Added: 4 years ago
From: Phyoe123
Views: 159,789
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (148)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • good movie...

  • tabu such an talented actress...

  • THERE IS NO SUCH THING IS TRUE JUSTICE IN INDIA. THERE'S ONLY JUSTICE FOR PEOPLE WHO CAN PAY THERE WAY OUT.

  • SO Sad. They should make more films like this in India so the Elite Middle Class & Upper Class should understand that - Poor people have feelings to.

  • The Ugly Truth Of Life,,,,, What A Story!!!

  • i was a skeptic till i really watched tabu in chandni bar and astitva, till date i havn't seen better female actor performances in bollywood, her acting was pitch perfect and outstandingly natural, if she can perform these roles with utter ease what can she do in character based movies. deserves her 2 national awards and should have won more. sorry but tabu is too good for indian movies as most indian films are commercial crap and the rest are class movies like chandni bar which dnt get recgnsd

  • omgg.. tabu is gorgeous.. and she is an amazing actress :D.. she really deserved some type of credit for this movie.. her acting is outstanding .. bless her :,)

  • im crying my eyes out

    wat a story..

  • it was really excellent story. the mother was trying to grow up her children like others so that they can spend their lives like civilized citizen but the society which is a pool of good and bad people does not allow her to spend a good life. the roots of the parents impact children's future life and the society create circumstances against their nature and they follow the bad ways due to the svere and harsh words of people.

  • really heart touching story....even at the end i cried with the last dialougues of Tabu

  • The most depressing movie ever. Shows harsh realities of life. Brilliant acting.

  • wat a movie!! Hats off to bandarkar , tabu !! fantastic depiction of bar girls life.. this film exposes wat riots can do.. people pls live peacefully... life is precious.. dont waste it !!

  • Hats off to Tabu. Why does the industry recognize shitless actresses such Kat, Ash etc when you have such veterans around?

  • It is good to see that he killed those tow gays whom fucked him ... Lol

  • thanks for uploading. one of the great movie in the bollywood. tabu did great job.

  • really moving film!

    Really picked this by chance was well worth it.

    thanks

  • that mumtaz might want her kids have a much better life, but at the same time she needs to be realistic. she lives in a world where women like her are suppressed and spit on. her kids will only try to get by each day like she had.

  • Hats off to Madhur Bhandarkar atleast for this thumbs up guys up

  • life and whores are cheap in india, 900 million to choose from

  • Its Tabu's film,Such a finest actress.She deserves thousands national awards for this film.What a performance.She is the current queen of Indian cinema not shit like Aishwarya etc..

  • great movie...i think everyone should watch it...and all of us that are so away from this side of the world can learn more..and mayb once day through awareness...something can be done to reduce this

  • Madhur Bhandarkar Rocks !...This is one of the best movies...Very Truthful and realistic ! That's why it received so many awards.....4 national awards and others

    2002 National Film Awards (India)

    Best Actress - Tabu

    Best Supporting Actor - Atul Kulkarni

    Best Supporting Actress - Ananya Khare

    National Film Award for Best Film on Other Social Issues

  • Madhur Bhandarkar is an awful director - his movies may become somewhat popular with indian audiences but internationally they would be considered nothing more than pure and utter "garbage". What he depicts in his movies are EXTREMES - not the norm even within the worst of Indian society. His movies either focus on poor people or nouveau riche in India - and in both cases he shows unrealistic, extreme views. Most poor in India are not prostitutes and gangsters -but they earn an honest living too

  • @mike25nyc Have you ever been to India? Have you lived in a city like Mumbai to know what poor people have to do to earn enough to survive? The movie isn't that "unrealistic" and at the same time it doesn't really implicate that this is the life of everyone in the city, but it is based on a bar dancer's journey.

    Aren't most action, sci-fi, drama, even comedy movies based on "extreme" situations and stories? If you didn't like the movie just say so...

  • Thank u very much for uploading it. I wanted to see this movie since long time. :-)

    Very Nice movie... Madhur's best work

  • after watching this..i went and gave my mother a hug

  • nice move its sotruthfull

  • whats this india pakistan fight that is going on here? r u guys stupid?

  • i dunno why but whenever i see this i see the reality and death of hope .... no matter whatever u try and whtever u do.... sometimes time holds such grudge for u that u are not spared

  • That bloody paki what did he say indian economy is worse abey bhadwe paap ke jaane india mut de pakistan mein baad aa jayegi bhadve saale pakistan ko log kya kehe hai pata hai na terrorist land aaj tak terrorist log ke siva kuch banaya hai tum log ne tumhaare baap logo ne bola to chal padte hai fatne killing innocent people isliye to aaj pakistan mein barbaadi hai and indian econmy is sky high pakistan mein hai he kya sab bheek mange hai kabhi US to kabhi China se bheek mangte hai Bheek MANGE

  • Comment removed

  • i think i feel sick now this is 2 sad i hope dis is not a real story cuz itz jus too ..........no words

  • Very goodavd movie,good acting by Tabbu, Rajpal Yadav,good story line.

  • wow this movie made me speechless..tabu's acting is superb..and the story and direction are great

  • best movie ever seriously this like the best movie but i didnt like the ending i wish mumtaz would have been happy and her kids shouldnt follow her past other wise it was such amazing movie by madhur his the best drector and tabu is wonderful great amazing actress hope she do more movies like this she is wonderful!!!

  • what nice movie.. and tabu act well..it tell us the problems in the society..

    and my hearty congratulation to its Director... he done a very good job..

  • thanks for this movie

  • why did abey kill those guys?

  • @fookhoihouse

    Abbay killed those guys because they raped him in prison.. the scene was cut out.

  • @fookhoihouse a scene is omitted....becoz they raped him in jail

  • i mean like damn pppl r getttin mad... i said no offense dude lol.....!!!

    nd

    assgl7693 dude u kinda ryte but w.e...!!

    nd

    arjun12345a go fuck yur self bharway... tere ma key maroon jaa bund....!!!

    ghasti yooon kay gundu....!! muhth chooos marey...!!

  • @paki0627 fuck offf...no offence! i said no offence okay? so dun mind:P

  • @paki0627 That bloody paki what did he say indian economy is worse abey bhadwe paap ke jaane india mut de pakistan mein baad aa jayegi bhadve saale pakistan ko log kya kehe hai pata hai na terrorist land aaj tak terrorist log ke siva kuch banaya hai tum log ne tumhaare baap logo ne bola to chal padte hai fatne killing innocent people isliye to aaj pakistan mein barbaadi hai and indian econmy is sky high pakistan mein hai he kya sab bheek mange hai kabhi US to kabhi China se bheek mangte hai

  • what a movie

    what an acting

    what a story

    superb !!

  • bro indian has the worse economy ever... no offense....!! nobdy has money so ppl start killing nd robering .....!!!

  • @paki0627 you're taking it in a wrong way.

    india's economy is 2nd fastest , india is not a developed country just because of population. they are showing the peoples from mainly slums and people fled to mumbai in search of jobs and else

  • abey ma ke bhadwe pakistani pig behanchod ter epak ko dekh sala bheek maang raha hai india se ipl khelne ki

  • Such a true and pathetic tale!

    This is why everyone has to be educated and refrain from doing illegal things in their life. It doesn't just affect their own lives but also ruins their families.

    A great piece of work from Madhur Bhandarkar. Impeccable acting by Tabu.

    But it's so sadly surprising that no matter how many such movies are made, there is really no change in the society that we see.

    I sincerely hope these movies create some awareness amongst people and make our world a better place.

  • @blue4u2054

    Change come within oneself, one's family and upbringing :)

    Movies hightlights and give hints tho :)

  • we should understand that by wrong source of income can't make our life peaceful, and respectful.

  • u know where mumtaz got wrong that she went again to bear bar after her husbands death u cant expect children growing up in bars to be lawyers she cud have worked in homes or offices as a mate atleast that she cud get or i was wondering if she shud accept habib bhais offer n go 2 uae and make earnings for 5-6 uyears so she cud cum bak n giv secure future 2 her kids

  • Great movie. First of all, a great story and great direction. As Akaila82 said, this is a Madhur Bhandarkar masterpiece. He is tremendously expert in making realistic and meaningful movies. Chandni Bar, Page 3, Traffic Signal, Fashion, all are so realistic.

    Tabu's acting was sensational. She is really an actress of the level of Shabana Azmi and Smita Patil. Tabu, you are great.

    Rajpal Yadav's performance of the supporting role was perfect. All in all, a perfect movie.

  • i totally agree with u !!

  • Madhur Bhandarker u r great,its really a master piece

  • i usually go to dance bar n donot respect these gals but this movie taught some lesson nice movie bollywood should make these kind of instead of crap comedy movie

  • why u go dance bar

    that is not good place i think u r so low case man

    n u like that all.............i hate man who go to dance bar n throw money on those gilrs

    n they dont like there wifes....n ignore them alwayes...........

  • i like the role rajpal yadav

  • madhur's best film

  • never saw such a poignant film

  • brilliant tabu and bhandarker should be applauded for making such a gritty realistic truthful movie b4 i usd to look down on bar dancers and other girls in the seedy business but iv opened up my eyes and have the utmost respect for them they are just like us trying to make a living in this unjust world. i agree that the government should do something to stop the abuse that women face in this profession and that they should be protected more on a wider scale and not be shunned from society...

  • one of the best movies made in bollywood...

  • Un film remarquable, et des acteurs qui le sont tout autant. Dommage que les distributeurs français aient négligé ce cinéma.

  • in this film Tabu acting is remarkless

  • wow.. tabu you are dam good in this movie...

  • No words to say :(

  • OMG !...this is soooo sad !.....but one of the best movies i have seen in a while !.....i like Tabu , must see another movie for her !

  • Y did it have to end that way...Great acting on Tabu part. Wasn't she in Tere Naam?

  • Mumtaz you should have dumped those two kids in the Arabian sea as soon as your paramour was dead and you should have jumped in too. Life wont change. Its a harsh reality out there!

  • i really want to see this movie when i saw it first at the magazine....at that time i was thirteen..for sure,without doubt it...i know it is a great movie coz it is TABU!! taking me so long juz to see it..phew

  • I have no words to comment for this phenomenal , marvellous , extraordinary movie !! It' s really a human expectation which is created by the human !!

    The ugly face of life where even your good deeds cant wipe it out !!

    CHANDNI BAR --- This is only one of the life portrayed in the movie !! Just thinks how many life are still yet to be witnessed !!

    I am happy now dance bar are closed otherwise we dont know how many life would have been still witnessing the pain of being a " BAR DANCER " !!

  • tabbu is the best, but without perfect story, dialog's, and direction nobody will get chance to enhance their skill's.

    everyone in this movie has done their best.

  • One of the best Indian films i have ever seen. Simply outstanding

  • Simply awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • crap! this movie is amazin although i never herd of it, madhur rox!!

  • i cant believe that over acting ki aaulat kajol got the best actress for k3g and not tabu at that stupid filmfare

    and cant belive that idiot, expressionless katrina kaif is a so called "A-list" queen of bollywood

    TABU IS THE BEST

  • @kazzibang

    That's why Indian Awards are the most famous ones (Pun intended).

  • @kazzibang true but now days it's all about the money. If goods looks can bring in more money then the people forget about the acting quality.

  • @kazzibang

    u r right

  • @kazzibang hey there is no doubt at all that tabu is The Best actress but kajol is not over acting ki aaulat. Gupt,Dushman,DDLJ,Fanaa, are some proofs that she is also 1 of the best actress of our time.Ye alag baat hai ki she didn't that kind offers where she can prove her mettle.

  • @kazzibang

    Don't exaggerate. Tabu is a class actress no doubt but to call kajol over acting, you must be an idiot.

    For K3G, you can call SRK over acting, not kajol. Besides, why do you care for Filmfare? how many awards SRK deserved when he got them? full of over acting no? just because your like 'Tabu didn't get it, you get confused about filmfare award? come on.

    Tabu is awesome bottom line, even Atul kulkarni is a way better actor than SRK, why don't you talk about them why not kajol/tabu?

  • @pearl1729

    why not Atul/SRK, why only tabu/kajol i mean

  • @pearl1729 kajol over acted in k3g

  • Tabu is a legendary Indian talent,,,Bravo for your work in this motion picture...and I consider Tabu in the same ranks as the late Sumita Patil.

  • Great work!!!

  • What a diffence with umrao jann!!!

  • I hate abay for not realising his mother dream in order to make her happy before dying and proud of her all sacrifice and even her sister!

    He will be like his father,like son like father what a pity!

  • this movie is a must-see for everyone.... thanks for uploading

  • wow, great movie..thanks for uploading it :-)

  • madhur is the best

  • eye opening movie. Shows what truely is going on in the world

  • it's interesting that the kids both lose their naivete but mother never does. mumtaz remains the simple village girl throughout, shocked & crushed each time calamity strikes. the kids though become hardened as youth.

    i guess it goes to show that everyone is ultimately a product of where they are raised, no matter where they live after that.

    thanks for exposing the world to this incredible film & story.

  • tht's called personality. Some people take time to feel things and others pick things quickly. and its like that in every community. mumtaz has a soft personality, but her kids have otherwise.

  • @reflectionsonlife totally agree with u..

  • @reflectionsonlife :: truly said.. nicely observed... 

  • @reflectionsonlife  BEAUTIFULK COMMENT....and very true too

  • @reflectionsonlife  BEAUTIULK COMMENT....and very true too

  • @reflectionsonlife

    Sums up the hole film great comment

  • now this is wot u call a good movie better then thos luvii duvi ones...5/5 wicked movie...buh u feel sad after the movie..imagin those people out there who still suffer...they r the real hero...bless them all.

  • luvy acting by tabu........the way she encted that scene of crushed hopes........the feleing of all gone in vain.......

    the way she cries........makes u feel the pathos.....wonderful.....

    but still grim reality.....sad film but really well acted

    even abhay ws good..........when we went on looking at no one caring for no one ,a perfect expression

  • Great film! Thanks for the upload!

  • i think its all about what happend in reall world so thanks tabu u was a greatful

  • oyeee abhayy ki fuckingg ka scene katatatatataa kyu

  • Alli can say is that if someone really want their kids to stay away frm their mom /dad profession is " JUST GET THE HELL OUT OF THAT PLACE"...TAKE UR KIDS TO MORE DECENT PLACE...MY HEART FEELS FOR THOSE WHO ACTUALLY GOES THRU ALL THIS...

  • Amazing Movie. Now you see, these types of movies should recieve awards. Not those Gay, motherfucking Sharukh or bachan movies.

    Beautifully portrayed story.

  • agrees...but shahrukh has done good movies also

  • great movie ...amaizing acting by tabu .... thanks for uploading

  • The actors were very good, especially the always perfect Tabu. But, this movie has now despressed me.

  • sad and real great movie thanks we have long rood to walk

  • a girl is only safe as long as she is with her parents...some are not even safe with parents....some not even in the womb!!!Sad but true...

  • Great Mother,

    Great Story,

    A mother does everything for her kid's

    A lesson of courage inside this movie.

    I wish i can do something for those people who are really needy.

    Zarori tu nahi her koi ro k dikhay

    khushk aankhon may b sailaab howa kartay hain...

  • dont forget the sacrificise the sister did.for her brother

  • Beautiful movie, thank you for uploading.

  • Good movie!!! Thanks for posting...

  • sad an great movie.thanks

  • this z an awesome movie

  • Wow great movie thanks Phyoe123

  • This had to be the best movie i ever seen..this is based on reality with what goes on with women in India. Im disgusted in these men but the movie had a point which amused me..Very well written!

  • one of the best indian films I would say- hangs a lot on Tabu- Oscar material actress-Love her

  • g8 movie. but quite sad...

  • This is result of a corrupted man society. We must respect equality so everyone can have a life of their own.

  • Wow! That was an intense movie. Thank YOU, for posting this movie with English subs!

  • man this movie is woefully long. sadist too. makes it boring though its pragmatic

  • sad movie :(

  • this was a great movie.. but if you guys think this movie shows hard life... watch "Bandit Queen"... it will shock you... really great movie & great acting...

  • I think this version is the censored one because it doesn't properly show the part when Payal (her daughter) limps when she gets off the minicoach, and when the two boys perform sexual acts on the Abhay (the son). Good film.

  • Thank you for filling in the "blanks".

    I kind of assumed that was why Abhay was behaving that way but wasn't sure. Thank you!

  • Thanks for explaining the part about Abhay because it doesnt explain in these parts as to why he would be so furious on those two boys.

  • sure..............i cudnt understand why abhay ws so ungrateful ........his mom n sis did such a sacrifice and he did what mumtaz had tried her best not to make out of him,

    thanks for fill in the blanks....

  • abhay was raped in jail by the boys he shot.

  • why does she limp? did she just dance or sleep with someone too?

  • Great movie but very sad, no explanation needed on that part. Thank you for the movie. Do you think the son killed himself in the end or no?

  • 5 star movie but the sad part is although its very close to reality the real thing is even worse...hopefully some us who watch it might one day

    be able to help some of them even one may god help these people and ease their suffering

  • Great movie.Thanks.

    Ramgopal verma and priyadarshan's movies are so realistic.

    Do you have any other realistic movies ?

  • What a wonderful movie....thank u.

  • what happened to her son while he was in jail? like wat did those two guys do to him?

  • he was raped by the other 2 guys.

  • ew what do u think indicated that?

  • one that there is crime even in prisons. Two that a helpless boy could only get aggrivated by what happenened to him....Was it not enough him having to see what his mother was going through....

  • hi, how do u know he was raped in the jail? i mean there was no such scene in the movie here on youtube....thanx!!!

  • There was a rape scene in the film but it think it got cut out for some reason. The rape scene I saw in the theater was pretty graphic.

  • hi thank you, the movie was good.

  • Reality is bitter. This is a almost true to life depiction of the plight of many unfortunate women, who are a so called 'bad name' for society and branded by the very men who use them. Hypocrisy, lies, and exploitation of human beings is our greatest sin, and it's being done every where in the world till today, and always will be. Excellent movie.

  • omg..........wut a great movie: Tabu's performance was just so outstanding, no other actress in her generation wouldve able to pull this off better or even close to her acting..............no wonder she received so much praises n awards for the movie......i hear theyre trying to get her to make a sequel aswell

  • damn this movie was really good and sad. poor indian woman.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more