CHRISTMAS CAROLER CALAMITY!

[KaiKinapela]

One of my favorite shaycarl videos. Mad love for Ptard!

[yipfrr]

I have not seen a video from them In years AND IS THAT SHAY CARL?

[PuppyGirl29]

Is it me or at 1:37 Shay is wering girl shoes?

[hussein2050]

I'm 99.9999999% sure people who say "I miss the fat shay...etc" are fat themselves who feel ashamed! How can you not be proud of someone who has lost 100 pounds and feels healthy and happy? You must be one of those people who are so selfish! SMH.

[MoenFilm]

WHAT HAPPENED TO SHAY CARL

[legoqueen12]

Shay you can't pull off being serious! LOL

[Jdawg1798]

uggs wtf

[RosaFelton]

wow he looks like a total different person

[Kerrtus69]

cut ur hair

[oreotitan4545]

KONY 2012 search and act

[SimonSaysEllo]

please grow a beardd

[arnicool8]

shay say'd the F word! SHAY!!

[KrimiWomy]

where is the BEARD!?!?!?!!

[Aristophile]

I hadn't watched a video of yours in forever, congrats, you look great!

[xoallieox07]

LOL

[dpfvpersonal]

I love PrincessTard.

[dementor619]

gr8 this was so funny lol

[786sami786]

I love this Shay tbh.

[RedHockey10]

I liked fat shay better.

[BelowTheZer0]

ROFL!  Go Princesstard!

[ParkpwnsAll2137]

Holy shit.... Shay is like.... Not overweight.

[moyisbick]

Who the fuck is this, where is shay carl

[SpaceDinoFTW]

Haven't watched a Shaycarl video in a while...

WTF happened? (In a good way)

[HZD09]

its the guy from the shining?

[ePranks]

hey shay u should make a shining parody

[hrag500]

What happened to the Daily Vlogs?

[KPFakeaccount]

@hrag500 Shaytards...

[rawrtastickk94]

HAHAHAHAHA!!! PT your my hero!!!

[xXOtakuPageXx]

shay looks fucking wierd nwo that he's skinny.

[ST4RBURSTS]

Oh my god, Shay wasn't as happy as he was now that he has lost weight. If you guys were his fans, why would you want him to be unhappy again? why would you do that to shay?

[CopperShortsword]

I just decided to visit the channel in months.. Whooooaaa! I didn't even recognize him!

[porkch0mp]

shay is not shay anymore now that he is skin and bone :(

[ChelseyCaldwell]

@porkch0mp Shay is healthy.. I mean i thought more people could be happy for him.. He is still the same Shay but hes actually healthy now

[italianadonna12]

EVERYONE STOP COMPLAINING ABOUT SHAY LOSING WEIGHT. I'M PROUD HE LOST WEIGHT AND HE WORKED VERY HARD. HE DIDN'T PUSH HIMSELF TO EAT HEALTHY AND WORKOUT JUST TO HEAR YOU B**** AND COMPLAIN!!!!!! GTFO IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT AND KISS MY A** HATERS.

[ChelseyCaldwell]

@italianadonna12 Exactly! I think everyone should feel the same as you do! They need to stop complaining hes healthy!

[Graphzcoder]

0mg is this shay? :S

[MegaHandsomeJack]

i dont want the fat shay back but i do want the buzz cut man beard shay back

[MissHepburnHerself]

i liked fat shay much more

[leelah92]

Shay looks soooo different :O

[leelah92]

shiiiiit hes lost a shit loads of weight

[greenredmnga25]

it's great he lost weight

[FaXhizors3ART]

How did he get skinny?

[SuperStonedWeed]

he looks good

[MeganKaty7]

creepiest video evar...

[ledbelly7]

wow, well done man, you look great!

[xMegaCookiex1]

I miss Fat Shay with his Beard he was MORE funner....:(

[Itzxthomasx]

Did they replace shay with someone else? I haven't watched one of these vlog things in about 9 months.....

[easilyamusedcinema]

@Itzxthomasx he lost weight

[hallmonitor98]

lol he's got to the only person who looks better fat than skinny

[missjuliieee]

WOW it's been such a while since I've seen your videos!! My you look real good!

Only thing I would tell you is that you might just need a haircut :)

Apart from that you look super good!!

[ActionSports199]

Is that shay? I haven't watched forever! Good job man!

[conman3234]

It's funny when he was falling down the stairs his robe was untied then magically tied when he was on the floor! :D its a Christmas miracle!!

[KBec87]

OMG! I'm ashamed & sad to say I've not watched one of your video's in a while. Life & what not. Oy! But wow you've lost so much weight. Last I watched, you were beginning the process. And look at you go! ;) Congratulations to ya!

[NocheeseSherlock]

Go PT :D

[RandomNumber511]

best video ever

[kyle112233]

So much has changed, been missing out on your videos for ages cause life took over. Good to see you're completing your goals still after all this time. Best of luck!

[drawesome2000]

He looks like a fucking boss okay guys, not jack nicholson, not tom cruise an not jack black. He looks like a fucking BOSS.

[BlueSpy545]

He kinda looks like Tom Cruise xD

[lukef42]

How long is Shay Carl going to be away? And how long is Shay's brother going to take care of them? Shay's brother is funny and all, but I like Shay better.

[marcotizer]

for a second there I saw Jack Black

[SkullCandyCharms]

OOMGG!!! SHAY thats you??? I stopped watching your videos like two years ago... You look completly different your children grew up too... Wow thats big changes

[CutieAsianChick]

rofl at Ptard

[heidihaydon]

ShayCarl you look amazing!!!! Great work man!

[karim1171]

did he sell his channel ?

[evelin93]

I can't even. He was fat when I last watched his videos. And now.. look at him. That astonishes me.

Shay, I want to know your weight loss tips! :D

[kateiceheart]

shaytards <3

[FoldedArt]

What the motherfuck... he's slim :o

[Vanlayale]

Someone please explain to me what happened :-) I'm glad he decided to do this, it's really good for his health...and the sex is awesome :p

[g0tcadaver]

he kinda looks like jack nicholsen...

[bmills1122]

@g0tcadaver in that scene wear he's trying to kill him family YES

[hockeydangler9]

the fat shay basically made shay, dont get me wrong i still like his video's and have the utmost respect for him and his dedication to losing weight... But jeesh, being skinny just doesn't suit him, he was just one of those fat guys that was just plain awsome, it just made shay well, shay!

I know this sounds totally luticrous, but I fucking miss the old shay!

[mystobluestars]

Guys...he's still Shay. Fat or skinny, doesn't matter.

[LordVerdo]

I still think he is funny and I'm glad to see he is healthy now. It's for his own good!

[pickleboy443]

you dont look like shay any more, i like the old shay better :/

[Maniakq1]

HOLY!!!!!!! he lost A LOT of weight.....i think it was better when he was fat :/

[karatearne123]

danm its good ;D

[lisa13214]

Did anyone else nodis that the Christmas list was just scribbles? LOVE THE VIDEO!

[cDayz]

Hoping that wasn't him. *sigh* but good for him being healthier.

[cDayz]

Oh man that really is him, hoping that it wasn't. I'm happy he's healthier but he had more character to me back then. *sigh*

[xmelissaruthx]

what are all of these negative comments? watching shay's transformation was amazing and inspiring (on the shaytards channel), he's so much more healthy, and he looks hot!

[daWilliamTT]

wow!!! i cant tell if its shay!!!

[churljix]

I like the skinny Shay way better!

[Natedawg422]

Holy crap thats him!!!! I must say he looks freakin good!

[jaguar123987x]

He has lost so much weight after that last offspring/babytard

[inmatejason]

I don't like his look anymore or his vids these days.

[davidmalone94]

Again, I miss the chubby. And again, he looks like Tom Cruise. At least cut the hair?

[YaWatBruv]

he looks cooler this way and more funnyer

[megaanjoaanne]

why does everyone want the fat shay back like really he was unhealthy and couldnt do alot of stuff, now he has more energy and he does more stuff!

hes no different now that he's not fat, like really guys stop saying you wish he was fat again

its like he cant win both ways

[COMMANDERmutlaq]

@megaanjoaanne thank god he lost wight

and it's good for him and everyone else.

but he looked better with beard :'(

[ecm4321]

Lol "if you dont get out of here and shut your freaken mouth... Ill call the cops." :)

[chesney121]

Please..I'll pay for all your food...just gain weight again!

[officialtouchdown]

me drawing shay

/watch?v=UOOetH11Wgs

[lokomicah]

Skinny Shay looks like a pedophile...

[LEETOQUILES]

WHOA! I HAVENT SEEN SHAYCARLS VIDEOS SINCE LIKE JUNE IDIDNT KNOW IT WAS HIM IN THE THUMBNAIL HE LOSE LOT OF WEIGHT

[nanabanana613]

i LOVE alex!!

[wigglynose]

I stopped watching Shaytards for a long while. And now I check back in with the videos and DANG I didn't even recognize Shay and I thought Babytard was Princesstard for a second. I have missed a lot.

[Goochbag8]

That's...shay? What. No fucking way.

[Benchiladas]

he went from jack black to jack nicholson

[tooskool4cool]

daaaang, he's lost a LOT of views, but i like skinny shay!

[LogicThEncrypter]

I don't like beardless skinny shay :(

[JoeyzMindSet]

wait... thats shay?

[shortii12341]

Way to go Princesstard! Way to show them that you are the BOSS! :).

[GillRant]

I love the over the top English accent.

[cygnarplayer]

i miss fat shay

[DivineBanana]

hey i didnt know he was actually a good actor

[TheNigerianScammer]

how is he so skinny

[bananapowaw]

Nice boots shay(:

[dlb86at]

silly people this isnt shaycarl its carlshay...duh

[PROtezamegajoint]

shaycarl is sexy and he knows it :D

[peanutdancer670]

Jim Carrey is here

[gutrp]

wow thats shay?!!

[puppyprincess12345]

It's amazing how much weight Shay has lost.. but i miss fat shay :/

[watergal619]

Idiot had it coming. GO FOR ANOTHER ONE PRINCESSTARD

[EpicSkyCat]

HILARIOUS

[worldman52]

i miss fat shay... =/

[souladucky]

He looks like Jack Nicholson!

[CodyTheAddictedGamer]

I have not watched a Shay vid in SOOO LONG! and LOOK AT HOW MUCH WEIGHT HE LOST! Congrats on the weight loss! I know it is not easy!!

[Lesssadmorehappy]

Princesstard is awesome.

[ehayes3791]

looks like jack nicholson in this video.

[TheDanamater]

WTF HOW'D HE GET SO SKINNY?

[Jagerboi21]

where's shay carl in the video? i thought this was shays channel?

[reganrocksmysocksoff]

@KingRobbStark Thats a little mean :/

[alexkg1]

@KingRobbStark he dosen't look like Shay anymore...lol

[ShufflerShaax]

@KingRobbStark His weight doesnt change who he is inside...

[Poliwhirl1]

@KingRobbStark I disagree

[meaghanrachel]

WOAHH THATS HIM

[kbproductions19]

anyone notice shay's boots at 0:18?

[icommentonvideos1]

Shay, I think you look like Jack Nickelson now :) You look great, congrats on losing the weight.

[soupaFREEK]

Who is this person, and what have you done with ShayCarl?

[dinoANDyak]

Uhm. So.. i havent seen a ShayCarl video in so long.. he lost so much freakin weight oh my goodness

[Interwebie]

@dinoANDyak Haha I was like. O_O

[cabbycat4444]

@dinoANDyak and grew hair.

[bluchickengirl17337]

@dinoANDyak Is that really him!?!? I was just on his video with EdBassMaster and was not sure if that was him.

[Juniversal]

@dinoANDyak...same here. Like damn, he looks like a different person haha. He'll probably be getting these type of comments for another year lol.

[eimichi]

I am probably the only one who cares but it is Deck the halls with BOUGHS of holly not BELLS of holly.

[beybladera]

I haven't seen a shay video in like a year. What did you do with Shay Carl and why are you having Leonardo DiCaprio do your skits now?

[HowItsDoneRunescape]

Mugs... really? (man uggs)

[melkateb1]

PT needs to be on the disney channel!

[EliasTheAmazing]

Where the fuck is the beard.

[xProudxIrishxGirlx]

loooooooolllllllll

[alesalinas1990]

hahahahah funny

[SaskiaAndJessica]

He should have just looked through the spy hole in the door to see if the caroler was singing xD

[djakkdjakkd]

I've had not looked his videos for a while and i was like huh where's Shaycarl.. and then OMFG!?

[RyuseiTV]

Long hair, no beard? THE HELL?!

[GreekGirl391]

Princesstard is beautiful! I love her hair! Shay your going to have trouble keeping the guys away from her when she's older!

[jic4512]

dood u need your beard

[etriousx]

What the duck shay... You look weird. Seriously for the good of all that is beard, get rid of that mullet

Yours scincearlytdxhrzbyrc

Timmothy du faic

[TomValedro]

Wow, shay is hot.

[Input4everyone]

Thumbs up for princesstard!!!

[PtheRich2]

@Brulszd I was talking about the character, i know he doesnt actually have his mouth open like that normally, it just annoyed me.

[NoShoesAllowed]

SHAY COMMENTED ON MY VIDEO!!

I didn't know you watch my videos Shay! :O

[l0vablelinda]

PT's hair looks great, love her

[Razetteo235]

DAMITSGOOD808!!!!!!!!!!

[Whisper104]

Shay looks like Jack Nicholson in The Shinning now

[StagGaming]

Shay you need a hair cut that would make you look alot better

[vtboi1234]

42 years ago ....

[jennarocks9595]

if you look at how many days its been since they put it up it says 42 years ago lol