I like the piece a lot, but in my opinion he didn't put enough of Brahms in there... You know? That fat, old man with the white beard? When I think of him, I always have a picture of a mad, evil genius playing the organ like crazy in mind. With a lot of power and thunder and... you know what I mean :D
He did a very good job, but I like it better if you can hear Brahms going mad on his piano :)
I read all the comments about being human and all... but it's not just one mistake, or two or three... and notice it's the same mistake on both repeats... he should really clean up the piece before recording it...
I'm just learning this and the intro is like O.O to me lol. The only thing I thought was a little forced and too fast was the 5 b6 1 riff, to me it wasn't enigmatic enough. But I haven't really looked too deep in the piece yet so I'm not grounded in my opinion. Anyways, great performance and pleasure to listen to.
Excellent interpretation. I like your control of the dynamics and your grasp of the rhythmic drive of the piece. You have a fine sense of balance in this performance.
Excellent Job... I know that you will have made great improvement since you uploaded the soundtrack. Stay on top of the verses that you know in your heart, you could be more fluent. This is your language, this is your song... you do so well.. This is one of my absolute favorite piano pieces to play, so my compliments. You've done more than I can immagine, claim to do at this time.
It is well played, but some breaks are too surprising I think. You don' take enough time to prepare in some places so that it has an effect. I play the piece next week at a concert too. Technically, I will not make it that good :)
my favorite interpretation of this piece so far it's slower than many i've heard, but still astounding...i actually think this slower tempo was what made it so fabulous. i will definitely remember your interpretation while i am playing this piece.
I've listened to many versions here on youtube, and this i have to say, is my favorite. this is supposed to be a dark piece, but all the others i've heard play too heavily
ja er hat auch ne menge talent, aber er kommt etz in die 10, um das mal richtig zu stellen... aber wie gesagt, diese version is ja fast wies original ;) un er spielt das ja lang nich so flüssig und fehlerfrei
molto cantabile!
ONDAPRODUCTION 3 weeks ago
toll. das beste.
TheLizJo 1 month ago
Superb young talent !
schumannlover1 2 months ago
Oui, c'est superb.
KiyaRoraito 2 months ago
I like the piece a lot, but in my opinion he didn't put enough of Brahms in there... You know? That fat, old man with the white beard? When I think of him, I always have a picture of a mad, evil genius playing the organ like crazy in mind. With a lot of power and thunder and... you know what I mean :D
He did a very good job, but I like it better if you can hear Brahms going mad on his piano :)
ViraaniTheEvil 7 months ago 2
@ViraaniTheEvil I kinda like this rendition more than the other few I've heard on YouTube. Have you found one that you prefer? I'd love to hear it!
zrisezlle 5 months ago
@zrisezlle
There is one performed by Martha Argerich -- that one is still my favourite. if you're still interested, you can find it here:
watch?v=Sr2q8-Sr__A
keetner 3 months ago
@ViraaniTheEvil I agree with you actually, maybe just a little bit too clean cut for a Brahms piece I think.
goofygolfer100 4 months ago
very beautifull peice...
tomato9816 7 months ago
5:40 Camera sound. XD
gwpotgieter 8 months ago
wie kann mann so etwas komponieren???
mascho1998 8 months ago
I read all the comments about being human and all... but it's not just one mistake, or two or three... and notice it's the same mistake on both repeats... he should really clean up the piece before recording it...
fernandofariajunior 8 months ago
He kinda looks like Frodo with a haircut...
fernandofariajunior 8 months ago 2
bello
pianomagghy 11 months ago
I'm just learning this and the intro is like O.O to me lol. The only thing I thought was a little forced and too fast was the 5 b6 1 riff, to me it wasn't enigmatic enough. But I haven't really looked too deep in the piece yet so I'm not grounded in my opinion. Anyways, great performance and pleasure to listen to.
CatchTh3Wind 1 year ago
Mistakes are normal. You are not used to it because of all the cuts in Cds. I never listened to a live pianist who never did mistakes. We are human.
luelue221 1 year ago 5
@luelue221 Then you should listen to Dang Thai Son ;)
StefanInvAsian 1 year ago
AAHHH!!!! What is it that mistake at 1:18 ???
munkustrap79 1 year ago
@munkustrap79 The proof that we're all humans... with our mistakes ;)
000marioshi000 9 months ago
o_0 !!!
vraiment magnifique!...
proutietruc 1 year ago 3
I think, a combination of what was said describes this perfectly:
technically very well played, I would not consider the very few mistakes as grave.
some of the breaks are a bit surprising, but all in all beautiful. you could only make it a bit more lyric by playing it a bit more piano.
nice job!
zerop97 1 year ago
I heard four or five mistakes, just wrong notes hit, but overall beautiful work.
xxWayoftheSunxx 1 year ago
wowwwwwwwwwwwww
contiale 1 year ago 13
Excellent interpretation. I like your control of the dynamics and your grasp of the rhythmic drive of the piece. You have a fine sense of balance in this performance.
horatiodreamt 1 year ago
Excellent Job... I know that you will have made great improvement since you uploaded the soundtrack. Stay on top of the verses that you know in your heart, you could be more fluent. This is your language, this is your song... you do so well.. This is one of my absolute favorite piano pieces to play, so my compliments. You've done more than I can immagine, claim to do at this time.
primexchange 1 year ago 2
Wow... excellent, excellent work.
FoolishLittleGirl 2 years ago
Comment removed
rickyboy632 2 years ago
The sound quality of your videos is very good.
It is well played, but some breaks are too surprising I think. You don' take enough time to prepare in some places so that it has an effect. I play the piece next week at a concert too. Technically, I will not make it that good :)
Hannilein100 2 years ago
my favorite interpretation of this piece so far it's slower than many i've heard, but still astounding...i actually think this slower tempo was what made it so fabulous. i will definitely remember your interpretation while i am playing this piece.
gabrieloquent 2 years ago
superb....
christambb01 2 years ago 8
I've listened to many versions here on youtube, and this i have to say, is my favorite. this is supposed to be a dark piece, but all the others i've heard play too heavily
liamariasophia 2 years ago
superbe interprétation !
TwoWoods13 2 years ago
mein kumpel spielt das stück auch grad... allerdings geht der erst in die 9 klasse
aber so perfekt kriegt ers auch nich ganz hin schätz ich, diese version is klasse
AngusKrueger 2 years ago
das in der neunten klasse zu spielen ist aber schon sehr gut....er scheint auf jeden fall begabt zu sein.
aperistu93 2 years ago
ja er hat auch ne menge talent, aber er kommt etz in die 10, um das mal richtig zu stellen... aber wie gesagt, diese version is ja fast wies original ;) un er spielt das ja lang nich so flüssig und fehlerfrei
AngusKrueger 2 years ago
Ja ich komme jetzt in die 11. klasse und hab es grad angefangen...es hat auch so seine tücken, ist aber nicht unmenschlich schwer.
egvztpwa 2 years ago
ich bin in der 10. klasse und spiels auch grad^^
FalkenLoridan 2 years ago
@FalkenLoridan aber halt nicht so ;))
kla16975 1 year ago
@kla16975 schon klar^^ bin ja auch kein konzertpianist
FalkenLoridan 1 year ago
@FalkenLoridan ja logo! ;) ich spiels auch grad, aber der typ ist schon hart^^
kla16975 1 year ago
amAzing
yalinneofarril 2 years ago
I've listened to half a dozen other youtube performances of this piece, this is by far and away the best. Well done.
yorkshiremusician 2 years ago
Comment removed
Chopin1986 2 years ago
1:18 schade
sonst exzellent!!!
tulpenschwanz 2 years ago
I like this interpretation! :)
aguyfromtexas 2 years ago
Grandios!
viow69 3 years ago
agreed.. awesome
aaronnada 3 years ago
i agree with you... awesome!
MLproject 3 years ago
awesome!
DerD85 3 years ago