ROBERT OR ED - who is hotter? (BIRTHDAY PRESENT FOR SOUL)

[majitupp]

me encanta tu video es genial robert es lo maximo es tan guapo es perfecto me podrias decir que proramas usas para hacer el video?

[SuperAnbl]

well robert is real but....edward is a vampire!!!! hahahahahha sorry i think maybe i'm loosing my mind!

[majitupp]

what pro0gram you use to make this video??

[majitupp]

i love robert pattinson is too sexy

[ludovicaceleste]

Rob is sooooooo hpy!!!*.*

[MegaLula23]

Espectacular! Is Perfect!

[Rozii25]

But i have more chance with robert and i love him more so......

Robert Wins!!! xD

[TEAMEDWARD4evr15]

They are both equally hott! Rob is real and that british accent is amazing but Edward just has this sex appeal that is irresistable!

[Rozii25]

@TEAMEDWARD4evr15 I'm totally agree with u

[Misspartygirl5]

ROB ROB ROB ROB ROB ALL THE MOTHER FUCKIN WAY I LOVE HIM

[mmaakie]

LOVELOVELOVE THIS VID!!!!!!!

[TwilightHostGirl]

Such a hard decision... ;)

[Bellabachir]

... Humm.. I would say Edward, because he'll be seventeen when I'll be seventeen, he'll just have to wait a little longer ;)

[Shaynaawesomebarclay]

both!!!! duh!!! EDWARD: hot vampire, pale, romantic, is a vampire!!! ROBERT: is humorous, has a english accent, IS AWESOME!!! (u know wuts even better, THEIR THE SME PEOPLE!!!)

[MsRobThomPattzable]

Obviously, Robert- even though pale Rob is awesome.

because:

*He doesn't sparkle

*His accent

*He's real

*He makes us smile

*His wittiness in interviews

*His Laugh

*And his down-to-earth personality

I love Rob and your videos :)

[tanyaxxtwilight]

Your videos are amazing!! I can just replay this over and over.

I would say Robert is hotter; because of his

* sense of humour

* accent

* he is real

* love his style

* love his personality

[lugo2165]

ROB!!! bcuz hes real,hot,and funny but i do love edward too

[Lostimortal2]

R*O*B*E*R*T !!!

[tallytwilight1]

This is really good how did you make it and roberts real not a character and he is english!!! xx

[pkmarita]

ya know for this being up a year its still one i always come back to watch! DAMN HOT bb! kudos!

[XxTheEclipsexX]

both are hot!

[ChachaCullen]

Robert forever and ever! (:

[SistaBandV]

i would have rob in costume as edward!!!! so when i want edward i have him but if one day i want rob i have him!!! so i like best of both worlds!!!

[diamondzyerr]

Robert 

[dwaynegarner92]

edward

[TEPCDM]

Definitivamente ROBERT, el color de sus ojos, su mireda, su sonrida, su ternura, lo gracioso que es, sencillamente perfecto

[Nastasik8]

I from Russia and badly know English, but I will try to write.

Robert certainly sexi)) it is not discussed at all!!!))) but me Edward) is more to taste

[KatiaAndreiaTeixeira]

Robert Pattinson...he is real, Hot, sexy, funny, carismatic, adorable, etc etc...I LOVE ROB...I love Edward but I would pick Robert over Edward any time

[energgetic]

wow

[MrsTwilightSoulmate]

ROB

HIS hair-just look at his hair-its soo sexy

and hes the cutest and hottest man on earth-i dont like formal guys like edward

[othnaleylover]

Edward because he is clean cut his hair looks washed and it isn't all over the place he looks a lot cleaner then Rob and most of all he doesn't smoke gross but that is just my opinion if you want hot look at Zac Efron

[eggi438]

Can't stop watching this video!! Probably the best Rob vid I've seen yet!<3

But please! Who could ever decide who's hotter?! :D

[OBiteMeO]

DAYYUM! i WANT one of those.

[Meelic18]

Aiii nunca me canso de verlo!! amazing!!!, rob is too hot!!!!!! I love him!!!

[BarelyNormall]

I love the vid! Damn he's hot.  ;D

[lifehouse33]

I just love this video:) OMG ... my favorite phrases as spoken by a Sex god :)

Awesome video:)

[agriggs6]

♥Robert. He's Real, and oh so HOT!!! ;)

[shizzilet508]

edward!!!♥♥

[hcullen74]

WOW!!! That a very hard to say but i guess i would have to sa ROB

[picolitajassi]

Roobert!

[gaby91ea]

OME! Your video is amazing! Wow! Rob is amazing! jajaja Well... well done

Saludos desde México!

[belimaki]

wow!! esta buenisiiimoooooooo, Rob porque no vives en Chile!! ..

[saphyn]

robert pattinson is so HOT!!!!!

[anaisabelnogueira]

OH GOD :Q

HOOOT

[LadyParis123]

OH MA GAWD. There is NO way that man could be ugly, he is so DAMn sexy

[xfadingskyx]

Hmm.. This is a tough one but I'm gonna have to say... Rob.. <3 He is just too good to be true <3

[BeautyQueen96S]

edward

[vostarlightov]

WOW great video!!!!!!

[oGeMmAo]

ROBERT! he's just... perfect! <3

[xMileyandDemifan]

Hmm... i love both but i may like edward the most

Beacuse he has beutiful eyes.

I don't like robert's eye color

[Milena1234593]

Robert!

[Tesszaaa]

ROBERT.

he is real

he is sexy

he is hot

he is cute



his sence of humor

i love rob !!!

[Viki92]

well done :)

[VampirMiley]

EDWARD!

[pattinsoncheeseburgs]

Ummm... I'm gonna have to go with ROB!! I like a little sence of humor and Rob is REAL!!

[MelbieToast]

GAAAH This is such an awesome vid!!! Fabulous animation, soundbites... wonderful!

[dinminmamma]

EDWARD but Rob too.. gaah its hard but.. yea im in love with edward <333

[pussycat933]

I Can't Believe My Eyes.. How Did You Do That? That's The Most Beautiful Video I Ever Saw! You're Amazing!

[glortwarren]

EDWARD!! (rob is an ugly crack head)

ps and im talking about the edward that S.M. has written about not rob as edward

[sharkbaby97]

ROB!!!!!!!! ♥

[xenamad]

Rob!, i love this sence of humor

[ztrellabooks]

Both are hot! (the same person) xP but in personality i like more edward... yes! team edward

[dijana97]

I know it sounds strange cause they r the same person but I like edward more than rob :D :D

[TheRobpattzlover]

God I love them both,but Rob is more scruffy so he's more sexy! :):)

[xxloveDisxx]

ohhh DAAAYYYUUUMMM ! ahahha \cant decide both are sooo spicy ! but i am gonna most prob have to like sayyy EDWARD !

[Sari7ta]

edward (inlove)

[yellowoodofrog]

THE BEST VID!! THANK YOU !!

[Angel69379]

this vid makes Robert hot ALL THE WAY!!!!

AMAZING VID!!!!

5*!

[7i7like7toast7]

both

[eatmySOULproductions]

oh hunny, i still love this video <3

and im still smiling over my whole face while watching it :D

LOVE you sweety <3

[mealove06]

rooobbb__XD

[FebruarySoul]

Robert all the way ^^

(even tho I did see a interview where he had lost his accent, but maybe that was acting? Not that it would matter if he had an accent or not, he's still hawt)

[Lucia94Ixchel]

o.0!!

Rob!!! :P

[Emsdabomb100]

ROB!!

[1girlforEdward]

Robert, that English accent is such a turn on

[patdlover4eva]

rob

[ThePipochka]

Robert-10000000000%

[VictoriNoRisuu]

Jacob of course :D But the vid makes me like Ed ... a little ^^

[demilovatofans234]

both

[xostephie]

They are technically the same person, so can't we all just have both ;)

[wildangel20]

dude your videos are fuckin amazing.i love theeeeeeeeem :)

[beanfromex]

brilliant.....

[ILoveYou080198]

rob...they are both fitty's but edward doesn't even exist! x

[FunkyPrettyLady]

I dont know! Rob or Ed!

[MrTroofell]

Edward <3 then Rob ;p

[leopard567]

I'll take both :P

[goofyperson2543]

Rob.Both are awsome but edward doesn't exist soooooooo......rob.

[TwilightAMS]

ill have BOTH...please

[ponygirl9595]

eDWARD HAS MY VOTE!

[teamrobward777]

can't decide i'll take BOTH :D

[DeeJayduCoeur]

Rob.

[TwilightObsessedEC]

HOT!

[schrotberger87]

Edwaaaaard is so much sexier. Rob is just a normal guy.

[natitasha]

O Gosh, choice is so difficult! I guess I'll choose Edward, but I love Robert too. It's one of the hardest choices in my whole life! lol :P

[escarletred82]

los 2 me gustan....

[since1918mar]

rob

[RunnerJam]

Ummm.... DUH!!! it's both sista!!!!!! HOW CAN YOU MAKE US DECIDE ON A THING LIKE THT?!?! lol

[marijo1314sp]

rob & edward <333

[lizz2sue]

EDWARD RULES!!!

Robert SUCKS!!! (O, god I'II get lots of hate commets...)

But very cool video

[MewMewGabby]

rob!

[daniell9990]

RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRob!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

[ciaususu92]

both

[ferrari71189]

Edward*

[aitch3]

Robert is much hotter--his personality and intelligence along with the face and body and mannerisms and accent.

[viperfan7]

neither, twilight is for fags

[MrAsher66]

Than why watch this video???

[viperfan7]

now, how many people here raged at this comment, because you twihards are so easy to troll

[TwilightTeamJalice]

Edward <3

[MDproductionSS]

It's the same person.. you cannot choose between the same person:D

But I love the video.. very very well-made.

what program do you use?

[rob1pattinson]

Rob!!

[whhaaaat]

EDWARD!

but just performed by Rob, just by Rob <3

[xoimlovinlifexo]

i love BOTH! ROBWARD! *swoon*

[paufau22]

you lim guys are so phantastic, luv all your vids! my rating: 6stars+

[niceayaa]

i dont now uuuuum... THEY ARE BOTH SOOOO HOT BUT if i shut say huh i think is hottest i will say EDWARD or ROBErt!!!! i dont now Edward becuse he dont smoke and he is a vampire and and robert becuse he is the hottest actor ever!!! hmmmm i just dont now... both

[summerchick123456]

Edward :) sry i liked the fictional character before i knew it was rob...

[Desire4EdwardCullen]

OMG It's Impossible 2 Decide. BOTH xD

[linni67]

I think..... both of them. Great Video! Thanks

[damnkatchill]

good job!! nice video, i like the rhythm and how it all fits together! :)

[watermeloncloud]

OMG YOU ARE ACTUALLY OBSESSED WTH TWILIGHT, its not fucking real and he is an ass in real life

[hotlips255]

Both of them!

[pkmarita]

wow..just..wow!

[Buddy8wuddy]

i love both they are both so hhhooottt =]

[missidcullen]

Uf!! difficult!! so difficult!! both!!

[Soriii20]

awesome!!! I don't know choose xDD well, yes! the both 8-) :p

[xostephie]

your vids are amazing :) i've subscribed :)

I cant decide! I'll just have them both please ;) haha

[TheMidnightBella]

definitely Edward.......

[eatmySOULproductions]

still love this so much hunny <3

and everytime Rob is wishing me a happy birthday atb the end im melting and feeling like its my b-day again *giggles*

[Pitchr99]

Robert is HHOOTT!!!!!!!! Edward is cute by he has nothing on Robert.

[MrsTwilightLover101]

i love both lmao

[Wiegeilisdasdenn1986]

cant decide whos hotte, but i like the music ^^

[chelseahot3]

rrrooooobbberrrt mmmmm :]

[pattinsoncheeseburgs]

ROBERT!!

[lory94best]

Robert <3

[Quiereme2]

Beautiful ... a question. Since it is called the song? :) plisss.......

jaja me encanto tu video muy chik..!! jaja :)

[lugo2165]

i love edward but i would pick rob over him anyday edward is not real and rob brought him to life rob is so hott and funny i love rob more than i love edward

[CAZJANE]

-DITTO- that's exactly what I was going to say!!!

Great minds, eh!!!

[BisszumHappyEnd]

Rob is ugly and he is not what Edward is.

But the very best-of-all: Jakeward!!!

[Tesszaaa]

Robert is HOTTER

Edward is lovely

[evelynlovesrpattz]

Both!:]

[xonicoleee17]

probably edward, but i love rob with all my heart! and edwards not even real. i have an actuall chance with rob. lol well not really that would be like a dream. and like 301francesca1 said withour rob there would be no edward. so maybee when u think of all that then it would be rob

[301francesca1]

Glad you agree with me. ..Handsome,gorgeous,dreamy Robert gave life to magnificent Edward. Thanks to him ...to his so beautiful face and to his talents. That's why I choose Rob all the way..:))))

[theroaster10]

they are both so handsome

[beachbabeee111]

edward!!!!!!!

but rob is a cutie too :)

[ilvhorseslvlv]

EDWARD!! but i still Love Robert!!!xD

[glamrosie]

EDWARD!

coz out the film rob looks like a tramp coz he dont take care of himself

[TeamJacob4eva9]

edward all the way ob is a drunk!

[sarahjp6]

ITS A TIE!!

[lislmf123]

I'm gonna have to say it's a tie! lol! ;)

[MrsMonaCullen]

oh my gosh ! oO

this is amaaaazing ... how you did it!?

[301francesca1]

Without Rob there will be no Edward...not the Edward we want to look at ...so it is Rob all the way.. Gorgeous Rob who gave life to beautiful Edward

[JoelMaddenLover101]

Rob aaaall the way!!

I love Rob! hes soo cute and funny and talented,etc! there is no words to describe how much i love Rob!

I dont like Edward at all!

not being mean or anything its just hes not real and stuff.. you know.. I just I love Rob and no one will change that!

[SOACEGIRL]

bothhhh!!!!!lol awesome vid how did u make it?!?!?

[love27xoxo]

wow amazing!!!!

[TheStardustlover13]

By the way..

Edward is a part of Rob!So,is your question not really fair;-)

But,you want a answer:

I love Edward`s smile,eyes and lips...and I like Rob,because he is so funny,cute

and a great actor;-)

Greets,

[TheStardustlover13]

OMG!!!This is really HOT!!!Puuhhhh!!!!

I love it!!!!!

[chellesterlnig]

I like Edwards eyes, his red lips and his dark brows but of course those eyes have contacts, he's wearing makeup. I think I would like to have Edward for fantasy but Robert in Reality.

[mulderandscully17]

Once again, FABULOUS work!

Of course, Rob is HOT no matter who is at the moment. I do like Edward's mannerisms, though. I wonder how much like Edward Robert is.

[Rockyourworld00]

Dont get me wrong but EDWARD!!!!!!!!!

come on robs a freakkkkk in r/l i dont like him

BUT I LOVE EDWARD CULLEN HES HOTTER THAN ROBB<3

[pattinsoncheeseburgs]

Rob as more personalitie and He's cuter with all that white makeup out and his eyes are gourgeous!! Dont get me wrong I love Edward<3  But I just ADORE ROB!!

[firstluckygirl]

Rob because I prefere the reality! xD

[rachelx1129]

rob. edward is gorgeous, don't get me wrong, but his eyes are just too creepy and rob still has awesome eyes. haha. but i <3 both.

[rrrracheywachey]

rob defoo! i think edward looks a little gay but he is still hot lol

[1901TeamEdward]

EDWARD!!!!

[ashleygg19]

oaah that`s not fair ;(

they both are so hot but because robert

plays edward I have to say Robert.

I mean without him edward wouldn`t be that hot. ^^

he`s just gorgeous

[magicalmalu]

Edward, Sorry Rob :-)

[MnK100pro]

im INLOVE with your video!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lugo2165]

man if i watched this on monday cuz monday was my birthday darn but edward or rob who's hotter? ROB

[AmericanTeenagerGirl]

rob's hotter, but i like edward a lot more!

[rocha244]

BOTH! :)

[lhkelly1986]

Rob is way hotter!!

[lostandfound17]

mhh... rob is hotter! :] but i also love edward <3

[muninazitatwilight]

EDWAAAARD is HOTTER.

[PiccolaKettyGoal]

Questo video è bellissimo!

[MiissDVAlle]

Eward or Rob ..

ROBBB !!! :)

[musicalwayshere4]

this vidoe sickens me

[PrInCeSsChEer4LiFe]

omg LOVE HIM TO DEATH. he looks amazing in all of the pictures! :)

[linzeyluv]

he looks cute ion 0:04 0:26 0:35 0:40

0:42 0:47

[robpattinsonuk]

This video is awesome - Robert FTW ... He's too funny .. but obviously Edward is gorgeous too

[scottrobb1982]

WOW he is The Same Alien as an Ilegal Edward