timeline order. So thanks, and keep it up. I enjoy the videos and knowledge of the characters!
Hey Andrew, I am new to comic books and I am trying to find Batman: Prey, but I am having a really hard time finding it. Is it one the ones that are hard to get?
I had those issues of Anarchy (I think in the 430s...) and they were definitely before Tim Drake....I don't know what other Anarchy stories are in that trade though....GREAT video!
Wow...when can I come over to read them?...lollollol...thank you for posting this video, not even my comicbook store, have a collection as complete as your...enjoy buddy...
Cool timeline, but I am curious about your timeline as it relates to Dick. You have him introduced like year 3 or 4, and then one year later you have Strange Apparitions, which I thought reprinted DET 471-476 where he is in college. It seems like you maybe should bump Strange Apparitions up a couple of years, no?
I am really no expert on modern continuity, but am a whiz at golden and silver age stuff. Really interesting stuff! Now you gotta figure out where Bat Hound fits in!!
@FanOfBats dick shows up t the end of year 2. strange apparitions happens during the 7th or 8th year of batman career its assumed that dick was older like 12 when bruce took him in
hey man just wanted you to know that most of the reason ive been getting into comics is because of your great videos.. i spent about 50 bucks on trade paper backs alone this past week.. so thank you for this curse? hahah anyways keep it up.
Thank You so much Andrew! I"ve been going nuts with this continuity for some time. I'm new to comics after loving the toons as a child and now am trying to collect the perfect continuity collection.
haha I like how you put them on the floor in chronological order. I do that when I'm bored sometimes. But at 7:56 you slipped up and said "Dick Grayson as Batman" instead of Robin :P And I don't think war crimes happens before Infinite Crisis because in Under the Hood pt.2, we see Chemo destroy Bludhaven which happens DURING Infinite Crisis
@VsxFedora under the hood and war crimes happens during the start of the infinite crisis. i said that it is the last story because right after it is the one year later story. i hope that clears things up for you.
holy shiat that is a lot of batman, that must have cost you a fortune. Love the videos keep um coming man. I just gotta say your lisp cracks me up like crazy.
Great timeline, can't wait for green lantern. Speaking of that, do you know where I can find Kyle Rayner's "run" as green lantern? And not when he's with the league , just by himself. I read " my brothers keeper" but that's all I can ever find.
I think you forgot to include "batman and robin: batman and robin must die!" it's part of Grant Morrisons run after all.
MrPJD18 3 days ago
does anyone know where i could find shaman. i live in the uk and i cant find it anywhere
tacticalboi 1 month ago
I was re reading batman knight fall and i noticed something in "part 2 : who rules the night", selina kyle tires to get on board bruce waynes private jet (that is travelling to santa prisca) . When alfred meet selina kyle they act as if they haven't met her before and try to get her off the plane. This did'nt quite make sense since bruce wayne and selina kyle had a relation ship in long halloween. But in this scene in knightfall it was obvious that they hadn't met before...????
marvelbrothers 7 months ago
you need to get a better camera
MrSweGibzon 7 months ago
hey man thanks for this video batman has always been my main superhero but this year i just bought arkham asylum(fucking excited as hell for arkham city)then i really got into batman more than before and just yesterday i bought year one so now im just gonna collect,im maily interested in the 1st few years so thanks again i wrote down the important ones this really helped
bkkinggdfn12 7 months ago
That could be case, after all like he says in killing joke...... "if i'm going to have a past, i perfer it to be multiple choice"....... like in the dark knight where he told many people multiple origin stories of "how he got his scars".
marvelbrothers 7 months ago
@marvelbrothers well thing is that there a "new Joker origin" every few years. the way i see it is all of them are canon but none of them tell the full story. its the only way for me personaly to resolve the issue of multiple joker origins with out just picking one
andrewcutter2 7 months ago
Is Batman Lovers and Madmen (a Batman Confidential storyline) considered non-canon? cos Joker's first apperance in this timeline is "the man who laughs"
marvelbrothers 7 months ago
@marvelbrothers kinda. its half canon
andrewcutter2 7 months ago
@andrewcutter2 cos after all like he says in killing joke...... "if i'm going to have a past, i perfer it to be multiple choice....... like in the dark knight where he told many people multiple origin story of "how he got his scars".
marvelbrothers 7 months ago
By any chance are you going to do an updated timeline before the reboot?
krypticzisback 7 months ago
Gosh, i really, really dont like Damian
XMackenzieMassacreX 1 year ago
Barbara Gorder haha 8:19
TWOMERCY 1 year ago
Batman: Fortunate Son is an Elseworld's story (and a crapy one, at that). Bruce and Dick weren't the Dynamic Duo during the time of Elvis.
VsxFedora 1 year ago
i know they are more stand alone stories but it would be great to hear when you think stories like deathblow: after the fire, Absolution, Secrets, joker and arkham asylum take place. hell even the alien and predator ones!
keep up the good work! some ones got to do it if DC themselves won't! x
Mattcorbett 1 year ago
:/ i will never get the batman full collection :( i kind of sad cuse i am a hardcore batman fan i love batman since i remember but with all those comics i think i will never make it :( but i been watching your reviews to get the most significants ones :/ u.u
fozkraw 1 year ago
crisis on infinite earth was made during the bronze age meaning it comes before the modern continuity
and you forgot to point out that final crisis comes right before battle for the cowl and infinite crisis right before face the face
ANTIcoFilms 1 year ago
@ANTIcoFilms Modern continuity includes parts of the bronze and silver age. the first crisis is remembered different then how it happen. i believe its referred to as the anti matter crisis. i didnt include the crisis in this time line because its batman only.
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
@andrewcutter2
ok...
ANTIcoFilms 1 year ago
@andrewcutter2
hey i am total noob to the crisis stories but i have been reading batman comics for the past couple of years....and i was under the impression that to reboot the batman series they did crisis on infinite earths, and then year one came out....what do you mean by your comment about including the bronze and silver age?
lscudder1901 1 year ago
@lscudder1901 although batman year one came out after the reboot, many of the silver and bronze age comics are still canon and set after year one. think of year one as a retelling of batman origins rather than a restart
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
@andrewcutter2 ah...so then why exactly did you place crisis on infinite earths when you did? and at what point would i read the other crisis stories? i plan on reading the books you listed in this video in the order that you did, but i am interested in the multiverse events things like 52 and zero hour and what not.
lscudder1901 1 year ago
@lscudder1901 coie would fall some where before the killing joke. zero hour after prodical, infinate crisis after war crimes ad well as 52 after war crimes. final crisis after rip
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
is it just me or does this guy look like john Conner in terminator 3?
stranger123100 1 year ago
hey andrew, idk if this is true but i herd bout a comic book that batman confronts the ghosts of his parents and goes toe to toe with the devil himself.. idk, thought id ask you.
MrMoviedreamer 1 year ago
hey andrew, i wanna subscribe to a batman comic but idk which one. i want one where batman is bruce wayne, alfred is still the butler and everything is just original.
spicyrulz101 1 year ago
hahaah "im keeping it in my timeline bcuz i payed the fucking $24 dollars for it! ok?! so for me its staying there!"
MrMoviedreamer 1 year ago
when does arkham asylum take place
dethronethesonofgod 1 year ago
Just starting out with my batman collection, this updated timeline is really helpful
nemesis776 1 year ago
i kluv u
TWOMERCY 1 year ago
Thanks for your hard work on the timelines, I don't have nearly as many batman tpbs like you, nor will I ever get them all. But for the ones I do have at least now I can put them in the timeline order. So thanks, and keep it up. I enjoy the videos and knowledge of the characters!
congojoea 1 year ago
i want this collection!!! lol but sooo many books =(
jdbabyv3 1 year ago
Hey Andrew, I am new to comic books and I am trying to find Batman: Prey, but I am having a really hard time finding it. Is it one the ones that are hard to get?
Annieelizm 1 year ago
@Annieelizm yea one of the top 4 hard ones to find. i suggest amazon
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
@andrewcutter2 What are the other three?
Annieelizm 1 year ago
What is your stance on were Final Crisis goes? Do you think it goes before or after R.I.P.?
cbot20 1 year ago
Honestly can't thank you enough for all these timelines you're posting up. Really aiding me a lot !!!
oldschool4091 1 year ago
Legacy looks awesome! Not just the badass cover art, but the name "legacy" brings certain interesting thoughts to mind...
VsxFedora 1 year ago
Lol! You're not the only one who payed 20 somthing bucks for "Whatever happened to the caped crusader."
MrM9991 1 year ago
man who laughs 2=killing joke
KroliggBloodhoof 1 year ago
with lonely place of dying im missing the 4th part i boguht the other 3 at a fair
SauskeX4 1 year ago
I had those issues of Anarchy (I think in the 430s...) and they were definitely before Tim Drake....I don't know what other Anarchy stories are in that trade though....GREAT video!
4amshift 1 year ago
@4amshift 70% of the trade is after knightfall while the issues you got was before tim
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
YOU FORGOT WRAITH, BLACK CASEBOOK, AND LAST ARKHAM
dukealoops1993 1 year ago
holy fucking shit that is a lot of batman comics
kometman 1 year ago
What's Batman story "Snow" about?
TheRadman107 1 year ago
@TheRadman107 first encounter with mr freeze
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
@andrewcutter2 thank you andrew, your one of my top reviewers.
TheRadman107 1 year ago
Wow...when can I come over to read them?...lollollol...thank you for posting this video, not even my comicbook store, have a collection as complete as your...enjoy buddy...
TheRadman107 1 year ago
holy shit dude
Stacey14491 1 year ago
Doesn't Return of Hush come before war games, because he is already teamed up with Prometheus by War Games?
loverman13 1 year ago
Cool timeline, but I am curious about your timeline as it relates to Dick. You have him introduced like year 3 or 4, and then one year later you have Strange Apparitions, which I thought reprinted DET 471-476 where he is in college. It seems like you maybe should bump Strange Apparitions up a couple of years, no?
I am really no expert on modern continuity, but am a whiz at golden and silver age stuff. Really interesting stuff! Now you gotta figure out where Bat Hound fits in!!
FanOfBats 1 year ago
@FanOfBats dick shows up t the end of year 2. strange apparitions happens during the 7th or 8th year of batman career its assumed that dick was older like 12 when bruce took him in
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
hey man just wanted you to know that most of the reason ive been getting into comics is because of your great videos.. i spent about 50 bucks on trade paper backs alone this past week.. so thank you for this curse? hahah anyways keep it up.
dubman116 1 year ago
Whoaaa thank you so much! I really enjoy your videos even though I am not into comics yet, but I am trying!
Annieelizm 1 year ago
If I were you, I'd include Nightwing: Year One, just cause it helps the transition between Dick Grayson to Jason Todd. (Just me though.)
DannyPhantomBeast 1 year ago
@DannyPhantomBeast sounds to me like that would fit better in a robin timline
wesleyv1 1 year ago
Thank You so much Andrew! I"ve been going nuts with this continuity for some time. I'm new to comics after loving the toons as a child and now am trying to collect the perfect continuity collection.
Please do a Superman timeline.
JuggaSic 1 year ago
My dad is a Batman fanatic
CaptainRoyMustang170 1 year ago
hey so just wondering did you buy Batman Hush the complete version because you got the others signed
padfoot0422 1 year ago
@padfoot0422 correct. i have my signed hush books in a display while i use the complete version for reading
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
haha I like how you put them on the floor in chronological order. I do that when I'm bored sometimes. But at 7:56 you slipped up and said "Dick Grayson as Batman" instead of Robin :P And I don't think war crimes happens before Infinite Crisis because in Under the Hood pt.2, we see Chemo destroy Bludhaven which happens DURING Infinite Crisis
VsxFedora 1 year ago
@VsxFedora under the hood and war crimes happens during the start of the infinite crisis. i said that it is the last story because right after it is the one year later story. i hope that clears things up for you.
andrewcutter2 1 year ago
holy shiat that is a lot of batman, that must have cost you a fortune. Love the videos keep um coming man. I just gotta say your lisp cracks me up like crazy.
TrevorHarris881 1 year ago
I love batman!!! =D but its gonna take me a while to collect all these... hahaha awesome vid!
batmanisawesome1 1 year ago
@batmanisawesome1 My dad also like batman more than superman
CaptainRoyMustang170 1 year ago
you made a tiny mistake you said the man who laughs instead of the killing joke but otherwise great job cant wait for the booster gold one
BKcritic 1 year ago
Great timeline, can't wait for green lantern. Speaking of that, do you know where I can find Kyle Rayner's "run" as green lantern? And not when he's with the league , just by himself. I read " my brothers keeper" but that's all I can ever find.
Giles231987 1 year ago
nice video. are you going to be doing a robin timline? there is a zoom button on a camera i take it? lol. I'm very enthusiastic about batman too.
hobbo3003 1 year ago
NIIIICE been waiting for this fora WHILE
obk227 1 year ago
man thats a lot
GBDCJRInc 1 year ago