Clay AI2 Rewind - 70s - Top 9

[katherineoa]

..thank you!!

[halfprincess97]

I thought Simon meant clay coz he said it was terrible but coz Paula agreed I think it was Ricky coz if you look at his reaction after Simon says it you see him lean forward

[scootieboots]

thank you for sharing. am loving the blast to the past.  clay's got "chops man!"

[Lissical]

Clay's voice is perfection. I love everything he sings and he nailed this song!

[omitchell04]

They always say he doesn't look like this and that but he's adoreable!!!

[crazyc0ffin]

"Everlasting Love" and disco may not be Clay Aiken's forte but he still was amazing. Clay could sing the PHONEBOOK and it would be AWESOME.

[omitchell04]

I so agree. Claymate 4 life here! LOL

[SimplyShelbey]

whose the superstar now?!?!

[SimplyShelbey]

flawlessly amazing...

[Freddybubbles]

Kimberely Locke and Trenyce were great, Simon obviously just doesn't like Trenyce and neither of them should have been in the bottom 3. It should have been Kimberly Caldwell Joshua Gracin, and Carmen Rasmusen

[yanmei1234321]

who was simon talking about,,,,when he said one person on that couch should be in the bottom 3??

[jbdramey]

I don't know. He didn't like any of the guys that night but Reuben. I kinda think he was talking about Ricky.

[yanmei1234321]

Thanks..at first, I thought he was talking about Clay, and that kind of made me mad..lol

[KHY72]

Def. shouldn't be about Clay, Simon referred to him as an unstoppable train at this time in the competition so yea, def. a Simon favorite at that point.

[gabyvalla]

@jbdramey NNNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. He was talking about Josh!!!!!!!!!!!