Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (229)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Well, well. If it isnt old Wedding Cake Waters taking time off inbetween his marriages to sing a few songs. Henry VIII can rest easy for the moment.

  • 15:20 choreography is all sloppy, kids should go back to school!

  • fucking hell this is phenominal!!!!!

  • Roger Walters in top form, which was a wonderful concert for the last time then.

  • Awesome!!! We´ll whatch the same show at Porto Alegre, IN Brazil, next March 25. Awesome and thanks for this video!

  • nATURE'S wRIGHT

    Nature's law of absolute right states that only right action gets right results. As with all natural laws, if wrong results occur, the law was somehow contradicted, showing that this law is the final arbiter of what is right behavior.

  • the stoner that we have rejected has become the cornerstone

    get that drone out of my face

  • in pre trojan war decree

    /watch?v=MZvDU-5kgXk

    insimple syrup

    reminds me of the vacuum in that dont like like mondays pad

  • He's coming to near where I live in July and I'm going to convince my dad to take me. I'm only 13 btw and Pink Floyd is my favorite band so this would be soooooooooooooooooo cool.

  • Dude, I just want to say, thank you so much for letting us listen to this awesomeness. It means so much, and really, I hope your kids are thankful to have such a badass dad who would take them to this concert. It's amazing, and I'm thinking of getting tickets for it this summer.

  • I'm going to this concert in 3 days time. Can't wait. Pink Floyd are my favourite band. Saw them live twice and can't wait to see the whole Wall album performed. Thanks for uploading.

  • Trustme when ur there his singing sound 1000000000 times better, (I went)

  • fucking incredible. i love roger and this show was amazing.

  • Is he pretending to play at 16:18 when the guitar solo starts? it looks like it caught him by suprise when the solo started...pretty much the equivelant of lip-synching....

  • @skittel68 it would be weird since he's playing bass...

  • scheinbar komplett aus dem publikum gefilmt aber der typ muss ne mega kamera gehabt haben!

  • ab 8 minuten wirds spannend :)

  • singings getting iffy, guess it comes with age

  • Wish I could have seen this when they were all still together

  • The show looks amazing. My brother and I are really big Pink Floyd fans, so when I found out he was coming, we defently got tickets as fast as we could. I cant wait for the show!!

  • woww great camera, thanks for the vid definatley gonna get tickets in winnipeg

  • Thanks to your video I have to buy the tickets for the show in Mexico and now I'm broke but what the hell xD

  • anyone please do you know when the dvd for this tour will be released??

  • 5 faggots fans os Justin Bieber don´t like of Waters´s music ... son of a bitch...

  • Absolutely Awesome ({ * L * })

  • this is awesome! im going to see this in may 2012 and i cant wati!!!

  • @tyryryrrr are you seeing the show in Edmonton

  • @tyryryrrr are you seeing the show in Edmonton

  • MEU INGRESSO TÁ LINDO. 

  • BRASIL 01/04/2012!!!! yeaahhh

  • argentina espera por vos!!!!!!!!!!

  • spartakus. i dont remember that being in trhe original bvut...i like it...its an improvement...

    peace nd love

    ...and light....

  • FALTA MENOS PARA QUE VENGAS A ARGENTINA ROGERRRRRRRRRRR TE ESPERAMOS CON ANSIAS

  • i got two cheap seat tickets for the show i july 2012 and im 19.todays

    music just does not compare to this great masterpiece and im so stoked for this once in a lifetime event.i was at the vh1 live and loud show for nickelback 2 years ago,but this will be more exciting then that night even though i was on cable then lol

  • Comment removed

  • I went to the performance on the 14th May at the O2 Arena in London. The greatest performance I will ever see. Like the comment below I could watch it every day. Music like that of Pink Floyd touches your soul. Modern music does not (in my opinion anyway).

    What makes The Wall so timeless is the fact that just over 30 years on it is still relevant to modern day society across the world. For all sorts of reasons. I'm 21 and I will treasure my memory of that great night forever.

    Thanks Roger!

  • i was at the same concert in arnhem in one of the first rows. thank you so much for sharing it. i fucking love it, i could watch it every day. great memories... :)

  • his voice is much better here than in some other recent vidoes ive seen with Waters

  • @olof07 I never would have believed it, but he is singing better than he did ten years ago.

  • great video, thanks for sharing.

    would be really helpful if you put the which song starts at which time.

  • Comment removed

  • 16:00

    Those kids don't know how lucky they are :P

  • Roger looks so excited to play The Wall to a new crowd, glad he's become a more connected performer with his audience now.

  • Comment removed

  • and the aeroplane in In the flesh???

  • i love this - you caught "the wife" in mechanical difficulties, and she had to be manually hauled off the stage. thank you so much for hanging in there and taping the entire first half! now, where's the second? :-)

  • Ik was er bij, op een stoeltje in de frontale tribune. Veel beter overzicht over de muur, perfect zicht door de gaten heen op wie je hoort te zien, en een heel andere ervaring dan het standpunt waarop dit gefilmd is.

    Hier zie je weer details als de opbouw van de muur, de gelaatsuitdrukkingen van Roger en de bandleden, en wie nu eigenlijk wat voor instrument speelt. Heel anders dus. Erg leuk om ook dit standpunt te kunnen zien! Thanks for sharing!

  • if youtube deletes this video because of rights or shit like that i'll be mad.

  • I like the part where Roger Waters sings:D

  • Any chance he'll do this again? at least back in the US?

  • @MrNerd314159 He'll be back in 2012!! Tix are on sale.

  • @1LaOriental YES!!

  • Respond to this video... ha, my dad found out before me I THINK WE'RE GOING!!!

  • Me voy a dar el gusto de verlo en Buenos Aires el 18 de Marzo del 2012,siendo el último de sus 8 (OCHO) presentaciones en el Estadio de River Plate con una capacidad de 50.000 personas por recital.Mas 400.000 almas verán lo que será uno de sus últimas presentaciones en vivo ya que se retira definitivamente de los shows.

  • Me voy a dar el gusto de verlo en Buenos Aires el 18 de Marzo del 2012,siendo el último de sus 8 (OCHO) presentaciones en el Estadio de River Plate con una capaci de 50.000

    I go away to giving the pleasure of seeing it in Buenos Aires On March 18, 2012, being the last one of his 8 (eight) presentations in River Plate's Stadium with a capacity of 50.000 persons for recital. Mas 400.000 souls will see what will be one of his last live presentations since he moves back definitively from the shows.

  • ik luister pink floyd pas sinds een jaar of 5 en ben zo blij dat ik hier nog bij kon zijn! was eigenlijk al bang dat hij niet meer langs zou komen met the wall.. was echt fan-tas-tisch! gewoon niet te beschrijven.

  • That poor miserable f'ed up Roger from all those years ago... ha. On a serious note, it seems Roger has put the past behind him and is a cheery chap, great to see.

  • Richard Gere is still awesome after all these years.

  • @evildane

    Oh C'mon!

    He wishes!

  • Comment removed

  • ben er ook geweest, en nu ik dit weer zie, zit ik er weer helemaal in, echt heel spectaculair!

  • GREAT. ABSOLUTELY GREAT! Saw him in Oslo :)

  • Fantastic piece of video, well edited. Thank you for uploading.

    I have just started the bittorrent load from dimeadozen - Thank you.

    I loved the shows at Manchester - I went twice!

  • You sir deserve a Subscriber thanks to your videos :D

  • 2 people obviously do not know what Pink Floyd and especially The Wall means to the music community!!!

  • lol! It seems the Base had a few Problems while hearing Rogers Voice while he is still waiting to get an exactly timing during 'Mother's Play!

  • why won't you people just shut up and enjoy the music and the show??? why do you have to keep shouting at each other about what was and what is now history?

  • Ich glaube es geht nicht darum zu sagen, dass Roger W. = Pink Floyd ist, oder war. Keine Frage, alle Songs die sie zusammen gemacht haben, sind natürlich auch Gemeinschaftsarbeit.

    Aber diese Ausnahme, und damit DAS Ausnahmealbum von P.Floyd und meiner Meinung nach, hauptsächlich von Roger Waters, wäre niemals möglich gewesen, hätte Roger nicht all sein Herzblut, seine Biographie und seine Energie hinein gesteckt. "The Wall" ist der Höhepunkt von Roger´s Lebenswerk. Verbeuge mich!! *thumbs up*

  • I can't quite make out what the kid's shirts say... do you know?

  • @EmFayg The kids shirts state: Fear Builds Walls

  • @PickupthePieces76 Thank you for uploading this spectacular and truly moving show.  I saw it in Oct. 2010 and always wanted to have a DVD. I am happy he will be doing it again!!! Great job!

  • bedankt !! ik heb genoten van het concert!

  • holland!! can you imagine how much good smoke was smoked that day

  • how did you sneak in with the cam?how didn't you get caught?

  • @threpsi because you may film in the gelredome?

  • Comment removed

  • i first listened the wall at 1998 from a tape i stole from my fathers car and i was so angry to my teachers back then,i was stuck to the lyrics for weeks,im 25 right now and im waiting for the concert like crazy!

  • Se lo dedico a ELISA MAXIMILIANE BARON OVALLE, KAREN VIVIANA RICO GOMEZ, LEIDY DAYANNA RODRIGUEZ SARMIENTO Y ANGELA VIVIANA LOPEZ ROJAS, dijo JORGE ALBERTO BARON desde Bogotá, Colombia, Suramérica.

  • great... Created my own DVD based on these vids.... it was really a great show!!

  • Went to watch it at the MEN in MAnchester, England yesterday 28th June. Amazing. Expensive at £85 but I knew it would be a one off thing so worth it.

  • "mother should i trust the government" *shakes his head*, epic.

  • Yesterday @ Zürich, Switzerland.

    Great show. Thx.

  • He 'll do this show on July 8th in Athens, where it will be ''filmed'' for Blue-Ray disk... I think tickets are far too expensive... starting from 65 to 165(!) euros. I think I'll pass this... After all, we've seen it before...

  • Seen this yesterday in Budapest! Was fantastic , too bad few understand the message!

  • @Kira200905 Budapest show was amazing - I whish I was taller though LOL :D

  • One of the best shows I have ever seen and I'm quite a concert-goer. Have seen this show in Berlin and Düsseldorf. Thank you for filming this! Brings it all back! What a brilliant show, words can't express what this show is like! It's a masterpiece! Roger Waters is a genius and I'm so happy that I could witness this rock-history!

  • One of the best shows I have ever seen and I'm quite a concert-goer. Have seen this show in Berlin and Düsseldorf. Thank you for filming this! Brings it all back! Roger Waters is a genius and I'm so happy that I could witness this rock-history!

  • it's so fantastic. Thank you for your videos. I saw Roger yesterday in Dusseldorf and the show was so great!

  • I nearly had an orgasm

  • I nearly had an orgasm

  • Great! Thank You!

  • can someone tell me where i can find the jacket roger whears for in the flesh?

  • Thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks,thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks,thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks,tha,ks,thanka,thanks,th­anks a lot.

  • pote tha erthei i 8h Ioylioy dn mporo na perimeno!!!!!

  • I'm spartacus. Considering it is a bootleg video so to speak it is quite good.

  • I'm spartacus.

  • Thanks for all your kind responses everybody. Glad to hear you are all enjoying the memories of a great show.

    I've had many requests to make this available as dvd and now it's done. You can dl it on dimeadozen (search waters arnhem). If you have any questions, you can contact me. This dvd is free, I believe in sharing live recordings, and no profit be made of the artists work.

    Please remember to buy the official recordings!

    Thanks to Roger for bringing us this great show!

  • @PickupthePieces76 -do u have the full monolog at the beginning , the one with Spartacus as could not understand all of it?

    Thanks so much!

  • @PickupthePieces76 thanks for putting this up,i seen it 2 times in toronto. 4th row so good,BEST SHOW EVER

  • @PickupthePieces76 Any idea when Roger is going to release the official DVD of the Wall concert?

    Thank you for uploading this video.

    Best wishes

  • looks like sad, lonely and boring old man

  • @blackwold stfu, Roger Waters is amazing.

  • saw him 4th may in sweden, really cool konsert overall but some parts were like being on a chinima and watching a movie... this konsert were filmed in england 12th may this year and i would think that is when david came on the stage..

  • saw him 4th may in sweden, really cool konsert overall but some parts were like being on a chinima and watching a movie

  • One of my dreams will come true, Roger I am waiting for you in Athens 8 of July!!!!!!

    tha se do syntoma

  • yesterday in antwerpen was awesome indeed :D i was there too :D

  • Yesterday in Antwerpen, Belgium, it was so nice

  • Nice filming, unfortunately I couldn't go.

    Somebody pushed the wrong button probably, I think it should be impossible to subscribe this with any negativity (unless you have questionabel reasons to do so.)

  • I'm proud to say that I'm one of the 2.5 Million people who will see this show with there own eye's. The visual effects were just spectacular, what a show !

  • 2 days to go for me yihaaaaaaaaa. Will be mindblowing after my "Berlin-experience" in 1990

  • i saw this it was amazing and will this be coming out on dvd does anyone know id love to buy it.

  • just home from the dublin show tonight absolutely amazing. take a bow roger

  • Anyone have any idea how long it lasts? I'm going tonight in Dublin, but I might have to leave early because of stupid bus timetables.

  • no one dislikes :D

    I was there in Arnhem, I was being emotional, it was so beautifull

  • Superrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

    ik ben op post de 28ste in Antwerpen :-)

  • que hermoso reencuentro de los hermanos que estan quedando...nunca se devieron separar......al fin reunidos....tremenda banda de todos los tiempos

  • look mummy, theres a aeroplane up in the sky...

  • i listened to Pinkfloyd all my life.. this is the best..

  • Roger was Pink Floyd... Dave, Rick and Nick. are great...especially Dave...

    . His writing is the best in rock music, thats a fact... no one touches him..

    forget your internal dialogue.......... he's the best.....

    my favourite is the pros and cons of hitch'hiking...

    its a matter of taste...

  • @dannyhughs now don't get me wrong, waters was a very important part of pink floyd, but you can't just go and say he WAS pink floyd. there was so much to that band and to the sound they had. I mean, come on, gilmore's guitar was a staple of the pink floyd sound just as much as roger's bass. and yeah he wrote a lot of the songs, but how many did gilmore write? and for that matter, what about wrights piano? great gig in the sky anyone?! listen to the final cut and tell me roger IS pink floyd!

  • @tydude64

    Your spot on, if you ask me roger is a brilliant lyrical writer. BUT, he will never had or shall have the skills that gave Pink floyd the sound it HAD. David gilmour guitar is timeless, you can hear on the album meddle how Roger is way behind on bass guitar compared to David. David became leadsinger/guitarist for a reason. He was simply the better singer and guitarist.

    Richard wright and David played on remember that night Echoes....<----i give left nut for that. Roger mehhh...

  • @Secondlifecreator

    Part 2 not saying Roger is bad! It is obvious were his talents lay, but i get tired of ppl telling " HE is pink floyd" wrong, he is Roger waters, Pink Floyd was Richard (rip) Roger, David, Nick . Now die hard fans will tell me you forgot Syd barret <--- Spare me , the left him home one day on a gig, got David and ever since syd was a done deal.

    He still lived from the royalties of FEW minor hits (Arnold Layne) far from a worthy career he had.

  • @dannyhughs wow....sorry but he couldnt have done what floyd has done by himself or with any other musicians....especially the sounds of gilmour

  • @dannyhughs

    YOur full of it, without the rest roger would have a so so band, the all form PINK FLOYD..

  • I was there too. The BEST concert ever in my life. I love you Roger xxx

  • wow, just amazing, I am going tomorrow in Manchester UK, 20th May 2011

  • thanks for the upload, It's amazing..

  • I was there :D Best concert of my life.

  • Ik was in the 02 gisteren (14 mei) het was geweldig!!! Deze recording is super, heel erg bedankt!!

  • DANK DANK DANK ik was erbij op 8 april de tranen staan nu weer in mijn ogen ....zo gaaf concert en nogmaals bedankt voor deze opname...... toppie

  • Pick-Up... Thanx !! Ik was er ook bij de 8ste en deze opnamen zijn een geweldige herinnering voor mij. Diepe buiging en dank voor je moeite ! De video('s) staat(n) bij mijn favo's ! Menno

  • Echt heel erg mooi gelukkig heb ik ook wat footage...precies van de andere kant

    my gratitudes for your effort ...

  • @PickupthePieces76 The concert they are going to film is the one in Athens, Greece on July 7th 2011. He announced it himself on the website

  • Comment removed

  • Ik ben niet geweest, wel verhalen gehoord van mensen die wel geweest zijn en die waren onder de indruk. Geweldig dat ik dit nu ook kan beleven. Ik zal diegene die geweest is ook even attent hierop maken.

    Rob

  • Geweldig om dit weer te zien; was er 08-04-11 bij. heb genoten en doe ik nu weer!

    Bedankt dat je dit op youtube hebt gezet. Ik zou dit graag op DVD willen hebben, maar begrijp dat dit niet zomaar even kan. De filmer dient beschermd te worden, toch? Wat een herbeleving! Hij staat bij mijn favorieten.

  • 1/4 i was in milan :)

  • I was there with my dad at 11-04-11 and i'm still in shock, i first heard pink floyd when i was 7 and since a few years ago i was dying to go to a concert and see Roger Waters live... and my wish came true ;_; <3

  • Should i trust the government?? No Fuckin Way!!

  • I saw this show in Poland! Mindblowing!

    But here I like his speech - very funny :)

    dankzij (hope, that really means 'thanks' ;) )

  • Heb "the wall" langeleden gezien met Pink Floyd in Dortmund en Londen.

    Roger doet hier goed zijn best, maar het is natuurlijk niet het meesterwerk.

    Ondanks dat, is het verrassend om leuke reacties te lezen, en bewijst het dat Pink Floyd muziek tijdloos is.

  • awesome

  • i understand and i appreciate immensely your efforts: images and sounds fade quickly in the memory...if u don't tape it..thanks so much!

  • Mister, you did a very good job here! I was there the same night, It was GREAT!

    Thanks a lot!

  • Beveiliging die met de rug naar het podium moet staan.

    Jokes on you!

  • heeeeel heel erg goed dit!!!!!

    wat een geweldige show.......

  • im a Greek guy who went to Nederlands just to see this awesome concert... I have no words for what i saw....

  • ik zat op de zuid tribune, kan het nu van dicht bij zien geweldig thanx man

  • @yffjuh Haha, ik ook!!

  • After watching this GREAT first part of the show i even more starting to love the music. First time i saw him was at Arow Classic Rock (@lichtenvoorde) he preformed Dark side of the moon. My dad took me there. To be honest i didn't like this kind of music. After the show i just loved id. saw people crie. saw (realy) big guys getting goosbuns. But realy this show still only tells the truth. What the guys from pink floyd wroth years ago is at some points starting to get reality

  • i was at the saturday night show, flew over from scotland for it, words cant describe how amazing it was, ive gotta get a ticket for the o2 now

  • @PickupthePieces76 Thanks for these recordings, I was at that gig and enjoy playing it back almost every day since then :-) Of course I also look forward to the offcial dvd/blu-ray when it comes out, and also I would like to see Gilmour on that, however: I think that should be as a bonus or something, as the other Dave (Kilminster) is doing such a great job at every single gig of this tour, that leaving him out on an offcial realease wouldn't do him justice!!

  • Comfy Numb AND Run Like Hell in London - 1 date

  • Zoek 2 veldkaartjes voor Antwerpen . Heeft iemand iets

  • @PickupthePieces76 I know David Gilmore is doing a guest appearance at 1 of the dates but does anybody know witch date..??..He did promise Roger an appearance because he had played with david on a charity gig last year.I don't suppose that info is out yet but as you say there are rumours...???? B T W Fantastic job.!!!

  • Thank you

  • Ik ben er maandag geweest, prachtig.

    Goede kwaliteit trouwens.

  • geweldig, dankjewel

  • Tnx man for this great upload I daily enjoy it. I was there monday 11th and this became a wonderful memory tnx again !

  • @PickupthePieces76 Zomg nearly 1 hour if 1 minute was added

  • Dit was de Beste concert Ooit

  • tyvm much for this upload , im a "fan" from floyd and the solostuff since i was very young,the wall completed everything for me 30 , 20 , 10 yrs ago and still i its more actual in every kind of way nowadays.

    I was upfront last monday 11 april,blewed my mind.

    if you dont mind contact me regarding a download..the new.projections/other or various then the nassau concert in N.Y. where so! much better!

    regards . R.

  • glad to see this i was at sat and monday...only sad you missed the plane but its nice to see the close ups i was in the center at the fence...both shows w2ere better then the one i saw in nyc

  • Prachtige opnamen! Ik had een GSM die z'n accu leegging voor het einde van het concert en dus niks opgeslagen heeft :((