There's a GREAT bit with McKellen talking about this and acting Shakespeare and making the speech sound natural like you don't already know the words. With Google video shutting down, someone should upload it here! I would if I knew how.
I find it puzzling that a play about the supernatural contains such an atheistic monologue. It's not an outright contradiction, but it isn't expected. Changing the topic a bit, I'm afraid I don't like McKellen's delivery too much. It seems unnatural to me, like he's trying too hard to make it sound thought through.
@Bolenderable I've read much commentary on Shakespeare, and much of it proves Hazlitt's dictum that if we wish to see the force of human genius, read Shakespeare; but if we wish to see the futility of human learning, read his commentators. The brightest, most sublime, most glorious exception to this rule is Harold Goddard. Read about Macbeth in vol. 2 of his The Meaning of Shakespeare. He mines the depths of this play to the fullest.
@Bolenderable Also, the best performance of Macbeth I've yet seen is part of vol. 2 of the BBC/Time Life DVD set of Shaky's tragedies. Nicol Williamson delivers a devastating performance as Macbeth, making what we see here seem merely perfunctory.
@Bolenderable That's the naturalism you're describing, and it's one of the things Shakespearean actors have to watch that they don't get too much into. You can watch "Playing Shakespeare" with John Barton and the RSC for more info.
I must ask again: Is there a good reason you post only fragments of certain performances? I certainly don't mean to sound ungrateful but it's most frustrating.
McDiarmid's was the only decent performance in Episode III. I can't help but think this was because Lucas respected him enough to give him free reign with his lines. He just sat back and let him work.
McGregor, Portman, Jackson etc are all excellent actors, yet were painfully bland and wooden. *cough* MISDIRECTION *cough*
I'm sorry to break the spell, but I don't like it. I mean, the overall conception of the character. He is too refined, too mannered, too self-conscious -besides being too young, but that was not his fault. This approach would be great to Hamlet, because the prince is in fact all that and much more, but here it simply doesn't work. Macbeth's crimes are the crimes of a primitive man from the dark ages, and here Sir Ian depicts him as Calligula's best friend.
I saw him do Hamlet on the stage when he was even younger (1972). It was brilliant - a Wednesday matinee of schoolgirls - I was one- and they would not stop clapping. He and the rest of the company, took at least 8 encores. Sadly it was never recorded on camera.
I think this version is as good as it gets. Usually you have either the loud and powerful (or pissed) Macbeth, the whispery and sympathetic Macbeth that's trying not to break down and cry, or the twitchy and paranoid Macbeth. I like how he combines them. It makes for one hell of an eerie villain.
"All our yesterdays" and "The way to dusty death", one a Star Trek spisode, the other a mediocre novel/movie by Alistar Maclean, I see now where they "borrowed" their titles from :)
I think that's the point. A prevailing theme in most of Shakespeare's tragedies is that of unnatural occurrences. Thus, breaking the fourth wall makes sense to make this utterly apparent.
That is the tragedy and the heart of the Tomorrow monologue. Hell is repetition, and this is what Macbeth faces in this moment - the horrific desperation of an continuation with no change and no end. In this moment of clarity he sees the path forward in the light of his life and, subconsciously if not directly, chooses to end that life, preferring death over the hell of existence.
This is the most painful, chilling,frightening,horrifying, sickening Macbeth-performance, I ever saw, and it might be a while before I watch it again (Just bought the DVD). My deepest respect for Ian McKellen and Judy Dench.
dear baldrick7, youre as disgusting as fucking somebody in his excrements which equals the said dung beetles - as for your open mind, there is no ethical component in fucking somebody up the ass, so there is none in defending it ; its rather more disgusting to think that youre a better person by defending people who turn brown excrements into the stinky path of love - aye, methinks there is the noble love, Romeo and Julia paid for with their starcrossed lifes!!!
There are other things, they don't necessarily have anal sex, they do the things other couples do like hold hands, kiss, cuddle. it's not as if they all like jamming their dick in an arse. Besides, even if they did, what difference does it make to a performance. The whole point of acting is taking on a character, even if you find homosexuality offensive, they can act as a straight man, like a straight man can act as a gay man.
Ian Mckellen is sooooooo different from Sean Connery and John Finch... Most of the development of the play happens in his mind... You can see that in his face... He's an amazing actor! Absolutely brilliant!
The Citizens Theatre came to do Macbeth at my school in the 1960s. Lady Macbeth stole the show with her hip length (real) jet black hair and 60s model figure. It was a boys school and we all reached puberty at once. It was as good as this brilliant performance. Really.
I FUCKING LOVE IAN MCKELLEN. HE CAN DO NO WRONG. NO. WRONG.
DearestCaitsie 1 week ago
I THINK HE SOUNDED THE SAME AT THE TIME OF HIS BIRTH MAN what an epic voice
megashani1991 2 weeks ago
He sounds the same as he does now.
Pahjx 3 weeks ago
I got a perfect score on a recited test because of this. Bravo Ian McKellen!
pjcasabuena 4 weeks ago
Gandalf is.. is.. is that you?!
Mursilia 1 month ago
00:12
notedown1010 1 month ago
Comment removed
notedown1010 1 month ago
I can't understand half the word's he's saying... I mean, I just can't HEAR them.
jjm121 2 months ago
Ian McKellen is a one in a trillion ... I just love him.
dakessi1 2 months ago
amazing performance
Geezyk 2 months ago
out, out brief candle
he is so awesome
1993DaVinci 2 months ago
Performing this for the National Shakespeare Competition...
shenvalley25 2 months ago
Let's face it - Shakespear is pretty awesome when done correctly
ThePaulHackett 2 months ago
omg my english teaacher made the whole class say the tomorrow and tommorrow part i noe it by heart now !!!
cooliocarla1 3 months ago
@cooliocarla1 haha me too
13MarioA 3 months ago
so his voice has ALWAYS BEEN THAT AWESOME?! :O
DemoraX 3 months ago 2
Billy Madison
Omatusano 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
marjan-siklic-1.blogspot.com/
marjansilkic2 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
makes so much sense!! beautiful :)
oliviami5 4 months ago
Bob Peck should have been a HUGE star. Thank god we at least have Edge of Darkness.
Rumpio 5 months ago
if I were in that audience, my jaw could never be repaired for having it hanging down for such a long time
cholpankapov 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf is this? LORD OF THE RINGS BETTAR! U SHALL NOT PASS SO EPIC!
TomValedro 6 months ago
at 2:34 I couldn't help but think of him yelling "YOU SHALL NOT PASS!"
theINCONVENIENCER 7 months ago
How old was McKellen here? Sheesh, how powerful. Absolutely jaw-dropping. Thanks for making this available.
MsTruNorth 8 months ago
Very nicely done. It's amazing to think that Edward de Vere could portray this depth at such a young age. facebook/TrueShakespeare
BenMAugust 9 months ago
There's a GREAT bit with McKellen talking about this and acting Shakespeare and making the speech sound natural like you don't already know the words. With Google video shutting down, someone should upload it here! I would if I knew how.
hanshotfirst1138 9 months ago
bellissimo
butterfly1995ful 9 months ago
EVERYONE LISTEN TO GANDALF
imgonnagetbanned 10 months ago 3
As far as I'm concerned, this is the greatest portrayal of Macbeth in history.
TheUnbreakableOtaku 11 months ago 2
Polanski's version has some visual flair but the acting is strictly bog-standard: Lady Macbeth is a teenage nonentity.
steerpike66 11 months ago
one of my favorite british actors
NewMediaRep 1 year ago
@03:31 is that Ian McDiarmid? :X
seamus136 1 year ago
@seamus136 Sure is. Great porter scene. Funny, then very scary.
steerpike66 11 months ago
@seamus136 Yes it is, Emperor Palpatine himself. I wonder if this was before the Star Wars Trilogy?
nyboy76 10 months ago
Excellent
ghomonica 1 year ago
Best performance of Macbeth's monologue!
DarkSloopy 1 year ago
nigel killa aka red wuz here--aproved 100%
2red2z 1 year ago
That guy can act.
libville 1 year ago
stupid fucking actor...go watch finch's version
khawajaarslanahmed 1 year ago
He acts as if it is the first time he's said those words. He is Macbeth.
VirtuosoGuy 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
ISt0leTheCookies 1 year ago
Goosebumps
borimirtheboring 1 year ago
Comment removed
khawajaarslanahmed 1 year ago
Ian seems so good looking!
sadguyfoundout1 1 year ago
his face looks like it was delicately chiseled out of the marble foyer from space mountain
adolfolicious 1 year ago 15
he played the title role in the critical hit Richard III, which transported the setting 400 years into the future in 1930s fascist England
peppercornbtbij 1 year ago
I find it puzzling that a play about the supernatural contains such an atheistic monologue. It's not an outright contradiction, but it isn't expected. Changing the topic a bit, I'm afraid I don't like McKellen's delivery too much. It seems unnatural to me, like he's trying too hard to make it sound thought through.
Bolenderable 1 year ago
@Bolenderable I've read much commentary on Shakespeare, and much of it proves Hazlitt's dictum that if we wish to see the force of human genius, read Shakespeare; but if we wish to see the futility of human learning, read his commentators. The brightest, most sublime, most glorious exception to this rule is Harold Goddard. Read about Macbeth in vol. 2 of his The Meaning of Shakespeare. He mines the depths of this play to the fullest.
Jitpring 1 year ago
@Bolenderable Also, the best performance of Macbeth I've yet seen is part of vol. 2 of the BBC/Time Life DVD set of Shaky's tragedies. Nicol Williamson delivers a devastating performance as Macbeth, making what we see here seem merely perfunctory.
Jitpring 1 year ago
@Jitpring
go watch roman polanski's version
khawajaarslanahmed 1 year ago
@Bolenderable That's the naturalism you're describing, and it's one of the things Shakespearean actors have to watch that they don't get too much into. You can watch "Playing Shakespeare" with John Barton and the RSC for more info.
docterphreak 1 year ago
I must ask again: Is there a good reason you post only fragments of certain performances? I certainly don't mean to sound ungrateful but it's most frustrating.
Is it a copyright issue?
polymath7 1 year ago
Emperor Palpatine @ 9:45 !!!
Love the theatrical work of both Ians.
McDiarmid's was the only decent performance in Episode III. I can't help but think this was because Lucas respected him enough to give him free reign with his lines. He just sat back and let him work.
McGregor, Portman, Jackson etc are all excellent actors, yet were painfully bland and wooden. *cough* MISDIRECTION *cough*
Candystripedshredder 1 year ago
How come Malcolm is wearing a woolen polo-neck sweater and what appears to be an army surplus greatcoat
incongra 1 year ago
OMG he already sounded like Gandalf
sondano 1 year ago
The brightness and contrast in this is tingling my photoshoppy senses.
NakedCreep 1 year ago
This line is amazing and the tomorrows are made to be monotanous
BiqqMacc1111 1 year ago
I'm sorry to break the spell, but I don't like it. I mean, the overall conception of the character. He is too refined, too mannered, too self-conscious -besides being too young, but that was not his fault. This approach would be great to Hamlet, because the prince is in fact all that and much more, but here it simply doesn't work. Macbeth's crimes are the crimes of a primitive man from the dark ages, and here Sir Ian depicts him as Calligula's best friend.
kiasmus 1 year ago
@kiasmus Just because you're sophisticated doesn't mean you're not capable of primitive barbarism, fear, insecurity, doubt, and obsession.
Raius1 1 year ago
great actor he is
leonheeroyue 1 year ago
Guh! So fucking good. McKellen is just so fucking good. And such a gentleman. Ah I could gush all day about him! xxx
ssarahalisonn 1 year ago
Fair is foul and foul is fair
blueanimal 1 year ago
McKellen bears a striking resemblance to my grandfather :-D
vanderbilt887 1 year ago
emo
badgerlord87 1 year ago
very very very good, there is a man feeling word by word feeling
israelmonrroy 1 year ago
Wow, if I didn't love Ian McKellen before, I certainly do after seeing this.
He could read from the phone book and it would sound poetic and awesome.
threestoogesfan2 1 year ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
"I just got done with Macbeth in school. We had to make a video and if you want to see it, it's on my channel."
R3KAB3J 1 year ago
hey i just saw this in 9th grade english
0bjectivist 1 year ago
I member seeing this in 9th grade english
ruizj2006 1 year ago
Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth! Macbeth!
morganfolz 1 year ago
its only a curse if your in a play and it has to be spoken aloud!
workingclassbum 1 year ago
I saw him do Hamlet on the stage when he was even younger (1972). It was brilliant - a Wednesday matinee of schoolgirls - I was one- and they would not stop clapping. He and the rest of the company, took at least 8 encores. Sadly it was never recorded on camera.
heliotropezzz333 1 year ago 2
He looks like a vampire lol
SagatProductions 1 year ago 2
I think this version is as good as it gets. Usually you have either the loud and powerful (or pissed) Macbeth, the whispery and sympathetic Macbeth that's trying not to break down and cry, or the twitchy and paranoid Macbeth. I like how he combines them. It makes for one hell of an eerie villain.
DulBeat 2 years ago 3
"All our yesterdays" and "The way to dusty death", one a Star Trek spisode, the other a mediocre novel/movie by Alistar Maclean, I see now where they "borrowed" their titles from :)
Gardena380 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Being but a mere butler, you will not know the great theatre tradition, that one does never speak the name, of the Scottish play.
kealyc 2 years ago
Damn! Ian McKellan was so handsome then!
UnclaimedTreasure 2 years ago 2
and he's not now :0
alanbalfe 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
check out my macbeth video
eric8rays 2 years ago
Holy Crap he IS Macbeth. Amazing preformance
DesmondMyersvids 2 years ago 13
its supposed to be. because its dramatic irony. if this was in real life, he would have been talking to the audience.
mastshke 2 years ago
ahh.....why is he looking straight at me? the camera?? its kinda awkward and creepy.
today20080523 2 years ago
I think that's the point. A prevailing theme in most of Shakespeare's tragedies is that of unnatural occurrences. Thus, breaking the fourth wall makes sense to make this utterly apparent.
ged424 2 years ago
because hes speeking his thoughts to the audiance directly and not twords another character
MikadoOkami 2 years ago
me too kalie77katy
myhamsterable 2 years ago
Comment removed
eric8rays 2 years ago
holy shit, Ian McKellen looked bloody handsome back then. I'd totally hit it.
kuzeryukotsu 2 years ago 4
He looks freakishly like Jason Isaak here.
Dragon1813 2 years ago
At last it makes sense. Wonderful actor.
missgreeneyes56 2 years ago 3
we just had to recite this for englishh
Kalie77Katy 2 years ago 2
same here lol
sixfouimpala 2 years ago
haha
Kalie77Katy 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He's not even Scottish. :(
stilliremainhere 2 years ago
OMG I love it I love it I love it! I am in love with (this) Ian McKellan lol if only he were that young again heehee
manderzluvsyou91 2 years ago
I hate to break your heart, but Ian McKellen is gayer than a bagful of rainbows. Seriously.
mikech78 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
wow, really? I now hate his acting and hold no respect for him.
My heart = broken :(
samautumnwood 2 years ago
You say all this under the assumption manderzluvsyou91 is a girl. He could be a gay guy, in that way, it makes perfect sense.
blancgab 2 years ago 2
lol
charrogent 2 years ago
I love this. It's the only bit of Shakespeare I know word for word! :)
sirtinycreep 2 years ago
I love his voice, its deep and strong.
Sir Ian Mckellen is AWESOME!
josianneRHCPinlove 2 years ago 14
Absolutely fantastic!
LIVVOFAUSBF 2 years ago
This is one of the reasons Ian Mckellen became Sir Ian Mckellen, and I'm glad he did
happynesiscatching 2 years ago
This performance of macbeth is legendary - get a grip guys..
laideebyrd 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
..this performance of Macbeth is an embarrassment!
ROWANV1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is that really Gandolf!!!???
Xs3v3n3l3v3nX 2 years ago
No, it's not Gandolf.... It's Gandalf! :)
IIDragonflyII 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh gosh, that's not a good version. utterly dead with no underlying feeling.
canvasbags1 2 years ago
I believe that's the point.
Kittkat88 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm auditioning for MacBeth Thursday using the "Tomorrow" speech. This is exactly the way I won't do it.
MattRichards711 3 years ago
@MattRichards711 ......so, how'd that work for you, Matt?
bealof 1 year ago
Comment removed
bulldog01209 3 years ago
That is the tragedy and the heart of the Tomorrow monologue. Hell is repetition, and this is what Macbeth faces in this moment - the horrific desperation of an continuation with no change and no end. In this moment of clarity he sees the path forward in the light of his life and, subconsciously if not directly, chooses to end that life, preferring death over the hell of existence.
manatorn 3 years ago 37
Comment removed
JiaPRiX 1 year ago
wait a minute is the emperor palpatine at 8:13
MasterLizzong 3 years ago
yea it is palpatine.
ghunderstank 2 years ago
gandolffff
s0d00 3 years ago
holy shit that is Gandolf!!!!
SayntAce 3 years ago
This is the most painful, chilling,frightening,horrifying, sickening Macbeth-performance, I ever saw, and it might be a while before I watch it again (Just bought the DVD). My deepest respect for Ian McKellen and Judy Dench.
metteholm75 3 years ago 20
Brilliant!!!! Facial expressions and the genius of his voice! Every word!
Dinarrra84 3 years ago 2
all you see is one of the greatest shakespearean stage performers of all time. BUT, gandalf is wonderful in his own right
CymbalRush 3 years ago
all i see is Gandalf
elessar2k49 3 years ago
Such talent, and what a voice!
NatashaNabokov 3 years ago 2
Ian McKellen may be the most talented actor alive. How can you beat that voice, that inflection?
jazzy1260 3 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
i'm feeling naughty at the moment
any guys have a cam? i have mine in my profile jq
cbrowngi 3 years ago
Pure brilliance, well not Shakespeare but McKellen!
terroristen 3 years ago 2
"Pure brilliance, well not Shakespeare but McKellen!"
No, the opposite of that.
NonSvankmajer 3 years ago 5
This is just spellbinding! I love Ian McKellen as Macbeth! I don't think I've ever seen anyone say this speech as well as he did here...
shandylass87 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He´s gay- gay actors cant be tragic - dungbeetles ...
(mind you, before i knew, i liked the scene)
yamejanakaratoprak 3 years ago
He's gay. SO? First of all he's a great actor and a very handsome man.
Iride 3 years ago 3
you are a disgusting person,
he happens to be one of the best actors of our time and his sexuality should have no affect on that
i would hate it if people hated my work just because they knew i was gay,
you really need to get a life and open your mind
baldrick7 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
dear baldrick7, youre as disgusting as fucking somebody in his excrements which equals the said dung beetles - as for your open mind, there is no ethical component in fucking somebody up the ass, so there is none in defending it ; its rather more disgusting to think that youre a better person by defending people who turn brown excrements into the stinky path of love - aye, methinks there is the noble love, Romeo and Julia paid for with their starcrossed lifes!!!
yamejanakaratoprak 3 years ago
You know not all gay people, like anal sex?
There are other things, they don't necessarily have anal sex, they do the things other couples do like hold hands, kiss, cuddle. it's not as if they all like jamming their dick in an arse. Besides, even if they did, what difference does it make to a performance. The whole point of acting is taking on a character, even if you find homosexuality offensive, they can act as a straight man, like a straight man can act as a gay man.
Gruffturnip 3 years ago
Comment removed
samautumnwood 2 years ago
Best MacBeth I've ever seen!
baneofnewbs 3 years ago 5
Wow... just wow. I can't say much more than that. Simply spellbinding.
scoot3663 3 years ago 4
this was a good one
melikabozorgi3 3 years ago 3
Ian Mckellen is sooooooo different from Sean Connery and John Finch... Most of the development of the play happens in his mind... You can see that in his face... He's an amazing actor! Absolutely brilliant!
Diamantenglanz 3 years ago 6
The beginning of this is completely hyonotic. I can't imagine anyone else reciting those lines with so much conviction.
MugsMcClain 4 years ago 8
Macbeth: ...I bear a charmed life, which must not yield
To one of woman born. Macduff: ... Macduff was from his mother's womb
Untimely ripp'd.
Oops!!! The jig is up, I'd say.
This is truly a grand and compelling performance. Thank you ever so much for providing it here!!!
~Megan
meganmurphy1212 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Meh. I wasn't sold on this.
NoSubstitute 4 years ago
The genius of Sir Ian is that he deconstructs the poetry, in order to foreground the thought of the speech.
drsigh 4 years ago 3
Love it! Bob Peck and Sir Ian McKellen my two fave stars on stage! Hail king!
AT0061 4 years ago
The Citizens Theatre came to do Macbeth at my school in the 1960s. Lady Macbeth stole the show with her hip length (real) jet black hair and 60s model figure. It was a boys school and we all reached puberty at once. It was as good as this brilliant performance. Really.
mikemckv 4 years ago 2
hahaha thats a great story
DesmondMyersvids 2 years ago
Awesome!!!!! Beautiful acting!
lenegan 4 years ago