David Goldman Custody Ruling?

[Ninic47]

This is a perfect example on why people shouldn't marry mother fuckers from other countries. MARRY AMERICAN...THAT'S THAT.

[ifilmhackersdotcom]

Lucky it's Brazil, not Japan. Japan does not recognize the other relative rights, and sides with tme more "stable environment", which may be just a few months (after kidnapping).

Japan nails the coffin by not providing visas for the other parent, so he/she can visit their kids.

So where are the USA politicians to blame Japan for anything? Cant take on someone your size?

DOUBLE STANDARDS.

Poor Tiana Weed, Seana Hillman, Marina Kaneda.

Unlucky for you, it's Japan, not Brazil....

[cne08]

The only way Sean's Brazilian family should be allowed to see him in America is under tight supervision.

[kipptumor]

I agree. I was disturbed, however, at how many people were willing to overlook the fact that Sean may have established a real family relationship with the people in Brazil. It was wrong the way he ended up there,YES, but never the less, he did have five years of life with them. As long as they weren't starving him or beating him and they really loved him and took care of him he may very well have some issues after this transition. Hopefully it is the last one though & it's looking good for him.

[pthaeloblue]

If Bruna had done the right thing in the beginning no matter how long it took to set things straight, it would have worked out eventually. That "woman" took matters into her own hands and now Sean is suffering because of it. Hope it is the last custody fight he has to go through, but the grandmother won't leave things be... so we'll see...

[Pimentinha1980]

Sugiro leiam o acordo SEQUESTRO INTERNACIONAL DE HAIA 1980,o qual Brasil assinou em 1983.Brasil nao se comportou como governo civilizado, nao querendo responder aos acordos e promessas que assina. Vejam o vídeo nesse site AUDIENCIA PÚBLICA- CASO SEAN parte1/1 e 1/2 do Dep. Paes e Lira, por favor.

[rachellaughs]

ohh no if i were him i wouldn't allow them to visit sean in the U.S. unless it is a strict supervised visit with armed guards in his presence! i bet david spent out big bucks with all the trips he made to & from brazil, & i wouldnt want to chance them kidnapping him or doing anything bad to him. hopefully the father & son hit it off great, & bond well for all the years they've lost together that'd be so sad!

[CarlosMacMartin]

Mess with KARMA and do things the wrong way

you pay dearly! If you don't believe me,just ask

Bruna Bianchi!

[vanessazulske]

It is just sad that Sean had to live on Christmas eve..it must be very hard for his brazilian family, specially for his little sister....But good luck to David and Sean..hope he can be happy...and that he can see his brazilian family on holidays....

[vanessazulske]

I'm Brazilian and I'm just glad this story is over...I don't know what is better for the boy, but hopefully he will get used to his new life in USA...Brazil is no jungle, and I'm sure Sean had a GREAT life with his grandparents..but he has a dad..so I guess his place is with him. We don't know why Bruna left David, to move away from your husband the way she did you must have strong reasons....I know this was wrong, but let's not talk about her...she is death, and cannot talk for herself anymore.

[FOAMANTE2]

thank God NBC chartered a private Jet to bring Sean and David to come home to New Jersey. Thank God for Today Show keeping the story in public.

[gildodorio]

Soon a bestseller and a movie.

[Michigandrunk]

Thats what happens you trust your 3rd world jungle bunny wife.

[Pimentinha1980]

Família Bianchi sequestradora e abominável! Nao deveriam ficar impunes por esse ato criminosos.E a avó queria embarcar junto com o neto? é muita cara de pau mesmo. E o bandido do padrasto fazer Sean desfilar entre os jornalistas em 100 m? Prisao pra todos eles. Felicidades família Goldman!

[am101171]

Muy feliz por el Señor Goldman y su hijo. Creo que la familia Brasilena equivoco el camino, lo que es una verdadera pena. Tengo una hija con Brasilena y aunque las diferencias culturales nos separaron tengo a mi hija visitando en mi país en este momento y gracias a Dios no tengo que vivir nada de lo que el Sr Goldman ha vivido. Disculpas con aquellos que hablan ingles y son gente de bien, algunas personas hacen comentarios desdeñosos a personas que escriben mal en ingles.aprendan lenguas uds

[ifilmhackersdotcom]

Quoting political consult. Stilgherrian:

"Going into Iraq, we ignored the UN Charter, which prohibits the use of force except in self-defense or with Security Council authorization.

Once in Iraq, we ignored the Hague Regulations, requiring us to put a stop to looting and to make only necessary changes to local law and government.

We ignored the Geneva Conventions, which prohibit secret detention and abuse of prisoners of the kind we saw at Abu Ghraib."

In contrast, Brazil _followed_ Hague.

[ifilmhackersdotcom]

@ifilmhackersdotcom

My bad. The above quote is from JURIST Contributing Editor Mary Ellen O'Connell of Notre Dame Law School in the article "Learning from the Iraq War: The Wisdom of International Law" (University of Pittsburgh School of Law).

[ThtPnoiChristian]

Plain and simple the boy should stay with his American father. NOT his STEPfather but his biological father.

The United States is the greatest country in the world and Brazil well thats another story

[Kymra]

Hey Alexrj2 - it's obvious you haven't been following the story. He has been down PLENTY of times, only to be blocked from visitation by the Brazilian family. Also, why would he move to Brazil? The point is to bring him home, to the US - where he was BORN and where his father resides.

[AlmightyBrazil]

He was born in HELL but he still belongs to Brazil.

This is God`s will you scum communist

Barack Obama is my bitch now

[racecarbackwards1]

Go check out your nearest favela and then tell me how almighty Brazil is.

That we surely do not have in (hell) the United States. But don't worry you will always be mighty in soccer so you have that to be proud.

[alexrj2]

i know very well the history. no just after the mother death. never he has sent money, never he was near the boy etc. the family cant block the visitation. this year he received temporary custody to stay with the boy during the week. but he didnt go to Brazil to stay with the boy.

where do we have to stay where we were born? that's no sense. the father didnt go to Brazil to stay with the boy, didnt pay anything etc and started a war, never we wanted to discuss.

[Kymra]

You just don't get it. And you are obviously affiliated with the kidnappers. Anyone who would be suspicious of a man trying to get his son back from KIDNAPPERS is a moron.

[alexrj2]

shut up. you are accusing me of what? pay attention with what you are saying.

i got it. you dont know what you say. are you one more brazilian that was obligated to fing a "gringo" to survive? and know is his maid?

she didnt do anything wrong. she hadnt any criminal charges agaisnt her the family and

the new husband neither.

so call them kidnappers is a lie.

they were in the US recently.

she decided to stay in Brazil as she didnt want to continue the marriage anymore. what's the problem?

[Kymra]

Ok, you are making no sense. Maybe it's just a language barrier. If you are trying to say poor Bruna had to go marry a 'gringo' give me a break. She was a model! she could have anyone she wanted. and the problem is SHE DIDN'T TELL DAVID SHE WAS LEAVING HIM. You can't just take someone's child to another country and say 'tough luck, I am not in love with you anymore'. She should have done the grown up thing and worked it out legally first instead of just running away.

[alexrj2]

the language barrier is from you, better problems with reading comprehension. she wasnt a model. never she was. i said about to be marry with a 'gringo'. she did what many does every time. many leave their home to return to parent house. cities, states etc the problem was they were from different countries.

she tryied to discuss but he didnt want. he started a process in nj and had 150000 dollars from the mothers family.

as he started in US she started in Brazil.

simple.

[Kymra]

Thanks for proving my point. You are a fool who doesn't even know the details of the case. David and Bruna met in Italy when they were both MODELS. Look it up, moron.

[Kymra]

also @alexrj2 - um, I am pretty sure the language barrier is from you. YOU are trying to write in English, which is obviously not your native tongue. I am NOT trying to write in Portugese or whatever language it is that you speak.

[alexrj2]

your english is terrible so the barrier come from you. i use to comment every where and no problems. i also sure that you are brazilian and think you are fluently in english. you are completely wrong. if you are american you couldnt go to the school.

[Kymra]

Oh my god, you need to stop!!! You are serioulsy making yourself look like the biggest jackass!!!!! You are not even using proper grammar. You are hilarious!!!! I am literally laughing my ass off over here!

[alexrj2]

no i will not look like you. your english is terrible. you fing a "gringo" and know is being his maid and that doesnt guarantee to speak and write well the english. i m sorry you always be considered a foreign a brazilian that found a gringo.

Brazil is ignoring nothing and is doing very well. it's saying to US that the laws must be respected.

[Kymra]

You won't look like me? what? Do you not see that you are making a fool of yourself? I pose a challenge to you ( pose means give, or ask since you OBVIOUSLY don't speak English and I DO). Copy and paste all of my comments into a word document. Set it to English. Do a spell and grammar check. I assure you it will come up flawless, save for a typo here or there. I was born in Boston and am a proud American - thanks for playing though ;)

[alexrj2]

i not making nothing. you made it of your own life. and you seem very unhappy and desesperate trying to receive attention. you made your choices now pay for it. i m not the first here that you tryied it. i m sorry for you.

[Kymra]

Oh, and I think the word you keep meaning to type is FIND. I am not sure there is such a word as FING :)

[Kymra]

I think I am 'fluently' in English.... hahahahahahaha!!! Keep 'em coming!!!

[AlmightyBrazil]

Kyma

I feel a little bad to insult you before, my reaction was wrong, ok, but

you dont know when it is time to stop play dont you?

You are too much stubborn to understand that you are wrong in this case.

How can a mother stole her OWN child.

It was her karma to die? Do you think God can make any intervenction AGAINST the mother of this innocent kid?

This TV propaganda is brainwashed your mind. Turn off your TV and start to think for yourself. It is better for the boy stay in Brazil. Thanks

[Kymra]

AlmightBrazil - I see where you are going with your point. Normally, a mother would not 'steal' her child. She would go to court , ask for a divorce , and in most cases she would be granted custody and the father would most likely be given visitation. Bruna did not do this. She just took him and left. That is against the law. Brazil is ignoring the fact that they are part of the Hague Convention. They should have returned him 5 years ago.

[alexrj2]

continue with your delusion dumbass. Brazil is ignoring nothing. Brazil signed others agreement and it constitution is more important than international agreements.Brazil is ignoring US pression etc.

no she would be obligated to stay forever in US and she wasnt interested on it.

US has no moral to say anything.

perhaps you are one more brazilian that had to fing a gringo to survive and now are afraid to be blocked in your travels to Brazil. you have no interest in the boy well being.

[Kymra]

Wow, your ignorance is astounding! Brazil IS ignoring something. You may not like it, but it's true! Sorry Charlie, but you do not speak for Brazil as a whole. I am definitely not Brazilian - can't you tell that I am NOT typing in broken english like you? You are making yourself look like a bigger fool everytime you post. I am absolutely concerned with the boy's well being. I feel for him that he doesn't want to leave but he has been BRAINWASHED by his "family". It's really disgusting!

[revolussaum]

@Kymra the problem is,, she wanst stupid like you , thats the difenrence,,,if she did evrething by the law of course they woundnt allowed her to take the kid , so she did what she did,,,

[tbower67]

alexj2- the problem is Sean was kidnapped/abducted/stolen from his father by this woman Bruna. That is illegal. She could have gotten a divorce, and moved back to Brazil by herself. But she chose to KIDNAp Sean and hold him hostage in Brazil- thinking that her families wealth would keep the child with her. Only one problem, she didnt plan on dying. lol

[alexrj2]

@tbower67 shut up you dont know what you are typing. no criminal charges against her or her family. is she had started a divorce in the us she would be obligated to stay in this country forever.

he is earning money from a channel... they paied the jet to him.he didnt give any interview... to others tvs. you can see by it how he acts.

she died but she did what she wanted. she died happy. you can also die or not?

[tbower67]

alexrj2- Exactly, if she had started a divorce in the US. she would have been obligated to stay. Thats what happens when you have a child with someone. There is an obligation to do whats best for the child. She didnt do that- she kidnapped him, and ran to her home country.- Only caring about herself. But she is gone now, and Sean is with his Father. Give it up. Its over with. Stop whining. Merry Christmas. We can all die- only GOD knows when-lol

[alexrj2]

@tbower67 no not exactly at all. and you continue to say your non sense things. she divorced in Brazil. why to stay in US far away from her family is good? i repeat to you again; no kidnaping as she and her family or new husband had no charges against them. i dont have to give up anything... i will continue to expose the lies. now the brazilian family can ask for custody in the usa.

[kipptumor]

I don't know. The kid HAS been living with his Brazillian family most of his life now. There is a lot to be said for where and how you grow up, and it might just be too late for the child's own good at this point to yank him out of what has basically become his familiar environment, and who's to say that he's getting starved and beaten by the Brazilian family? He will have a Hell of a lot better health care down there for one thing, that's for sure.

[racecarbackwards1]

I am not supporting Mr. Goldman because he is American but because it is the right thing. I supported Elian Gonzalez return to Cuba because a parent has the right to be with his son first and foremost before any other relative. Unless there is evidence of abuse or something and that is clearly not the case. The Brazilian judicial system baffles me. How could this have taken so long?

[racecarbackwards1]

? I think I know the answer...Money. Rich influential people have made sure things go in favor of the Brazilian family. It disgusts me. The good news is that I believe this case will be over soon and Mr. Goldman will get his son back today. Again money...the Brazilian government realizes they will be faced with sanctions of some sort if they even go against international law. Especially now that they have to polish their image with the World Cup and the Olympics.

[racecarbackwards1]

As far as Sean's mom....what a nice person....says goodbye...then she wants a divorce giving no rights to the father...then gets married within a year. I dont feel the least sorry for her. For the boy yes. And the Brazilian family wants to make Mr. Goldman the bad guy because he didn't send money and doesn't want to move to Brazil. YOU GOT TO BE KIDDING ME. Please don't let your patriotism for Brazil cloud your common sense on this issue.

[tbower67]

Well said- excellent comment!

[ifilmhackersdotcom]

@tbower67 Given your private comment on my profile (dont have the guts to make it in public?) saying screw international law and institutions, you have no moral authority to say whether something is illegal or not.

Grow up.

[cne08]

The lawyer for Sean's Brazilian family said everyone's suffering especially Sean? Boy I'm glad he said that because I never would have know if he didn't, I pray for Sean & David and hope they're reunited.

[alexrj2]

never he sent money, never he has asked to visitation, never he moved to Brazil it"s strange.

[racecarbackwards1]

Why should he move to Brazil for Godsake? This is his child. Why would he go through all this if he doesn't simply want to be with his child. My son is the same age and I tell you I would be a raging bull if someone did this to me. So now that the Brazilian family has illegaly kept the boy for 4 years it makes it ok? So if I kidnap a child and keep him for 4 years I should get custody because we wouldn't want to take him out of his familiar environment? What kind of thinking is that?

[alexrj2]

to be near the boy. imagine if would had moved from nj to california. it's the same matter. she just decided to separate. be a bull and nothing are the same always there are bulls stronger. diplomacy and conversation can fix the problems. he wasnt kidnapped he travel with his mother. never she was accused criminally in U.S as her family and new husband neither.

Brazil is not only favelas as the US are not only dangerous peripheries.

brazil is not only soccer as US is not only basketball

[Kymra]

Yes, but you are leaving out one very large detail. Bruna did not tell David she was leaving him. What she did was deceitful and illegal. He was not abusive to her ( she admitted this). There is NO excuse for what she did!!!!

[cne08]

@alexrj2. How do you know this? Is this what Sean's Brazilian family said? The family of a woman who kidnapped him? I ask this because in all the news stories I've heard David did everything in his power to get Sean back.

[alexrj2]

@cne08 know what man?

[cne08]

@alexrj2. How do you know David never sent Sean money or asked for visitation? You said that in an earlier post.

[alexrj2]

@cne08 because he has no money. he doenst work and the grandmother gave an interview while visiting the US.

[skiyogagirl]

We support you David in your courageous & grueling fight to reunite with your son! Stay the course & you will succeed. You are strong & loving & your son needs you. We are all praying for a reunion.

[SuperFreakNZ]

Now this stupid lawyer states that everybody is suffering especially the boy.Well, it is because of your own selfish corrupt clients Sean has been suffering for 5 years.BRING SEAN HOME NOW!

[AlmightyBrazil]

No. Everybody is suffering especially the boy because of one GAY COMMUNIST MALE MODEL which wants only the publicity that he failed to have in his model career. I almost cry when I see this acting in the 0:20 of this video This is probably the worst actor of the human history

" I am on my knees begging to my OWN FAME soon to come home, begging for justice begging why is it DICK so hard in MY ASS WHY?"

Is that a robot speaking or what? No, he is not a good actor. HE IS A CHEAP PRETENDER!

[racecarbackwards1]

when you have a son you will understand

[kipptumor]

There is something about David Goldman that I can't quite put my finger on that makes me highly suspicious of him. Like I said before though - even if Jesus Christ himself came to Earth and pointed out to Goldman that his son is better off financially and every other way in Brazil, he would still be fighting to get him back because he has reached the point where his vendetta is the most important thing to him-Not what is best for Sean. Let the kid decide where he wants to live then. Why not?

[SuperFreakNZ]

Are you talking about tio Luca?If the father is a robot, I dont know what the Nona is, because she looks like she has been sucking Satan's d*** forever.God has nothing to do with this since this was a criminal act from the mom.God is related only with righteousness.

Stop being a dick,got the joke?

[AlmightyBrazil]

SuperFreakNZ

Sorry I dont understand your COMMUNIST PERVERT DIRTY SCUM jokes.

The most righteousness thing ever a mother can do is to take her kid out of a unhappy life and to start all over again in a BETTER country. Sorry if she died, now the boy will live again in a horrible COMMUNIST place called USA.

Merry Christmas

[hollowpoint84]

holy crap your crazy,

"The most righteousness thing ever a mother can do is to take her kid out of a unhappy life and to start all over again in a BETTER country"

the father has rights too it's his child, she abducted that kid, also better country LOL, your country is ruled by drug lords. 5000 cops died in ur country last year less then 200 in ours. you and your country are jokes no control and obviously no power.

[AlmightyBrazil]

hollowpoint84

Our cops are fighting with all they have, with heart , your corrupeted cops are earning money to NOT fight against the REAL drug lords that are hidden inside the WHITE HOUSE side by side with Barack Obama and all corrupted politicians of America.

Your power is just delusional.

Soon when Jesus returned only Brazil and Brazilians friends will be saved, sorry if you dont join us.

Merry Christmas.

[fred9821]

Acho piada falares da corrupção policial americana quando a polícia brasileira não é assim tão diferente, sendo muitos os relatos da violência extrema a que chegam quando entram em favelas.

Já não é uma nem duas que ouço notícias de crianças que morrem à conta de polícias.

[ShawnyMartin]

haha brazil is useless. and jesus will not return, dude died like 2000 years ago.

[SuperFreakNZ]

Comunista?Como os US sao comunistas se a estrela vermelha nao faz parte das bandeiras daqui?Se o presidente nao foi um lider sindical,tem doutorado em leis e nao tem amizade com Chavez, Castro e Ahmadinejad?Vc esta falando do Lula, neh?It is indeed a very merry christmas to all americans.Justice prevailed just because of the AMERICANS e not brazilians.SUCK IT NOW!

[fred9821]

It's easy to be biased considering you're brazilian like the mother was and standing at her side. But let's face it: no one but David, Bruna and their son know what reasons actually led her to leave her husband the way she did.

Only two possible reasons though:

1) she was cheating on her husband and acted irresponsably OR

2) David, the father, was an abusive father/husband.

[ShawnyMartin]

3) she was a whore and wanted some brazilian dick.

[pthaeloblue]

Well seeing as how Bruna herself admitted that David was a good husband but that the love wasn't there anymore, ... I'd say she was a lying cheating kidnapping whore. sometimes it is what it is. Congrats to David for finally getting his son back! I feel sorry for the boy, but unfortunately he's suffering because of his mother and her family's past actions.

[fred9821]

Maybe she had good, solid reasons to leave her husband the way she did, the thing is that all she looks is like she just cheated on him and married soon after.