Added: 3 years ago
From: mejtd1
Views: 22,232
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (81)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It really suits Liam better .. but don't tell me Noel's version is crap! They're both great.. is just that we're more used to listening to Liam in songs like this.. that's it.

  • fucking great!! liam vercion!!

    i like both!!!

    madferit!!

  • I can't seem to find the liam version on iTunes...

  • You can't buy this version on iTunes, it's a demo that was leaked on the internet over a year ago, Various Oasis websites have this song, along with the others that were leaked, available.

  • thank you!

  • @snapsoidpablo1 mp3raid.com

  • @snapsoidpablo1 well.., just copy this url of this above. ten go to zamzar.com and follow the following steps to download this song .. :)

    good luck and enjoy .. =)

  • @snapsoidpablo1 It's in the Don't Believe The Truth demos.

  • @snapsoidpablo1 youtube downloader is what you need my friend, just google it

    i should get payed for advertising lol

    its free anyway

  • esta version no esta mal, pero prefiero la que canta Noel, le imprime + fuerza a la cancion con su voz, ademas el tiene mejor conservada la voz que Liam

  • Tbh although i fuckin lvoe Liams voice. Noels version is defo better :) still a good version though, its Oasis init, cant go wrong:) x

  • no, liam doesn't get it right. 10 years ago his version, his voice would be the better, still is for many songs. but this is better with noel's voice

  • Oasi are lucky to have two great singers when most don't even have one.

  • it's even more crazy that they r from the same family....haaaa....best band mate!!

  • both are awsome , its a very nice tune, should have been in dont believe the truth

  • But Liam is rock and roll!!! And we are all waiting for him... to rock

  • i like them both!

    liam`s voice is more rocker

    but noel`s voice is more melodic

    but noel has a higher rank in vocals he can reach higher notes than liam

    but liam`s voice is just amzing

  • liam canta mejor q noel pero su voz ha estado decayendo con el tiempo, en cambio noel la ha perfeccionado

  • I do prefer this version but the other version is still awesome :D

    Ithink Liam brings something better to it. His voice is better :D

  • oasis - search for songs like alive, take me away, i will believe. amazing early oasis stuff. fav oasis song is headshrinker - proper fucking rock and roll TURN IT UP!!! OASIS LIVE FOREVER!!

  • why the FUCK didn't they release this version? the song gets ten times better when liam's singing it

  • where can I find this on mp3 ?

  • Love both versions

  • better version...

  • Noel's take is more blues, you know? Its rocking good, but Liam's is good too. His version is more rock -ish, lol. Both versions are super awesome! OASIS LIVE FOREVER

  • I totally agree..

    Love ZAK STARKEYS SOLOS!!!

  • I think both versions work well!!

  • nah, i prefer noals version to this. dont get me wrong im aposolty in love with oasis i havent listned to anything else for 4 days. ive also descovred new songs i dident even know about. like 'whatever' its now my favorite oasis song, the masterplan was my fav but 'whatever' kicks arse. this is still a really good version of this song, but noel is better in my opinion. x

  • oh, well, you just found out 'whatever'. then i think you are the first. tell us, is it good?

  • yeah its awsome !

    sorry about late reply!

    ahh oasis is soo good !!

    i got an A in drama for doing a mime to 'songbird' haha

    good old oasis !!

  • This version is better.

  • this is a great song

  • this version is 10 times better! actually makes it a good song with liam singing!

  • This is a good version, but it's not like Noel's take isn't awesome. It's the same song.

  • grande liam..

  • We do not discover anything if we say that liam is a god!!!he is really the fucking great and Truth oasis rocknroll...But let's not forget that noel is the composer...NOEL AND LIAM,ARE OASIS

  • I agree with the lot of you. I do think the one thing this song needs is more distortion, especially when Liam is singing.

  • amazing

    cool

  • agreed, Liam just rocks the shit out of this song. Noel's version was fine but Liam makes this song almost an anthem.

  • noels is better

  • as soon as I heard this version I was hooked, Liams voice rocks on this! I've deleted the Noel version off my computer completely! This song was made for Liam! He's the Bollocks on this track!!!

  • This is more of a Liam Jam, no effience noel. Liam is the man!

  • Great voice Liam boy!! You`re my hero :-)

  • Liam's great!! And his voice is the one we were waiting for!! Fuck off the ones who thought his voice was destroyed!

  • man this song is oasis swaggering back to main stream dragging other bands kickin and screaming!!! rock on!!!!!

  • pffft oh my god...the voice is still awesome!

    wot a tune with him singin it!!!!!

  • amo a liam gallagher!!!!!!!!!

  • Bravo

  • liam sounds mega on this who said his voice was shot

  • much better with liam on vocals.

  • in una canzone in cui il testo va aggredito liam è meglio, c'è poco altro da dire

  • qui ci voleva la vekkia voce di liam,sarebbe stata ancora più bella...

  • forse è qst che ha dissuaso noel... poi magari liam dal vivo faceva le fregnaccie...

  • sta canzone qui non verrà mai suonata in un live

  • Su questa è meglio la voce di ora...anzi la migliore di Liam: quella dei tempi di Be Here Now!

  • noel è down... è un sacco meglio cantata da liam!!! fesso... cm sempre

  • vabbè mo nn ci allarghiamo su noel,lui è sempre il migliore...anke se a me sembra più carina cn noel xò cn liam nn è male...

  • liam you're my god

  • They're both good.

    But Noel is by far the better singer for this kind of song.

  • agreed.

  • this should have been the released version. although i do have doubts as to his ability to sing it live over the course of a tour. liam is the greatest rock n roll singer of his generation but his voice struggles sometimes and anyone who saw Lyla at the very end of the last tour will know exactly what i mean. still, THIS IS THE DOGS DANGLEYS. Oasis should do more of this 12bar blues shit. there's only this and Shakermaker....

  • Slightly better than Noel's version, but still not a good song.

  • meglio cantata da liam

  • i LOVE LIAMS VOICE ON THIS dont get me wrong liam has a better voice than noel but i think that noels voice sang it better!

  • this is DEFINATELY better than noel's version. damnit oasis, why do you keep releasing inferior songs to the public, when demos, and better versions of songs are either kept locked up or released as b-sides.

    No wonder no one has heard of you in the United states!

  • Nooo Noel got it much better!!! Noel got more feeling in it!!!!

  • Only the younger generation.

    People in their Colledge years in the United States now are hugely aware of Oasis, they were the "in-thing" in the ninities over there.

  • Yes, only people aged 25-30 have heard of oasis. so, thats probably about 0.5% of the population. as i said before, no one has heard of them, and the ones that HAVE heard of them dont like them because they're too soft. we dont get songs like Acquiesce, Lyla, and Hindu Times popularized over here. They only have heard of Wonderwall and Champagne Supernova

  • u talking about only in america? they didnt make it in america as mainstream like u2 and coldplay cuz they fucked around too much..

    anyway they have a big fan b ase

  • i think liams voice is gr8 on this but noel does sound very rock n roll wen he sings it if u get me lol

  • Love it, suits Liam more!

  • Exactly! its an aggressive song for an aggressive voice - Noels voice is too soft for this song.

  • whoever says liams voice is shit shud listen to this.

  • Liam is GOD

  • this is my new fravourite song

  • VERY BETTER!!!!

  • I think liams voice suits this song more.

  • I like this version better!

  • woooooooow awesome! :)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more